Towards Making the Indian Rupee a Hard Currency of the World Economy: An analysis from British times until the present day

Interview by the BBC of Dr Subroto Roy at Oxford after Sonia Gandhi’s May 2004 victory

Conversations with Kashmiris: An Ongoing Facebook Note

From Facebook:

Subroto Roy regrets getting the sisters’ names wrong earlier; they were not Kulsooma and Yasmin but Akhtara, 19, and Arifa, 17. Their killings by terrorists in Sopore, and that of young Manzoor Ahmad Magray, 22, by the Army in Handwara within the week, mark a tipping point, for myself at least.

Subroto Roy reflecting on the Lashkar-e-Toiba killing of the teenage Sopore sisters and the Indian Army killing of Manzoor Ahmad Magray in Handwara, all in one week, is reminded only of: *Where be these enemies?… See, what a scourge is laid upon your hate,…all are punish’d.*

 

 

From Facebook:

Subroto Roy says at Seema Mustafa’s Wall “Some of these comments seem to be addressed to me in a somewhat ill-mannered way.  I am due to speak in Lahore next month on Kashmir and Pakistan, and have published quite extensively over 20 years perhaps on the subject, apropos the University of Hawaii volume *Foundations of Pakistan’s Political Economy: Towards an Agenda for the 1990s* etc.

http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=247284116125&id=632437284

http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=171926377284&set=a.136688412284.112038.632437284

I am quite happy to engage in any conversation with any shade of opinion from the leader of the United Jehad Council onwards. But discussion needs to be in English not pidgin English or slang, it needs to be polite and well-mannered, and it needs to be as well thought out and well-informed as possible. I may be addressed as Dr Roy or Mr Roy by people I do not know.

Subroto Roy says to Mr Changal, Apropos your “@mr roy…. i hope u carry a message that KASHMIRIS WIL NEVER LIKE TO B A PART OF INDIA”, I am given to understand that you as an individual have no wish to be an Indian national, which to me is fair enough. A lot of Indian nationals have travelled after all to the USA, Britain etc and there have gone about freely renouncing their Indian nationality and accepting that of another country. May I assume that if you, as an individual, were given such a choice by the Govt of India to formally renounce, on paper, in a private  decision with full security and no fear of repercussions, your Indian nationality, you would do so? You may then become stateless in international law, following which the Govt of India could assist you as an individual to accept the nationality of some other country for which you were eligible, e.g. the Islamic Republic of Iran or the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan or the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. If that went through properly, the Govt of India could also give you full “Green Card” or PIO status vis a vis the Indian territory you may wish to live or work etc in.

Ajmal Nazir ‎@ subroto sir…..I personally appreciate the kind of efforts you are putting to highlight the meseries that kashmiris are going through. May God succeed you in your efforts . However there are lot of realities that one need to understand before talking about Kashmir.This issue is not a demographical or political issue. This is an human issue where kashmiris suffer. Before going into any discussion , both Pakistan and India should understand that this problems is taking its toll on common kashmiri who is getting killed everyday.  Kashmir is like a beautiful prison where one can survive but cannot live freely. It looks completely normal from outside. But unfortunately you cannot see the fear that is inside the hearts of common people. You cannot see the uncertainty in the minds of those people.I wish you could have feel the fear in the mind of mothers when their kids are outside. I wish you could have feel the fear in the eyes of kids, when they see these indian forces roaming in their fields. There is a check post in every corner of the street, where it is obligatory for us to go through checking. We have to prove our identity in our own homes. It is not happening only on 26th Jan (like it happens in your states ]. It happening everyday, every-hour and every-time.I wish you could feel the fear when we have to go through these checking. Everyday, we have to make sure that we come home before 6:00 pm otherwise you will be picked up and your name will get added into hundrends and thousands of disappeared people. There are so many fake encounters happening in valley that nobody from outside world knows. Try to listen to local news here and there is a separate sections which tells you about the number of people that got killed every 24 hours. In 90′s that list was always above 20 and there was no such news outside kashmir. There is no such family in kashmir that hasn’t suffer I am not talking about mental suffering, I am talking about where somebody got killed.I wish you could have seen the pain of those mothers who lost their innocent sons, I wish you could seen the hopelessness in the minds of those fathers, who lost their only sons. There are so many half widows in kashmir, whose husbands were picked by forces and they never came back. they are still waiting for their husbands to return. In every community , there is an orphanage, where you will find the so many orphan kids. i believe you will find the most numbers orphans in kashmir than in any other state. These suffering are not visible from outside.We need to feel like kashmiris to understand these problems You need to take little pain to find the actual realities in kashmir. Every kashmir including our pandiths brothers suffer. KAshmir issue is not the political issue, neither is it regional issue. This is a human issue . This issue is not related to the geographical demographies, it is related with the people who live there.These boundaries are of no meaning for those mothers and fathers, who suffer everyday. If Indian wants kashmir, you have to win the hearts of kashmiris, Treat us like humans, Give us basic human rights . Release kashmiris from this militarized prison. Let us decide what is good for us.. Give us the freedom to express our problems. Let us bring kashmiris youth in your national media and let them discuss this issue. India is a democratic country so i believe everybody has a right to express their feelings.Highlight our miseries and punish the culprits who have killed innocent kashmiris.  How can you justify the killing of those small kids who pelt stones on the streets. Does indian constitution allow killings of kids if they pelt stones. If they damage property, arrest them but how can we kill those small kids.Even some where beaten to death.What about Tufail Matoo who got killed when he was going to tuition classes. He didn;t damage any property. There are so many untold stories in kashmir that nobody knows.

Subroto Roy says to Mr Nazir, Thank you for the lengthy and pertinent statement which clearly reflects your experience as well as your hopes and fears. I have no hesitation in accepting your saying the situation in recent times has become intolerable for ordinary people. I believe it is the outcome of a process which has evolved over decades in which the peoples and Governments of India, the peoples and Governments of Pakistan, and the peoples and Governments of J&K too, have all contributed. It is something for which *everyone* is responsible, no single person or country or community can be said to be exempt (other than perhaps the gentle people of Laddakh). And all the facts of history and the present have to be understood, and yes felt as well — each and every clear fact. I hope to show how this may be done during my Lahore lectures next month. Cordial regards and thanking you once more.

Subroto Roy says to Mr Changal, Thank you for the reply though you may have made a mistake with my identity: I am not Mr Subroto who has been a senior minister in Indonesia, but rather Dr Roy or Mr Roy as you please. No I do not think I am or would want to be blind to any atrocities by armed forces on civilians in any country, my own included. Apropos your statement “we reject the illegal n forceful occupation of kashmir by the cruel hindu india”, I shall be glad to hear the basis of your opinion. Re Hindus and Muslims and my opinion thereof, there is a lot of material to be found at my site and among my Notes. Cordially, SR

Sajad Malik I just wud humbly like to ask you a question sir, Do you deny the disputed nature of kashmir?

Subroto Roy Mr Malik, Thank you for the question. I think it was I who said *twenty years ago*, when I was almost as young as some of you are now “The core of the continuing dispute between Pakistan and India has been Kashmir, where vast resources have been drained from the budgets of both countries by two large armies facing one another for decades over a disputed boundary”. I do not think the Govt of Pakistan had used the word “core” until that time. Please see p 15 of the book

http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=171926377284&set=a.136688412284.112038.632437284

Subroto Roy says to Mr Changal, I cannot know but perhaps you speak from terrible personal experiences as an individual at the hands of governmental machinery; I know what that can be like.

I would agree it is important in this grave and mortal matter to go into the whole history piece by piece, frankly and candidly, with scientific honesty and freedom of inquiry and thought.  That is the only real way to aim for complete agreement across the political spectrum in the subcontinent. Such an agreement is possible too, and the only real way forward for all, especially the people of J&K, your generation and the future. I am sure my Lahore lectures will be public immediately after they are delivered next month, which you may find of interest.

Clearly we have a number of factual questions for one another whose answers may emerge in time. Rape is an evil thing, and I find what you mention is discussed here. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kunan_Poshpora_incident

Thank you for your comment and suggestion. The solution I have proposed since 2005 is far better than the plebiscite idea you mention. But I am afraid you will have to make a study of my publications here at FB or at my site or in my books, or wait until the Lahore lectures. I also wonder if you are aware that Sheikh Abdullah and Bakshi Ghulam Mohammad *offered a plebiscite* when it was first mentioned in 1948 during the Pashtun tribal invasion from Pakistan but Pakistan balked.

Subroto Roy says the solution he has proposed since 2005 is far better than the plebiscite idea often mentioned. Many are also unaware that Sheikh Abdullah and Bakshi Ghulam Mohammad *offered a plebiscite* when it was first mentioned in 1948 during the Pashtun tribal invasion from Pakistan but Pakistan balked.

Ganai Danish:  It was pandit nehru,who in 1952 addressed the public gathering in lal chowk sgr,promised that the people of jk will be given a chance to decide their future whether they want to be part of india or accede with pakistan.It is worth mentioning that it was india itself who took the case of disputed nature of kashmir to UN by passing a resolution in 1948.But 63 years passed, india is yet to fulfull its promise and has mulishly held on to the uncompromising stance that jk is an integral part of india.

Subroto Roy:  Mr Danish, Thank you for the comment. Pandit Nehru’s Lal Chowk speech may have been 1947/48 during the Pashtun invasion. There is a small pic at my site here http://independentindian.com/2009/03/28/india-is-not-a-monarchy-and-urgently-needs-to-universalize-the-french-concept-of-citoyen-some-personal-thoughts/

By 1952, Sheikh Abdullah had pioneered the J&K Constitution

http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=244956301112

Ganai Danish Respected Dr Roy,1952 or 1948,that isn’t the question.The question is why india uses its military might to crush our movement.By calling itself the world’s largest democrac<z>y,its democracy is buried in kashmir.Our movement is indegenious,peaceful,genuine,and non violent and we will take it to its conclusion

Subroto Roy Mr Danish, Thank you for the comment. The difference between 1948 and 1952 is vital because that is the time Kashmir *made its decision*, and it was a *democratic* decision led by Sheikh-Sahib who had — practically single-handedly — awoken the Muslim masses from their slumber and oppression under the Dogras. Sheikh Abdullah paid the penalty for that most heavily– being jailed by the Dogras numerous times because of it. But even so I think you have raised a critically important question — which is how it is that your generation has become so utterly alienated and disaffected with their political experience of repression, war, terrorism etc that they want to free themselves of it.

Ganai Danish It is very true that late sheikh abdullah traitor fought against dogra rule but he did such a blunder that whatever happened in kashmir since 1989 to 2010,sheikh is responsible for this.He sold kashmir to india and sold the blood of martyrs that were in favour of accession to pakistan.It was the same traitor’s son farooq abdullah who signed noozle to Shaheed Maqbool bhat,the first martyr of kashmir.It was the same farooq abdullah’s leadership in 1989 who killed 1 lac kashmiris and brought POTA,AFSPA,PSA and so on in kashmir.It was the same traitors son omer abdullah who killed 112 innocents in kashmir in just 4 months.So far as the imprisonment is concerned.,It is Syed Ali shah geelani,a vetern leader of kashmir,who spent more than 22 years in jail and is still under house arrest.

Subroto Roy says to Mr Danish, Thanks for this point of view of which I know less than I should. I am glad we have reached a stage so quickly where we may discuss different interpretations of factual events. I reaoet what I have said to Mr Nazir, that I have no hesitation in accepting your saying the situation in recent times has become intolerable for ordinary people. I believe it is the outcome of a process which has evolved over decades in which the peoples and Governments of India, the peoples and Governments of Pakistan, and the peoples and Governments of J&K too, have all contributed. It is something for which *everyone* is responsible, no single person or country or community can be said to be exempt (other than perhaps the gentle people of Laddakh). And all the facts of history and the present have to be understood, and yes felt as well — each and every clear fact. I hope to show how this may be done during my Lahore lectures next month. Cordial regards and thanking you once more.

Sajad Malik ‎@ Mr. Roy, you mean Sheikh Abdullah “offered” Plebiscite? well this is a news to me; as i am wondering on what authority wud they do that? All i have been knowing till now is, Plebiscite was in the offing, had Nehru not insisted that the tribes men from NWFP leave Kashmir and at the same time Jinnah insisting that for the plebiscite to happen, Indian forces need to be out of kashmir first.

Subroto Roy says to Mr Malik, Yes, Sheikh Abdullah and Bakshi Ghulam Mohammad *offered* a plebiscite when it was first mentioned and it was the Pakistanis who balked.

Re. “disputed territory” and “core issue”, as I said yesterday, I do not have to *admit* it because I may have been the first to say so *twenty years ago* when I was almost as young as some of you are now “The core of the continuing dispute between Pakistan and India has been Kashmir, where vast resources have been drained from the budgets of both countries by two large armies facing one another for decades over a disputed boundary”. I do not think the Govt of Pakistan had used the word “core” until that time. Please see p 15 of the book

http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=171926377284&set=a.136688412284.112038.632437284

You may perhaps see that it is a leap of logic from saying Pakistan and India have a disputed boundary to saying as you suggest “So what is the problem if a Kashmiri asks Azadi sir?”. :)

Subroto Roy says to Mr Malik: Mr Malik, Indeed as I have said Sheikh-Sahib and Bakshi did so; you would have to know how ghastly and vicious the tribal invasion from Pakistan was starting on October 22 1947, and how the Rape of Baramulla had proceeded (with Kashmiri women of all communities, Muslim, Sikh and Hindu, being abducted by lorry en masse to be sold in markets in Peshawar etc), to know that Sheikh Abdullah and Bakshi Ghulam Mohammad could confidently predict the outcome at the time of any such plebiscite, which would explain why Liaquat Ali Khan (who had condemned Sheikh as a “Quisling of India”) would have ignored it. I say this having read reports from the original newspapers at the time, and have today asked the editor of that national newspaper to produce a set of reprints of all articles published from, say, the 1946 Cabinet Mission to the Jan-Feb 1949 ceasefire, since all this material is unknown by all the parties, and making it known would contribute to resolving this grave and mortal problem. Do please explain what you mean or Sheikh meant by “Siyasi Awaragardi”; also I would certainly be grateful to learn of your view and that of your friends on the history of J&K between, say, 1952 and the 1965 War.

Sajad Malik: Mr Roy, I have been lately reading a piece done by Haroon Rashid. He pens down all that Kashmiri’s suffered at the hands of tribesmen..looting and arson, even killing of a lady running a convent. He outrightly rejects rape, (anyway thats altogether a diffrent debate). Sheikh Abdullah, wen released from the prison (Imprisoned by Nehru,for taking the plebscite front) scorned his ownself for taking up Plebscite front and termed it as “Siyasi-Awaragardi” (Political Intrigue). For your further enlightment here Mr. Roy;- 1951: Indian holds elections and tries to impose its democratic institution in Kashmir. It is opposed by the United Nations. They pass a resolution to declare elections void and stress on plebiscite. India ignores the opposition blatantly. Sheikh Abdullah wins unopposed and rumors of election rigging plague Kashmiri politics. 1952: Sheikh Abdullah signs the Delhi Agreement on July, 1952. It chalks out state-centre sharing of power and gives abidance to Kashmir to have its own flag. Sheikh Abdullah creates Kashmir centric land reforms which create resentment among the people of Jammu and Ladakh. Delhi Agreement provides the first genuine erosion in international resolution of Kashmir.  Nehru’s Speech: ”On August1952, Jawahar Lal Nehru gives a negating speech contradicting the settlement provided in the Delhi Agreement: “Ultimately – I say this with all deference to this Parliament – the decision will be made in the hearts and minds of the men and women of Kashmir; neither in this Parliament, nor in the United Nations nor by anybody else”  1953-1954: Sheikh Abdullah takes U turns and procrastinates in conforming the accession of Kashmir to India. Sheikh Abdullah is jailed. In August, Bakhshi Ghulam Muhammad is installed in place of Sheikh Abdullah. He officially ratifies Kashmir’s accession with India. On April, 1954, India & Pakistan both agree in appointment of a Plebiscite Administrator.  1956-1957: On 30th October, 1956, J&K Constituent Assembly adopts a fresh constitution, and dissolves the Constituent Assembly, which further defines the relationship of Kashmir with the Indian Dominion. UN strongly condemns the developments and passes a resolution stating such attempts will not result in any final resolution. On 26th January, 1957, the new constitution is made enforceable. Kashmir is now a Republican-Democratic state under Indian Union. 1964: Sheikh Abdullah is released from jail. Jawahar Lal Nehru sends Sheikh Abdullah with a delegation to Pakistan in an effort to find a resolution discourse for Kashmir. In the meantime, masses in Kashmir protest against the implementation of Article 356 & 357, which allows Indian central authority over constituting legislative powers in Kashmir. The special status of Kashmir continues to get eroded. 1965-1971: The nomenclature is changed from ‘Sadr-e-Riyasat’ to Governor and from Prime Minister to Chief Minister. The Governor is now no longer elected locally, and is installed as per the orders of the President of India. This amendment lightens off Kashmir from its special titles. Free & fair elections in the guise of democracy are championed as just causes, and Indian mainstream parties are allowed to contest in the elections. However, these elections aren’t well received by the public. In many cases, international watchdogs accuse India of rigging elections. In 1967, Jammu Autonomy Forum is constituted with the aim of institutionalizing regional autonomy. Excerpts, “chronology of Kashmir conflict” by Naveed Qazi”

Subroto Roy says to Mr Sajad Malik: thank you for this brief chronology which I shall certainly study more carefully. Am I to understand that you and perhaps others with you deny the Rape of Baramullah? Perhaps you mean that the thousands, but thousands, of Kashmiri women of all three communities who were abducted against their will by the tribesmen in lorries and later sold in Peshawar and other markets were not raped but taken in matrimony at their new destinations?

Sajad Malik: Mr Roy, I am not denying anything. All I am saying is that Haroon Rashid (BBC) is rejecting it and that I maintain, its a separate debate. The thing which we are discussing here is that India has no legitimate authority over Kashmir. It’s military might, deciept, savagery has not been able to turn a leaf in Kashmir, despite tens of thousands been killed, despite all the laws it sought from the “once wicked” Britian. I am not a political analyst nor a strategist but with full conviction Mr. Roy, m telling you Kashmir can never be India. Smell our land it smells saffron, m not sure what it smells in India. Comment not intended to hurt your or any Indian’s emotions Mr. Roy. If it inadvertently does, I apologise.

Subroto Roy: Mr Malik, Thank you; no not at all, there is *absolutely* no need for you to apologise in this discussion for anything. Clearly there are many factual disagreements here, as to what happened precisely, who said and did what precisely, and so on, and an exchange of views and references is always constructive. From what you say, you may find of interest these two articles of mine from 2006; the former is “History of J&K” and the latter contains a Brief History of Gilgit too:

http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=152343836125

http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=152345826125

You may also like to see my FB Note giving Sheikh Abdullah in his own words for you and others to judge, here

http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=244956301125

and also Sheikh-Sahib, and Dr Zakir Hussain and Maulana Azad and others here:

http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=153977181125

Your statement “Kashmir can never be India” is perhaps intended to be controversial as it appears to beg the question, though of course you may agree *some* Kashmiris are Indians and wish to be Indians, and I may agree *some* Kashmiris are not Indians and do not wish to be Indians and also *some* Kashmiris are Indians and do not wish to be Indians; there may also be *some* Kashmiris who are not Indians but who wish to be Indians. Cordially.

Subroto Roy

Mr Malik, you are quoting from perhaps Dr Zakir Hussain or Sheikh Abdullah, not from my words. Secondly, are you saying Pakistan did not invade J&K in 1947? Britain did? I would agree there was a British-induced coup d’etat in Gilgit, but I trust you do not deny the whole history of the (then new) Pakistan’s military and political forces causing the vicious and ghastly Pashtun invasion along the Nowshera Road commencing October 22 1947. Modern Pakistan’s most eminent historians may agree with me I am afraid as to what happened as a matter of fact! You and I may not be able to progress much with conversation at this rate if our factual histories are so far apart as at present.. :) But rest assured, all may become clear after my Lahore lectures next month, or at least all of my analysis and assessment of what happened and prescription of what may be best done now for everyone. I shall try to comment further on your statement later in the day.

Sajad Malik Sir, I am not saying Britian carried out the invasion *laughs*. All, m saying is, General Gracey was heading the Pak army at the time of invasion and there has been no evidence so far, to establish a link b/n Pak army and the tribes men. I can furnish to you the reference of what I assert. shall inshallah pray for your lahore lecture, and hope our thinking and understanding converge as per the aspirations of me, the prime stake holder..and a kashmiri. (smiles)

Subroto Roy  Mr Malik, I am grateful for the clarification :) — though as I have said, there *was* a British-induced coup in Gilgit, and you may also find my article “Pakistan’s Allies” of interest about the US and UK seeing themselves in battle against the old USSR etc.

Suppose I said to you and your friends that in fact Sheikh-Sahib (and his mentor at the time Jawaharlal Nehru) were influenced by socialism and, at one remove perhaps by Soviet communism — and *that* is why they were against the Dogra regime?  While the Hurriyat’s predecessor, Muslim Conference, were *opposed* to Sheikh Abdullah, and because the Dogras were also opposed to Sheikh-Sahib, the Muslim Conference’s Hamidullah Khan as of May 22-24 1947 said they wanted to not only preserve the Dogra regime but make him an international sovereign so he could be called “Your Majesty” instead of merely “Your Highness”? :) !  And in that they were, oddly enough, joined by many in the Hindu and Sikh minorities who saw the Dogras as protecting them from Sheikh Sahib’s secular majoritarianism, as well as by perhaps British Conservatives like Churchill as well as Mr Jinnah…. History yields some unusual and paradoxical things…. :)  Re your offer to furnish a reference that “there has been no evidence so far, to establish a link b/n Pak army and the tribesmen” I would be most grateful for this. The classic work on it has been by the late General Akbar Khan of the Pakistan Army who was an author of the invasion,  http://openlibrary.org/books/OL15997912M/Raiders_in_Kashmir.

I have yet to own a copy of this book though am aware of its contents.   I am most grateful for your good wishes for Lahore! I certainly need them, and I assure you, if you send me an email at my site, I shall send you a copy of what I say there as soon as possible after it is said. And indeed, I *completely* agree with you that the ordinary people of J&K of all communities have suffered most from this terrible and awful state of affairs, and their material and moral wellbeing needs most important and urgent relief. Cordially.

I wrote & publicized a document “An Economic Solution to Kashmir” in Washington back in 1993, which referred for the first time to ideas of a condominium, an Andorra solution etc….This seemed at the time a logical result of the UH Manoa Pakistan project.   But in retrospect it has seemed naive and uninformed.   I’m afraid I think Mr Kasuri has been overoptimistic about the robustness of the near-agreement he suggests was reached some years ago.  .


On Pakistan and the Theory & Practice of the Islamic State: An Excerpt from the Munir Report of 1954

On Pakistan and the Theory & Practice of the Islamic State: An Excerpt from the Munir Report of 1954

From REPORT of THE COURT OF INQUIRY constituted under PUNJAB ACT II OF 1954 to enquire into the PUNJAB DISTURBANCES OF 1953 “Munir Report”

“ISLAMIC STATE
It has been repeatedly said before us that implicit in the demand for Pakistan was the demand for an Islamic State. Some speeches of important leaders who were striving for Pakistan undoubtedly lend themselves to this construction. These leaders while referring to an Islamic State or to a State governed by Islamic laws perhaps had in their minds the pattern of a legal structure based on or mixed up with Islamic dogma, personal law, ethics and institutions. No one who has given serious thought to the introduction of a religious State in Pakistan has failed to notice the tremendous difficulties with which any such scheme must be confronted. Even Dr. Muhammad Iqbal, who must be considered to be the first thinker who conceived of the possibility of a consolidated North Western Indian Muslim State, in the course of his presidential address to the Muslim League in 1930 said:

“Nor should the Hindus fear that the creation of autonomous Muslim States will mean the introduction of a kind of religious rule in such States. The principle that each group is entitled to free development on its own lines is not inspired by any feeling of narrow communalism”.

When we come to deal with the question of responsibility we shall have the occasion to point out that the most important of the parties who are now clamouring for the enforcement of the three demands on religious grounds were all against the idea of an Islamic State. Even Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi of Jama’at-i-Islami was of the view that the form of Government in the new Muslim State, if it ever came into existence, could only be secular.

Before the Partition, the first public picture of Pakistan that the Quaid-i-Azam gave to the world was in the course of an interview in New Delhi with Mr. Doon Campbell, Reuter’s Correspondent. The Quaid-i-Azam said that the new State would be a modern democratic State, with sovereignty resting in the people and the members of the new nation having equal rights of citizenship regardless of their religion, caste or creed. When Pakistan formally appeared on the map, the Quaid-i-Azam in his memorable speech of 11th August 1947 to the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan, while stating the principle on which the new State was to be founded, said:—

“All the same, in this division it was impossible to avoid the question of minorities being in one Dominion or the other. Now that was unavoidable. There is no other solution. Now what shall we do? Now, if we want to make this great State of Pakistan happy and prosperous we should wholly and solely concentrate on the well-being of the people, and specially of the masses and the poor. If you will work in co-operation, forgetting the past, burying the hatchet, you are bound to succeed. If you change your past and work together in a spirit that every one of you, no matter to what community he belongs, no matter what relations he had with you in the past, no matter what is his colour, caste or creed, is first, second and last a citizen of this State with equal rights, privileges and obligations., there
will be no end to the progress you will make. “I cannot emphasise it too much. We should begin to work in that spirit and in course of time all these angularities of the majority and minority communities—the Hindu community and the Muslim community— because even as regards Muslims you have Pathana, Punjabis, Shias, Sunnis and so on and among the Hindus you have Brahmins, Vashnavas, Khatris, also Bengalis, Madrasis and so on—will vanish. Indeed if you ask me this has been the biggest hindrance in the way of India to attain its freedom and independence and but for this we would have been free peoples long long ago. No power can hold another nation, and specially a nation of 400 million souls in subjection; nobody could have conquered you, and even if it had happened, nobody could have continued its hold on you for any length of time but for this (Applause). Therefore, we must learn a lesson from this. You are free; you are free to go to your temples, you are free to go to your mosques or to any other places of worship in this State of Pakistan. You may belong to any religion or caste or creed— that has nothing to do with the business of the State (Hear, hear). As you know, history shows that in England conditions sometime ago were much worse than those prevailing in India today. The Roman Catholics and the Protestants persecuted each other. Even now there are some States in existence where there are discriminations made and bars imposed against a particular class. Thank God we are not starting in those days. We are starting in the days when there is no discrimination, no distinction between one community and another, no discrimination between one caste or creed and another. We are starting with this fundamental principle that we are all citizens and equal citizens of one State (Loud applause). The people of England in course of time had to face the realities of the situation and had to discharge the responsibilities and burdens placed upon them by the Government of their country and they went through that fire step by step. Today you might say with justice that Roman Catholics and Protestants do not exist: what exists now is that every man is a citizen, an equal citizen, of Great Britain and they are all members of the nation. “Now, I think we should keep that in front of us as our ideal and you will find that in course of time Hindus would cease to be Hindus and Muslims would cease to be Muslims, not in the religious sense, because that is the personal faith of each individual, but in the political sense as citizens of the State”.

The Quaid-i-Azam was the founder of Pakistan and the occasion on which he thus spoke was the first landmark in the history of Pakistan. The speech was intended both for his own people including non-Muslims and the world, and its object was to define as clearly as possible the ideal to the attainment of which the new State was to devote all its energies. There are repeated references in this speech to the bitterness of the past and an appeal to forget and change the past and to bury the hatchet. The future subject of the State is to be a citizen with equal rights, privileges and obligations, irrespective of colour, caste, creed or community. The word ‘nation’ is used more than once and religion is stated to have nothing to do with the business of the State and to be merely a matter of personal faith for the individual.

We asked the ulama whether this conception of a State was acceptable to them and everyone of them replied in an unhesitating negative, including the Ahrar and erstwhile Congressites with whom before the Partition this conception was almost a part of their faith.

If Maulana Amin Ahsan Islahi’s evidence correctly represents the view of Jama’at-i-Islami, a State based on this idea is the creature of the devil, and he is confirmed in this by several writings of his chief, Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi, the founder of the jama’at. None of the ulama can tolerate a State which is based on nationalism and all that it implies; with them millat and all that it connotes can alone be the determining factor in State activity.

The Quaid-i-Azam’s conception of a modern national State, it is alleged, became obsolete with the passing of the Objectives Resolution on 12th March 1949; but it has been freely admitted that this Resolution, though grandiloquent in words, phrases and clauses, is nothing but a hoax and that not only does it not contain even a semblance of the embryo of an Islamic State but its provisions, particularly those relating to fundamental rights, are directly opposed to the principles of an Islamic State.

FOUNDATIONS OF ISLAMIC STATE
What is then the Islamic State of which everybody talks but nobody thinks? Before we seek to discover an answer to this question, we must have a clear conception of the scope and function of the State.

The ulama were divided in their opinions when they were asked to cite some precedent of an Islamic State in Muslim history. Thus, though Hafiz Kifayat Husain, the Shia divine, held out as his ideal the form of Government during the Holy Prophet’s time, Maulana Daud Ghaznavi also included in his precedent the days of the Islamic Republic, of Umar bin Abdul Aziz, Salah-ud-Din Ayyubi of Damascus, Sultan Mahmud of Ghazni, Muhammad Tughlaq and Aurangzeb and the present regime in Saudi Arabia. Most of them, however, relied on the form of Government during the Islamic Republic from 632 to 661 A. D., a period of less than thirty years, though some of them also added the very short period of Umar bin Abdul Aziz.

Maulana Abdul Haamid Badayuni stated that the details of the ideal State would be worked out by the ulama while Master Taj-ud-Din Ansari’s confused notion of an Islamic State may be gathered from the following portion of his interrogation :—

“Q.—Were you also in the Khilafat movement ?
A.—Yes.
Q.—When did the Khilafat movement stop in India ?
A.—In 1923. This was after the Turks had declared their country to be a secular State.
Q.—If you are told that the Khilafat movement continued long after the Turks had abolished Khilafat, will that be correct?
A.—As far as I remember, the Khilafat movement finished with the abolition of the Khilafat by the Turks.
Q.—You are reported to have been a member of the Khilafat movement and having made speeches. Is it correct ?
A.—It could not be correct.
Q.—Was the Congress interested in Khilafat ?
A.— Yes.
Q.—Was Khilafat with you a matter of religious conviction or just a political movement ?
A.— It was purely a religious movement.
Q.— Did the Khilafat movement have the support of Mr. Gandhi ?
A.—Yes.
Q.— What was the object of the Khilafat movement ?
A.— The Britisher was injuring the Khilafat institution in Turkey and the Musalman was aggrieved by this attitude of the Britisher.
Q.— Was not the object of the movement to resuscitate the Khilafat among the    Musalmans ?
A.—No.
Q.— Is Khilafat with you a necessary part of Muslim form of Government ?
A.—Yes.
Q.— Are you, therefore, in favour of having a Khilafat in Pakistan ?
A.—Yes.
Q.— Can there be more than one Khalifa of the Muslims ?
A.— No.
Q.— Will the Khalifa of Pakistan be the Khalifa of all the Muslims of the world ?
A.— He should be but cannot be.”

Throughout the three thousand years over which political thought extends, and such thought in its early stages cannot be separated from religion, two questions have invariably presented themselves for consideration : —

(1) what are the precise functions of the State ? and
(2) who shall control the State ?

If the true scope of the activities of the State is the welfare, temporal or spiritual or both of the individual, then the first question directly gives rise to the bigger question:

What is the object of human life and the ultimate destiny of man ? On this, widely divergent views have prevailed, not at different times but at one and the same time. The pygmies of equatorial West Africa still believe that their God Komba has sent them into the forest to hunt and dance and sing. The Epicureans meant very much the same when they said that the object of human life is to drink and eat and be merry, for death denies such pleasures. The utilitarians base their institutions on the assumption that the object of human life is to experience pleasant sensations of mind and body, irrespective of what is to come hereafter. The Stoics believed in curbing and reducing all physical desires, and Diogenes found a tub good enough to live in. German philosophers think that the individual lives for the State and that therefore the object of life is service of the State in all that it might decide to undertake and achieve. Ancient Hindu philosophers believed in the logic of the fist with its natural consequence, the law of natural selection and the struggle for survival. The Semitic theory of State, whether Jewish, Christian or Islamic, has always held that the object of human life is to prepare ourselves for the next life and that, therefore, prayer and good works are the only object of life. Greek philosophers beginning with Socrates thought that the object of human life was to engage in philosophical meditation with a view to discovering the great truths that lie in nature and that the business of the others is to feed the philosophers engaged in that undertaking.

Islam emphasises the doctrine that life in this world is not the only life given to man but that eternal life begins after the present existence comes to an end, and that the status of a human being in the next world will depend upon his beliefs and actions in this world. As the present life is not an end in itself but merely a means to an end, not only the individual but also the State, as opposed to the secular theory which bases all political and economic institutions on a disregard of their consequences on the next life, should strive for human conduct which ensures for a person better status in the next world.

According to this theory Islam is the religion which seeks to attain that object. Therefore the question immediately arises : What is Islam and who is a momin or a Muslim ? We put this question to the ulama and we shall presently refer to their answers to this question. But we cannot refrain from saying here that it was a matter of infinite regret to us that the ulama whose first duty should be to have settled views on this subject, were hopelessly disagreed among themselves.

Apart from how these learned divines have expressed themselves, we conceive of Islam as a system that covers, as every systematic religion must, the following five topics :—
(1) the dogma, namely, the essentials of belief ;
(2) the cult, namely, religious rites and observances which a person must
perform ;
(3) ethics, i. e. rules of moral conduct ;
(4) institutions, social, economic and political ; and
(5) law proper.

The essential basis of the rules on all these subjects is revelation and not reason, though both may coincide. This coincidence, however, is accidental because human reasoning may be faulty and ultimate reason is known only to God, Who sends His message to humanity through His chosen messengers for the direction and guidance of the people. One must, therefore, accept the dogma, observe the cult, follow the ethics, obey the law and establish institutions which God has revealed, though their reason may not be apparent—nay even if they be opposed to human reason. Since an error by God is an impossibility, anything that God has revealed, whether its subject be something occult or preternatural, history, finance, law, worship or something which according to human thought admits of scientific treatment as for instance, birth of man, evolution, cosmology, or astronomy, has got to be accepted as absolute truth. The test of reason is not the acid
test and a denial of this amounts to a denial of the supreme wisdom and designs of Allah—it is kufr. Now God has revealed Himself from time to time to His favoured people of whom our Holy Prophet was the last. That revelation is contained in the Qur’an and covers the five topics mentioned above. The true business of a person who believes in Islam is therefore to understand, believe in and act upon that revelation. The people whom God chooses as medium for the transmission of His messages are rasuls (messengers) or nabis (prophets). Since every action or saying of a prophet is, in the case of our own Holy Prophet it certainly was, prompted by Allah, it has the same degree of inerrancy as the formal revelation itself, because prophets are ma’sum, incapable of doing or saying something which is opposed to Divine wishes. These sayings and actions are sunna having the same infallibility as the Qur’an. The record of this sunna is hadith which is to be found in several books which were compiled by Muslim scholars after long, laborious and careful research extending over several generations.

The word hadith means a record of actions or sayings of the Prophet and his companions. At first the sahaba. i. e. people who had lived in the society of the Prophet, were the best authority for a knowledge of the sunna. Later people had to be content with the communications of the tabi’un, i. e. successors, people of the first generation after the Holy Prophet who had received their information from the sahaba, and then in the following generations with the accounts of the so-called successors of the successors (tabi’ul-tabi’un), i.e. people of the second generation after the Holy Prophet, who had concerted with the successors. Marfu’ is a tradition which contains a statement about the Prophet ; mawquf, a tradition that refers only to the sayings or doings of the sahaba ; and maqtu’ a tradition which does not at most go further back than the first generation after the Holy Prophet and deals only with sayings or doings of tabi’un. In some of the ahadith
the actual word of God is to be found. Any such tradition is designated Hadith-i-Qudsi or Ilahi as distinguished from an ordinary Hadith-i-Nabvi.

A very large portion of sayings ascribed to the Prophet deals with the ahkam (legal professions), religious obligations, halal and haram (what is allowed and forbidden), with ritual purity, laws regarding food and criminal and civil law. Further they deal with dogma, retribution at the Last Judgment, hell and paradise, angels, creation, revelations, the earlier prophets. Many traditions also contain edifying sayings and moral teachings by the Holy Prophet. The importance of ahadith was realised from the very beginning and they were not only committed to memory but in some cases were reduced to writing. The work of compilation of hadith began in the third century after the Hijra and the Sihah Sitta were all compiled in that century. These are the musannifs of —
(1) Al-Bukhari, died 256/870,
(2) Muslim, died 261/875,
(3) Abu Dawud, died 275/888,
(4) Al-Tirmizi, died 279/892,
(5) All Nasa’i, died 303/915, and
(6) Ibn-i-Maja, died 273/886.

According to modern laws of evidence, including our own, the ahadith are inadmissible evidence of sunna because each of them contains several links of hearsay, but as authority on law they are admissible pro prio vigore. The merit of these collections lies not so much in the fact that (as is often wrongly stated) their authors decided for the first time which of the numerous traditions in circulation were genuine and which false but rather in the fact that they brought together everything that was recognised as genuine in orthodox circles in those days.

The Shias judge hadith from their own stand-point and only consider such traditions reliable as are based on the authority of Ali and his adherents. They have, therefore, their own works on the subject and hold the following five works in particularly high esteem—
(1) Al-Kafi of Muhammad b. Yaqub Al-Kulini, died 328/939,
(2) Man La Yastahdiruhu’ul-Fakih of Muhammad b. Ali b. Babuya Al-Kummi,
died 381/991,
(3) Tahdib Al-Ahkam,
(4) Al-Istibsar Fi-Ma’khtalafa Fihi’l-Akhbar (extract from the preceding) of
Muhammad Altusi, died 459/1067, and
(5) Nahj Al-Balagha (alleged sayings of Ali) of Ali b. Tahir Al-Sharif Al-
Murtaza, died 436/1044 (or of his brother Radi Al-Din Al-Baghdadi.)

After the ritual, the dogma and the most important political and social institutions had taken definite shape in the second and third centuries, there arose a certain communis opinio regarding the reliability of most transmitters of tradition and the value of their statement. The main principles of doctrine had already been established in the writings of Malik b. Anas, Al-Shafi’i and other scholars regarded as authoritative in different circles and mainly on the authority of traditional sayings of the Holy Prophet. In the long run no one dared to doubt the truth of these traditions and this almost conclusive presumption of truth has since continued to be attached to the ahadith compiled in the Sihah Sitta.

We have so far arrived at this result that any rule on any subject that may be derived from the Qur’an or the sunna of the Holy Prophet is binding on every Musalman. But since the only evidence of sunna is the hadith, the words sunna and hadith have become mixed up with, and indistinguishable from, each other with the result that the expression Qur’an and hadith is not infrequently employed where the intention is to refer to Qur’an and sunna.

At this stage another principle, equally basic, comes into operation, and that is that Islam is the final religion revealed by God, complete and exhaustive in all respects, and that God will not abrogate, detract from or add to this religion (din) any more than He will send a fresh messenger. The din having been perfected (Akmalto lakum dinokum, Sura V, verse 3), there remains no need for any new code repealing, modifying or amplifying the original code; nor for any fresh messenger or message. In this sense, therefore, prophethood ceased with the Holy Prophet and revelation stopped for ever. This is the doctrine of the cessation of wahi-i-nubuwwat.

If the proposition that Muslim dogma, ethics and institutions, etc., are all based on the doctrine of inerrancy, whether such inerrancy lies in the Qur’an, the sunna, ijma’ or ijtihad-i-mutlaq, is fully comprehended, the various deductions that follow from it will be easily understandable. As the ultimate test of truth, whether the matter be one of a ritual or political or social or economic nature, is revelation and revelation has to be gathered from the Qur’an, and the sunna carries almost the same degree of inerrancy as revelation and the only evidence of sunna is hadith, the first duty of those who desire to establish an Islamic State will be to discover the precise rule applicable to the existing circumstances whether that rule is to be found in the Qur’an or hadith. Obviously the persons most suited for the purpose would be those who have made the Qur’an and hadith their lifelong study, namely, among the Sunnies, the ulama, and among the Shias, the mujtahids who are the spokesmen of the hidden Imam, the ruler de jure divino. The function of
these divines would be to engage themselves in discovering rules applicable to particular situations and they will be engaged in a task similar to that in which Greek philosophers were engaged, with only this difference that whereas the latter thought that all truth lay in nature which had merely to be discovered by individual effort, the ulama and the mujtahids will have to get at the truth that lies in the holy Book and the books of hadith.

The ulama Board which was recommended by the Basic Principles Committee was a logical recognition of this principle, and the true objection against that Board should indeed have been that the Board was too inadequate a mechanism to implement the principle which had brought that body into existence.

Ijma’ means concurrence of the mujtahids of the people, i.e., of those who have a right, in virtue of knowledge, to form a judgment of their own, after the death of the Holy Prophet. The authority of ijma’ rests on the principle of a divine protection against error and is founded on a basal tradition of the Holy Prophet, “My people will never agree in error”, reported in Ibn Maja, By this procedure points which had been in dispute were fixed, and when fixed, they became an essential part of the faith and disbelief in them an act of unbelief (kufr). The essential point to remember about ijma’ is that it represents the agreement of the mujtahids and that the agreement of the masses is especially excluded.

Thus ijma’ has not only fixed unsettled points but has changed settled doctrines of the greatest importance.

The distinction between ijma’ and ijtihad is that whereas the former is collective, the latter is individual. Ijtihad means the exerting of one’s self to the utmost degree to form an opinion in a case or as to a rule of law. This is done by applying analogy to the Qur’an and the sunna. Ijtihad did not originally involve inerrancy, its result being always zann or fallible opinion. Only combined ijtihad led to ijma, and was inerrant. But this broad ijtihad soon passed into special ijtihad of those who had a peculiar right to form judgments. When later doctors looked back to the founding of the four legal schools, they assigned to their founders an ijtihad of the first rank (ijtihad-i-mutlaq). But from time to time individuals appeared who returned to the earliest meaning of ijtihad and claimed for themselves the right to form their own opinion from first principles. One of these was the Hanbalite Ibn Taimiya (died 728). Another was Suyuti (died 911) in whom the claim to ijtihad unites with one to be the mujaddid or renewer of religion in his century. At every time there must exist at least one mujtahid, was his contention, just as in every century there must come a mujaddid.

In Shia Islam there are still absolute mujtahids because they are regarded as the spokesmen of the hidden Imam. Thus collective ijtihad leads to ijma’, and the basis of ijma’ is divine protection against error—inerrancy.

ESSENTIALS OF ISLAMIC STATE
Since the basis of Islamic law is the principle of inerrancy of revelation and of the Holy Prophet, the law to be found in the Qur’an and the sunna is above all man-made laws, and in case of conflict between the two, the latter, irrespective of its nature, must yield to the former. Thus, provided there be a rule in the Qur’an or the sunna on a matter which according to our conceptions falls within the region of Constitutional Law or International Law, the rule must be given effect to unless that rule itself permits a departure from it. Thus no distinction exists in Islamic law between Constitutional Law and other law, the whole law to be found in the Qur’an and the sunna being a part of the law of the land for Muslim subjects of the State. Similarly if there be a rule in the Qur’an or the sunna relating to the State’s relations with other States or to the relations of Muslim subjects of the State with other States or the subjects of those States, the rule will have the same superiority of sanction as any other law to be found in the Qur’an or the
sunna.

Therefore if Pakistan is or is intended to be converted into an Islamic State in the
true sense of the word, its Constitution must contain the following five provisions:—

(1) that all laws to be found in the Qur’an or the sunna shall be deemed to be a
part of the law of the land for Muslims and shall be enforced accordingly;
(2) that unless the Constitution itself is framed by ijma’-i-ummat, namely, by the
agreement of the ulama and mujtahids of acknowledged status, any
provision in the Constitution which is repugnant to the Qur’an or sunna
shall to the extent of the repugnancy be void;
(3) that unless the existing laws of Pakistan are adapted by ijma’-i-ummat of the
kind mentioned above, any provision in the existing law which is contrary
to the Qur’an or sunna shall to the extent of the repugnancy be void;
(4) that any provision in any future law which is repugnant to Qur’an or sunna
shall be void;
(5) that no rule of International Law and no provision in any convention or treaty
to which Pakistan is a party, which is contrary to the Qur’an or the sunna
shall be binding on any Muslim in Pakistan.

SOVEREIGNTY AND DEMOCRACY IN ISLAMIC STATE
That the form of Government in Pakistan, if that form is to comply with the principles of Islam, will not be democratic is conceded by the ulama. We have already explained the doctrine of sovereignty of the Qur’an and the sunna. The Objectives Resolution rightly recognised this position when it recited that all sovereignty rests with God Almighty alone. But the authors of that Resolution misused the words ‘sovereign’ and ‘democracy’ when they recited that the Constitution to be framed was for a sovereign State in which principles of democracy as enunciated by Islam shall be fully observed.

It may be that in the context in which they were used, these words could not be misunderstood by those who are well versed in Islamic principles, but both these words were borrowed from western political philosophy and in that sense they were both wrongly used in the Resolution. When it is said that a country is sovereign, the implication is that its people or any other group of persons in it are entitled to conduct the affairs of that country in any way they like and untrammelled by any considerations except those of expediency and policy. An Islamic State, however, cannot in this sense be sovereign, because it will not be competent to abrogate, repeal or do away with any law in the Qur’an or the sunna. Absolute restriction on the legislative power of a State is a restriction on the sovereignty of the people of that State and if the origin of this restriction lies elsewhere than in the will of the people, then to the extent of that restriction the sovereignty of the State and its people is necessarily taken away. In an Islamic State, sovereignty, in its essentially juristic sense, can only rest with Allah. In the same way, democracy means the rule of the demos, namely, the people, directly by them as in ancient Greece and Rome, or indirectly through chosen representatives as in modern democracies. If the power of the people in the framing of the Constitution or in the framing of the laws or in the sphere of executive action is subject to certain immutable rules, it cannot be said that they can pass any law that they like, or, in the exercise of executive functions, do whatever they like. Indeed if the legislature in an Islamic State is a sort of ijma’, the masses are expressly disqualified from taking part in it because ijma’-i-ummat in Islamic jurisprudence is restricted to ulama and mujtahids of acknowledged status and does not at all extend, as in democracy, to the populace.

OTHER INCIDENTS OF ISLAMIC STATE ACCORDING TO ULAMA
In the preceding pages we have attempted to state as clearly as we could the principles on which a religious State must be built if it is to be called an Islamic State. We now proceed to state some incidents of such State, with particular reference to the ulamas’ conception of it.

LEGISLATURE AND LEGISLATION
Legislature in its present sense is unknown to the Islamic system. The religiopolitical system which is called din-i-Islam is a complete system which contains in itself the mechanism for discovering and applying law to any situation that may arise. During the Islamic Republic there was no legislature in its modern sense and for every situation or emergency that arose law could be discovered and applied by the ulama. The law had been made and was not to be made, the only function of those entrusted with the administration of law being to discover the law for the purposes of the particular case, though when enunciated and applied it formed a precedent for others to follow. It is wholly incorrect, as has been suggested from certain quarters, that in a country like Pakistan, which consists of different communities, Muslim and non-Muslim, and where representation is allowed to non-Muslims with a right to vote on every subject that comes up, the legislature is a form of ijma’ or ijtihad, the reason being that ijtihad is not collective but only individual, and though ijma’ is collective, there is no place in it for those who are not experts in the knowledge of the law. This principle at once rules out the infidels (kuffar) whether they be people of Scriptures (ahl-i-kitab) or idolators (mushrikeen).

Since Islam is a perfect religion containing laws, express or derivable by ijma’ or ijtihad, governing the whole field of human activity, there is in it no sanction for what may, in the modern sense, be called legislation.

Questioned on this point Maulana Abul Hasanat, President, Jami’at-ul-Ulama-i-Pakistan says :—

“Q.—Is the institution of legislature as distinguished from the institution of a
person or body of persons entrusted with the interpretation of law, an
integral part of an Islamic State?
A.—No. Our law is complete and merely requires interpretation by those who are
experts in it. According to my belief no question can arise the law relating
to which cannot be discovered from the Qur’an or the hadith.
Q.—Who were Sahib-ul-hall-i-wal-aqd
A.—They were the distinguished ulama of the time. These persons attained their
status by reason of the knowledge of the law. They were not in any way
analogous or similar to the legislature in modern democracy.”

The same view was expressed by Amir-i-Shari’at Sayyad Ata Ullah Shah Bukhari
in one of his speeches reported in the ‘Azad’ of 22nd April, 1947, in the course of which he said that our din is complete and perfect and that it amounts to kufr to make more laws.

Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi, however, is of the opinion that legislation in the true sense is possible in an Islamic State on matters which are not covered by the Qur’an, the sunna, or previous ijma’ and he has attempted to explain his point by reference to the institution of a body of persons whom the Holy Prophet, and after him the khulafa consulted on all matters relating to affairs of State. The question is one of some difficulty and great importance because any institution of legislature will have to be reconciled with the claim put forward by Maulana Abul Hasanat and some other religious divines that Islam is a perfect and exhaustive code wide enough to furnish an answer to any question that may arise relating to any human activity, and that it does not know of any “unoccupied field” to be filled by fresh legislation. There is no doubt that Islam enjoins consultation and that not only the Holy Prophet but also the first four caliphs and even their successors resorted to consultation with the leading men of the time, who for their knowledge of the law and piety could well be relied upon.

In the inquiry not much has been disclosed about the Majlis-i-Shura except what is contained in Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi’s written statement which he supplied to the Court at its request. That there was a body of men who were consulted is true, but whether this was a standing body and whether its advice had any legal or binding force, seems somewhat doubtful. These men were certainly not elected in the modern way, though their representative character cannot be disputed. Their advice was certainly asked ad hoc, but that they were competent to make law as the modern legislatures make laws is certainly not correct. The decisions taken by them undoubtedly served as precedents and were in the nature of ijma’, which is not legislation but the application of an existing law to a particular case. When consulted in affairs of State, their functions were truly in the nature of an advice given by a modern cabinet but such advice is not law but only a decision.

Nor can the legislature in a modern State correspond to ijma’ because as we have already pointed out, the legislature legislates while the ulama of Majlis-i-Shura who were called upon to determine what should be the decision on a particular point which was not covered by the Qur’an and the sunna, merely sought to discover and apply the law and not to promulgate the law, though the decision when taken had to be taken not only for the purposes of the particular case but for subsequent occasions as a binding precedent.

An intriguing situation might arise if the Constitution Act provided that any provision of it, if it was inconsistent with the Qur’an or the sunna, would be void, and the intra vires of a law made by the legislature were questioned before the Supreme Court on the ground that the institution of legislature itself was contrary to the Qur’an and the sunna.

POSITION OF NON-MUSLIMS
The ground on which the removal of Chaudhri Zafrullah Khan and other Ahmadis occupying key positions in the State is demanded is that the Ahmadis are non-Muslims and that therefore like zimmies in an Islamic State they are not eligible for appointment to higher offices in the State. This aspect of the demands has directly raised a question about the position of non-Muslims in Pakistan if we are to have an Islamic Constitution.

According to the leading ulama the position of non-Muslims in the Islamic State of Pakistan will be that of zimmies and they will not be full citizens of Pakistan because they will not have the same rights as Muslims They will have no voice in the making of the law, no right to administer the law and no right to hold public offices.

A full statement of this position will be found in the evidence of Maulana Abul Hasanat Sayyad Muhammad Ahmad Qadri, Maulana Ahmad Ali, Mian Tufail Muhammad and Maulana Abdul Haamid Badayuni. Maulana Abul Hasanat on being questioned on the subject stated as follows :—

“Q.—If we were to have an Islamic State in Pakistan, what will be the position of the kuffar (non-Muslims)? Will they have a voice in the making of laws, the right of administering the law and the right to hold public offices?
A.—Their position will be that of zimmies. They will have no voice in the making of laws, no right to administer the law and no right to hold public offices.
Q.—In an Islamic State can the head of the State delegate any part of his powers to kuffar?
A.—No.”

Maulana Ahmad Ali, when questioned, said:—
“Q.—if we were to have an Islamic State in Pakistan, what will be the position of the kuffar? Will they have a hand in the making of the law, the right to administer the law and the right to hold public offices ?
A.—Their position will be that of zimmies. They will have no say in the making of law and no right to administer the law. Government may, however, permit them to hold any public office”.

Mian Tufail Muhammad stated as follows :—
“Q.—Read the article on minorities’ rights in the ‘Civil and Military Gazette’ of 13th October, 1953, and say whether it correctly represents your view of an Islamic State? (It was stated in the articles that minorities would have the same rights as Muslims).
A.—I have read this article and do not acknowledge these rights for the Christians or other non-Muslims in Pakistan if the State is founded on the ideology of the Jama’at”.

The confusion on this point in the mind of Maulana Abdul Haamid Badayuni, President, Jami’at-ul-Ulama-i-Pakistan, is apparent from the following: —

“Q.—Have you ever read the aforesaid speech (the speech of the Quaid-i-Azam to the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan on 11th August, 1947)?
A.—Yes, I have read that speech.
Q.—Do you still agree with the conception of Pakistan that the Quaid-i-Azam presented to the Constituent Assembly in this speech in which he said that thereafter there would be only one Pakistan nation, consisting of Muslims and non-Muslims, having equal civic rights, without any distinction of race, religion or creed and that religion would be merely a private affair of the individual ?
A.—I accept the principle that all communities, whether Muslims or non-Muslims, should have, according to their population, proper representation in the administration of the State and legislation, except that non-Muslims cannot be taken in the army or the judiciary or be appointed as Ministers or to other posts involving the reposing of confidence.
Q.—Are you suggesting that the position of non-Muslims would be that of zimmies or any better ?
A.—No. By zimmies are meant non-Muslim people of lands which have been conquered by an Islamic State, and the word is not applicable to non-Muslim minorities already living in an Islamic State. Such minorities are called mu’ahids, i.e. those people with whom some agreement has been made.
Q.—What will be their status if there is no agreement with them ?
A.—In that case such communities cannot have any rights of citizenship.
Q.—Will the non-Muslim communities inhabiting Pakistan be called by you as mu’ahids?
A.—No, not in the absence of an agreement with them. To my knowledge there is no such agreement with such communities in Pakistan.”

So, according to the evidence of this learned divine, the non-Muslims of Pakistan will neither be citizens nor will they have the status of zimmies or of mu’ahids. During the Islamic Republic, the head of the State, the khalifa, was chosen by a system of election, which was wholly different from the present system of election based on adult or any other form of popular suffrage. The oath of allegiance (ba’it) rendered to him possessed a sacramental virtue, and on his being chosen by the consensus of the people (ijma’-ul-ummat) he became the source of all channels of legitimate Government. He and he alone then was competent to rule, though he could delegate his powers to deputies and collect around him a body of men of outstanding piety and learning, called Majlis-i-Shura or Ahl-ul-Hall-i-wal-Aqd. The principal feature of this system was that the kuffar, for reasons which are too obvious and need not be stated, could not be admitted to this majlis and the power which had vested in the khalifa could not be delegated to the kuffar. The khalifa was the real head of the State, all power vesting in him and not a powerless individual like the President of a modern democratic State who is merely to sign the record of decisions taken by the Prime Minister and his Cabinet. He could not appoint non-Muslims to important posts, and could give them no place either in the interpretation or the administration of the law, the making of the law by them, as already pointed out, being a legal impossibility.

This being the position, the State will have to devise some machinery by which the distinction between a Muslim and a non-Muslim may be determined and its consequences enforced. The question, therefore, whether a person is or is not a Muslim will be of fundamental importance, and it was for this reason that we asked most of the leading ulama, to give their definition of a Muslim, the point being that if the ulama of the various sects believed the Ahmadis to be kafirs, they must have been quite clear in their minds not only about the grounds of such belief but also about the definition of a Muslim because the claim that a certain person or community is not within the pale of Islam implies on the part of the claimant an exact conception of what a Muslim is. The result of this part of the inquiry, however, has been anything but satisfactory, and if considerable confusion exists in the minds of our ulama on such a simple matter, one can easily imagine what the differences on more complicated matters will be. Below we reproduce the definition of a Muslim given by each alim in his own words. This definition was asked after it had been clearly explained to each witness that he was required to give the irreducible minimum conditions which, a person must satisfy to be entitled to be called a Muslim and that the definition was to be on the principle on which a term in grammar is defined.

Here is the result : —

Maulana Abul Hasanat Muhammad Ahmad Qadri, President, Jami’at-ul-Ulamai-
Pakistan —
“Q.— What is the definition of a Muslim ?
A — (1) He must believe in the Unity of God.
(2) He must believe in the prophet of Islam to be a true prophet as well as in all other prophets who have preceded him,
(3) He must believe in the Holy Prophet of Islam as the last of the prophets (khatam-un-nabiyin).
(4) He must believe in the Qur’an as it was revealed by God to the Holy
Prophet of Islam.
(5) He must believe as binding on him the injunctions of the Prophet of
Islam.
(6) He must believe in the qiyamat.
Q.—Is a tarik-us-salat a Muslim ?
A.—Yes, but not a munkir-us-salat”

Maulana Ahmad Ali, President, Jami’at-ul-Ulama-i-Islam, Maghribi Pakistan —
“Q.— Please define a Muslim ?
A.—A person is a Muslim if he believes (1) in the Qur’an and (2) what has been said by the prophet. Any person who possesses these two qualifications is entitled to be called a Muslim without his being required to believe in anything more or to do anything more.”

Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi, Amir Jama’at-i-Islami —
“Q.—Please define a Muslim ?
A.—A person is a Muslim if he believes (1) in tauheed, (2) in all the prophets (ambiya), (3) all the books revealed by God, (4) in mala’ika (angels), and (5) yaum-ul-akhira (the Day of Judgment).
Q.—Is a mere profession of belief in these articles sufficient to entitle a man
to call himself a Musalman and to be treated as a Musalman in an Islamic State ?
A.—Yes.
Q.—If a person says that he believes in all these things, does any one have a right to question the existence of his belief ?
A.—The five requisites that I have mentioned above are fundamental and any alteration in anyone of these articles will take him out of the pale of Islam.”

Ghazi Siraj-ud-Din Munir—
“Q.—Please define a Muslim ?
A.—I consider a man to be a Muslim if he professes his belief in the kalima, namely, La Ilaha Illalah-o-Muhammad-ur-Rasulullah, and leads a life in the footsteps of the Holy Prophet.”

Mufti Muhammad Idris, Jamia Ashrafia, Nila Gumbad, Lahore—
“Q.—Please give the definition of a Musalman ?
A.—The word ‘Musalman’ is a Persian one. There is a distinction between the word ‘Musalman’ which is a Persian word for Muslim and the word ‘momin’. It is impossible for me to give a complete definition of the word ‘momin’. I would require pages and pages to describe what a momin is. A person is a Muslim who professes to be obedient to Allah. He should believe in the Unity of God, prophethood of the ambiya and in the Day of Judgment. A person who does not believe in the azan or in the qurbani goes outside the pale of Islam. Similarly, there are a large number of other things which have been received by tavatir from our prophet. In order to be a Muslim, he must believe in all these things. It is almost impossible for me to give a complete list of such things.”

Hafiz Kifayat Hussain, Idara-i-Haquq-i-Tahaffuz-i-Shia—
“Q.—Who is a Musalman?
A.—A person is entitled to be called a Musalman if he believes in (1) tauheed, (2) nubuwwat and (3) qiyamat. These are the three fundamental beliefs which a person must profess to be called a Musalman. In regard to these three basic doctrines there is no difference between the Shias and the Sunnies. Besides the belief in these three doctrines, there are other things called ‘zarooriyat-i-din’ which a person must comply with in order to be entitled to be called a Musalman. These will take me two days to define and enumerate. But as an illustration I might state that the respect for the Holy Book, wajoob-i-nimaz, wajoob-i-roza, wajoob-i-hajj-ma’a-sharait, and other things too numerous to mention, are among the ‘zarooriyat-i-din’ ”

Maulana Abdul Hamid Badayuni, President, Jami’at-ul-Ulama-i-Pakistan :
“Q.—Who is a Musalman according to you ?
A.—A person who believes in the zarooriyat-i-din is called a momin and every momin is entitled to be called a Musalman.
Q.—What are these zarooriyat-i-din ?
A.—A person who believes in the five pillars of Islam and who believes in the rasalat of our Holy Prophet fulfils the zarooriyat-i-din.
Q.—Have other actions, apart from the five arakan, anything to do with a man being a Muslim or being outside the pale of Islam?
(Note—Witness has been explained that by actions are meant those rules of moral conduct which in modern society are accepted as correct.)
A.—Certainly.
Q.—Then you will not call a person a Muslim who believes in arakan-ikhamsa and the rasalat of the prophet but who steals other peoples’ things, embezzles property entrusted to him, has an evil eye on his neighbour’s wife and is guilty of the grossest ingratitude to his benefector?
A.—Such a person, if he has the belief already indicated, will be a Muslim despite all this”.

Maulana Muhammad Ali Kandhalvi, Darush-Shahabia, Sialkot —
“Q.—Please define a Musalman?
A.—A person who in obedience to the commands of the prophet performs all the zarooriyat-i-din is a Musalman.
Q.—Can you define zarooriyat-i-din ?
A.—Zarooriyat-i-din are those requirements which are known to every Muslim irrespective of his religious knowledge.
Q.—Can you enumerate zarooriyat-i-din ?
A.—These are too numerous to be mentioned. I myself cannot enumerate these zarooriyat. Some of the zarooriyat-i-din may be mentioned as salat, saum, etc.”

Maulana Amin Ahsan Islahi —
“Q.—Who is a Musalman?
A.—There are two kinds of Musalmans, a political (siyasi) Musalman and a real (haqiqi) Musalman. In order to be called a political Musalman, a person must:
(1) believe in the Unity of God,
(2) believe in our Holy Prophet being khatam-un-nabiyin, i.e., ‘final
authority’ in all matters relating to the life of that person,
(3) believe that all good and evil comes from Allah,
(4) believe in the Day of Judgment,
(5) believe in the Qur’an to be the last book revealed by Allah,
(6) perform the annual pilgrimage to Mecca,
(7) pay the zaka’at,
(8) say his prayers like the Musalmans,
(9) observe all apparent rules of Islami mu’ashira, and
(10) observe the fast (saum).

If a person satisfies all these conditions he is entitled to the rights of a full citizen of an Islamic State. If any one of these conditions is not satisfied, the person concerned will not be a political Musalman. (Again said) It would be enough for a person to be a Musalman if he merely professes his belief in these ten matters irrespective of whether he puts them into practice or not. In order to be a real Musalman, a person must believe in and act on all the injunctions by Allah and his prophet in the manner in which they have been enjoined upon him.
Q.—Will you say that only the real Musalman is ‘mard-i-saleh’ ?
A.—Yes.
Q.—do we understand you aright that in the case of what you have called a political (siyasi) Musalman, belief alone is necessary, while in the case of a haqiqi Musalman there must not only be belief but also action?
A.—No, you have not understood me aright. Even in the case of a political (siyasi) Musalman action is necessary but what I mean to say is that if a person does not act upon the belief that is necessary in the case of such a Musalman, he will not be outside the pale of a political (siyasi) Musalman.
Q.—If a political (siyasi) Musalman does not believe in things which you
have stated to be necessary, will you call such a person be-din ?
A.—No, I will call him merely be-amal”.

The definition by the Sadr Anjuman Ahmadiya, Rabwah, in its written statement
is that a Muslim is a person who belongs to the ummat of the Holy Prophet and professes belief in kalima-i-tayyaba.

Keeping in view the several definitions given by the ulama, need we make any comment except that no two learned divines are agreed on this fundamental. If we attempt our own definition as each learned divine has done and that definition differs from that given by all others, we unanimously go out of the fold of Islam. And if we adopt the definition given by any one of the ulama, we remain Muslims according to the view of that alim but kafirs according to the definition of every one else.

APOSTASY
Apostasy in an Islamic State is punishable with death. On this the ulama are practically unanimous (vide the evidence of Maulana Abul Hasanat Sayyad Muhammad Ahmad Qadri, President, Jami’at-ul-Ulama-i-Pakistan, Punjab; Maulana Ahmad Ali, Sadr Jami’at-ul-Ulama-i-Islam, West Pakistan; Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi, founder and ex-Amir-i-Jama’at-i-Islami, Pakistan; Mufti Muhammad Idris, Jami’Ashrafia, Lahore, and Member, Jami’at-ul-Ulama-i-Pakistan; Maulana Daud Ghaznavi, President, Jami’at-i-Ahl-i-Hadith, Maghribi Pakistan; Maulana Abdul Haleem Qasimi, Jami’at-ul-Ulama-i-Islam, Punjab; and Mr. Ibrahim Ali Chishti). According to this doctrine, Chaudhri Zafrullah Khan, if he has not inherited his present religious beliefs but has voluntarily elected to be an Ahmadi, must be put to death. And the same fate should befall Deobandis and Wahabis, including Maulana Muhammad Shafi Deobandi, Member, Board of Talimat-i-Islami attached to the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan, and Maulana Daud Ghaznavi, if Maulana Abul Hasanat Sayyad Muhammad Ahmad Qadri or Mirza Raza Ahmad Khan Barelvi, or any one of the numerous ulama who are shown perched on every leaf of a beautiful tree in the fatwa, Ex. D. E. 14, were the head of such Islamic State. And if Maulana Muhammad Shafi Deobandi were the head of the State, he would exclude those who have pronounced Deobandis as kafirs from the pale of Islam and inflict on them the death penalty if they come within the definition of murtadd, namely, if they have changed and not inherited their religious views.

The genuineness of the fatwa, Ex. D. E. 13, by the Deobandis which says that Asna Ashari Shias are kafirs and murtadds, was questioned in the course of enquiry, but Maulana Muhammad Shafi made an inquiry on the subject from Deoband, and received from the records of that institution the copy of a fatwa signed by all the teachers of the Darul Uloom including Maulana Muhammad Shafi himself which is to the effect that those who do not believe in the sahabiyyat of Hazrat Siddiq Akbar and who are qazif of Hazrat Aisha Siddiqa and have been guilty of tehrif of Qur’an are kafirs. This opinion is also supported by Mr. Ibrahim Ali Chishti who has studied and knows his subject. He thinks the Shias are kafirs because they believe that Hazrat Ali shared the prophethood with our Holy Prophet. He refused to answer the question whether a person who being a Sunni changes his view and agrees with the Shia view would be guilty of irtidad so as to deserve the death penalty. According to the Shias all Sunnis are kafirs, and Ahl-i-Qur’an; namely, persons who consider hadith to be unreliable and therefore not binding, are unanimously kafirs and so are all independent thinkers. The net result of all this is that neither Shias nor Sunnis nor Deobandis nor Ahl-i-Hadith nor Barelvis are Muslims and any change from one view to the other must be accompanied in an Islamic State with the penalty of death if the Government of the State is in the hands of the party which considers the other party to be kafirs. And it does not require much imagination to judge of the consequences of this doctrine when it is remembered that no two ulama have agreed before us as to the definition of a Muslim. If the constituents of each of the definitions given by the ulama are given effect to, and subjected to the rule of ‘combination and permutation’ and the form of charge in the Inquisition’s sentence on Galileo is adopted mutatis mutandis as a model, the grounds on which a person may be indicted for apostasy will be too numerous to count.

In an earlier part of the report we have referred to the proscription of the ‘Ashshahab’, a pamphlet written by Maulana Shabbir Ahmad Usmani who later became Sheikh-ul-Islam-i-Pakistan. In that pamphlet the Maulana had attempted to show from the Qur’an, the sunna, the ijma’ and qayas that in Islam the punishment for apostasy (irtidad) simpliciter is death. After propounding the theological doctrine the Maulana had made in that document a statement of fact that in the time of the Caliph Siddiq-i-Akbar and the subsequent Caliphs vast areas of Arabia became repeatedly red with the blood of apostates. We are not called upon to express any opinion as to the correctness or otherwise of this doctrine but knowing that the suggestion to the Punjab Government to proscribe this pamphlet had come from the Minister for the Interior we have attempted to inquire of ourselves the reasons for Government’s taking a step which ex hypothesi amounted to condemning a doctrine which the Maulana had professed to derive from the Qur’an and the sunna. The death penalty for irtidad has implications of a far-reaching character and stamps Islam as a religion of fanatics, which punishes all independent thinking. The Qur’an again and again lays emphasis on reason and thought, advises toleration and preaches against compulsion in religious matters but the doctrine of irtidad
as enunciated in this pamphlet strikes at the very root of independent thinking when it propounds the view that anyone who, being born a Muslim or having embraced Islam, attempts to think on the subject of religion with a view, if he comes to that conclusion, to choose for himself any religion he likes, has the capital penalty in store for him. With this implication Islam becomes an embodiment of complete intellectual paralysis. And the statement in the pamphlet that vast areas of Arabia were repeatedly bespattered with human blood, if true, could only lend itself to this inference that even when Islam was at the height of its splendour and held absolute sway in Arabia there were in that country a large number of people who turned away from that religion and preferred to die than to
remain in that system. It must have been some such reaction of this pamphlet on the mind of the Minister for the Interior which prompted him to advise the Punjab Government to proscribe the pamphlet. Further the Minister who was himself well-versed in religious matters must have thought that the conclusion drawn by the author of the pamphlet which was principally based on the precedent mentioned in paras. 26, 27 and 28 of the Old Testament and which is only partially referred to in the Qur’an in the 54th verse of the Second Sura, could not be applicable to apostasy from Islam and that therefore the author’s opinion was in fact incorrect, there being no express text in the Qur’an for the death penalty for apostasy. On the contrary each of the two ideas, one underlying the six brief verses of Surat-ul-Kafiroon and the other the La Ikrah verse of the second Sura, has merely to be understood to reject as erroneous the view propounded in the ‘Ash-Shahab’.
Each of the verses in Surat-ul-Kafiroon which contains thirty words and no verse of
which exceeds six words, brings out a fundamental trait in man engrained in him since his creation while the La Ikrah verse, the relevant portion of which contains only nine words, states the rule of responsibility of the mind with a precision that cannot be surpassed. Both of these texts which are an early part of the Revelation are, individually and collectively, the foundation of that principle which human society, after centuries of conflict, hatred and bloodshed, has adopted in defining one of the most important fundamental rights of man. But our doctors would never dissociate chauvinism from Islam.

PROPAGATION OF OTHER RELIGIONS
Closely allied to the punishment for apostasy is the right of non-Muslims publicly to preach their religion. The principle which punishes an apostate with death must be applicable to public preaching of kufr and it is admitted by Maulana Abul Hasanat, Ghazi Siraj-ud-Din Munir and Master Taj-ud-Din Ansari, though the last subordinates his opinion to the opinion of the ulama, that any faith other than Islam will not be permitted publicly to be preached in the State. And Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi, as will appear from his pamphlet ‘Punishment in Islam for an apostate’, has the same views on the subject.

Ghazi Siraj-ud-Din Munir, when questioned on this point, replied :—
“Q.—What will you do with them (Ahmadis) if you were the head of the
Pakistan State ?
A.—I would tolerate them as human beings but will not allow them the right
to preach their religion”.

The prohibition against public preaching of any non-Muslim religion must logically follow from the proposition that apostasy will be punished with death and that any attack on, or danger to Islam will be treated as treason and punished in the same way as apostasy.

JIHAD
Earlier we have pointed out that one of the doctrines on which the Musalmans and Ahmadis are at variance is that of jihad. This doctrine at once raises a host of other allied matters such as the meanings of ghazi, shahid, jihad-bis-saif, jihad fi sabili’llah, dar-ul-Islam, dar-ul-harb, hijrat, ghanima, khums and slavery, and the conflict or reconciliation of these conceptions with modern international problems such as aggression, genocide, international criminal jurisdiction, international conventions and rules of public international law.

An Islamic State is dar-ul-Islam, namely, a country where ordinances of Islam are
established and which is under the rule of a Muslim sovereign. Its inhabitants are
Muslims and also non-Muslims who have submitted to Muslim control and who under
certain restrictions and without the possibility of full citizenship are guaranteed their lives and property by the Muslim State. They must, however, be people of Scriptures and may not be idolaters. An Islamic State is in theory perpetually at war with the neighbouring non-Muslim country, which at any time may become dar-ul-harb, in which case it is the duty of the Muslims of that country to leave it and to come over to the country of their brethren in faith. We put this aspect to Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi and reproduce his views :—

“Q.—is a country on the border of dar-ul-Islam always qua an Islamic State
in the position of dar-ul-harb ?
A.—No. In the absence of an agreement to the contrary, the Islamic State will be potentially at war with the non-Muslim neighbouring country. The non-Muslim country acquires the status of dar-ul-harb only after the Islamic State declares a formal war against it”.

According to Ghias-ul-Lughat, dar-ul-harb is a country belonging to infidels which has not been subdued by Islam, and the consequences of a country becoming darul-harb are thus stated in the Shorter Encyclopaedia of Islam :—

“When a country does become a dar-ul-harb, it is the duty of all Muslims to
withdraw from it, and a wife who refuses to accompany her husband in
this, is ipso facto divorced”.

Thus in case of a war between India and Pakistan, if the latter is an Islamic State, we must be prepared to receive forty million Muslims from across the border into Pakistan.

In fact, Maulana Abdul Haamid Badayuni, President, Jami’at-ul-Ulama-i- Pakistan, thinks that a case for hijrat already exists for the Musalmans of India. The following is his view on this subject :—
“Q.—Do yon call your migration to Pakistan as hijrat in the religious sense ?
A.—Yes”.

We shall presently point out why Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s version of the doctrine of jihad is relied on as a ground for his and his community’s kufr, but before we do that it is necessary first to state how jihad has been or is understood by the Musalmans. There are various theories about jihad which vary from the crude notion of a megalomaniac moved by religious frenzy going out armed with sword and indiscriminately slaughtering non-Muslims in the belief that if he dies in the combat he becomes a shahid and if he succeeds in killing attains the status of a ghazi, to the conception that a Musalman throughout his life is pitted against kufr, kufr here being used in the sense of evil and wrong, and that his principal activity in life is to strive by argument a where necessary by force to spread Islam until it becomes a world religion. In the latter case he fights not for any personal end but because he considers such strife as a duty and an obligation which he owes to Allah and the only recompense for which is the pleasure of Allah. The Shorter Encyclopedia of Islam contains the following brief article on djihad :—
“DJIHAD (A), holy war. The spread of Islam by arms is a religious duty upon
Muslims in general. It narrowly escaped being a sixth rukn, or fundamental duty, and is indeed still so regarded by the descendants of the Kharidjis. This position was reached gradually but quickly. In the Meccan Suras of the Qur’an patience under attack is taught ; no other attitude was possible. But at Medina the right to repel attack appears, and gradually it became a prescribed duty to fight against and subdue the hostile Meccans.
Whether Muhammad himself recognised that his position implied steady and unprovoked war against the unbelieving world until it was subdued to Islam may be in doubt. Traditions are explicit on the point ; but the Qur’anic passages speak always of the unbelievers who are to be subdued as dangerous or faithless. Still, the story of his writing to the powers around him shows that such a universal position was implicit in his mind, and it certainly developed immediately after his death, when the Muslim armies advanced out of Arabia. It is now a fard ala’l-kifaya, a duty in general on all male, free, adult Muslims, sane in mind and body and having means enough to reach the Muslim army, yet not a duty necessarily incumbent on every individual but sufficiently performed when done by a certain number. So it must continue to be done until the whole world is under the rule of Islam. It must be controlled or headed by a Muslim sovereign or imam. As the imam of the Shias is now invisible, they cannot have a djihad until he reappears. Further, the requirement will be met if such a sovereign makes an expedition once a year, or, even, in the later view, if he makes annual preparation for one. The people against whom the djihad is directed must first be invited to embrace Islam. On refusal they have another choice. They may submit to Muslim rule, become dhimmis (q. v.) and pay djizya and kharadj (q. v.) or fight. In the first case, their lives, families and property are assured to them, but they have a definitely inferior status, with no technical citizenship, and a standing only as protected wards. If they fight, they and their families may be enslaved and all their property seized as booty, four-fifths of which goes to the conquering army. If they embrace Islam, and it is open to them to do so even when the armies are face to face, they become part of the Muslim community with all its rights and duties. Apostates must be put to death. But if a Muslim country is invaded by unbelievers, the imam may issue a general summons calling all Muslims there to arms, and as the danger grows so may be the width of the summons until the whole Muslim world is involved. A Muslim who dies fighting in the path of Allah (fi sabil Allah) is martyr (shahid) and is assured of Paradise and of peculiar privileges there. Such a death was, in the early generations, regarded as the peculiar crown of a pious life. It is still, on occasions, a strong incitement, but when Islam ceased to conquer it lost its supreme value. Even yet, however, any war between Muslims and non-Muslims must be a djihad with its incitements and rewards. Of course, such modern movements as the so-called Mu’tazili in India and the Young Turk in Turkey reject this and endeavour to explain away its basis; but the Muslim masses still follow the unanimous voice of the canon lawyers. Islam must be completely made over before the doctrine of djihad can be eliminated”.

The generally accepted view is that the fifth verse to Sura-i-Tauba (Sura IX) abrogated the earlier verses revealed in Mecca which permitted the killing of kuffar only in self-defence. As against this the Ahmadis believe that no verso in the Qur’an was abrogated by another verse and that both sets of verses, namely, the Meccan verses and the relative verses in Sura-i-Tauba have different scopes and can stand together. This introduces the difficult controversy of nasikh and mansukh, with all its implications. It is argued on behalf of the Ahmadis that the doctrine of nasikh and mansukh is opposed to the belief in the existence of an original Scripture in Heaven, and that implicit in this doctrine is the admission that unless the verse alleged to be repealed was meant for a specific occasion and by the coming of that occasion fulfilled its purpose and thus spent itself, God did not know of the subsequent circumstances which would make the earlier verse inapplicable or lead to an undesired result.

The third result of this doctrine, it is pointed out, cuts at the very root of the claim that laws of Islam are immutable and inflexible because if changed circumstances made a new revelation necessary, any change in the circumstances subsequent to the completion of the revelation would make most of the revelation otiose or obsolete.

We are wholly incompetent to pronounce on the merits of this controversy but what has to be pointed out is the result to which the doctrine of jihad will lead if, as appears from the article in the Shorter Encyclopaedia of Islam and other writings produced before us including one by Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi and another by Maulana Shabbir Ahmad Usmani, it involves the spread of Islam by arms and conquest. ‘Aggression’ and ‘genocide’ are now offences against humanity for which under sentences pronounced by different International tribunals at Nuremburg and Tokio the war lords of Germany and Japan had to forfeit their lives, and there is hardly any difference between the offences of aggression and genocide on the one hand and the doctrine of spread of Islam by arms and conquest on the other. An International Convention on genocide is about to be concluded but if the view of jihad presented to us is correct, Pakistan cannot be a party to it. And while the following verses in the Mecca Suras :—

Sura II, verses 190 and 193 :190. “Fight in the Cause of God Those who fight you,
But do not transgress limits ;
For God loveth not transgressors”.
193. “And fight them on
Until there is no more
Tumult or oppression,
And there prevail
Justice and faith in God ;
But if they cease,
Let there be no hostility
Except to those
Who practise oppression”.
Sura XXII, verses 39 and 40:
39. “To those against whom
War is made, permission
Is given (to fight) because
They are wronged;— and verily,
God is most Powerful
For their aid;—”
40. “(They are) those who have
Been expelled from their homes
In defiance of right,—
(For no cause) except
That they say, ‘Our Lord
Is God.’ Did not God
Check one set of people
By means of another,
There would surely have been
Pulled down monasteries, churches,
Synagogues, and mosques, in which
The name of God is commemorated
In abundant measure. God will
Certainly aid those who
Aid His (cause);—for verily
God is Full of Strength,
Exalted in Might,
(Able to enforce His Will),”

contain in them the sublime principle which international jurists have only faintly begun to discover, we must go on preaching that aggression is the chief characteristic of Islam. The law relating to prisoners of war is another branch of Islamic law which is bound to come in conflict with International Law.

As for instance, in matters relating to the treatment of prisoners of war, we shall have to be governed by Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi’s view, assuming that view is based on the Qur’an and the sunna, which is as follows :—

“Q.—Is there a law of war in Islam?
A.—Yes.
Q.—Does it differ fundamentally from the modern International Law of war?
A.—These two systems are based on a fundamental difference.
Q.—What rights have non-Muslims who are taken prisoners of war in a jihad?
A.—The Islamic law on the point is that if the country of which these prisoners are nationals pays ransom, they will be released. An exchange of prisoners is also permitted. If neither of these alternatives is possible, the prisoners will be converted into slaves for ever. If any such person makes an offer to pay his ransom out of his own earnings, he will be permitted to collect the money necessary for the fidya (ransom).
Q.—Are you of the view that unless a Government assumes the form of an Islamic Government, any war declared by it is not a jihad?
A.—No. A war may be declared to be a jihad if it is declared by a national Government of Muslims in the legitimate interests of the State. I never expressed the opinion attributed to me in Ex. D. E. 12:—
“Raha yeh masala keh agar hukumat-i-Pakisten apni maujuda shukl-o-surat ke sath Indian Union ke sath apne mu’ahadat khatm kar-ke i’lan-i-jang bar bhi de to kya us-ki yeh jang jihad ke hukam men a-ja’egi ? Ap ne is bare men jo rae zahir ki hai woh bilkul darust hai – Jab-tak hukumat Islami nizam ko ikhtiyar kar-ke Islami nah ho jae us waqt tak us-ki kisi jang ko jihad kehna aisa hi hai jaisa kisi ghair Muslim ke Azad Kashmir ki fauj men bharti ho-kar larne ko jihad aur us-ki maut ko shahadat ka nam dediya jae – Maulana ka jo mudd’a hai woh yeh hai keh mu’ahadat ki maujudgi men to hukumat ya us-ke shehriyon ka is jang men sharik hona shar’-an ja’iz hi nahin – Agar hukumat mu’ahadat khatm kar-ke jang ka
i’lan kar-de to hukumat ki jang to jihad phir bhi nahin hogi ta-an keh hukumat Islami nah ho jae.’

(translation)

‘The question remains whether, even if the Government of Pakistan, in its present form and structure, terminates her treaties with the Indian Union and declares war against her, this war would fall under the definition of jihad? The opinion expressed by him in this behalf is quite correct. Until such time as the Government becomes Islamic by adopting the Islamic form of Government, to call any of its wars a jihad would be tantamount to describing the enlistment and fighting of a non-Muslim on the side of the Azad Kashmir forces jihad and his death martyrdom. What the Maulana means is that, in the presence of treaties, it is against Shari’at, if the Government or its people participate in such a war. If the Government terminates the treaties and declares war, even then the war started by Government would not be termed jihad unless the Government becomes Islamic’.

About the view expressed in this letter being that of Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi, there is the evidence of Mian Tufail Muhammad, the writer of the letter, who states: “Ex. D. E. 12 is a photostat copy of a letter which I wrote to someone whose name I do not now remember.”

Maulana Abul Hasanat Muhammad Ahmad Qadri’s view on this point is as
follows:—
“Q.—Is there a law of war in Islam?
A.—Yes.
Q.—Does it differ in fundamentals from the present International Law?
A.—Yes.
Q.—What are the rights of a person taken prisoner in war?
A.—He can embrace Islam or ask for aman, in which case he will be treated as a musta’min. If he does not ask for aman, he would be made a slave”.
Similar is the opinion expressed by Mian Tufail Muhammad of Jam’at-i-Islami who says:—
“Q.—Is there any law of war in Islamic laws?
A.—Yes.
Q.—If that comes into conflict with International Law, which will you follow?
A.—Islamic law.
Q.—Then please state what will be the status of prisoners of war captured by your
forces?
A.—I cannot reply to this off hand. I will have to study the point.”
Of course ghanima (plunder) and khums (one-fifth) if treated as a necessary incident of
jihad will be treated by international society as a mere act of brigandage.

REACTION ON MUSLIMS OF NON-MUSLIM STATES
The ideology on which an Islamic State is desired to be founded in Pakistan must have certain consequences for the Musalmans who are living in countries under non-Muslim sovereigns.

We asked Amir-i-Shari’at Sayyad Ataullah Shah Bukhari whether a Muslim could be a faithful subject of a non-Muslim State and reproduce his answer:—
“Q.—In your opinion is a Musalman bound to obey orders of a kafir
Government?
A.—It is not possible that a Musalman should be faithful citizen of a non-Muslim
Government.
Q.—Will it be possible for the four crore of Indian Muslims to be faithful citizens
of their State?
A—No.”

The answer is quite consistent with the ideology which has been pressed before us, but then if Pakistan is entitled to base its Constitution on religion, the same right must be conceded to other countries where Musalmans are in substantial minorities or if they constitute a preponderating majority in a country where sovereignty rests with a non-Muslim community. We, therefore, asked the various ulama whether, if non-Muslims in Pakistan were to be subjected to this discrimination in matters of citizenship, the ulama would have any objection to Muslims in other countries being subjected to a similar discrimination. Their reactions to this suggestion are reproduced below:—

Maulana Abul Hasanat Sayyed Muhammad Ahmad Qadri, President, Jami’at-ul-
Ulama-i-Pakistan:—
“Q.—You will admit for the Hindus, who are in a majority in India, the right
to have a Hindu religious State?
A.—Yes.
Q.—Will you have any objection if the Muslims are treated under that form
of Government as malishes or shudras under the law of Manu?
A.— No.”

Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi :—
“Q.—If we have this form of Islamic Government in Pakistan, will you
permit Hindus to base their Constitution on the basis of their own
religion?
A—Certainly. I should have no objection even if the Muslims of India are
treated in that form of Government as shudras and malishes and Manu’s laws are applied to them, depriving them of all share in the Government and the rights of a citizen. In fact such a state of affairs already exists in India.”

Amir-i-Shari’at Sayyad Ata Ullah Skak Bukhari :—
“Q.—How many crores of Muslims are there in India?
A.—Four crores.
Q.—Have you any objection to the law of Manu being applied to them
according to which they will have no civil right and will be treated as
malishes and shudras?
A.—I am in Pakistan and I cannot advise them.”

Mian Tufail Muhammad of Jama’at-i-Islami :—
“Q.—What is the population of Muslims in the world?
A.—Fifty crores.
Q.—If the total population of Muslims of the world is 50 crores, as you say,
and the number of Muslims living in Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Yemen,
Indonesia, Egypt, Persia, Syria, Lebanon, Trans-Jordan, Turkey and
Iraq does not exceed 20 crores, will not the result of your ideology be
to convert 30 crores of Muslims in the world into hewers of wood and
drawers of water?
A.—My ideology should not affect their position.
Q.—Even if they are subjected to discrimination on religious grounds and
denied ordinary rights of citizenship ?
A.—Yes.”
This witness goes to the extent of asserting that even if a non-Muslim Government were to offer posts to Muslims in the public services of the country, it will be their duty to refuse such posts.

Ghazi Siraj-ud-Din Munir :—
“Q.—Do you want an Islamic State in Pakistan?
A.—Surely.
Q.—What will be your reaction if the neighbouring country was to found
their political system on their own religion?
A.—They can do it if they like.
Q.—Do you admit for them the right to declare that all Muslims in India, are
shudras and malishes with no civil rights whatsoever?
A.—We will do our best to see that before they do it their political
sovereignty is gone. We are too strong for India. We will be strong
enough to prevent India from doing this.
Q.—Is it a part of the religious obligations of Muslims to preach their
religion?
A—Yes.
Q.—Is it a part of the duty of Muslims in India publicly to preach their
religion?
A.—They should have that right.
Q.—What if the Indian State is founded on a religious basis and the right to
preach religion is disallowed to its Muslim nationals?
A —If India makes any such law, believer in the Expansionist movement as I
am, I will march on India and conquer her.”

So this is the reply to the reciprocity of discrimination on religious grounds.

Master Taj-ud-Din Ansari :—
“Q.—Would you like to have the same ideology for the four crores of
Muslims in India as you are impressing upon the Muslims of
Pakistan?
A.—That ideology will not let them remain in India for one minute.
Q.—Does the ideology of a Muslim change from place to place and from
time to time?
A.—No.
Q.—Then why should not the Muslims of India have the same ideology as
you have?
A.—They should answer that question.”

The ideology advocated before us, if adopted by Indian Muslims, will completely
disqualify them for public offices in the State, not only in India but in other countries also which are under a non-Muslim Government. Muslims will become perpetual suspects everywhere and will not be enrolled in the army because according to this ideology, in case of war between a Muslim country and a non-Muslim country, Muslim soldiers of the non-Muslim country must either side with the Muslim country or surrender their posts.

The following is the view expressed by two divines whom we questioned on this point:—

Maulana Abul Hasanat Sayyed Muhammad Ahmad Qadri, President, Jami’at-ul-
Ulama-i-Pakistan :—
“Q.—What will be the duty of Muslims in India in case of war between India
and Pakistan?
A.—Their duty is obvious, namely, to side with us and not to fight against us
on behalf of India.”

Maulana Abul Ala Maudoodi : —
“Q.—What will be the duty of the Muslims in India in case of war between
India and Pakistan?
A.—Their duty is obvious, and that is not to fight against Pakistan or to do
anything injurious to the safety of Pakistan.”

OTHER INCIDENTS
Other incidents of an Islamic State are that all sculpture, playing of cards, portrait
painting, photographing human beings, music, dancing, mixed acting, cinemas and
theatres will have to be closed.

Thus says Maulana Abdul Haleem Qasimi, representative of Jami’at-ul-Ulama-i-Pakistan: —

“Q.—What are your views on tashbih and tamseel ?
A.—You should ask me a concrete question.
Q.—What are your views on lahw-o-la’b?
A.—The same is my reply to this question.
Q.—What are your views about portrait painting?
A.—There is nothing against it if any such painting becomes necessary.
Q.—What about photography?
A.—My reply to it is the same as the reply regarding portrait painting.
Q.—What about sculpture as an art?
A.—It is prohibited by our religion.
Q.—Will you bring playing of cards in lohw-o-la’b?
A.—Yes, it will amount to lahw-o-la’b.
Q.—What about music and dancing?
A.—It is all forbidden by our religion.
Q.—What about drama and acting?
A —It all depends on what kind of acting you mean. If it involves immodesty
and intermixture of sexes, the Islamic law is against it.
Q.—If the State is founded on your ideals, will you make a law stopping
portrait painting, photographing of human beings, sculpture, playing
of cards, music, dancing, acting and all cinemas and theatres?
A.—Keeping in view the present form of these activities, my answer is in the
affirmative.”

Maulana Abdul Haamid Badayuni considers it to be a sin (ma’siyat) on the part of
professors of anatomy to dissect dead bodies of Muslims to explain points of anatomy to the students.

The soldier or the policeman will have the right, on grounds of religion, to disobey a command by a superior authority. Maulana Abul Hasanat’s view on this is as follows :—

“I believe that if a policeman is required to do something which we consider to be
contrary to our religion, it should be the duty of the policeman to disobey the authority. The same would be my answer if ‘army’ were substituted for ‘police’.

Q.—You stated yesterday that if a policeman or a soldier was required by a
superior authority to do what you considered to be contrary to religion, it would be the duty of that policeman or the soldier to disobey such authority. Will you give the policeman or the soldier the right of himself determining whether the command he is given by his superior authority is contrary to religion ?
A.—Most certainly.
Q.—Suppose there is war between Pakistan and another Muslim country and
the soldier feels that Pakistan is in the wrong; and that to shoot a
soldier of other country is contrary to religion. Do you think he would
be justified in disobeying his commanding officer ?
A.—In such a contingency the soldier should take a fatwa of the ‘ulama’.”

We have dwelt at some length on the subject of Islamic State not because we intended to write a thesis against or in favour of such State but merely with a view to presenting a clear picture of the numerous possibilities that may in future arise if true causes of the ideological confusion which contributed to the spread and intensity of the disturbances are not precisely located. That such confusion did exist is obvious because otherwise Muslim Leaguers, whose own Government was in office, would not have risen against it; sense of loyalty and public duty would not have departed from public officials who went about like maniacs howling against their own Government and officers; respect for property and human life would not have disappeared in the common man who with no scruple or compunction began freely to indulge in loot, arson and murder; politicians would not have shirked facing the men who had installed them in their offices; and administrators would not have felt hesitant or diffident in performing what was their obvious duty. If there is one thing which has been conclusively demonstrated in this inquiry, it is that provided you can persuade the masses to believe that something they are asked to do is religiously right or enjoined by religion, you can set them to any course of action, regardless of all considerations of discipline, loyalty, decency, morality or civic sense.

Pakistan is being taken by the common man, though it is not, as an Islamic State. This belief has been encouraged by the ceaseless clamour for Islam and Islamic State that is being heard from all quarters since the establishment of Pakistan. The phantom of an Islamic State has haunted the Musalman throughout the ages and is a result of the memory of the glorious past when Islam rising like a storm from the least expected quarter of the world—wilds of Arabia—instantly enveloped the world, pulling down from their high pedestal gods who had ruled over man since the creation, uprooting centuries old institutions and superstitions and supplanting all civilisations that had been built on an enslaved humanity. What is 125 years in human history, nay in the history of a people, and yet during this brief period Islam spread from the Indus to the Atlantic and Spain, and from the borders of China to Egypt, and the sons of the desert installed themselves in all old centres of civilisation—in Ctesiphon, Damascus, Alexandria, India and all places associated with the names of the Sumerian and the Assyrian civilisations. Historians have often posed the question : what would have been the state of the world today if Muawiya’s siege of Constantinople had succeeded or if the proverbial Arab instinct for plunder had not suddenly seized the mujahids of Abdur Rahman in their fight against Charles Martel on the plains of Tours in Southern France. May be Muslims would have discovered America long before Columbus did and the entire world would have been Moslemised; may be Islam itself would have been Europeanised. It is this brilliant achievement of the Arabian nomads, the like of which the world had never seen before, that makes the Musalman of today live in the past and yearn for the return of the glory that was Islam. He finds himself standing on the crossroads, wrapped in the mantle of the past and with the dead weight of centuries on his back, frustrated and bewildered and hesitant to turn one corner or the other. The freshness and the simplicity of the faith, which gave determination to his mind and spring to his muscle, is now denied to him. He has neither the means nor the ability to conquer and there are no countries to conquer. Little does he understand that the forces, which are pitted against him, are entirely different from those against which early Islam, had to fight, and that on the clues given by his own ancestors human mind has achieved results which he cannot understand. He therefore finds himself in a state of helplessness, waiting for some one to come and help him out of this morass of uncertainty and confusion. And he will go on waiting like this without anything happening. Nothing but a bold re-orientation of Islam to separate the vital from the lifeless can preserve it as a World Idea and convert the Musalman into a citizen of the present and the future world from the archaic in congruity that he is today. It is this lack of bold and clear thinking, the inability to understand and take decisions which has brought about in Pakistan a confusion which will persist and repeatedly create situations of the kind we have been inquiring into until our leaders have a clear conception of the goal and of the means to reach it. It requires no imagination to realise that irreconcilables remain irreconcilable even if you believe or wish to the contrary. Opposing principles, if left to themselves, can only produce confusion and disorder, and the application of a neutralising agency to them can only produce a dead result. Unless, in case of conflict between two ideologies, our leaders have the desire and the ability to elect, uncertainty must continue. And as long as we rely on the hammer when a file is needed and press Islam into service to solve situations it was never intended to solve, frustration and disappointment must dog our steps. The sublime faith called Islam will live even if our leaders are not there to enforce it. It lives in the individual, in his soul and outlook, in all his relations with God and men, from the cradle to the grave, and our politicians should understand that if Divine commands cannot make or keep a man a Musalman, their statutes will not….

Posted in Academic freedom, Ahimsa, Ahmadis, Arabs, Asia and the West, Bangladesh, Bengal Constitutional Politics, Bhagavad Gita, Books, Britain in India, British imperialism, Caliphate, Christianity, Common Law and Equity, Comparative Government, Constitutional law, Constitutional Politics, Good and Evil, Government of Afghanistan, Government of India, Government of Pakistan, Ground Zero Mosque, Hindu political traditions, Hinduism, Hindus and Muslims, Imperialism, India's military doctrine, India's History, India's independence, India's Muslims, India's Partition, India's Politics, India's Polity, India's Rule of Law, India's secularism, India-Pakistan cooperation against terrorism, Indian subcontinent, International diplomacy, International immigration, International Law, International politics, Iqbal, Iran, Iran's politics, Iran's modern history, Islam, Israel-Iran conflict-resolution, Jammu & Kashmir, Jammu & Kashmir in international law, Judaism, Jurisprudence, Just war, Law, Law of the Sea, Law of the Sea applied to international terrorists, Laws and customs of parliaments, Laws of war, Laws of war applied to international terrorists, Life and death, MA Jinnah, Master and Servant Law, Metaphysics (Ontology), Mob violence and behaviour, Monarchy vs Republicanism, Moral reasoning, Mumbai massacres, Munir Report, Muslim and Hindu communalism, Nationalism, Natural Justice, Pakistan in international law, Pakistan's civil war, Pakistan's origins, Pakistan's constitutional politics, Pakistan's diplomacy, Pakistan's history, Pakistan's judiciary, Pakistan's military, Pakistan's murder of Indian POWs, Pakistan's nuclear weapons, Pakistan's politics, Pakistan's Rule of Law, Pakistan's terrorist masterminds, Pakistan's terrorist training institutes, Pakistan, Balochistan, Afghanistan, Iran, Pakistani expansionism, Parliamentary Government, Parliamentary law, Pashtuns, Patriarchy, Pervez Hoodbhoy, Pervez Musharraf, Political assassinations, Political asylum, Political cynicism, Political legitimacy, Political mendacity, Political Philosophy, Political Science, Qadian, Racism, Rational decisions, Rationality, Reason, Religion, Rule of Law, Saudi Arabia, Scepticism and Dogmatism, Schizophrenia in international relations, Secular governance, Secularism in practice, September 11 attacks, Serendipity and international relations, Sikhs, Sindhis, Srinagar, Sunnis and Shias, Terrorist techniques, Terrorist-hostage situations, Turkey, Uighurs, Unconscious Mind, US AfPak policy, US Pakistan policy, US-Iran relations, War, War crimes, World War, Zionism. 1 Comment »

“I’m on my way out”: Siddhartha Shankar Ray (1920-2010)

I  am grieved to hear of the death of Siddhartha Shankar Ray last night.

I was introduced to him by an uncle who had been his college-buddy, and he took up a grave personal matter of mine in the Supreme Court of India in 1990 with great kindness, charging me not a penny, being impressed by a little explicit “civil disobedience” I had had to show at the time towards Judge Evelyn Lance.

He also told me he and his wife had been in London on May 29 1984 and had seen *The Times*’s leader that day about my critique of Indian economic policy. He invited me to his Delhi home where I told him about the perestroika-for-India project I had led at the University of Hawaii since 1986, at which he, of his own accord, declared

“You must meet Rajiv Gandhi.  I will arrange a meeting”.

That led to my meeting with Rajiv Gandhi, then Congress President & Leader of the Opposition, on September 18 1990, which contributed to the origins of India’s 1991 economic reform as has been told elsewhere. Rajiv’s assistant George told me Rajiv had said he had not heard more fulsome praise.

In Bengal, he took me as a guest to visit the Legislative Assembly in session when he was Leader of the Opposition; it was the legislature of which my great grandfather, Surendranath Roy, had been a founder, being the first Deputy President and acting President too; Surendranath had been friends with his maternal grandfather, CR Das, leader of the Congress Party before MK Gandhi, and he said to me in the car heading to the legislature about that relationship in Bengal’s politics some seven decades earlier “They were friends”.

He introduced me to all the main leaders of the Bengal Congress at the time (except Mamata Banerjee who could not come) and I was tasked by him to write the manifesto for the State elections that year, which I did (in English, translated into Bangla by Professor Manjula Bose); the Communists won handily again but one of their leaders (Sailen Dasgupta) declared there had never been a State Congress manifesto of the sort before, being as it was an Orwell-like critique of Bengal’s Stalinism.

In a later conversation, I said to him I wished he be appointed envoy to Britain, he instead came to be appointed envoy to the USA.

In Washington in September 1993, he said “You must meet Manmohan Singh”, and invited me to a luncheon at the Ambassador’s Residence where, to Manmohan Singh and all his aides, he declared pointing at me

“The Congress manifesto (of 1991) was written on his (laptop) computer”.

In later years I kept him informed of developments and gave him my publications.   We last met in July last year where I gave him a copy, much to his delight, of *Margaret Thatcher’s Revolution: How it Happened and What it Meant*.

I said to him Bengal’s public finances were in abysmal condition, calling for emergency measures financially, and that Mamata Banerjee seemed to me to be someone who knew how to and would dislodge the Communists from their entrenched misgovernance of decades but not quite aware that dislodging a bad government politically was not the same thing as knowing how to govern properly oneself.

He,  again of his own accord, said immediately,

“I will call her and her main people to a meeting here so you can meet them and tell them that directly”.

It never transpired.

He and I were supposed to meet a few months ago but could not due to his poor health; on the phone in our last conversation I mentioned to him my plans of creating a Public Policy Institute — an idea he immediately and fully endorsed as being essential though adding

“I can’t be part of it,  I’m on my way out”.

“I’m on my way out”.   :)

That was Siddhartha Shankar Ray — always intelligent, always good-humoured, always public-spirited, always a great Indian.

I shall miss a good friend, indeed my only friend among politicians other than the late Rajiv Gandhi himself.

Kolkata, November 7 2010

On Applying Disraeli’s “Two Nations” of Victorian England to Modern India: Roy & James, Rajiv, Rahul & Manmohan

From Subroto Roy & WE James’s Introduction 1989-1990 to Foundations of India’s Political Economy: Towards an Agenda for the 1990s edited by them, published by Sage 1992, received by Rajiv Gandhi on September 1990 in manuscript form.

“Finally, no discussion of the subcontinent’s political economy can ignore the fact of the monumental poverty of external goods on the part of a vast population, in contrast with a fairly large class of people with adequate livelihoods, in turn contrasting with small islands of indolence and conspicuous consumption.  Benjamin Disraeli said of Victorian England that it consisted of two nations.  The Indian subcontinent today consists in many respects of two nations living side by side, the real division being much less longitudinal on religious or communal lines (as intended by Muslim separatists at the time of Partition and Hindu imperialists today) as it is latitudinal on class lines between “bhadralok” and “janata”, middle class and working classes, bourgeoisie and masses, “nomenclatura” and proletariat.  The sheer numbers can justify speaking of whole nations, the janata in India alone consisting of something like seven hundred million people, the bhadralok of one hundred and fifty million.  The Indian bhadralok on their own constitute one of the largest nations on earth.

The bhadralok are not to be distinguished from the janata by any self-styled civility, nor is there any inevitable conflict which will lead to the victory of one and decimation of the other, nor is it that one derives its income from productive effort or enterprise and the other does not.  A more effective criterion by which to distinguish the two nations of India may have to do not with work but with leisure, as well as with the kind of capital that comes to be inherited over time. The janata are the unleisured nation of India, people who mostly due to the meagreness of their initial resources come to possess little or no leisure in the course of their lifetimes.  They are scattered and illiterate, without connections in high places, often too involved with the hardships of daily life to care for much else.  They eat and sleep to maintain the minimum energy needed to survive, reproduce and send their children to school or work, travelling through life day by day and week by week.  They may have some short time devoted to religion or entertainment, but life is too often too hard, not so much without happiness or culture as without much time for either.  Expectations of what life has to offer may be unambitious and yet successful.

Inequality from an economic point of view may consist of the fact that the poor do not inherit any leisure from the past.  They do not inherit the savings of their parents and ancestors because most did not have parents and ancestors who had any savings to leave behind.  Capital and the income it generates, and the consumption which such income makes possible, are among the most subtle notions of political economy.  As a rough approximation, if we distinguish between human capital, physical and financial capital, and social and political capital, it may be said that the inheritance of economic inequality in India may consist of the inheritance of economic inequality in India may consist of the inheritance by the janata of no form of capital except their own stock of human capital. There is little or no inheritance from parents of savings or any other form of capital.  Hence the janata are also the “garib lok”, the masses are also the poor folk.

By contrast the bhadralok are also the leisured nation of the subcontinent, with the time and inclination to praise or decry the state of the culture or the economy or the prime minister, to visit or return from the outside world (“baahar”) to the subcontinent or vice versa, to take a walk in the morning or a nap in the afternoon, to express compassion for or embarrassment about the existence of the janata (especially in relation to the foreigner since the bhadralok have to explain both their privileged position relative to the janata and their often underprivileged position relative to the foreigner with whom they desire to consort), to study the janata or lead them in revolution or take measurements of them, and to read, write, edit or publish books such as this one.  The bhadralok are the “respectable people” of the subcontinent, with names, family histories and reputations, literate and often highly educated, bilingual at least, with an inheritance of or illusions about acknowledged places in society.  They inherit from their parents and save for their children physical and financial capital, invest in their human capital, and bestow to them as much social and political capital as they can.  The mercantile and industrial bhadralok own and transfer to their children relatively more physical and financial capital, while the managerial, administrative and professional bhadralok may transfer relatively more social and political capital.  At the apex of both groups is an elite amounting to a few million people, united perhaps by their membership or attempted membership of the post-British social clubs and centres of intellectualism, or foreign universities and the lower middle classes of Britain and North America.

What may be expected in the long run is mobility between the two nations and in both directions.  Through indolence or bad luck, families can fall by a half or a third of a social class each generation, or move in the opposite direction through chance or cunning or enterprise and effort.  It is an essential feature of mass economic development that there will be net mobility upwards in the long run, and an attendant breakdown of social barriers and the gradual assimilation of classes and castes into one another.  Contrary to an assumption of the working classes being united in their despair and contempt for the middle class, and motivated in their desire to bloodily dispose of them, it may be more accurate to say that what unleisured people want most (after employment, food, shelter and clothing) is what they value most at the margin, namely, leisure.  What the working classes desire most may be something like the kind of life as the bourgeoisie.  Let aside there being a potential or open conflict arising from the janata against the bhadralok, the truth of the matter could be there is a desire of the janata to have at least some leisure like the bhadralok.

If this is an accurate assumption, the main source of conflict between the two nations of India or the subcontinent could be different from what is often supposed by many people.  Instead of being revolutionary in nature and deriving from below, the source may be reactionary in nature and amount to resistance from the top.  Like all cartels, the bhadralok may want to preserve their numbers and not look with favour at the prospect of large-scale mass economic development, entailing as this will greater competition on all fronts, the erosion of privilege, the breakdown of social barriers and the assimilation of classes into one another.

The Jacobin/Bolshevik/Maoist method of reducing inequalities was to expropriate physical and financial capital, and decimate social and political capital and all that stands in the way of such destruction.  The upheaval and chaos of such blood-letting leaves a new order which is, or seems, for a moment, more egalitarian than the regime it replaces.  But it also leaves a society without knowledge of its past, alternately enervated by its present and terrified of its future.  Recovery from such a state of near social death has been long and hard and painful, where it has happened at all.  Despite the wishes of a few, India does not seem likely to experience such social death on a national scale, although the temporary effects of terrorism and civil chaos in pockets of the country would seem to be similar.

A more far-sighted method would be by the creation of capital for the janata to increase their sources of income and consumption and thereby reduce the inequality of wealth and political power.  It would mean investment in the only form of capital that the janata have: their own human capital.  It would mean fundamentally a change of focus away from the theoretical and grandiose in the drawing-rooms and corridors of New Delhi (and Washington), and towards the simple and commonsensical: stopping the wastage of the tax-resources; making the currency sound at home and abroad; redirecting public investment towards public goods such as civil justice, roads, fresh water and sanitation; and fostering a civilized rural life, built around village schools with blackboards and chalk, with playgrounds and libraries and hot meals, with all-weather buildings and all-weather roads to their doors.

India today resembles a kind of gigantic closed city with high walls and few gates.  Within the walls are concurrently represented many different ages in the history of man, from pre-historic and early Aryan, to medieval and Moghul, to Dickensian and American, the members of each age having some common and some individual sets of life-expectations, yet all being due to enter the next century together. Outside is the rest of human civilization, as well as the free circulation of gold and foreign exchange.  Nearabouts the gates of the city, and with ability to travel in and out, are the few million of the elite.  If the walls of the city are to be knocked down or at least if the gates opened and kept wide open, it will have to be the elite who do this or consent to have it done.

If it is done properly, after adequate preparation of the economic and political expectations of citizens, there may be many positive results, not only for the economy but also for the culture and civilization of the subcontinent as a whole. The free flow of ideas and opportunities across national borders; the freedom to travel in the world; the free movement of goods and capital; the freedom to save one’s tangible wealth, small as this may be, in whatever form or currency one considers best — these are fundamentally important freedoms which have been denied to most of the people of the subcontinent thus far and yet are taken for granted elsewhere in the world.  There seems little reason to doubt that if such freedoms come to be gradually exercised by the janata there would be a permanent trend of increase in mass income and consumption.

Yet there are genuine questions of sovereignty which have to be anticipated as well.  The consequences of a true opening are not fully or easily foreseeable.  The prompt arrival of new East India Companies may be expected.  Will there be enough competition between them?  Or will the elite come to be further subverted, taking the first Indian Republic with it?  After the long experience of foreign rule and nationalism and independent democracy, is the Indian polity mature enough to survive and gain from such an opening, or will it collapse once again as it did in the eighteenth century?  The spectres of Plassey and Avadh must haunt every Indian nationalist, even as the hopes of a free economy and a progressive culture and an open civilization, beckon from the future.  Is it a silent and implicit fear of this sort which constitutes the only possible rational barrier to greater freedom?  Has the continued poverty been, in effect, the cost of nationalism?  These are hard questions to which answers may not be found easily. It is hoped by the editors that the present volume may engage the citizens and friends of India to reflect upon them….”

From Facebook 7 Sep 2010:

Rajiv Gandhi received this book in manuscript form in hand from me on Sep 18 1990, and it contributed to the origins of India’s 1991 economic reform as has been described elsewhere.  I am delighted to hear his son Rahul has in the last few days also been referring to India as “Two Nations”, rich and poor.  Dr Manmohan Singh received the book itself in hand from me at the Indian Ambassador’s Residence in Washington in Sepember 1993; I am glad to see he too has yesterday mentioned the same “Two Nations” theory that I had applied from Disraeli’s book about Victorian England.

Will the Telangana flare-up awaken New Delhi from its dream-world and into India’s political reality?

From Facebook:

Subroto Roy thinks the flare-up of the Telangana issue has one and only one positive consequence: it brings home to New Delhi’s ruling elite that there are real political questions in India, and not everything can be left to spin-doctors and lobbyists to handle.

Important summits in the USA, Russia, Copenhagen can be attended by the Prime Minister of India as he is not a Member of the Lok Sabha

From Facebook:

Subroto Roy notes that since Dr Manmohan Singh is the first Indian Prime Minister ever to have chosen with deliberation not to be a member of the Lok Sabha, he has been free to hold important summits at the White House, Kremlin, Copenhagen etc while the Lok Sabha debates mundane matters like the Liberhan Commission report, inflation etc.

Do diplomatic parties help the common man?

From Facebook

Subroto Roy is afraid he does not think the interests of the common man and woman of India come to be served in the slightest by a fancy dinner-party whether given by the Queen of  England at Buckingham Palace for the President of India or by the President of the United States at the White House for the Prime Minister of India….(…though some businessmen and bureaucrats become happy…)

Is Dr Manmohan Singh the “aam admi” that the Congress Party means?

Dr Manmohan Singh has in a televised meeting with children said about himself:

“I am an aam admi“.

I am afraid this caused me to say at Facebook today:

Subroto Roy  finds disconcerting Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s claim of being himself  “a common man”.

In “Rajiv Gandhi and the Origins of India’s 1991 Economic Reform”, I wrote about my encounter with Rajiv:

“I said the public sector’s wastefulness had drained scarce resources that should have gone instead to provide public goods. Since the public sector was owned by the public, it could be privatised by giving away its shares to the public, preferably to panchayats of the poorest villages. The shares would become tradable, drawing out black money, and inducing a historic redistribution of wealth while at the same time achieving greater efficiency by transferring the public sector to private hands. Rajiv seemed to like that idea too, and said he tried to follow a maxim of Indira Gandhi’s that every policy should be seen in terms of how it affected the common man. I wryly said the common man often spent away his money on alcohol, to which he said at once it might be better to think of the common woman instead. (This remark of Rajiv’s may have influenced the “aam admi” slogan of the 2004 election, as all Congress Lok Sabha MPs of the previous Parliament came to receive a previous version of the present narrative.)”

I am afraid I do not think Dr Singh was whom Rajiv or Indira had in mind in speaking of the common man.

Subroto Roy

Kolkata

Revisiting “On Hindus and Muslims”

It is four years exactly since I published “On Hindus and Muslims”.   I have had cause to revisit it today while saying at Facebook:

“Subroto Roy does not mind at all that 150 million Muslim Indians have been forbidden by their clergy from singing Vande Mataram — in fact rather sees their point of view. The Supreme Court of India also once upheld the right of two Jehovah’s Witnesses children who declined to sing Jana Gana Mana at school. India is a free country in such respects.

The Muslim point of view is that Muslim patriotism can be one of *love* for India without having to be one of *worship* of India — worship having to be reserved for Allah alone.

Hindus, for their part, do not take their own worship quite so seriously, and there is a lot of it — being happy enough to worship the mountains, the seas, the rivers, the birds and beasts and even sometimes other humans too…Or, for that matter, nothing at all…”

“Subroto Roy feels that if he had been Muslim by faith and a believer he may have preferred to live in a society where Muslims are a minority rather than one where almost everyone is Muslim. A Muslim believer allowed to freely practise among a majority of non-Muslims constantly finds faith reaffirmed within every day, whereas in a society where everyone is Muslim the problem always arises as to who is a bad, good or better Muslim.”

Memo to Mr Chidambaram: On the Existence of a Unique and Stable Solution to the Jammu & Kashmir Problem that is Lawful, Just and Economically Efficient

The Honourable P. Chidambaram
Home Minister of India

Respected Sir,

You may recall our brief interaction at the residence of the late Shri Rajiv Gandhi in September-October 1990, and also my visit to you in July 1995 when you were a member of the late Shri Narasimha Rao’s Government.

I am delighted to read in today’s paper that you believe a “unique solution” exists to the grave mortal problem of Jammu & Kashmir.   I write to say that almost four years ago, I published in The Statesman my discovery of the existence of precisely such a  unique solution in the three-part article “Solving Kashmir”.

This came to be followed by “Law, Justice and J&K”, “History of Jammu & Kashmir”, “Pakistan’s Allies”, “What to tell Musharraf” and a few others.  The purpose of this open letter is to describe that solution which provides, I believe, the only just and lawful  path available to the resolution of what has been known universally as the Kashmir problem.

Very briefly, it involves recognizing that the question of lawful territorial sovereignty in J&K is logically distinct from the question of the choice of nationality by individual inhabitants.   The solution requires

(a) acknowledging that the original legal entity in the world system  of nations known as Jammu & Kashmir arose on March 16 1846 and ceased to exist on or about October 22 1947; that the military contest that commenced on the latter date has in fact resulted, given all particular circumstances of history, in the lawful and just outcome in international law;

(b) offering all who may be Indian nationals or stateless and who presently live under Article 370, a formal choice of nationality between the Republics of India, Iran, Afghanistan and Pakistan: citizen-by-citizen, without fear or favour, under conditions of full information, individual privacy and security; any persons who voluntarily choose to renounce Indian nationality in such private individual decisions would be nevertheless granted lawful permanent residence in the Indian Republic and J&K in particular.

In other words, the dismemberment of the original J&K State and annexation of its territories by the entities known today as the Republic of Pakistan and Republic of India that occurred since October 22 1947, as represented first by the 1949 Ceasefire Line and then by the 1972 Line of Control, is indeed the just and lawful outcome prevailing in respect of the question of territorial sovereignty and jurisdiction. The remaining democratic question has to do with free individual choice of nationality by inhabitants, under conditions of full information and privacy, citizen-by-citizen, with the grant of permanent residency rights by the Indian Republic to persons under its jurisdiction in J&K who might wish to choose, for deeply personal individual reasons, not to remain Indian nationals but become Afghan, Iranian or Pakistani nationals instead (or remain stateless).  Pakistan has said frequently its sole concern has been the freedom of Muslims of J&K under Indian rule, and any such genuine concern shall have been thereby fully met by India. Indeed if Pakistan agreed to act similarly this entire complex mortal problem of decades shall have begun to be resolved most appropriately. Pakistan and India are both wracked by corruption, poverty and bad governance, and would be able to mutually draw down military forces pit against one another everywhere, so as to begin to repair the grave damage to their fiscal health caused over decades by the deleterious draining away of vast public resources.

The full reasoning underlying this, which I believe to be the only lawful, just, efficient and stable solution that exists, is thoroughly explained in the following six articles. The first five, “Solving Kashmir”, “Law, Justice & J&K”, “History of J&K”, and “Pakistan’s Allies”, “What to Tell Musharraf” were published in The Statesman in 2005-2006 and are marked ONE, TWO, THREE, FOUR and FIVE below, and are also available elsewhere here. The sixth “An Indian Reply to President Zardari”, marked SIX, was published for the first time here following the Mumbai massacres.

I believe careful reflection upon this entire body of reasoning may lead all reasonable men and women to a practically unanimous consensus about this as the appropriate course of action; if such a consensus happened to arise, the implementation of the solution shall only be a matter of (relatively) uncomplicated procedural detail.

Cordially yours

Subroto Roy, PhD (Cantab.), BScEcon (London)
Kolkata, October 15 2009

ONE
SOLVING KASHMIR: ON AN APPLICATION OF REASON by Subroto Roy First published in three parts in The Statesman, Editorial Page Special Article, December 1,2,3 2005, http://www.thestatesman.net

(This article has its origins in a paper “Towards an Economic Solution for Kashmir” which circulated in Washington DC in 1992-1995, including at the Indian and Pakistani embassies and the Carnegie Endowment, and was given as an invited lecture at the Heritage Foundation on June 23 1998. It should be read along with other articles also republished here, especially “History of J&K”, “Law, Justice and J&K” , “Understanding Pakistan”, “Pakistan’s Allies” and “What to Tell Musharraf”. The Washington paper and lecture itself originated from my ideas in the Introduction to Foundations of Pakistan’s Political Economy, edited by WE James and myself in the University of Hawaii project on Pakistan 1986-1992.)

I. Give Indian `Green Cards’ to the Hurriyat et al

India, being a liberal democracy in its constitutional law, cannot do in Jammu & Kashmir what Czechoslovakia did to the “Sudeten Germans” after World War II. On June 18 1945 the new Czechoslovakia announced those Germans and Magyars within their borders who could not prove they had been actively anti-fascist before or during the War would be expelled — the burden of proof was placed on the individual, not the State. Czechoslovakia “transferring” this population was approved by the Heads of the USA, UK and USSR Governments at Potsdam on August 2 1945. By the end of 1946, upto two million Sudeten Germans were forced to flee their homes; thousands may have died by massacre or otherwise; 165,000 remained who were absorbed as Czechoslovak citizens. Among those expelled were doubtless many who had supported Germany and many others who had not — the latter to this day seek justice or even an apology in vain. Czechoslovakia punished none of its nationals for atrocities, saying it had been revenge for Hitler’s evil (”badla” in Bollywood terms) and the post Cold War Czech Government too has declined to render an apology. Revenge is a wild kind of justice (while justice may be a civilised kind of revenge).

India cannot follow this savage precedent in international law. Yet we must recognise there are several hundred and up to several hundred thousand persons on our side of the boundary in the State of Jammu & Kashmir who do not wish to be Indian nationals. These people are presently our nationals ius soli, having been born in territory of the Indian Republic, and/or ius sanguinis, having been born of parents who are Indian nationals; or they may be “stateless” whom we must treat in accordance with the 1954 Convention on Stateless Persons. The fact is they may not wish to carry Indian passports or be Indian nationals.

In this respect their juridical persons resemble the few million “elite” Indians who have in the last few decades freely placed their hands on their hearts and solemnly renounced their Indian nationality, declaring instead their individual fidelity to other nation-states — becoming American, Canadian or Australian citizens, or British subjects or nationals of other countries. Such people include tens of thousands of the adult children of India’s metropolitan “elite”, who are annually visited abroad in the hot summer months by their Indian parents and relatives. They are daughters and sons of New Delhi’s Government and Opposition, of retired generals, air marshals, admirals, ambassadors, cabinet secretaries, public sector bureaucrats, private sector businessmen, university professors, journalists, doctors and many others. India’s most popular film-actress exemplified this “elite” capital-flight when, after a tireless search, she chose a foreign husband and moved to California.

The difference in Jammu & Kashmir would be that those wishing to renounce Indian nationality do not wish to move to any other place but to stay as and where they are, which is in Kashmir Valley or Jammu. Furthermore, they may wish, for whatever reason, to adopt, if they are eligible to do so, the nationality of e.g. the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan or the Islamic Republic of Iran or the Islamic Republic of Pakistan.

They may believe themselves descended from Ahmad Shah Abdali whose Afghans ruled or mis-ruled Kashmir Valley before being defeated by Ranjit Singh’s Sikhs in 1819. Or they may believe themselves of Iranian descent as, for example, are the Kashmiri cousins of the late Ayatollah Khomeini. Or they may simply have wished to be, or are descended from persons who had wished to be on October 26 1947, citizens of the then-new British Dominion of Pakistan — but who came to be prevented from properly expressing such a desire because of the war-like conditions that have prevailed ever since between India and Pakistan. There may be even a few persons in Laddakh who are today Indian nationals but who wish to be considered Tibetans instead; there is, however, no Tibetan Republic and it does not appear there is going to be one.

India, being a free and self-confident country, should allow, in a systematic lawful manner, all such persons to fulfil their desires, and furthermore, should ensure they are not penalised for having expressed such “anti-national” desires or for having acted upon them. Sir Mark Tully, the British journalist, is an example of someone who has been a foreign national who has chosen to reside permanently in the Republic of India — indeed he has been an exemplary permanent resident of our country. There are many others like him. There is no logical reason why all those persons in Jammu & Kashmir who do wish not to be Indians by nationality cannot receive the same legal status from the Indian Republic as has been granted to Sir Mark Tully. There are already thousands of Sri Lankan, Bangladeshi and Nepalese nationals who are lawful permanent residents in the Indian Republic, and who travel back and forth between India and their home countries. There is no logical reason why the same could not be extended to several hundred or numerous thousand people in Jammu & Kashmir who may wish to not accept or to renounce their Indian nationality (for whatever personal reason) and instead become nationals, if they are so eligible, of the Islamic Republics of Afghanistan, Iran or Pakistan, or, for that matter, to remain stateless. On the one hand, their renunciation of Indian nationality is logically equivalent to the renunciation of Indian nationality by the adult children of India’s “elite” settled in North America and Western Europe. On the other hand, their wish to adopt, if they are eligible, a foreign nationality, such as that of Afghanistan, Iran or Pakistan, and yet remain domiciled in Indian territory is logically equivalent to that of many foreign nationals domiciled in India already like Sir Mark Tully.

Now if you are a permanent resident of some country, you may legally have many, perhaps most, but certainly not all the rights and duties of nationals of that country. e.g., though you will have to pay all the same taxes, you may not be allowed to (or be required to) vote in national or provincial elections but you may in local municipal elections. At the same time, permanently residing foreign nationals are supposed to be equal under the law and have equal access to all processes of civil and criminal justice. (As may be expected though from human frailty, even the federal courts of the USA can be notorious in their injustice and racism towards “Green Card” holders relative to “full” American citizens.) Then again, as a permanently resident foreigner, while you will be free to work in any lawful trade or profession, you may not be allowed to work in some or perhaps any Government agencies, certainly not the armed forces or the police. Many Indians in the USA were engineering graduates, and because many engineering jobs or contracts in the USA are related to the US armed forces and require US citizens only, it is commonplace for Indian engineers to renounce their Indian nationality and become Americans because of this. Many Indian-American families have one member who is American, another Indian, a third maybe Canadian, a fourth Fijian or British etc.

The same can happen in the Indian State of Jammu & Kashmir if it evolves peacefully and correctly in the future. It is quite possible to imagine a productive family in a peaceful Kashmir Valley of the future where one brother is an officer in the Indian Armed Forces, another brother a civil servant and a sister a police officer of the J&K State Government, another sister being a Pakistani doctor, while cousins are Afghan or Iranian or “stateless” businessmen. Each family-member would have made his/her choice of nationality as an individual given the circumstances of his/her life, his/her personal comprehension of the facts of history, his/her personal political and/or religious persuasions, and similar deeply private considerations. All would have their children going to Indian schools and being Indian citizens ius soli and/or ius sanguinis. When the children grow up, they would be free to join, if they wished, the existing capital flight of other Indian adult children abroad and there renounce their Indian nationality as many have come to do.

II Revealing Choices Privately with Full Information
For India to implement such a proposal would be to provide an opportunity for all those domiciled in Kashmir Valley, Jammu and Laddakh to express freely and privately as individuals their deepest wishes about their own identities, in a confidential manner, citizen by citizen, case by case. This would thereby solve the fundamental democratic problem that has been faced ever since the Pakistani attack on the original State of Jammu & Kashmir commenced on October 22 1947, which came to be followed by the Rape of Baramulla — causing the formal accession of the State to the then-new Dominion of India on October 26 1947.

A period of, say, 30 months may be announced by the Government of India during which full information would be provided to all citizens affected by this change, i.e. all those presently governed by Article 370 of the Indian Constitution. The condition of full information may include, for example, easy access to Afghan, Iranian and Pakistani newspapers in addition to access to Indian media. Each such person wishing to either remain with Indian nationality (by explicitly requesting an Indian passport if he/she does not have one already — and such passports can be printed in Kashmiri and Urdu too), or to renounce Indian nationality and either remain stateless or adopt, if he/she is so eligible, the nationality of e.g. Afghanistan, Iran, or Pakistan, should be administratively assisted by the Government of India to make that choice.

In particular, he/she should be individually, confidentially, and without fear or favour assured and informed of his/her new rights and responsibilities. For example, a resident of Kashmir Valley who chooses to become a Pakistani citizen, such as Mr Geelani, would now enjoy the same rights and responsibilities in the Indian Republic that Mr Tully enjoys, and at the same time no longer require a visa to visit Pakistan just as Mr Tully needs no visa to enter Britain. In case individual participants in the Hurriyat choose to renounce Indian nationality and adopt some other, they would no longer be able to legally participate in Indian national elections or J&K’s State elections. That is something which they say they do not wish to do in any case. Those members of the Hurriyat who chose e.g. Pakistani nationality while still residing in Jammu & Kashmir, would be free to send postal ballots or cross the border and vote in Pakistan’s elections if and when these occur. There are many Canadians who live permanently in the USA who cross home to Canada in order to cast a ballot.

After the period of 30 months, every person presently under Article 370 of the Indian Constitution would have received a full and fair opportunity to privately and confidentially reveal his/her preference or choice under conditions of full information. “Partition”, “Plebiscite”, and “Military Decision” have been the three alternatives under discussion ever since the National Conference of Sheikh Mohammad Abdullah and his then-loyal Deputy, Bakshi Ghulam Mohammad, helped the Indian Army and Air Force in 1947-1948 fight off the savage attack against Jammu & Kashmir State that had commenced from Pakistan on October 22 1947. When, during the Pakistani attack, the Sheikh and Bakshi agreed to the Muslim Conference’s demand for a plebiscite among the people, the Pakistanis balked — the Sheikh and Bakshi then withdrew their offer and decisively and irrevocably chose to accede to the Indian Union. The people of Jammu & Kashmir, like any other, are now bound by the sovereign political commitments made by their forebears. Even so, given the painful mortal facts of the several decades since, the solution here proposed if properly implemented would be an incomparably more thorough democratic exercise than any conceivable plebiscite could ever have been.

Furthermore, regardless of the outcome, it would not entail any further “Partition” or population “transfer” which inevitably would degenerate into a savage balkanization, and has been ruled out as an unacceptable “deal-breaker” by the Indian Republic. Instead, every individual person would have been required, in a private and confidential decision-making process, to have chosen a nationality or to remain stateless — resulting in a multitude of cosmopolitan families in Jammu & Kashmir. But that is something commonplace in the modern world. Properly understood and properly implemented, we shall have resolved the great mortal problem we have faced for more than half a century, and Jammu & Kashmir can finally settle into a period of peace and prosperity. The boundary between India and Pakistan would have been settled by the third alternative mentioned at the time, namely, “Military Decision”.

III. Of Flags and Consulates in Srinagar and Gilgit
Pakistan has demanded its flag fly in Srinagar. This too can happen though not in the way Pakistan has been wishing to see it happen. A Pakistan flag might fly in the Valley just as might an Afghan and Iranian flag as well. Pakistan has wished its flag to fly as the sovereign over Jammu & Kashmir. That is not possible. The best and most just outcome is for the Pakistani flag to fly over a recognised Pakistani consular or visa office in Srinagar, Jammu and Leh. In diplomatic exchange, the Indian tricolour would have to fly over a recognised Indian consular or visa office in Muzaffarabad, Gilgit and Skardu.

Pakistan also may have to act equivalently with respect to the original inhabitants of the territory of Jammu & Kashmir that it has been controlling — allowing those people to become Indian nationals if they so chose to do in free private decisions under conditions of full information. In other words, the “Military Decision” that defines the present boundary between sovereign states must be recognised by Pakistan sincerely and permanently in a Treaty relationship with India — and all of Pakistan’s official and unofficial protégés like the Hurriyat and the “United Jehad Council” would have to do the same. Without such a sovereign commitment from the Government of Pakistan, as shown by decisive actions of lack of aggressive intent (e.g. as came to be implemented between the USA and USSR), the Government of India has no need to involve the Government of Pakistan in implementing the solution of enhancing free individual choice of nationality with regard to all persons on our side of the boundary.

The “Military Decision” regarding the sovereign boundary in Jammu & Kashmir will be so recognised by all only if it is the universally just outcome in international law. And that in fact is what it is.

The original Jammu & Kashmir State began its existence as an entity in international law long before the present Republics of India and Pakistan ever did. Pakistan commences as an entity on August 14 1947; India commences as an entity of international law with its signing of the Treaty of Versailles on June 20 1918. Jammu & Kashmir began as an entity on March 16 1846 — when the Treaty of Amritsar was signed between Gulab Singh Dogra and the British, one week after the Treaty of Lahore between the British and the defeated Sikh regency of the child Daleep Singh.

Liaquat Ali Khan and Zafrullah Khan both formally challenged on Pakistan’s behalf the legitimacy of Dogra rule in Jammu & Kashmir since the Treaty of Amritsar. The Pakistani Mission to the UN does so even today. The Pakistanis were following Sheikh Abdullah and Jawaharlal Nehru himself, who too had at one point challenged Dogra legitimacy in the past. But though the form of words of the Pakistan Government and the Nehru-Abdullah position were similar in their attacks on the Treaty of Amritsar, their underlying substantive reasons were as different as chalk from cheese. The Pakistanis attacked the Dogra dynasty for being Dogra — i.e. because they were Hindus and not Muslims governing a Muslim majority. Nehru and Abdullah denounced monarchic autocracy in favour of mass democracy, and so attacked the Dogra dynasty for being a dynasty. All were wrong to think the Treaty of Amritsar anything but a lawful treaty in international law.

Furthermore, in this sombre political game of great mortal consequence, there were also two other parties who were, or appeared to be, in favour of the dynasty: one because the dynasty was non-Muslim, the other, despite it being so. Non-Muslim minorities like many Hindus and Sikhs in the business and governmental classes, saw the Dogra dynasty as their protector against a feared communalist tyranny arising from the Sunni Muslim masses of Srinagar Valley, whom Abdullah’s rhetoric at Friday prayer-meetings had been inciting or at least awakening from slumber. At the same time, the communalists of the Muslim Conference who had broken away from Abdullah’s secular National Conference, sought political advantage over Abdullah by declaring themselves in favour of keeping the dynasty — even elevating it to become an international sovereign, thus flattering the already pretentious potentate that he would be called “His Majesty” instead of merely “His Highness”. The ancestry of today’s Hurriyat’s demands for an independent Jammu & Kashmir may be traced precisely to those May 21-22 1947 declarations of the Muslim Conference leader, Hamidullah Khan.

Into this game stumbled the British with all the mix of cunning, indifference, good will, impatience, arrogance and pomposity that marked their rule in India. At the behest of the so-called “Native Princes”, the 1929 Butler Commission had hinted that the relationship of “Indian India” to the British sovereign was conceptually different from that of “British India” to the British sovereign. This view was adopted in the Cabinet Mission’s 12 May 1946 Memorandum which in turn came to be applied by Attlee and Mountbatten in their unseemly rush to “Divide and Quit” India in the summer of 1947.

It created the pure legal illusion that there was such a thing as “Lapse of Paramountcy” at which Jammu & Kashmir or any other “Native State” of “Indian India” could conceivably, even for a moment, become a sovereign enjoying the comity of nations — contradicting Britain’s own position that only two Dominions, India and Pakistan, could ever be members of the British Commonwealth and hence members of the newly created UN. British pusillanimity towards Jammu & Kashmir’s Ruler had even extended to making him a nominal member of Churchill’s War Cabinet because he had sent troops to fight in Burma. But the legal illusion had come about because of a catastrophic misunderstanding on the part of the British of their own constitutional law.

The only legal scholar who saw this was B R Ambedkar in a lonely and brilliant technical analysis released to the press on June 17 1947. No “Lapse of Paramountcy” over the “Native Princes” of Indian India could occur in constitutional law. Paramountcy over Indian India would be automatically inherited by the successor state of British India at the Transfer of Power. That successor state was the new British Dominion of India as well as (when it came to be finalised by Partition from India) the new British Dominion of Pakistan (Postscript: the deleted words represent a mistake made in the original paper, corrected in “Law, Justice & J&K” in view of the fact the UN in 1947 deemed India alone the successor state of British India and Pakistan a new state in the world system). A former “Native Prince” could only choose to which Dominion he would go. No other alternative existed even for a single logical moment. Because the British had catastrophically failed to comprehend this aspect of their own constitutional law, they created a legal vacuum whereby between August 15 and October 22-26 1947, Jammu & Kashmir became a local and temporary sovereign recognised only by the Dominion of Pakistan (until October 22) and the Dominion of India (until October 26). But it was not a globally recognised sovereign and was never going to be such in international law. This was further proved by Attlee refusing to answer the J&K Prime Minister’s October 18 1947 telegram.

All ambiguity came to end with the Pakistani attack of October 22 1947, the Rape of Baramulla, the secession of an “Azad Kashmir”declared by Sardar Ibrahim, and the Pakistani coup détat in Gilgit on October 31 1947 followed by the massacre of Sikh soldiers of the J&K Army at Bunji. With those Pakistani actions, Gulab Singh’s Jammu & Kashmir State, founded on March 16 1846 by the Treaty of Amritsar, ceased to logically exist as an entity in international law and fell into a state of ownerless anarchy. The conflict between Ibrahim’s Muslim communalists backed by the new Dominion of Pakistan and Abdullah’s secularists backed by the new Dominion of India had become a civil war within a larger intra-Commonwealth war that itself was almost a civil war between forces of the same military.

Jammu & Kashmir territory had become ownerless. The Roman Law which is at the root of all municipal and international law in the world today would declare that in the ownership of such an ownerless entity, a “Military Decision” was indeed the just outcome. Sovereignty over the land, waters, forests and other actual and potential resources of the erstwhile State of Jammu & Kashmir has become divided by “Military Decision” between the modern Republics of India and Pakistan. By the proposal made herein, the people and their descendants shall have chosen their nationality and their domicile freely across the sovereign boundary that has come to result.

TWO
LAW, JUSTICE AND J&K
by Subroto Roy First published in two parts in The Sunday Statesman, July 2 2006 and The Statesman July 3 2006 http://www.thestatesman.net Editorial Page Special Article

I.
For a solution to J&K to be universally acceptable it must be seen by all as being lawful and just. Political opinion in Pakistan and India as well as all people and parties in J&K ~ those loyal to India, those loyal to Pakistan, and any others ~ will have to agree that, all things considered, such is the right course of action for everyone today in the 21st Century, which means too that the solution must be consistent with the facts of history as well as account reasonably for all moral considerations.

On August 14, 1947, the legal entity known as “British India”, as one of its final acts, and based on a sovereign British decision made only two months earlier, created out of some of its territory a new State defined in international law as the “Dominion of Pakistan”. British India extinguished itself the very next day, and the newly independent “Dominion of India” succeeded to all its rights and obligations in international law. As the legal successor of the “India” which had signed the Treaty of Versailles in 1919 and the San Francisco Declaration of 1945, the Dominion of India was already a member of the new UN as well as a signatory to many international treaties. By contrast, the Dominion of Pakistan had to apply afresh to sign treaties and become a member of international organisations. The theory put forward by Argentina that two new States, India and Pakistan, had been created ab initio, came to be rejected and was withdrawn by Argentina. Instead, Pakistan with the wholehearted backing of India was made a member of the UN, with all except Afghanistan voting in favour. (Afghanistan’s exceptional vote signalled presence of conflict over the Durand Line and idea of a Pashtunistan; Dr Khan Sahib and Abdul Ghaffar Khan were imprisoned by the Muslim League regime of NWFP which later supported the tribesmen who attacked J&K starting October 22, 1947; that conflict remains unresolved to this day, even after the American attack on the Taliban, the restart of a constitutional process in Afghanistan, and the purported mediation of US Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice.)

Zafrullah Khan, Pakistan’s distinguished first ambassador to the UN, claimed in September 1947: “Pakistan is not a new member of UNO but a successor to a member State which was one of the founders of the Organisation.” He noted that he himself had led India to the final session of the League of Nations in Geneva in 1939, and he wished to say that Pakistan had been present “as part of India… under the latter name” as a signatory to the Treaty of Versailles. This was, however, logically impossible. The Treaty of Versailles long predated (1) Mohammad Iqbal’s Allahabad Address which conceptualised for the first time in the 20th Century a Muslim State in Northwest India; (2) Rahmat Ali’s invention of the word “PAKSTAN” on the top floor of a London omnibus; (3) M. A. Jinnah and Fazlul Haq’s Lahore Resolution; and (4) the final British decision of June 3, 1947 to create by Partition out of “British India” a Dominion named Pakistan. Pakistan could not have acted in international law prior to having come into being or been created or even conceived itself. Zafrullah Khan would have been more accurate to say that the history of Pakistanis until August 14, 1947 had been one in common with that of their Indian cousins ~ or indeed their Indian brothers, since innumerable North Indian Muslim families came to be literally partitioned, with some brothers remaining Indians while other brothers became Pakistanis.

Pakistan was created at the behest of Jinnah’s Muslim League though with eventual agreement of the Indian National Congress (a distant ancestor of the political party going by the same name today). Pakistan arose not because Jinnah said Hindus and Muslims were “two nations” but because he and his League wished for a State where Muslims would find themselves ruled by fellow-Muslims and feel themselves part of a pan-Islamic culture. Yet Pakistan was intended to be a secular polity with Muslim-majority governance, not an Islamic theocracy. That Pakistan failed to become secular was exemplified most poignantly in the persecution Zafrullah himself later faced in his personal life as an Ahmadiya, even while he was Pakistan’s Foreign Minister. (The same happened later to Pakistan’s Nobel-winning physicist Abdus Salaam.) Pakistan was supposed to allow the genius of Indo-Muslim culture to flourish, transplanted from places like Lucknow and Aligarh which would never be part of it. In fact, the areas that are Pakistan today had in the 1937 provincial elections shown scant popular Muslim support for Jinnah’s League. The NWFP had a Congress Government in the 1946 elections, and its supporters boycotted the pro-Pakistan referendum in 1947. The imposition of Urdu culture as Pakistan’s dominant ethos might have come to be accepted later in West Punjab, Sindh and NWFP but it was not acceptable in East Bengal, and led inevitably to the Pakistani civil war and creation of Bangladesh by Sheikh Mujib in 1971.

In August 1947, the new Dominions of India and Pakistan were each supposed to protect their respective minority populations as their first political duty. Yet both palpably failed in this, and were reduced to making joint declarations pleading for peace and an end to communal killings and the abduction of women. The Karachi Government, lacking the wherewithal and administrative machinery of being a nation-state at all, and with only Liaquat and an ailing Jinnah as noted leaders, may have failed more conspicuously, and West Punjab, the Frontier and Sindh were soon emptied of almost all their many Sikhs and Hindus. Instead, the first act of the new Pakistan Government in the weeks after August 14, 1947 was to arrange for the speedy and safe transfer of the North Indian Muslim elite by air from Delhi using chartered British aeroplanes. The ordinary Muslim masses of UP, Delhi and East Punjab were left in danger from or were subjected to Sikh and Hindu mob attacks, especially as news and rumours spread of similar outrages against Pakistan’s departing minorities.

In this spiral of revenge attacks and counter-attacks, bloodshed inevitably spilled over from West and East Punjab into the northern Punjabi plains of Jammu, though Kashmir Valley remained conspicuously peaceful. Zafrullah and Liaquat would later claim it was this communal civil war which had caused thousands of newly decommissioned Mirpuri soldiers of the British Army, and thousands of Afridi and other Frontier tribesmen, to spontaneously act to “liberate” J&K’s Muslims from alleged tyranny under the Hindu Ruler or an allegedly illegal Indian occupation.

But the main attack on J&K State that began from Pakistan along the Manshera-Muzaffarabad road on October 22, 1947 was admittedly far too well-organised, well-armed, well-planned and well-executed to have been merely a spontaneous uprising of tribesmen and former soldiers. In all but name, it was an act of undeclared war of the new Dominion of Pakistan first upon the State of J&K and then upon the Indian Dominion. This became obvious to Field Marshall Auchinlek, who, as Supreme Commander of the armed forces of both India and Pakistan, promptly resigned and abolished the Supreme Command in face of the fact that two parts of his own forces were now at war with one another.

The invaders failed to take Srinagar solely because they lost their military purpose while indulging in the Rape of Baramula. Thousands of Kashmiri women of all communities ~ Muslim, Sikh and Hindu ~ were violated and transported back to be sold in markets in Peshawar and elsewhere. Such was standard practice in Central Asian tribal wars from long before the advent of Islam, and the invading tribesmen shared that culture. India’s Army and Air Force along with the militias of the secular democratic movement led by Sheikh Abdullah and those remaining loyal units of J&K forces, fought off the invasion, and liberated Baramula, Naushera, Uri, Poonch etc. Gilgit had a British-led coup détat against it bringing it under Pakistan’s control. Kargil was initially taken by the Pakistanis and then lost by them. Leh could have been but was not taken by Pakistani forces. But in seeking to protect Leh and to retake Kargil, the Indian Army lost the siege of Skardu ~ which ended reputedly with the infamous communication from the Pakistani commander to his HQ: “All Sikhs killed; all women raped.”

Legal theory
Now, in this grave mortal conflict, the legal theory to which both the Indian and Pakistani Governments have been wedded for sixty years is one that had been endorsed by the British Cabinet Mission in 1946 and originated with the Butler Commission of 1929. Namely, that “Lapse of Paramountcy” over the “Indian India” of the “Native States” could and did occur with the extinction of British India on August 15, 1947. By this theory, Hyderabad, J&K, Junagadh and the several other States which had not acceded to either Dominion were no longer subject to the Crown’s suzerainty as of that date. Both Dominions drew up “Instruments of Accession” for Rulers to sign upon the supposed “Lapse” of Paramountcy that was to occur with the end of British India.

Ever since, the Pakistan Government has argued that Junagadh’s Ruler acceded to Pakistan and Hyderabad’s had wished to do so but both were forcibly prevented by India. Pakistan has also argued the accession to India by J&K’s Ruler was “fraudulent” and unacceptable, and Sheikh Abdullah was a “Quisling” of India and it was not his National Conference but the Muslim Conference of Ibrahim, Abbas and the Mirwaiz (precursor of the Hurriyat) which represented J&K’s Muslims.

India argued that Junagadh’s accession to Pakistan or Hyderabad’s independence were legal and practical impossibilities contradicting the wills of their peoples, and that their integration into the Indian Dominion was carried out in an entirely legitimate manner in the circumstances prevailing.

On J&K, India has argued that not only had the Ruler requested Indian forces to fight off the Pakistani attack, and he acceded formally before Indian forces were sent, but also that democratic principles were fully adhered to in the unequivocal endorsement of the accession by Sheikh Abdullah and the National Conference and further by a duly called and elected J&K Constituent Assembly, as well as generations of Kashmiris since. In the Indian view, it is Pakistan which has been in illegal occupation of Indian territory from Mirpur, Muzaffarabad and Gilgit to Skardu all the way to the Khunjerab Pass, Siachen Glacier and K2, some of which it illegally ceded to its Communist Chinese ally, and furthermore that it has denied the peoples of these areas any democratic voice.

Roman law
In June 1947, it was uniquely and brilliantly argued by BR Ambedkar in a statement to the Press that the British had made a catastrophic error in comprehending their own constitutional law, that no such thing as “Lapse” of Paramountcy existed, and that suzerainty over the “Native States” of “Indian India” would be automatically transferred in international law to the successor State of British India. It was a legal illusion to think any Native State could be sovereign even for a single logical moment. On this theory, if the Dominion of India was the sole successor State in international law while Pakistan was a new legal entity, then a Native State which acceded to Pakistan after August 15, 1947 would have had to do so with the consent of the suzerain power, namely, India, as may be said to have happened implicitly in case of Chitral and a few others. Equally, India’s behaviour in integrating (or annexing) Junagadh and Hyderabad, would become fully explicable ~ as would the statements of Mountbatten, Nehru and Patel before October 1947 that they would accept J&K going to Pakistan if that was what the Ruler and his people desired. Pakistan unilaterally and by surprise went to war against J&K on October 22, declared the accession to India “fraudulent”, and to this day has claimed the territory of the original State of J&K is “disputed”. Certainly, even if the Ambedkar doctrine is applied that no “Lapse” was possible under British law, Pakistan did not recognise India’s jurisdiction there as the suzerain power as of August 15, 1947. Altogether, Pakistan’s sovereign actions from October 22 onwards amounted to acting to annex J&K to itself by military force ~ acts which came to be militarily resisted (with partial success) by India allied with Sheikh Abdullah’s National Conference and the remaining forces of J&K. By these military actions, Pakistan revealed that it considered J&K territory to have descended into a legal state of anarchy as of October 22, 1947, and hence open to resolution by “Military Decision” ~ as is indeed the just outcome under Roman Law, the root of all municipal and international law today, when there is a contest between claimants over an ownerless entity.

Choice of nationality
Hence, the present author concluded (“Solving Kashmir”, The Statesman December 1-3, 2005) that the dismemberment of the original J&K State and annexation of its territories by India and Pakistan that has occurred since 1947, as represented first by the 1949 Ceasefire Line and then by the 1972 Line of Control, is indeed the just and lawful outcome prevailing in respect of the question of territorial sovereignty and jurisdiction. The remaining “democratic” question described has to do with free individual choice of nationality by the inhabitants, under conditions of full information and privacy, citizen-by-citizen, with the grant of permanent residency rights by the Indian Republic to persons under its jurisdiction in J&K who may choose not to remain Indian nationals but become Afghan, Iranian or Pakistani nationals instead. Pakistan has said frequently its sole concern has been the freedom of the Muslims of J&K under Indian rule, and any such genuine concern shall have been thereby fully met by India. Indeed, if Pakistan agreed to act similarly, this entire complex mortal problem of decades shall have begun to be peacefully resolved. Both countries are wracked by corruption, poverty and bad governance, and would be able to mutually draw down military forces pit against one another everywhere, so as to begin to repair the grave damage to their fiscal health caused by the deleterious draining away of vast public resources.

THREE
HISTORY OF JAMMU & KASHMIR
by Subroto Roy First published in two parts in The Sunday Statesman, Oct 29 2006 and The Statesman Oct 30 2006, Editorial Page Special Article, http://www.thestatesman.net

At the advent of Islam in distant Arabia, India and Kashmir in particular were being visited by Chinese Buddhist pilgrims during Harsha’s reign. The great “Master of Law” Hiuen Tsiang visited between 629-645 and spent 631-633 in Kashmir (”Kia-chi-mi-lo”), describing it to include Punjab, Kabul and Kandahar. Over the next dozen centuries, Buddhist, Hindu, Muslim, Sikh and again Hindu monarchs came to rule the 85 mile long 40 mile wide territory on the River Jhelum’s upper course known as Srinagar Valley, as well as its adjoining Jammu in the upper plains of the Punjab and “Little Tibet” consisting of Laddakh, Baltistan and Gilgit.

In 1344, a Persian adventurer from Swat or Khorasan by name of Amir or Mirza, who had “found his way into the Valley and in time gained great influence at the Raja’s court”, proclaimed himself Sultan Shamsuddin after the death of the last Hindu monarchs of medieval Kashmir. Twelve of his descendants formed the Shamiri dynasty including the notorious Sikander and the just and tolerant Zainulabidin. Sikander who ruled 1386-1410 “submitted himself” to the Uzbek Taimur the Lame when he approached Kashmir in 1398 “and thus saved the country from invasion”. Otherwise, “Sikander was a gloomy ferocious bigot, and his zeal in destroying temples and idols was so intense that he is remembered as the Idol-Breaker. He freely used the sword to propagate Islam and succeeded in forcing the bulk of the population to conform outwardly to the Muslim religion. Most of the Brahmins refused to apostatise, and many of them paid with their lives the penalty for their steadfastness. Many others were exiled, and only a few conformed.”

Zainulabidin who ruled 1417-1467 “was a man of very different type”. “He adopted the policy of universal toleration, recalled the exiled Brahmins, repealed the jizya or poll-tax on Hindus, and even permitted new temples to be built. He abstained from eating flesh, prohibited the slaughter of kine, and was justly venerated as a saint. He encouraged literature, painting and music, and caused many translations to be made of works composed in Sanskrit, Arabic and other languages.” During his “long and prosperous reign”, he “constructed canals and built many mosques; he was just and tolerant”.

The Shamiri dynasty ended in 1541 when “some fugitive chiefs of the two local factions of the Makri and the Chakk invited Mirza Haidar Dughlat, a relation of Babar, to invade Kashmir. The country was conquered and the Mirza held it (nominally in name of Humayan) till 1551, when he was killed in a skirmish. The line… was restored for a few years, until in 1559 a Chakk leader, Ghazi Shah, usurped the throne; and in the possession of his descendants it remained for nearly thirty years.” This dynasty marks the origins of Shia Islam in Srinagar though Shia influence in Gilgit, Baltistan and Laddakh was of longer standing. Constant dissensions weakened the Chakks, and in 1586, Akbar, then at Attock on the Indus, sent an army under Raja Bhagwan Das into Srinagar Valley and easily made it part of his Empire.

Shivaism and Islam both flourished, and Hindu ascetics and Sufi saints were revered by all. Far from Muslims and Hindus forming distinct nations, here they were genetically related kinsmen living in proximity in a small isolated area for centuries. Indeed Zainulabidin may have had a vast unspoken influence on the history of all India insofar as Akbar sought to attempt in his empire what Zainulabidin achieved in the Valley. Like Zainulabidin, Akbar’s governance of India had as its “constant aim” “to conciliate the Hindus and to repress Muslim bigotry” which in modern political parlance may be seen as the principle of secular governance ~ of conciliating the powerless (whether majority or minority) and repressing the bigotry of the powerful (whether minority or majority). Akbar had made the Valley the summer residence of the Mughals, and it was Jahangir, seeing the Valley for the first time, who apparently said the words agar behest baushad, hamee in hast, hamee in hast, hamee in hast: “if Heaven exists, it is here, it is here, it is here”. Yet like other isolated paradises (such as the idyllic islands of the Pacific Ocean) an accursed mental ether can accompany the magnificent beauty of people’s surroundings. As the historian put it: “The Kashmiris remained secure in their inaccessible Valley; but they were given up to internal weakness and discord, their political importance was gone…”

After the Mughals collapsed, Iran’s Turkish ruler Nadir Shah sacked Delhi in 1739 but the Iranian court fell in disarray upon his death. In 1747 a jirga of Pashtun tribes at Kandahar “broke normal tradition” and asked an old Punjabi holy man and shrine-keeper to choose between two leaders; this man placed young wheat in the hand of the 25 year old Ahmed Shah Saddozai of the Abdali tribe, and titled him “Durrani”. Five years later, Durrani took Kashmir and for the next 67 years the Valley was under Pashtun rule, a time of “unmitigated brutality and widespread distress”. Durrani himself “was wise, prudent and simple”, never declared himself king and wore no crown, instead keeping a stick of young wheat in his turban. Leaving India, he famously recited: “The Delhi throne is beautiful indeed, but does it compare with the mountains of Kandahar?”

Kashmir’s modern history begins with Ranjit Singh of the Sikhs who became a soldier at 12, and in 1799 at age 19 was made Lahore’s Governor by Kabul’s Zaman Shah. Three years later “he made himself master of Amritsar”, and in 1806 crossed the River Sutlej and took Ludhiana. He created a fine Sikh infantry and cavalry under former officers of Napoleon, and with 80,000 trained men and 500 guns took Multan and Peshawar, defeated the Pashtuns and overran Kashmir in 1819. The “cruel rule” of the Pashtuns ended “to the great relief of Kashmir’s inhabitants”.

The British Governor-General Minto (ancestor of the later Viceroy), seeing advantage in the Sikhs staying north of the Sutlej, sent Charles Metcalfe, “a clever young civilian”, to persuade the Khalsa; in 1809, Ranjit Singh and the British in the first Treaty of Amritsar agreed to establish “perpetual amity”: the British would “have no concern” north of the Sutlej and Ranjit Singh would keep only minor personnel south of it. In 1834 and 1838 Ranjit Singh was struck by paralysis and died in 1839, leaving no competent heir. The Sikh polity collapsed, “their power exploded, disappearing in fierce but fast flames”. It was “a period of storm and anarchy in which assassination was the rule” and the legitimate line of his son and grandson, Kharak Singh and Nao Nihal Singh was quickly extinguished. In 1845 the Queen Regent, mother of the five-year old Dalip Singh, agreed to the Khalsa ending the 1809 Treaty. After bitter battles that might have gone either way, the Khalsa lost at Sobraon on 10 February 1846, and accepted terms of surrender in the 9 March 1846 Treaty of Lahore. The kingdom had not long survived its founder: “created by the military and administrative genius of one man, it crumbled into powder when the spirit which gave it life was withdrawn; and the inheritance of the Khalsa passed into the hands of the English.”

Ranjit Singh’s influence on modern J&K was even greater through his having mentored the Rajput Gulab Singh Dogra (1792-1857) and his brothers Dhyan Singh and Suchet Singh. Jammu had been ruled by Ranjit Deo until 1780 when the Sikhs made it tributary to the Lahore Court. Gulab Singh, a great grand nephew of Ranjit Deo, had left home at age 17 in search of a soldierly fortune, and ended up in 1809 in Ranjit Singh’s army, just when Ranjit Singh had acquired for himself a free hand to expand his domains north of the River Sutlej.

Gulab Singh, an intrepid soldier, by 1820 had Jammu conferred upon him by Ranjit Singh with the title of Raja, while Bhimber, Chibal, Poonch and Ramnagar went to his brothers. Gulab Singh, “often unscrupulous and cruel, was a man of considerable ability and efficiency”; he “found his small kingdom a troublesome charge but after ten years of constant struggles he and his two brothers became masters of most of the country between Kashmir and the Punjab”, though Srinagar Valley itself remained under a separate Governor appointed by the Lahore Court. Gulab Singh extended Jammu’s rule from Rawalpindi, Bhimber, Rajouri, Bhadarwah and Kishtwar, across Laddakh and into Tibet. His General Zorawar Singh led six expeditions into Laddakh between 1834 and 1841 through Kishtwar, Padar and Zanskar. In May 1841, Zorawar left Leh with an army of 5000 Dogras and Laddakhis and advanced on Tibet. Defeating the Tibetans at Rudok and Tashigong, he reached Minsar near Lake Mansarovar from where he advanced to Taklakot (Purang), 15 miles from the borders of Nepal and Kumaon, and built a fort stopping for the winter. Lhasa sent large re-inforcements to meet him. Zorawar, deciding to take the offensive, was killed in the Battle of Toyu, on 11-12 December 1841 at 16,000 feet.

A Laddakhi rebellion resulted against Jammu, aided now by the advancing Tibetans. A new army was sent under Hari Chand suppressing the rebellion and throwing back the Tibetans, leading to a peace treaty between Lhasa and Jammu signed on 17 September 1842: “We have agreed that we have no ill-feelings because of the past war. The two kings will henceforth remain friends forever. The relationship between Maharajah Gulab Singh of Kashmir and the Lama Guru of Lhasa (Dalai Lama) is now established. The Maharajah Sahib, with God (Kunchok) as his witness, promises to recognise ancient boundaries, which should be looked after by each side without resorting to warfare. When the descendants of the early kings, who fled from Laddakh to Tibet, now return they will not be stopped by Shri Maharajah. Trade between Laddakh and Tibet will continue as usual. Tibetan government traders coming into Laddakh will receive free transport and accommodations as before, and the Laddakhi envoy will, in turn, receive the same facilities in Lhasa. The Laddakhis take an oath before God (Kunchok) that they will not intrigue or create new troubles in Tibetan territory. We have agreed, with God as witness, that Shri Maharajah Sahib and the Lama Guru of Lhasa will live together as members of the same household.” The traditional boundary between Laddakh and Tibet “as recognised by both sides since olden times” was accepted by the envoys of Gulab Singh and the Dalai Lama.

An earlier 1684 treaty between Laddakh and Lhasa had said that while Laddakh would send tribute to Lhasa every three years, “the king of Laddakh reserves to himself the village of Minsar in Ngarees-khor-sum, that he may be independent there; and he sets aside its revenue for the purpose of meeting the expense involved in keeping up the sacrificial lights at Kangree (Kailas), and the Holy Lakes of Mansarovar and Rakas Tal”. The area around Minsar village near Lake Mansarovar, held by the rulers of Laddakh since 1583, was retained by Jammu in the 1842 peace-treaty, and its revenue was received by J&K State until 1948.

After Ranjit Singh’s death in 1839, Gulab Singh was alienated from the Lahore Court where the rise of his brothers and a nephew aroused enough Khalsa jealousy to see them assassinated in palace intrigues. While the Sikhs imploded, Gulab Singh had expanded his own dominion from Rawalpindi to Minsar ~ everywhere except Srinagar Valley itself. He had apparently advised the Sikhs not to attack the British in breach of the 1809 Treaty, and when they did so he had not joined them, though had he done so British power in North India might have been broken. The British were grateful for his neutrality and also his help in their first misbegotten adventure in Afghanistan. It was Gulab Singh who was now encouraged by both the British and the Sikhs to mediate between them, indeed “to take a leading part in arranging conditions of peace”, and he formally represented the Sikh regency in the negotiations. The 9 March 1846 Treaty of Lahore “set forth that the British Government having demanded in addition to a certain assignment of territory, a payment of a crore and a half of rupees, and the Sikh Government being unable to pay the whole”, Dalip Singh “should cede as equivalent to one crore the hill country belonging to the Punjab between the Beas and the Indus including Kashmir and the Hazara”.

For the British to occupy the whole of this mountainous territory was judged unwise on economic and military grounds; it was not feasible to occupy from a military standpoint and the area “with the exception of the small Valley of Kashmir” was “for the most part unproductive”. “On the other hand, the ceded tracts comprised the whole of the hereditary possessions of Gulab Singh, who, being eager to obtain an indefeasible title to them, came forward and offered to pay the war indemnity on condition that he was made the independent ruler of Jammu & Kashmir.

A separate treaty embodying this arrangement was thus concluded between the British and Gulab Singh at Amritsar on 16 March 1846.” Gulab Singh acknowledged the British Government’s supremacy, and in token of it agreed to present annually to the British Government “one horse, twelve shawl goats of approved breed and three pairs of Kashmir shawls. This arrangement was later altered; the annual presentation made by the Kashmir State was confined to two Kashmir shawls and three romals (handkerchiefs).” The Treaty of Amritsar “put Gulab Singh, as Maharaja, in possession of all the hill country between the Indus and the Ravi, including Kashmir, Jammu, Laddakh and Gilgit; but excluding Lahoul, Kulu and some areas including Chamba which for strategic purposes, it was considered advisable (by the British) to retain and for which a remission of Rs 25 lakhs was made from the crore demanded, leaving Rs 75 lakhs as the final amount to be paid by Gulab Singh.” The British retained Hazara which in 1918 was included into NWFP. Through an intrigue emanating from Prime Minister Lal Singh in Lahore, Imamuddin, the last Sikh-appointed Governor of Kashmir, sought to prevent Gulab Singh taking possession of the Valley in accordance with the Treaty’s terms. By December 1846 Gulab Singh had done so, though only with help of a British force which included 17,000 Sikh troops “who had been fighting in the campaign just concluded”. (Contemporary British opinion even predicted Sikhism like Buddhism “would become extinct in a short time if it were not kept alive by the esprit de corps of the Sikh regiments”.)

The British in 1846 may have been glad enough to allow Gulab Singh take independent charge of the new entity that came to be now known as the “State of Jammu & Kashmir”. Later, however. they and their American allies would grow keen to control or influence the region vis-à-vis their new interests against the Russian and Soviet Empires.

FOUR
PAKISTAN’S ALLIES
by Subroto Roy First published in two parts in The Sunday Statesman, June 4 2006, The Statesman June 5 2006, Editorial Page Special Article, http://www.thestatesman.net

From the 1846 Treaty of Amritsar creating the State of Jammu & Kashmir until the collapse of the USSR in 1991, Britain and later the USA became increasingly interested in the subcontinent’s Northwest. The British came to India by sea to trade. Barren, splendid, landlocked Afghanistan held no interest except as a home of fierce tribes; but it was the source of invasions into the Indian plains and prompted a British misadventure to install Shah Shuja in place of Dost Mohammad Khan leading to ignominious defeat. Later, Afghanistan was seen as the underbelly of the Russian and Soviet empires, and hence a location of interest to British and American strategic causes.

In November 1954, US President Dwight Eisenhower authorized 30 U-2 spy aircraft to be produced for deployment against America’s perceived enemies, especially to investigate Soviet nuclear missiles which could reach the USA. Reconnaissance balloons had been unsuccessful, and numerous Western pilots had been shot down taking photographs from ordinary military aircraft. By June 1956, U-2 were making clandestine flights over the USSR and China. But on May 1 1960, one was shot or forced down over Sverdlovsk, 1,000 miles within Soviet territory. The Americans prevaricated that it had taken off from Turkey on a weather-mission, and been lost due to oxygen problems. Nikita Kruschev then produced the pilot, Francis Gary Powers, who was convicted of spying, though was exchanged later for a Soviet spy. Powers had been headed towards Norway, his task to photograph Soviet missiles from 70,000 ft, his point of origin had been an American base 20 miles from Peshawar.

America needed clandestine “forward bases” from which to fly U-2 aircraft, and Pakistan’s ingratiating military and diplomatic establishment was more than willing to offer such cooperation, fervently wishing to be seen as a “frontline state” against the USSR. “We will help you defeat the USSR and we are hopeful you will help us defeat India” became their constant refrain. By 1986, the Americans had been permitted to build air-bases in Balochistan and also use Mauripur air-base near Karachi.

Jammu & Kashmir and especially Gilgit-Baltistan adjoins the Pashtun regions whose capital has been Peshawar. In August-November 1947, a British coup d’etat against J&K State secured Gilgit-Baltistan for the new British Dominion of Pakistan.

The Treaty of Amritsar had nowhere required Gulab Singh’s dynasty to accept British political control in J&K as came to be exercised by British “Residents” in all other Indian “Native States”. Despite this, Delhi throughout the late 19th Century relentlessly pressed Gulab Singh’s successors Ranbir Singh and Partab Singh to accept political control. The Dogras acquiesced eventually. Delhi’s desire for control had less to do with the welfare of J&K’s people than with protection of increasing British interests in the area, like European migration to Srinagar Valley and guarding against Russian or German moves in Afghanistan. “Sargin” or “Sargin Gilit”, later corrupted by the Sikhs and Dogras into “Gilgit”, had an ancient people who spoke an archaic Dardic language “intermediate between the Iranian and the Sanskritic”. “The Dards were located by Ptolemy with surprising accuracy on the West of the Upper Indus, beyond the headwaters of the Swat River (Greek: Soastus) and north of the Gandarae (i.e. Kandahar), who occupied Peshawar and the country north of it. This region was traversed by two Chinese pilgrims, Fa-Hsien, coming from the north about AD 400 and Hsuan Tsiang, ascending from Swat in AD 629, and both left records of their journeys.”

Gilgit had been historically ruled by a Hindu dynasty called Trakane; when they became extinct, Gilgit Valley “was desolated by successive invasions of neighbouring rulers, and in the 20 or 30 years ending with 1842 there had been five dynastic revolutions. The Sikhs entered Gilgit about 1842 and kept a garrison there.” When J&K came under Gulab Singh, “the Gilgit claims were transferred with it, and a boundary commission was sent” by the British. In 1852 the Dogras were driven out with 2,000 dead. In 1860 under Ranbir Singh, the Dogras “returned to Gilgit and took Yasin twice, but did not hold it. They also in 1866 invaded Darel, one of the most secluded Dard states, to the south of the Gilgit basin but withdrew again.”

The British appointed a Political Agent in Gilgit in 1877 but he was withdrawn in 1881. “In 1889, in order to guard against the advance of Russia, the British Government, acting as the suzerain power of Kashmir, established the Gilgit Agency”. The Agency was re-established under control of the British Resident in Jammu & Kashmir. “It comprised the Gilgit Wazarat; the State of Hunza and Nagar; the Punial Jagir; the Governorships of Yasin, Kuh-Ghizr and Ishkoman, and Chilas”. In 1935, the British demanded J&K lease to them for 60 years Gilgit town plus most of the Gilgit Agency and the hill-states Hunza, Nagar, Yasin and Ishkuman. Hari Singh had no choice but to acquiesce. The leased region was then treated as part of British India, administered by a Political Agent at Gilgit responsible to Delhi, first through the Resident in J& K and later a British Agent in Peshawar. J& K State no longer kept troops in Gilgit and a mercenary force, the Gilgit Scouts, was recruited with British officers and paid for by Delhi. In April 1947, Delhi decided to formally retrocede the leased areas to Hari Singh’s J& K State as of 15 August 1947. The transfer was to formally take place on 1 August.

On 31 July, Hari Singh’s Governor arrived to find “all the officers of the British Government had opted for service in Pakistan”. The Gilgit Scouts’ commander, a Major William Brown aged 25, and his adjutant, a Captain Mathieson, planned openly to engineer a coup détat against Hari Singh’s Government. Between August and October, Gilgit was in uneasy calm. At midnight on 31 October 1947, the Governor was surrounded by the Scouts and the next day he was “arrested” and a provisional government declared.

Hari Singh’s nearest forces were at Bunji, 34 miles from Gilgit, a few miles downstream from where the Indus is joined by Gilgit River. The 6th J& K Infantry Battalion there was a mixed Sikh-Muslim unit, typical of the State’s Army, commanded by a Lt Col. Majid Khan. Bunji controlled the road to Srinagar. Further upstream was Skardu, capital of Baltistan, part of Laddakh District where there was a small garrison. Following Brown’s coup in Gilgit, Muslim soldiers of the 6th Infantry massacred their Sikh brothers-at-arms at Bunji. The few Sikhs who survived escaped to the hills and from there found their way to the garrison at Skardu.

On 4 November 1947, Brown raised the new Pakistani flag in the Scouts’ lines, and by the third week of November a Political Agent from Pakistan had established himself at Gilgit. Brown had engineered Gilgit and its adjoining states to first secede from J&K, and, after some talk of being independent, had promptly acceded to Pakistan. His commander in Peshawar, a Col. Bacon, as well as Col. Iskander Mirza, Defence Secretary in the new Pakistan and later to lead the first military coup détat and become President of Pakistan, were pleased enough. In July 1948, Brown was awarded an MBE (Military) and the British Governor of the NWFP got him a civilian job with ICI~ which however sent him to Calcutta, where he came to be attacked and left for dead on the streets by Sikhs avenging the Bunji massacre. Brown survived, returned to England, started a riding school, and died in 1984. In March 1994, Pakistan awarded his widow the Sitara-I-Pakistan in recognition of his coup détat.

Gilgit’s ordinary people had not participated in Brown’s coup which carried their fortunes into the new Pakistan, and to this day appear to remain without legislative representation. It was merely assumed that since they were mostly Muslim in number they would wish to be part of Pakistan ~ which also became Liaquat Ali Khan’s assumption about J&K State as a whole in his 1950 statements in North America. What the Gilgit case demonstrates is that J&K State’s descent into a legal condition of ownerless anarchy open to “Military Decision” had begun even before the Pakistani invasion of 22 October 1947 (viz. “Solving Kashmir”, The Statesman, 1-3 December 2005). Also, whatever else the British said or did with respect to J & K, they were closely allied to the new Pakistan on the matter of Gilgit.

The peak of Pakistan’s Anglo-American alliance came with the enormous support in the 1980s to guerrilla forces created and headquartered in Peshawar, to battle the USSR and Afghan communists directly across the Durand Line. It was this guerrilla war which became a proximate cause of the collapse of the USSR as a political entity in 1991. President Ronald Reagan’s CIA chief William J. Casey sent vast sums in 1985-1988 to supply and train these guerrillas. The Washington Post and New Yorker reported the CIA training guerrillas “in the use of mortars, rocket grenades, ground-to-air missiles”. 200 hand-held Stinger missiles were supplied for the first time in 1986 and the New Yorker reported Gulbudin Hikmatyar’s “Hizbe Islami” guerrillas being trained to bring down Soviet aircraft. “Mujahideen had been promised two Stingers for every Soviet aircraft brought down. Operators who failed to aim correctly were given additional training… By 1986, the United States was so deeply involved in the Afghan war that Soviet aircraft were being brought down under the supervision of American experts”. (Raja Anwar, The Tragedy of Afghanistan, 1988, p. 234).

The budding US-China détente brokered by Pakistan came into full bloom here. NBC News on 7 January 1980 said “for the first time in history (a senior State Department official) publicly admitted the possibility of concluding a military alliance between the United States and China”. London’s Daily Telegraph reported on 5 January 1980 “China is flying large supplies of arms and ammunition to the insurgents in Afghanistan. According to diplomatic reports, supplies have arrived in Pakistan from China via the Karakoram Highway…. A major build-up of Chinese involvement is underway ~ in the past few days. Scores of Chinese instructors have arrived at the Shola-e-Javed camps.”

Afghan reports in 1983-1985 said “there were eight training camps near the Afghan border operated by the Chinese in Sinkiang province” and that China had supplied the guerrillas “with a variety of weapons including 40,000 RPG-7 and 20,000 RPG-II anti tank rocket launchers.” Like Pakistan, “China did not publicly admit its involvement in the Afghan conflict: in 1985 the Chinese Mission at the UN distributed a letter denying that China was extending any kind of help to the Afghan rebels” (Anwar, ibid. p. 234). Support extended deep and wide across the Arab world. “The Saudi and Gulf rulers … became the financial patrons of the Afghan rebels from the very start of the conflict”. Anwar Sadat, having won the Nobel Peace Prize, was “keen to claim credit for his role in Afghanistan…. by joining the Afghanistan jihad, Sadat could re-establish his Islamic credentials, or so he believed. He could thus not only please the Muslim nations but also place the USA and Israel in his debt.” Sadat’s Defence Minister said in January 1980: “Army camps have been opened for the training of Afghan rebels; they are being supplied with weapons from Egypt” and Sadat told NBC News on 22 September 1981 “that for the last twenty-one months, the USA had been buying arms from Egypt for the Afghan rebels. He said he had been approached by the USA in December 1979 and he had decided to `open my stores’. He further disclosed that these arms were being flown to Pakistan from Egypt by American aircraft. Egypt had vast supplies of SAM-7 and RPG-7 anti-aircraft and anti-tank weapons which Sadat agreed to supply to Afghanistan in exchange for new American arms. The Soviet weapons, being light, were ideally suited to guerrilla warfare. … the Mujahideen could easily claim to have captured them from Soviet and Afghan troops in battle.… Khomeini’s Iran got embroiled in war (against Iraq) otherwise Kabul would also have had to contend with the full might of the Islamic revolutionaries.” (Anwar ibid. p. 235).

Afghanistan had been occupied on 26-27 December 1979 by Soviet forces sent by the decrepit Leonid Brezhnev and Yuri Andropov to carry out a putsch replacing one communist, Hafizullah Amin, with a rival communist and Soviet protégé, Babrak Karmal. By 1985 Brezhnev and Andropov were dead and Mikhail Sergeyevich Gorbachev had begun his attempts to reform the Soviet system, usher in openness, end the Cold War and in particular withdraw from Afghanistan, which by 1986 he had termed “a bleeding wound”. Gorbachev replaced Karmal with a new protégé Najibullah Khan, who was assigned the impossible task of bringing about national reconciliation with the Pakistan-based guerrillas and form a national government. Soviet forces withdrew from Afghanistan in February 1989 having lost 14,500 dead, while more than a million Afghans had been killed since the invasion a decade earlier.

Not long after Russia’s Bolshevik Revolution, Gregory Zinoviev had said that international communism “turns today to the peoples of the East and says to them, `Brothers, we summon you to a Holy War first of all against British imperialism!’ At this there were cries of Jehad! Jehad! And much brandishing of picturesque Oriental weapons.” (Treadgold, Twentieth Century Russia, 1990, p. 213). Now instead, the Afghan misadventure had contributed to the collapse of the Soviet Empire itself, the USSR ceasing to be a political entity by 1991, and even Gorbachev being displaced by Boris Yeltsin and later Vladimir Putin in a new Russia.

What resulted for the people of the USA and Britain and the West in general was that they no longer had to live under threat of hostile Soviet tanks and missiles, while the people of Russia, Ukraine and the other erstwhile Soviet republics as well as Eastern Europe were able to throw off the yoke of communism that had oppressed them since the Bolshevik Revolution and instead to breathe the air of freedom.

What happened to the people of Afghanistan, however, was that they were plunged into further ghastly civil war for more than ten years. And what happened to the people of Pakistan was that their country was left resembling a gigantic Islamist military camp, awash with airfields, arms, ammunition and trained guerrillas, as well as a military establishment enlivened as always by perpetual hope that these supplies, provisions and personnel of war might find alternative use in attacks against India over J& K. “We helped you when you wished to see the Soviet Union defeated and withdrawing in Afghanistan”, Pakistan’s generals and diplomats pleaded with the Americans and British, “now you must help us in our wish to see India defeated and withdrawing in Kashmir”. Pakistan’s leaders even believed that just as the Soviet Union had disintegrated afterwards, the Indian Union perhaps might be made to do the same. Not only were the two cases as different as chalk from cheese, Palmerstone’s dictum there are no permanent allies in the politics of nations could not have found more apt use than in what actually came to take place next.

Pakistan’s generals and diplomats felt betrayed by the loss of Anglo-American paternalism towards them after 1989.

Modern Pakistanis had never felt they subscribed to the Indian nationalist movement culminating in independence in August 1947. The Pakistani state now finally declared its independence in the world by exploding bombs in a nuclear arsenal secretly created with help purchased from China and North Korea. Pakistan’s leaders thus came to feel in some control of Pakistan’s destiny as a nation-state for the first time, more than fifty years after Pakistan’s formal creation in 1947. If nothing else, at least they had the Bomb.

Secondly, America and its allies would not be safe for long since the civil war they had left behind in Afghanistan while trying to defeat the USSR now became a brew from which arose a new threat of violent Islamism. Osama bin Laden and the Taliban, whom Pakistan’s military and the USA had promoted, now encouraged unprecedented attacks on the American mainland on September 11 2001 ~ causing physical and psychological damage which no Soviet, Chinese or Cuban missiles ever had been allowed to do. In response, America attacked and removed the Taliban regime in Afghanistan, once again receiving the cooperative use of Pakistani manpower and real estate ~ except now there was no longer any truck with the Pakistani establishment’s wish for a quid pro quo of Anglo-American support against India on J&K. Pakistan’s generals and diplomats soon realised their Anglo-American alliance of more than a half-century ended on September 11 2001. Their new cooperation was in killing or arresting and handing over fellow-Muslims and necessarily lacked their earlier feelings of subservience and ingratiation towards the Americans and British, and came to be done instead under at least some duress. No benefit could be reaped any more in the fight against India over Jammu & Kashmir. An era had ended in the subcontinent.

FIVE

WHAT TO TELL MUSHARRAF: PEACE IS IMPOSSIBLE WITHOUT NON-AGGRESSIVE PAKISTANI INTENTIONS by Subroto Roy, First published in The Statesman December 15 2006 Editorial Page Special Article, www.thestatesman.net

In June 1989 a project at an American university involving Pakistani and other scholars, including one Indian, led to the book Foundations of Pakistan’s Political Economy: Towards an Agenda for the 1990s published in Karachi, New Delhi and elsewhere. The book reached Nawaz Sharif and the Islamabad elite, and General Musharraf’s current proposal on J&K, endorsed warmly by the US State Department last week, derives from the last paragraph of its editorial introduction: “Kashmir… must be demilitarised and unified by both countries sooner or later, and it must be done without force. There has been enough needless bloodshed on the subcontinent… Modern Pakistanis and Indians are free peoples who can voluntarily agree in their own interests to alter the terms set hurriedly by Attlee or Mountbatten in the Indian Independence Act 1947. Nobody but we ourselves keeps us prisoners of superficial definitions of who we are or might be. The subcontinent could evolve its political identity over a period of time on the pattern of Western Europe, with open borders and (common) tariffs to the outside world, with the free movement of people, capital, ideas and culture. Large armed forces could be reduced and transformed in a manner that would enhance the security of each nation. The real and peaceful economic revolution of the masses of the subcontinent would then be able to begin.”

The editors as economists decried the waste of resources involved in the Pakistan-India confrontation, saying it had “greatly impoverished the general budgets of both Pakistan and India. If it has benefited important sections of the political and military elites of  both countries, it has done so only at the expense of the general welfare of the masses.”

International law

Such words may have been bold in the early 1990s but today, a decade and a half later, they seem incomplete and rather naïve even to their author, who was myself, the only Indian in that project. Most significantly, the position in international law in the context of historical facts had been wholly neglected. So had been the manifest nature of the contemporary Pakistani state.

Jammu & Kashmir became an entity in international law when the Treaty of Amritsar was signed between Gulab Singh and the British on March 16 1846. British India itself became an entity in international law much later, possibly as late as June 1919 when it signed the Treaty of Versailles. As for Pakistan, it had no existence in world history or international law until August 14 1947, when the British created it as a new entity out of certain demarcated areas of British India and gave it the status of a Dominion. British India dissolved itself on August 15 1947 and the Dominion of India became its successor-state in international law on that date. As BR Ambedkar pointed out at the time, the new India automatically inherited British India’s suzerainty over any and all remaining “princely” states of so-called “Indian India”. In case of J&K in particular, there never was any question of it being recognised as an independent entity in global international law.

The new Pakistan, by entering a Standstill Agreement with J&K as of August 15 1947, did locally recognise J&K’s sovereignty over its decision whether to join Pakistan or India. But this Pakistani recognition lasted only until the attack on J&K that commenced from Pakistani territory as of October 22 1947, an attack in which Pakistani forces were complicit (something which, in different and mutating senses, has continued ever since). The Dominion of India had indicated it might have consented if J&K’s Ruler had decided to accede to Pakistan in the weeks following the dissolution of British India. But no such thing happened: what did happen was the descent of J&K into a condition of legal anarchy.

Beginning with the Pakistani attack on J&K as of October 22 upto and including the Rape of Baramulla and the British-led Pakistani coup détat in Gilgit on one side, and the arrival of Indian forces as well as mobilization by Sheikh Abdullah and Bakshi Ghulam Mohammad of J&K’s civilians to repel the Pakistani invaders on the other side, the State of Jammu & Kashmir became an ownerless entity in international law. In Roman Law, from which all modern international and municipal law ultimately derives, the ownership of an ownerless entity is open to be determined by “military decision”. The January 1949 Ceasefire Line that came to be renamed the Line of Control after the 1971 Bangladesh War, demarcates the respective territories that the then-Dominions and later Republics of India and Pakistan acquired by “military decision” of the erstwhile State of J&K which had come to cease to exist.

What the Republic of India means by saying today that boundaries cannot be redrawn nor any populations forcibly transferred is quite simply that the division of erstwhile J&K territory is permanent, and that sovereignty over it is indivisible. It is only sheer ignorance on the part of General Musharraf’s Indian interviewer the other day which caused it to be said that Pakistan was willing to “give up” its claim on erstwhile J&K State territory which India has held: Pakistan has never had nor even made such a  claim in international law. What Pakistan has claimed is that India has been an occupier and that there are many people inhabiting the Indian area who may not wish to be Indian nationals and who are being compelled against their will to remain so ~  forgetting to add that precisely the same could be said likewise of the Pakistani-held area.

Accordingly, the lawful solution proposed in these pages a year ago to resolve that matter, serious as it is, has been that the Republic of India invite every person covered under Article 370, citizen-by- citizen, under a condition of full information, to privately and without fear decide, if he/she has not done so already, between possible Indian, Iranian, Afghan or Pakistani nationalities ~ granting rights and obligations of permanent residents to any of those persons who may choose for whatever private reason not to remain Indian nationals. If Pakistan acted likewise, the problem of J&K would indeed come to be resolved. The Americans, as self- appointed mediators, have said they wish “the people of the region to have a voice” in a solution: there can be no better expression of such voice than allowing individuals to privately choose their own nationalities and their rights and responsibilities accordingly. The issue of territorial sovereignty is logically distinct from that of the choice of nationality by individual inhabitants.

Military de-escalation

Equally significant though in assessing whether General Musharraf’s proposal is an  anachronism, is Pakistan’s history since 1947: through Ayub’s 1965 attack, the civil war and secession of Bangladesh, the Afghan war and growth of the ISI, the Kargil incursion, the 1999 coup détat, and, once or twice removed, the 9/11 attacks against America. It is not a history that allows any confidence to arise in Indians that we are not dealing with a country misgoverned by a tiny arrogant exploitative military elite who remain hell-bent on aggression against us. Like the USA and USSR twenty years ago, what we need to negotiate about, and negotiate hard about, is an overall mutual military drawdown and de-escalation appropriate to lack of aggressive intent on both sides. Is General Musharraf willing to discuss that? It would involve reciprocal verifiable assessment of one another’s reasonable military requirements on the assumption that each was not a threatening enemy of the other. That was how the USA-USSR drawdown and de-escalation occurred successfully. If General Musharraf is unwilling to enter such a discussion, there is hardly anything to talk about with him. We should wait for democracy to return.

SIX

“AN INDIAN REPLY TO PRESIDENT ZARDARI: REWARDING PAKISTAN FOR BAD BEHAVIOUR LEADS TO SCHIZOPHRENIC RELATIONSHIPS”

by Subroto Roy, December 17 2008

Pakistan President Asif Ali Zardari’s recent argument in the New York Times resembles closely the well-known publications of his ambassador to the United States, Mr Husain Haqqani. Unfortunately, this Zardari-Haqqani thesis about Pakistan’s current predicament in the world and the world’s predicament with Pakistan is shot through with clear factual and logical errors. These need to be aired because true or useful conclusions cannot be reached from mistaken premises or faulty reasoning.

1. Origins of Pakistan, India, J&K, and their mutual problems

Mr Zardari makes the following seemingly innocuous statement:

“…. the two great nations of Pakistan and India, born together from the same revolution and mandate in 1947, must continue to move forward with the peace process.”

Now as a matter of simple historical fact, the current entities in the world system known as India and Pakistan were not “born together from the same revolution and mandate in 1947”. It is palpably false to suppose they were and Pakistanis indulge in wishful thinking and self-deception about their own political history if they suppose this.

India’s Republic arose out of the British Dominion known as “India” which was the legal successor of the entity known previously in international law as “British India”. British India had had secular governance and so has had the Indian Republic.

By contrast, the Islamic Republic of Pakistan arose out of a newly created state in international law known as the British Dominion of Pakistan, consisting of designated territory carved out of British India by a British decision and coming into existence one day before British India extinguished itself. (Another new state, Bangladesh, later seceded from Pakistan.)

The British decision to create territory designated “Pakistan” had nothing to do with any anti-British “revolution” or “mandate” supported by any Pakistani nationalism because there was none. (Rahmat Ali’s anti-Hindu pamphleteering in London could be hardly considered Pakistani nationalism against British rule. Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan’s Pashtun patriots saw themselves as Indian, not Pakistani.)

To the contrary, the British decision had to do with a small number of elite Pakistanis — MA Jinnah foremost among them — demanding not to be part of the general Indian nationalist movement that had been demanding a British departure from power in the subcontinent. Jinnah’s separatist party, the Muslim League, was trounced in the 1937 provincial elections in all the Muslim-majority areas of British India that would eventually become Pakistan. Despite this, in September 1939, Britain, at war with Nazi Germany, chose to elevate the political power of Jinnah and his League to parity with the general Indian nationalist movement led by MK Gandhi. (See, Francis Robinson, in William James and Subroto Roy (eds), Foundations of Pakistan’s Political Economy: Towards an Agenda for the 1990s.) Britain needed India’s mostly Muslim infantry-divisions — the progenitors of the present-day Pakistan Army — and if that meant tilting towards a risky political idea of “Pakistan” in due course, so it would be. The thesis that Pakistan arose from any kind of “revolution” or “mandate” in 1947 is fantasy — the Muslim super-elite that invented and endorsed the Pakistan idea flew from Delhi to Karachi in chartered BOAC Dakotas, caring not a hoot about the vulnerability of ordinary Muslim masses to Sikh and Hindu majority wrath and retaliation on the ground.

Modern India succeeded to the rights and obligations of British India in international law, and has had a recognized existence as a state since at least the signing of the Armistice and Treaty of Versailles in 1918-1919. India was a founding member of the United Nations, being a signatory of the 1945 San Francisco Declaration, and an original member of the Bretton Woods institutions. An idea put forward by Argentina that as of 1947 India and Pakistan were both successor states of British India was rejected by the UN (Argentina withdrew its own suggestion), and it was universally acknowledged India was already a member of the UN while Pakistan would have to (and did) apply afresh for membership as a newly created state in the UN. Pakistan’s entry into the UN had the enthusiastic backing of India and was opposed by only one existing UN member, Afghanistan, due to a conflict that continues to this day over the legitimacy of the Durand Line that bifurcated the Pashtun areas.

Such a review of elementary historical facts and the position in law of Pakistan and India is far from being of merely pedantic interest today. Rather, it goes directly to the logical roots of the conflict over the erstwhile State of Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) — a state that itself originated as an entity in the world system a full century before Pakistan was to do so and more than half a century before British India did, but which would collapse into anarchy and civil war in 1947-1949.

Britain (or England) had been a major nation-state in the world system recognized since Grotius first outlined modern international law. On March 16 1846, Britain entered into a treaty, the Treaty of Amritsar, with one Gulab Singh, and the “State of Jammu & Kashmir” came to arise as a recognizable entity in international law for the first time. (See my “History of Jammu and Kashmir” published in The Statesman, Oct 29-30 2006, available elsewhere here.)

Jammu & Kashmir continued in orderly existence as a state until it crashed into legal and political anarchy and civil war a century later. The new Pakistan had entered into a “Standstill Agreement” with the State of Jammu & Kashmir as of August 15 1947. On or about October 22 1947, Pakistan unilaterally ended that Standstill Agreement and instead caused military forces from its territory to attack the State of Jammu & Kashmir along the Mansehra Road towards Baramula and Srinagar, coinciding too with an Anglo-Pakistani coup d’etat in Gilgit and Baltistan (see my “Solving Kashmir”; “Law, Justice & J&K”; “Pakistan’s Allies”, all published in The Statesman in 2005-2006 and available elsewhere here).

The new Pakistan had chosen, in all deliberation, to forswear law, politics and diplomacy and to resort to force of arms instead in trying to acquire J&K for itself via a military decision. It succeeded only partially. Its forces took and then lost both Baramula and Kargil; they may have threatened Leh but did not attempt to take it; they did take and retain Muzaffarabad and Skardu; they were never near taking the summer capital, Srinagar, though might have threatened the winter capital, Jammu.

All in all, a Ceasefire Line came to be demarcated on the military positions as of February 1 1949. After a war in 1971 that accompanied the secession of Bangladesh from Pakistan, that Ceasefire Line came to be renamed the “Line of Control” between Pakistan and India. An ownerless entity may be acquired by force of arms — the erstwhile State of Jammu & Kashmir in 1947-1949 had become an ownerless entity that had been dismembered and divided according to military decision following an armed conflict between Pakistan and India. The entity in the world system known as the “State of Jammu & Kashmir” created on March 16 1846 by Gulab Singh’s treaty with the British ceased to exist as of October 22 1947. Pakistan had started the fight over J&K but there is a general rule of conflicts that he who starts a fight does not get to finish it.

Such is the simplest and most practical statement of the history of the current problem. The British, through their own compulsions and imperial pretensions, raised all the talk about a “Lapse of Paramountcy” of the British Crown over the “Native Princes” of “Indian India”, and of how, the “Native Princes” were required to “accede” to either India or Pakistan. This ignored Britain’s own constitutional law. BR Ambedkar pointed out with unsurpassed clarity that no “Lapse of Paramountcy” was possible even for a single logical moment since “Paramountcy” over any “Native Princes” who had not joined India or Pakistan as of August 15 1947, automatically passed from British India to its legal successor, namely, the Dominion of India. It followed that India’s acquiescence was required for any subsequent accession to Pakistan – an acquiescence granted in case of Chitral and denied in case of Junagadh.

What the Republic of India means by saying today that boundaries cannot be redrawn nor any populations forcibly transferred is quite simply that the division of erstwhile J&K territory is permanent, and that sovereignty over it is indivisible. What Pakistan has claimed is that India has been an occupier and that there are many people inhabiting the Indian area who may not wish to be Indian nationals and who are being compelled against their will to remain so ~ forgetting to add that precisely the same could be said likewise of the Pakistani-held area. The lawful solution I proposed in “Solving Kashmir, “Law, Justice and J&K” and other works has been that the Republic of India invite every person covered under its Article 370, citizen-by-citizen, under a condition of full information, to privately and without fear decide, if he/she has not done so already, between possible Indian, Iranian, Afghan or Pakistani nationalities ~ granting rights and obligations of permanent residents to any of those persons who may choose for whatever private reason not to remain Indian nationals. If Pakistan acted likewise, the problem of J&K would indeed come to be resolved. The Americans, as self-appointed mediators, have said they wish “the people of the region to have a voice” in a solution: there can be no better expression of such voice than allowing individuals to privately choose their own nationalities and their rights and responsibilities accordingly. The issue of territorial sovereignty is logically distinct from that of the choice of nationality by individual inhabitants.

2. Benazir’s assassination falsely compared to the Mumbai massacres
Secondly, President Zardari draws a mistaken comparison between the assassination last year of his wife, Benazir Bhutto, and the Mumbai massacres a few weeks ago. Ms Bhutto’s assassination may resemble more closely the assassinations in India of Indira Gandhi in 1984 and Rajiv Gandhi in 1991.

Indira Gandhi died in “blowback” from the unrest she and her younger son and others in their party had opportunistically fomented among Sikh fundamentalists and sectarians since the late 1970s. Rajiv Gandhi died in “blowback” from an erroneous imperialistic foreign policy that he, as Prime Minister, had been induced to make by jingoistic Indian diplomats, a move that got India’s military needlessly involved in the then-nascent Sri Lankan civil war. Benazir Bhutto similarly may be seen to have died in “blowback” from her own political activity as prime minister and opposition leader since the late 1980s, including her own encouragement of Muslim fundamentalist forces. Certainly in all three cases, as in all assassinations, there were lapses of security too and imprudent political judgments made that contributed to the tragic outcomes.

Ms Bhutto’s assassination has next to nothing to do with the Mumbai massacres, besides the fact the perpetrators in both cases were Pakistani terrorists. President Zardari saying he himself has lost his wife to terrorism is true but not relevant to the proper diagnosis of the Mumbai massacres or to Pakistan-India relations in general. Rather, it serves to deflect criticism and condemnation of the Pakistani state’s pampered handing of Pakistan’s terrorist masterminds, as well as the gross irresponsibility of Pakistan’s military scientists (not AQ Khan) who have been recently advocating a nuclear first strike against India in the event of war.

3. Can any religious nation-state be viable in the modern world?

President Zardari’s article says:

“The world worked to exploit religion against the Soviet Union in Afghanistan by empowering the most fanatic extremists as an instrument of destruction of a superpower. The strategy worked, but its legacy was the creation of an extremist militia with its own dynamic.”

This may be overly simplistic. As pointed out in my article “Pakistan’s Allies”, Gregory Zinoviev himself after the Bolshevik Revolution had declared that international communism “turns today to the peoples of the East and says to them, ‘Brothers, we summon you to a Holy War first of all against British imperialism!’ At this there were cries of Jehad! Jehad! And much brandishing of picturesque Oriental weapons.” (Treadgold, Twentieth Century Russia, 1990, p. 213). For more than half of the 20th century, orthodox Muslims had been used by Soviet communists against British imperialism, then by the British and Americans (through Pakistan) against Soviet communism. Touché! Blowback and counter-blowback! The real question that arises from this today may be why orthodox Muslims have allowed themselves to be used either way by outside forces and have failed in developing a modern nation-state and political culture of their own. Europe and America only settled down politically after their religious wars were over. Perhaps no religious nation-state is viable in the modern world.

4. Pakistan’s behaviour leads to schizophrenia in international relations

President Zardari pleads for, or perhaps demands, resources from the world:

“the best response to the Mumbai carnage is to coordinate in counteracting the scourge of terrorism. The world must act to strengthen Pakistan’s economy and democracy, help us build civil society and provide us with the law enforcement and counterterrorism capacities that will enable us to fight the terrorists effectively.”

Six million pounds from Mr Gordon Brown, so much from here or there etc – President Zardari has apparently demanded 100 billion dollars from America and that is the price being talked about for Pakistan to dismantle its nuclear weapons and be brought under an American “nuclear umbrella” instead.

I have pointed out elsewhere that what Pakistan seems to have been doing in international relations for decades is send out “mixed messages” – i.e. contradictory signals, whether in thought, word or deed. Clinical psychologists following the work of Gregory Bateson would say this leads to confusion among Pakistan’s interlocutors (a “double bind”) and the symptoms arise of what may be found in schizophrenic relationships. (See my article “Do President-elect Obama’s Pakistan specialists believe…”; on the “double bind” theory, an article I chanced to publish in the Journal of Genetic Psychology, 1986, may be of interest).

Here are a typical set of “mixed messages” emanating from Pakistan’s government and opinion-makers:

“We have nuclear weapons
“We keep our nuclear weapons safe from any misuse or unauthorized use
“We are willing to use nuclear weapons in a first strike against India
“We do not comprehend the lessons of Hiroshima-Nagasaki
“We do not comprehend the destruction India will visit upon us if we strike them
“We are dangerous so we must not be threatened in any way
“We are peace-loving and want to live in peace with India and Afghanistan
“We love to play cricket with India and watch Bollywood movies
“We love our Pakistan Army as it is one public institution that works
“We know the Pakistan Army has backed armed militias against India in the past
“We know these militias have caused terrorist attacks
“We are not responsible for any terrorist attacks
“We do not harbour any terrorists
“We believe the world should pay us to not use or sell our nuclear weapons
“We believe the world should pay us to not encourage the terrorists in our country
“We believe the world should pay us to prevent terrorists from using our nuclear weapons
“We hate India and do not want to become like India
“We love India and want to become like India
“We are India and we are not India…”

Etc.

A mature rational responsible and self-confident Pakistan would have said instead:

“We apologise to India and other countries for the outrageous murders our nationals have committed in Mumbai and elsewhere
“We ask the world to watch how our professional army is deployed to disarm civilian and all “non-state” actors of unauthorized firearms and explosives
“We do not need and will not demand or accept a dollar in any sort of foreign aid, military or civilian, to solve our problems
“We realize our economic and political institutions are a mess and we must clean them up
“We will strive to build a society imbued with what Iqbal described as the spirit of modern times..”

As someone who created at great personal cost at an American university twenty years ago the book Foundations of Pakistan’s Political Economy: Towards an Agenda for the 1990s, I have a special interest in hoping that Pakistan shall find the path of wisdom.”

Finally, a dozen years late, the Sonia-Manmohan Congress takes a small Rajivist step: Yes Prime Minister, our Judiciary is indeed a premier public good (or example of “infrastructure” to use that dreadful bureaucratic term)

I was very harsh and did not beat about the bush in my Sep 23-24 2007 article  in The Statesman “Against Quackery” when I said in its subtitle

“Manmohan and Sonia have violated Rajiv Gandhi’s intended reforms”.

I said inter alia

“WASTE, fraud and abuse are inevitable in the use and allocation of public property and resources in India as elsewhere, but Government is supposed to fight and resist such tendencies. The Sonia-Manmohan Government have done the opposite, aiding and abetting a wasteful anti-economics ~ i.e., an economic quackery. Vajpayee-Advani and other Governments, including Narasimha-Manmohan in 1991-1996, were just as complicit in the perverse policy-making. So have been State Governments of all regional parties like the CPI-M in West Bengal, DMK/ AIADMK in Tamil Nadu, Congress/NCP/ BJP/Sena in Maharashtra, TDP /Congress in Andhra Pradesh, SP/BJP/BSP in Uttar Pradesh etc. Our dismal politics merely has the pot calling the kettle black while national self-delusion and superstition reign in the absence of reason. The general pattern is one of well-informed, moneyed, mostly city-based special interest groups (especially including organised capital and organised labour) dominating government agendas at the cost of ill-informed, diffused anonymous individual citizens ~ peasants, small businessmen, non-unionized workers, old people, housewives, medical students etc….Rajiv Gandhi had a sense of noblesse oblige out of remembrance of his father and maternal grandfather. After his assassination, the comprador business press credited Narasimha Rao and Manmohan Singh with having originated the 1991 economic reform. In May 2002, however, the Congress Party itself passed a resolution proposed by Digvijay Singh explicitly stating Rajiv and not either of them was to be so credited. The resolution was intended to flatter Sonia Gandhi but there was truth in it too. Rajiv, a pilot who knew no political economy, was a quick learner with intelligence to know a good idea when he saw one and enough grace to acknowledge it. …Rajiv was entirely convinced when the suggestion was made to him in September 1990 that an enormous infusion of public resources was needed into the judicial system for promotion and improvement of the Rule of Law in the country, a pre-requisite almost for a new market orientation. Capitalism without the Rule of Law can quickly degenerate into an illiberal hell of cronyism and anarchy which is what has tended to happen since 1991. The resources put since Independence to the proper working of our judiciary from the Supreme Court and High Courts downwards have been abysmal, while the state of prisons, borstals, mental asylums and other institutions of involuntary detention is nothing short of pathetic. Only police forces, like the military, paramilitary and bureaucracies, have bloated in size….Neither Sonia-Manmohan nor the BJP or Communists have thought promotion of the Rule of Law in India to be worth much serious thought ~ certainly less important than attending bogus international conclaves and summits to sign expensive deals for arms, aircraft, reactors etc. Yet Rajiv Gandhi, at a 10 Janpath meeting on 23 March 1991 when he received the liberalisation proposals he had authorized, explicitly avowed the importance of greater resources towards the Judiciary. Dr Singh and his acolytes were not in that loop, indeed they precisely represented the bureaucratic ancien regime intended to be changed, and hence have seemed quite uncomprehending of the roots of the intended reforms ever since 1991.”

Days after the article appeared there were press reports Dr Singh was murmuring about quitting, and then came a fierce speech in Hindi from the Congress President saying “enemies” would receive their dues or whatever – only to be retracted a few days later saying that no more had been meant than a local critique of the BJP in Haryana politics!  (Phew! I said to myself in relief…)

Today I am very happy to learn that Dr Manmohan Singh spoke on Sunday of the importance of the Rule of Law and an effective and efficient judiciary. The new Law Minister in the second Sonia-Manmohan Government has been eagerly saying the same.

All this is constructive and positive, late as it is since Sonia Gandhi and Manmohan Singh both became heavy-duty Congress Party politicians for the first time a dozen years ago.

I was privileged to advise a previous Congress President in his last months from September 1990 as has been told elsewhere. And six years before that I had  said:

“….….The most serious examples of the malfunctioning of civil government in India are probably the failure to take feasible public precautions against the monsoons and the disarray of the judicial system. …The Statesman lamented in July 1980:`The simplest matter takes an inordinate amount of time, remedies seldom being available to those without means or influence. Of the more than 16,000 cases pending in the Supreme Court, about 5,000 were introduced more than five years ago; while nearly 16,000 of the backlog of more than 600,000 cases in our high courts have been hanging fire for over a decade. Allahabad is the worst offender but there are about 75,000 uncleared cases in the Calcutta High Court in addition to well over a million in West Bengal’s lower courts.” Such a state of affairs has been caused not only by lazy and corrupt policemen, court clerks and lawyers, but also by the paucity of judges and magistrates. . . . a vast volume of laws provokes endless litigation as much because of poor drafting which leads to disputes over interpretation as because they appear to violate particular rights and privileges…. When governments determinedly do what they need not or should not do, it may be expected that they will fail to do what civil government positively should be doing.” A few months ago was the 25th anniversary of this statement… ! :)

Yes Prime Minister, having an effective and efficient judiciary is indeed a premier public good and one that has failed to be provided to India’s people from Nehru’s time and through Indira’s. I managed to persuade Rajiv about it completely. Might I next be so bold as to draw attention as well to the paragraphs of the 2007 article that followed?

“Similarly, Rajiv comprehended when it was said to him that the primary fiscal problem faced by India is the vast and uncontrolled public debt, interest payments on which suck dry all public budgets leaving no room for provision of public goods.  Government accounts: Government has been routinely “rolling over” its domestic debt in the asset-portfolios of the nationalised banks while displaying and highlighting only its new additional borrowing in a year as the “Fiscal Deficit”. More than two dozen States have been doing the same and their liabilities ultimately accrue to the Union too. The stock of public debt in India is Rs 30 trillion (Rs 30 lakh crore) at least, and portends a hyperinflation in the future. There has been no serious recognition of this since it is political and bureaucratic actions that have been causing the problem. Proper recognition would entail systematically cleaning up the budgets and accounts of every single governmental entity in the country: the Union, every State, every district and municipality, every publicly funded entity or organisation, and at the same time improving public decision-making capacity so that once budgets and accounts recover from grave sickness over decades, functioning institutions exist for their proper future management. All this would also stop corruption in its tracks, and release resources for valuable public goods and services like the Judiciary, School Education and Basic Health. Institutions for improved political and administrative decision-making are needed throughout the country if public preferences with respect to raising and allocating common resources are to be elicited and then translated into actual delivery of public goods and services. Our dysfunctional legislatures will have to do at least a little of what they are supposed to. When public budgets and accounts are healthy and we have functioning public goods and services, macroeconomic conditions would have been created for the paper-rupee to once more become a money as good as gold ~ a convertible world currency for all of India’s people, not merely the metropolitan special interest groups that have been controlling our governments and their agendas.”

Subroto Roy

Kolkata


Does the Govt. of India assume “foreign investors and analysts” are a key constituency for Indian economic policy-making? If so, why so? Have Govt. economists “learnt nothing, forgotten everything”? Some Bastille Day thoughts

Today is Bastille Day in France and the Prime Minister of India, Dr Manmohan Singh, at the invitation of President Sarkozy, is visiting Paris (where the Government of India has flown in military contingents to participate in the annual parade), before he goes to another summit in Egypt with Present Mubarak and others, following his recent summits in Italy with the Pope and others, and in Russia with President Medvedev and others, and in London with President Obama and others, etc.   Dr Singh has  almost certainly become the most internationally well-travelled of all Indian leaders on official visits ever in history, which adds to his having had the longest experience in India’s bureaucracy of any Indian political leader in history, which came to be followed by his stint in the Rajya Sabha as Finance Minister and now as a two-term Prime Minister.

But as a result of being out of the country yesterday, the Prime Minister would have missed the TV interview broadcast last night with his chief economic policy aide when it was said that “foreign investors and analysts” are an important constituency for Indian economic policy-makers, as expressed in the President’s speech to the new 15th Lok Sabha or Pranab Mukherjee’s Budget speech last week.  The interviewer seemed to agree and constantly pressed the aide, who is doubtless the most prominent Government economist on television,  about how stock-market brokers and businessmen seemed to have found the Budget not to their immediate liking, and how  privatisation or “raising insurance caps” would have been seen by businessmen as  crucial elements of future economic reform.  In fact privatisation or the insurance business have little to do with any important economic reform but the lobbying power and spin-control of  organised business becomes manifest in getting interviewers to ask such questions of Government spokesmen –  all part of the (doubtless unconscious) process of camouflaging their private interests in the guise of purported public economic policy discussion.

I have taken a very different view.  For example, I said a few years ago in starkest contrast:

“Running through the new foreign policy is a fiction that it is driven by a new economic motivation to improve development and mass well-being in India. The bizarre idea of creating hundreds of so-called “Special Economic Zones” (reminiscent of 17th and 18th Century colonial fortifications) illustrates this. India’s ordinary anonymous masses ~ certainly the 850 million people entirely outside the organised sector ~ have little or nothing to do with any of this. Benefits will accrue only to the ten million Indian nomenclatura controlling or having access to the gaping exit holes to the outside world in the new semi-closed economy with its endless deficit finance paid for by unlimited printing of an inconvertible domestic currency. It is as fallacious to think private investment from foreign or domestic businessmen will support public “infrastructure” creation as it is to think foreign exchange reserves are like tax revenues in being available for Government expenditure on “infrastructure”. Such fallacies are intellectual products of either those who know no economics at all or those who have forgotten whatever little they might have been once mistaught in their youth. What serious economics does say is that Government should generally have nothing to do with any kind of private business, and instead should focus on properly providing public goods and services, encourage competition in all avenues of economic activity and prevent or regulate monopoly, and see to it all firms pay taxes they are due to pay.  That is it. It is as bad for Government to be pampering organised foreign or domestic business or organised labour with innumerable subsidies, as has been happening in India for decades, as it is to make enterprise difficult with red tape and hurdles. Businessmen are grown ups and should be allowed to freely risk their capital and make their profits or their losses without public intervention. An economics-based policy would have single-mindedly sought to improve the financial condition of every governmental entity in the country, with the aim of improving the provision of public goods and services to all 1,000 million Indians. If and when budgets of all governmental entities become sound, foreign creditors would automatically line up before them with loans to sell, and ambitious development goals can be accomplished. As long as public budgets (and public accounts) remain in an outrageous shambles, nothing can be in fact achieved and only propaganda, corruption and paper-money creation results instead. Whatever economic growth does occur is due to new enterprise and normal technological progress, and is mostly despite and not because of New Delhi’s bureaucrats (see “The Dream Team: A Critique”, The Statesman 6-8 January 2006).  The first aspect of the new Indian foreign policy has been for Government to become wholly ingratiating towards any and all “First World” members visiting India who may deign to consider any kind of collaboration whatsoever. The long line of foreign businessmen and heads of government having photo-ops with the Indian PM began with Vajpayee and has continued with Manmohan, especially when there is a large weapons’ or commercial aircraft or other purchase to be signed. The flip-side has been ministerial and especially Prime Ministerial trips abroad ~ from Vajpayee’s to a Singapore golf-cart immediately after commiserating Gujarat, to Manmohan receiving foreign honorary doctorates while still holding public office.  Subservience to foreign business interests in the name of economic policy extends very easily to Indian naval, military or diplomatic assets being used to provide policing or support services for the great powers as and when they may ask for it. Hence, Indian naval forces may be asked by the Americans to help fight pirates in the Indian Ocean, or escort this vessel or that, or India may be asked to provide refuelling or base facilities, or India may be requested to vote against Iran, Venezuela or whomever here or there. But there would be absolutely no question of India’s role in international politics being anything greater than that of a subaltern or comprador whose response must be an instant “Ji, Huzoor”. The official backing of the Tharoor candidacy was as futile and ridiculous as the quest for UN veto-power or the willingness to attend G-8 summits as an observer. While subservience towards the First World’s business and military interests is the “kiss up” aspect of the new foreign policy, an aggressive jingoism towards others is the “kick down” aspect….”

Dr Singh’s aide at one point challenged his friendly interviewer  suggesting the very need for “fiscal stimulus” could hardly be questioned as if such a thing was beyond his imagination.  And again, I am afraid, I may have been quite alone  in December 2008 in lambasting as counter-productive all this purported “fiscal stimulus”. Just another colossal, indeed perverse, waste of public resources driven by organised business lobbies in their own interests, since in fact no one — not Dr Singh nor any of his aides, acolytes or flatterers, foreign or domestic, or anyone else anywhere — has any empirical or theoretical models of any kind depicting the phase, period or amplitude of any possible business-cycle that India’s economy may be on.  Since none of them has any idea whatsoever of what the amplitude or frequency is of any such purported business cycle, they are as likely to have caused a pro-cyclical exacerbation of the amplitude as any sort of counter-cyclical dampening! (Viz., Leibniz ‘s principle of insufficient reason.)

How to see what is happening in Indian macroeconomic policy in the simplest comparative static terms is this: both the IS and LM curves are being pushed outwards drastically based on a deliberately erroneous assumption that there is  or might develop mass involuntary unemployment of the sort Maynard Keynes once described in 1936.  The overall impact on nominal interest-rates is indeterminate; the process of inflationary deficit-finance with an inconvertible currency that the Government has indulged in for half a century merely continues, further pushing us towards a potential hyperinflation.

The Bourbon regime swept away by the French Revolution that Bastille Day celebrates were said to have “learnt nothing and forgotten nothing”.   I am afraid the macroeconomic illogic often found among Government economists, private commentators and business lobbyists in India today suggests to me nothing less than that they have  either learnt nothing or forgotten everything from their economics classes decades ago! We in India may need our own storming of the Bastille to sweep away the perverse thoughts and power structures of the post-1947 Dilli Raj.

Subroto Roy
Kolkata

Parliament is supposed to control the Government, not be bullied or intimidated by it: Will Rahul Gandhi be able to lead the Backbenches in the 15th Lok Sabha?

Any Lok Sabha MP who neither sits with the Opposition nor is a sworn-in member of the Government is a Backbench MP of the Government party or its coalition.

Shrimati Sonia Gandhi is the most prominent of such Backbench MPs in the 15th Lok Sabha, just as she was of the 14th Lok Sabha, and has chosen to be in a most peculiar position from the point of view of parliamentary law. As the leader of the largest parliamentary party, she could have been not merely a member of the Government but its Prime Minister. She has in fact had a decisive role in determining the composition of the Manmohan Government as well as its policies. She in fact sits on the Frontbenches in the Lok Sabha along with the Manmohan Government. But she is not a member of the Government and is, formally speaking, a Backbench MP who is choosing to sit in the Frontbenches.

(Dr Manmohan Singh himself, not being a member of the Lok Sabha, may, formally speaking, sit or speak from among the Frontbenches of his own Government only by invitation of the Lok Sabha Speaker as a courtesy – such would have been the cardinal reason why Alec Douglas-Home resigned from being Lord Home and instead stood for a House of Commons seat when he was appointed British Prime Minister.)

Sonia Gandhi’s son, Mr Rahul Gandhi, is also a Backbench MP. From all accounts, including that of Dr Singh himself, he could have been a member of Dr Singh’s Government but has specifically chosen not to be. He has appeared to have had some much lesser role than Sonia Gandhi in determining the composition of the Government and its policies but he is not a member of it. He is, formally speaking, a Backbench MP, indeed the most prominent to actually sit in the Backbenches, as he had done in the 14th Lok Sabha, which, it is to be hoped, he does in the 15th Lok Sabha too.

Now Rahul Gandhi, Sonia Gandhi and their 541 other fellow 15th Lok Sabha MPs were declared winners by May 16 2009 having won the Indian people’s vote.

(Incidentally, I predicted the outcome here two hours before polls closed on May 13 – how I did so is simply by having done the necessary work of determining that some 103 million people had voted for Congress in 2004 against some 86 million for the BJP; in my assessment Congress had done more than enough by way of political rhetoric and political reality to maintain if not extend that difference in 2009, i.e., the BJP had not done nearly enough to even begin to get enough of a net drift in its favour. I expect when the data are out it shall be seen that the margin of the raw vote between them has been much enlarged from 2004.)

As I have pointed out here over the last fortnight, there was no legal or logical reason why the  whole 15th Lok Sabha could not have been sworn in latest by May 18 2009.

Instead, Dr Manmohan Singh on May 18 held a purported “Cabinet” meeting of the defunct 14th Lok Sabha – an institution that had been automatically dissolved when Elections had been first announced! The Government then went about forming itself over two weeks despite the 15th Lok Sabha, on whose confidence it depended for its political legitimacy, not having been allowed to meet. Everyone – the Congress Party’s Supreme Court advocates, the Lok Sabha Secretariat, the Election Commission, Rashtrapati Bhavan too –  seems to have gotten it awfully wrong by placing the cart before the horse.

In our system it is Parliament that is sovereign, not the Executive Government. In fact the Executive is accountable to Parliament, specifically the Lok Sabha, and is supposed to be guided by it as well as hold its confidence at all times.

What has happened instead this time is that Government ministers have been busy taking oaths and entering their offices and making policy-decisons days before they have taken their oaths and their seats as Lok Sabha MPs!  The Government has thus started off by diminishing Parliament’s sovereignty and this should not be allowed to happen again.

(Of course why it took place is because of the peculiarity of the victory relative to our experience in recent decades – nobody could remember parliamentary traditions from Nehru’s time in the 1950s.  Even so, someone, e.g. the former Speaker, should have known and insisted upon explaining the relevant aspect of parliamentary law and hence avoided this breach.)

A central question now is whether a Government which has such a large majority, and which is led by someone in and has numerous ministers from the Rajya Sabha, is going to be adequately controlled and feel itself accountable to the Lok Sabha.

Neither of the Lok Sabha’s most prominent Backbenchers, Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi, have thus far distinguished themselves as Parliamentarians on the floor of the Lok Sabha. In the 14th Lok Sabha, Sonia Gandhi, sitting in the Frontbenches, exercised the  enormous control that she did over the Government not on the floor of the House itself but  from outside it.

It would be best of all if she chose in the 15th Lok Sabha to actually physically sit in the Congress’s Backbenches because that would ensure best that the Government Party’s ministers in the Frontbenches will keep having to seek to be accountable to the  Backbenches!

But this seems unlikely to happen in view of the fact she herself seems to have personally influenced the choice of a Speaker for the 15th Lok Sabha and it may be instead expected that she continues to sit on the Frontbenches with the Government without being a member of it.

That leaves Rahul Gandhi. If he too comes to be persuaded by the sycophants to sit on the Frontbenches with the Government, that will not be a healthy sign.

On the other hand, if he continues to sit on the Backbenches, he may be able to have a salubrious influence on the 15th Lok Sabha fulfilling its responsibility of seeking to seriously control and hold accountable the Executive Government,  and not be bullied or intimidated by it. His paternal grandfather, Feroze Gandhi, after all, may have been India’s most eminent and effective Backbench MP yet.

Subroto Roy, Kolkata

Note to Posterity: 79 Ministers in office but no 15th Lok Sabha until June 1 2009!

The Government of India’s 79 Ministers have taken to their offices like bees to honey yet the 15th Lok Sabha that the people of India elected a fortnight ago is still three days from being convened.

In other words, people have been taking oaths and entering offices as Ministers even before they have taken their oaths or their seats in the 15th Lok Sabha which accords the Government its political legitimacy by its confidence!

Let posterity recall that the 15th Lok Sabha was made to needlessly wait from May 16 2009 until June 1 2009 and despite this the Government formed itself and entered office during that time.  It cannot be something that helps the psychology or morale of  our elected representatives nor be something conducive to the smooth working of the House.

It is all a terrible constitutional muddle  which I doubt the PM or his party or Government, or even the Opposition, will admit to or want to clear up on their own but shall probably have to await a Constitutional Bench of the Supreme Court of India telling them  what  parliamentary law is in due course.

Subroto Roy, Kolkata

Eleven days and counting after the 15th Lok Sabha was elected and still no Parliament of India! (But we do have 79 Ministers — might that be a world record?)

A lawyer friend tells me she thinks it a “technicality” that there is no Lok Sabha or Parliament in India today despite eleven long days and nights having passed since the 15th Lok Sabha came to be elected by the people of India.  “At least we did not get Advani and Modi to rule”, is how she sought to justify the current circumstance.   I am afraid I think she has produced a non sequitur, and also forgotten the constitutional law she would have read as a student.

The best argument that I think the Government of India shall be able to give justifying their legal error in not having the 15th Lok Sabha up and running yet 11 days after India’s people have spoken would run something like this:

(1) The President of India invites a Council of Ministers led by a PM to form the government and has done so.

(2) The President must be satisfied that the PM commands a majority in the Lok Sabha, and the President has been satisfied by the 322  “letters of support” that the PM produced.

(3) The Government of the day calls parliamentary sessions and does so at its discretion, and the Government of the day headed by this PM has announced when it shall call the 15th Lok Sabha which will be in a few days yet.

Any such argument, I am afraid, would be specious because it simply puts the cart before the horse.

Parliament is sovereign in India, to repeat what I have said several times before.

Parliament is sovereign in India — not even the President who is the symbol of that sovereignty.  We do not follow the British quite exactly in this because we are a republic and not a monarchy.  In Britain sovereignty rests with “The King in Parliament”.  With us, Parliament is sovereign and the President is the symbol of that sovereignty.  In all matters of state, our President must act in a manner that Parliament and parliamentary law says.

Parliament is sovereign in India — not the Executive Government, certainly not its largest political party or its leader.

Parliament is sovereign in India because the people of India have chosen it to be so within the Constitution of India.

Parliament is sovereign in India and the people of India have elected the 15th Lok Sabha which has still not been allowed to meet eleven days later.

To the contrary, as noted days ago, the purported “Cabinet” of the 14th Lok Sabha, a dead institution, met on May 18 2009, some 48 hours after the 15th Lok Sabha had already been declared!   The 14th Lok Sabha in fact stood automatically dissolved in law when General Elections came to be announced.

Is all this merely a “technicality” as my friend believes?  I think not.

Executive Government in India derives its political legitimacy from being elected  by Parliament,  i.e., from holding the confidence of Parliament, and that means the Lok Sabha.

The Government of the day might  for sake of convenience have a prerogative of calling sessions of the 15th Lok Sabha once it has been constituted but the Government of the day cannot logically constitute a Lok Sabha after a General Election because it itself receives legitimacy from such a Lok Sabha.

If the 15th Lok Sabha has not met, confidence in any Executive has yet to be recorded, and hence any such Government has yet to receive legitimacy.

Do “322 letters of support” suffice?  Hardly.  They are signed after all by persons who have yet to take their seats in the Lok Sabha!  (Let us leave aside the fact that the PM, not being a member of the Lok Sabha, is in this case unable to be one of those 322 himself!)

Yet we have 79 “Ministers” of this new “Government” holding press-conferences and giving out free-bees and favours etc already.  As I have said before, Ambedkar, Nehru and others of their generation, plus Indira and Rajiv too, would all have been appalled.

Because the incompetence of the fascists and communists in the Opposition may continue to  be expected, it will be up to ordinary citizens and voters of India to point out such  simple truths whenever the Emperor is found to be naked.  (Our docile juvenile ingratiating media may well remain mostly hopeless.)

Subroto Roy, Kolkata.

Why does India not have a Parliament ten days after the 15th Lok Sabha was elected? Nehru and Rajiv would both have been appalled

There are at least three Supreme Court lawyers, all highly voluble, among the higher echelons of Congress Party politicians; it is surprising that not one of them has been able to get the top Party leadership of Sonia Gandhi and Manmohan Singh to see the apparent breach of normal constitutional law in Parliament not having met more than 10 days after it was elected.

A Government has been formed, Ministers have entered their offices and have been holding press-conferences and taking executive decisions,  wannabe-Ministers continue to be wrangling night-and-day for the plums of office — BUT THERE IS NO PARLIAMENT!

Today is the death-anniversary of Jawaharlal Nehru and last week was the death anniversary of  Rajiv Gandhi.

Nehru, whatever his faults and infirmities, was an outstanding parliamentarian and a believer in the Westminster model in particular.  He was intimately familiar with its  unpoken customs and unwritten laws.   He would have been completely appalled by the situation today where luminaries of the party that goes by the  same name as the one he had led are paying obeisance to his memory 45 years after his death but have failed to see the absurdity in having a Government in office with no new Parliament ten days after a month-long General Election was over!  (Incidentally, had he not left explicit instructions against any hero-worship  taking place of himself too?)

Rajiv knew his grandfather and had acquired a sense of noblesse oblige from him.  He too would have been appalled that the procedural business of government  had been simply  procrastinated over like this.

It surprises me that Dr Manmohan Singh, having been a post-graduate of Cambridge, having earned a doctorate from Oxford, and more recently having been awarded honorary doctorates from both Ancient Universities, should seem so unaware of the elements of the Westminster model of  constitutional jurisprudence which guides our polity too.

It is too late now and the mistakes have been made.   I hope his  new Government will  come to realise at some point and then keep in mind that our Executive receives political legitimacy from Parliament, not vice versa.   An Executive can hardly be legitimately in office until the  Parliament that is supposed to elect it has been sworn in.

As for our putative Opposition in the Parliament-yet-to-meet, it seems to have drawn a blank too, and eo ipso revealed its own constitutional backwardness and lethargy.

Subroto Roy, Kolkata

Parliament’s sovereignty has been diminished by the Executive: A record for future generations to know

Sad to say, Parliament’s sovereignty has been diminished, indeed usurped, by the new Executive Government.

Here is a brief record for future generations to know.

India’s people completed their voting in the 15th General Elections on Wednesday May 13 2009.

The results of how they had spoken, what was their will, were known and declared by Saturday May 16 2009.

There was no legal or logical reason why the 543 members of the 15th Lok Sabha could not have been sworn in as new MPs by the close-of-business on Monday May 18 at the latest.

On Tuesday May 19 the 15th Lok Sabha could have and should have met to elect itself a pro tem or even a permanent Speaker.

The Speaker would have divided the new House into its Government Party and its Opposition.

There would have been a vote of confidence on the floor of the House, which in the circumstances would have been in favour of the Government Party.

Observing this to have taken place, the Hon’ble President of India as the Head of State would have sent for the leader of the Government Party and invited her to form the new Government.

In this particular case, the leader of the largest political party, namely Sonia Gandhi, would have been accompanied perhaps by the Leader of the Lok Sabha, Pranab Mukherjee, as well as her personal nominee for the position of PM, namely, Manmohan Singh.

Sonia Gandhi would have respectfully declined the invitation of the President to be the new Prime Minister, and she would have also explained that she wanted Manmohan Singh to have the position instead.

The President would have said “Very well, Dr Singh, can you please form the Government?”

He would have said, “Yes Madame President it shall be a privilege and an honour to do so”.

The President would have added, “Thank you, and I notice you are not a member of the Lok Sabha at the moment but I am sure you are taking steps towards becoming one.”

End of visit.

Manmohan Singh would have been sworn in as PM and would have gone about adding Ministers at a measured pace.   Later, he would have resigned his Rajya Sabha seat and sought election to the Lok Sabha on the parliamentary precedent set by Alec Douglas-Home.

What has happened instead?

On May 18 2009, instead of 543 members of the 15th Lok Sabha taking their oaths as required by parliamentary law and custom, Dr Singh held a purported “Cabinet”  meeting of the 14th Lok Sabha — a long-since dead institution!

Some of the persons attending this  meeting as purported “Cabinet ministers” had even lost their seats in the elections decided a few days earlier and so had absolutely zero democratically legitimate status left. All these persons then submitted their purported resignations which Dr Singh carried to the President, stating his Government had resigned. The President then appointed him a caretaker PM and he, along with Sonia Gandhi, then went about “staking claim” to form the next Government — turning up at the President’s again with “letters of support” signed by some 322 persons  who were MP-elects but were yet to become MPs formally by not having been sworn in.

The President appeared satisfied the party Sonia Gandhi and Manmohan Singh belonged to would command a majority in prospect in the Lok Sabha and invited him to be PM.   Some major public wrangling then took place with at least one of his allies about cabinet berths — and that is the situation as of the present moment except that Dr Singh and several others have been sworn in as the Council of Ministers even though the  new 15th Lok Sabha of 543 members has still not convened!  It has been all rather sloppy and hardly uplifting.

Parliament is supposed to be sovereign in India.

Not the Executive Government or the largest political party or its leader.

The sovereignty of Parliament required Sonia Gandhi and Dr Singh to have realised

first, that the 14th Lok Sabha stood automatically dissolved when elections were announced;

secondly, that the 15th Lok Sabha could have and should have been sworn in by Monday May 18;

thirdly, that there should have been a vote of confidence in the Lok Sabha immediately which would have gone in favour of the Government Party;

fourthly, that only then should the Executive Government have been sought to be formed;

and of course fifthly, that if that Executive Government was to be led by someone who happened to be a member of the Rajya Sabha and not the Lok Sabha, parliamenary law and custom required him to follow the Douglas-Home precedent of resigning from the former and seeking election to the latter at the earliest opportunity.

Let future generations know that as of today, May 25, the 543 persons whom the people of India voted to constitute the 15th Lok Sabha still remain in limbo without having been sworn in though we already have an Executive Government appointed!

The sovereignty of Parliament, specifically that of the Lok Sabha, has come to be diminished, indeed usurped, by the Executive.   It is the Executive that receives its political legitimacy from Parliament, not vice versa.  Nehru and his generation knew all this intimately well and would have been appalled at where we in the present have been taking it.

Subroto Roy, Kolkata

Why has the Sonia Congress done something that the Congress under Nehru-Indira-Rajiv would not have done, namely, exaggerate the power of the Rajya Sabha and diminish the power of the Lok Sabha?

We in India did not invent the idea of Parliament, the British did.  Even the British did not invent the idea of a “Premier Ministre”, the French did that, though the British came to develop its meaning most.  Because these are not our own inventions, when something unusual happens in contemporary India to political entities and offices known as “Parliament”, “Prime Minister” etc, contrast and comparison is inevitable with standards and practices that have prevailed around the world in other parliamentary democracies.

Indeed we in India did not even fully invent the idea of our own Parliament though the national struggle led by the original Indian National Congress caused it to come to be invented.  The Lok Sabha is the outcome of a long and distinguished constitutional and political history from the Morley-Minto reforms a century ago to the Montagu-Chelmsford reforms and Government of India Act of 1919 to the Government of India Act of 1935 and the first general elections of British India in 1937 (when Jawaharlal Nehru briefly became PM for the first time) and in due course the 1946 Constituent Assembly.   Out of all this emerged the 1950 Constitution of India, drafted by that brilliant jurist BR Ambedkar as well as other sober intelligent well-educated and dedicated men and women of his time, and thence arose our first Lok Sabha following the 1951 General Elections.

About the Lok Sabha’s duties, I said in my March 30 2006 article “Logic of Democracy” in The Statesman

“What are Lok Sabha Members and State MLAs legitimately required to be doing in caring for their constituents? First of all, as a body as a whole, they need to elect the Government, i.e. the Executive Branch, and to hold it accountable in Parliament or Assembly. For example, the Comptroller and Auditor General submits his reports directly to the House, and it is the duty of individual legislators to put these to good use in controlling the Government’s waste, fraud or abuse of public resources.   Secondly, MPs and MLAs are obviously supposed to literally represent their individual constituencies in the House, i.e. to bring the Government and the House’s attention to specific problems or contingencies affecting their constituents as a whole, and call for the help, funds and sympathy of the whole community on their behalf.  Thirdly, MPs and MLAs are supposed to respond to pleas and petitions of individual constituents, who may need the influence associated with the dignity of their office to get things rightly done. For example, an impoverished orphan lad once needed surgery to remove a brain tumour; a family helping him was promised the free services of a top brain surgeon if a hospital bed and operating theatre could be arranged. It was only by turning to the local MLA that the family were able to get such arrangements made, and the lad had his tumour taken out at a public hospital. MPs and MLAs are supposed to vote for and create public goods and services, and to use their moral suasion to see that existing public services actually do get to reach the public.”

What about the Rajya Sabha?  I said in the same article:

“Rajya Sabha Members are a different species altogether. Most if not all State Legislative Councils have been abolished, and sadly the present nature of the Rajya Sabha causes similar doubts to arise about its utility. The very idea of a Rajya Sabha was first mooted in embryo form in an 1888 book A History of the Native States of India, Vol I. Gwalior, whose author also advocated popular constitutions for the “Indian India” of the “Native States” since “where there are no popular constitutions, the personal character of the ruler becomes a most important factor in the government… evils are inherent in every government where autocracy is not tempered by a free constitution.”  When Victoria was declared India’s “Empress” in 1877, a “Council of the Empire” was mooted but had remained a non-starter even until the 1887 Jubilee. An “Imperial Council” was now designed of the so-called “Native Princes”, which came to evolve into the “Chamber of Princes” which became the “Council of the States” and the Rajya Sabha.  It was patterned mostly on the British and not the American upper house except in being not liable to dissolution, and compelling periodic retirement of a third of members. The American upper house is an equal if not the senior partner of the lower house. Our Rajya Sabha follows the British upper house in being a chamber which is duty-bound to oversee any exuberance in the Lok Sabha but which must ultimately yield to it if there is any dispute.  Parliament in India’s democracy effectively means the Lok Sabha — where every member has contested and won a direct vote in his/her constituency. The British upper house used to have an aristocratic hereditary component which Tony Blair’s New Labour Government has now removed, so it has now been becoming more like what the Rajya Sabha was supposed to have been like.”

The Canadian upper house is similar to ours in intent: a place for “sober second thought” intended to curb the “democratic excesses” of the lower house.   In the Canadian, British, Australian, Irish and our own cases, the Prime Minister, as the chief executive of the lower house has immense indirect power over the upper house, whether in appointing members or even, in the Australian case, dissolving the entire upper house if he/she wishes.

Now yesterday apparently Shrimati Sonia Gandhi, as the duly elected leader of the largest political party in the 15th Lok Sabha, accompanied by Dr Manmohan Singh, as her party’s choice for the position of Prime Minister, went to see the President of India where the Hon’ble President apparently appointed Dr Singh to be the Prime Minister of India – meaning the Prime Minister of the 15th Lok Sabha, except that Dr Singh is not a member of the Lok Sabha and apparently has had no intent of becoming one.

In 2004 Shrimati Gandhi had declined to accept an invitation to become PM and instead effectively recommended Dr Singh to be PM despite his not being a member of the Lok Sabha nor intending to be so.   This exploited a constitutional loophole to the extent that the drafters of our 1950 Constitution happened not to have explicitly stated that the PM must be from the Lok Sabha.  But the reason the founders of our democratic polity such as BR Ambedkar and Jawaharlal Nehru did not specify that the PM must be from the Lok Sabha was quite simply that it was a matter of complete obviousness to them and to their entire generation that this must be so — it would have been  appalling to them and something beyond their wildest imagination that a later generation, namely our own, would exploit such a loophole and allow a PM to be appointed who is not a member of the Lok Sabha and intends not to be so.

Ambedkar, Nehru and all others of their time knew fully well that the history and intended purpose of the Lok Sabha was completely different from the history and intended purpose of the Rajya Sabha.  They knew too fully well that Lord Curzon had been explicitly denied the leadership of Britain’s Tory Party in 1922 because that would have made him a potential PM  when he was not prepared to be a member of the House of Commons.  That specific precedent culminated a centuries’-old  democratic trend of  political power flowing from monarchs to lords to commoners, and has governed all parliamentary democracies  worldwide ever since — until Dr Singh’s appointment in 2004.

When such an anomalous situation once arose in Britain, Lord Home resigned his membership of the House of Lords to contest a House of Commons seat as Sir Alec Douglas Home so that he could be PM in a manner consistent with parliamentary law.

Dr Singh instead for five years remained PM of India while not being a member of the Lok Sabha.  Even if reasons and exigencies of State could have been cited for such an anomalous situation during his first term, there was really no such reason for him not to contest the 2009 General Election if he wished to be the Congress Party’s prime ministerial candidate a second time.  Numerous Rajya Sabha members alongside him have contested Lok Sabha seats this time, and several have won.

As of today, Dr Singh is due to be sworn in tomorrow as Prime Minister for a second term while still having no declared intention of resigning from the Rajya Sabha and contesting a Lok Sabha seat instead.   What the present-day Congress has done is elect him the leader of the “Congress Parliamentary Party” and claim that it is in such a capacity that he received the invitation to be Prime Minister of India.   But surely if the question had been asked to the Congress Party under Nehru or Indira or Rajiv: “Can you foresee a circumstance ever in which the PM of India is not a member of the Lok Sabha?” their answer in each case would have been a categorical and resounding  “no”.

So the question does arise why the Congress under Sonia Gandhi has with deliberation allowed such an anomalous situation to develop.  Its effect is to completely distort the trends of relative political power between the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha.  On the one hand, the Lok Sabha’s power is deliberately made to diminish as the chief executive of the Government of India shall not be from the Lok Sabha but from “the other place” despite the Lok Sabha having greater political legitimacy by having been directly elected by India’s people.   This sets a precedent that  might  get repeated in India  in the future but which contradicts the worldwide trend in parliamentary democracies over decades and centuries in precisely the opposite direction –  of power flowing in the direction of the people not away from them.   On the other hand, the fact this anomalous idea has been pioneered by the elected leader of the largest political party in the Lok Sabha while her PM is in the Rajya Sabha causes a member of the lower house to have unexpected control over the upper house when the latter is supposed to be something of an independent check on the former!

It all really seems an unnecessary muddle and a jumbling up of normal constitutional law and parliamentary procedure.  The Sonia-Manmohan Government at the outset of its second term should hardly want to be seen by history as having set a poor precedent using brute force.  The situation can be corrected with the utmost ease by following the Alec Douglas Home example, with Dr Singh being given a relatively safe seat to contest as soon as possible, if necessary by some newly elected Congress MP resigning and allowing a bye-election to be called.

Subroto Roy, Kolkata

Inviting a new Prime Minister of India to form a Government: Procedure Right and Wrong

Better Procedure

The Hon’ble President of India invites the leader of the single largest political party in the 15th Lok Sabha to visit Rashtrapati Bhavan.

The leader does so, bringing with her, her own nominee for the Prime Ministership of India as she herself wishes to decline the invitation to be PM.

The President meets the leader alone and extends the invitation.

The invitation is respectfully declined with the recommendation that the Hon’ble President may perhaps consider instead the name of the person nominated by the leader.

The President agrees and extends the invitation to the latter in the presence of the leader.  The latter accepts with thanks.

The President observes that since the PM-elect in this case happens not to be  a member of the Lok Sabha, she hopes that he shall soon become one.

The meeting ends.

Worse Procedure

The leader of the single largest political party in the 15th Lok Sabha publicly announces her nominee for the position of Prime Minister.

The Hon’ble President of India comes to learn of this from the newspapers or television and extends an invitation to the latter.

The latter visits Rashtrapati Bhavan, receives and accepts the President’s invitation to form a Government.

Of related interest:

Parliament’s sovereignty has been diminished by the Executive

Memo to the Hon’ble President of India: It is Sonia Gandhi, not Manmohan Singh, who should be invited to our equivalent of the “Kissing Hands” Ceremony

Starting with Procedural Error: Why has the “Cabinet” of the 14th Lok Sabha been meeting today AFTER the results of the Elections to the 15th Lok Sabha have been declared?!

Memo to the Hon’ble President of India: It is Sonia Gandhi, not Manmohan Singh, who should be invited to our equivalent of the “Kissing Hands” Ceremony

H.E. The Hon’ble Shrimati Pratibha Patil

President of India

Your Excellency,

As India is fortunately a Republic and not a Monarchy, we do not have  a “Kissing Hands Ceremony”  where “the monarch invites the incoming prime minister to form a government and swear allegiance to the throne”.

While we do not have such a ceremony literally, we do have its republican equivalent in the well-established constitutional custom of the President of India after a General Election inviting one person to be Prime Minister and to form the new  Government.

It soon shall be your solemn duty to invite such a new Prime Minister of India to form the Government.

Given the results of the 15th General Elections to the Lok Sabha, that invitation may be extended only to the Leader of the winning coalition in the Lok Sabha, who is Shrimati Sonia Gandhi.

The outgoing Prime Minister, Dr Manmohan Singh, not having contested the Lok Sabha election, may not by  you be invited to be Prime Minister at this stage.

What happened in 2004 was that Shrimati Sonia Gandhi declined to accept such an invitation and instead effectively appointed Dr Singh to be PM despite his not being a member of the Lok Sabha nor intending to be so.

This exploited a constitutional loophole to the extent that our Constitution did not explicitly state that the PM must be from the Lok Sabha.

What may have been passable as the hurried exploitation of a loophole in 2004 is surely not acceptable in 2009.

Why the founders of our democratic polity such as BR  Ambedkar and Jawaharlal Nehru did not specify that the PM must be from the Lok Sabha was quite simply that it was a matter of complete obviousness to them and to their entire generation that this must be so — it would have been  appalling to them and something beyond their wildest imagination that a later generation, namely our own, would exploit this loophole and allow a PM to be appointed who is not a member of the Lok Sabha and intends not to be so.

Ambedkar, Nehru and all others of their time knew fully well that Lord Curzon had been explicitly denied the leadership of Britain’s Tory Party in 1922 because that would have made him a potential PM  when he was not prepared to be a member of the House of Commons.

That specific precedent (culminating a centuries-old  democratic trend of  political power flowing from monarchs to lords to commoners) has governed all parliamentary democracies  worldwide ever since  — until Dr Singh’s appointment in 2004.

In fact,  when such an anomalous situation once arose in Britain, Lord Home resigned his membership of the House of Lords to contest a House of Commons seat as Sir Alec Douglas Home  so that he could be PM in a manner consistent with parliamentary law.

I believe you are fully within constitutional law and precedent to invite Shrimati Sonia Gandhi to form the new Government of India after the 15th General Elections to the Lok Sabha.  If she declines and instead requests again the use of the loophole to appoint Dr Singh as PM,  I believe that parliamentary law and precedent requires him to resign from the Rajya Sabha and instead contest a seat in the Lok Sabha.

Respectfully submitted

Subroto Roy, PhD (Cantab.), BScEcon (London)

Kolkata

Citizen and Voter

Postscript: Please see also here “Inviting a new Prime Minister of India to form a Government: Procedure Right and Wrong”.

India’s 2009 General Elections: Provisional Results from the EC as of 1400 hours Indian Standard Time May 16 2009

Const.        PC NAME        Leading/Winning Candidate    Leading Party    Trailing Candidate Name    Trailing Party    Margin of Votes    Result Declared
1    AP    ADILABAD         Rathod Ramesh    Telugu Desam    Kotnak Ramesh    Indian National Congress    115752    NO
2    AP    PEDDAPALLE         Dr.G.Vivekanand    Indian National Congress    Gomasa Srinivas    Telangana Rashtra Samithi    48503    NO
3    AP    KARIMNAGAR         Ponnam Prabhakar    Indian National Congress    Vinod Kumar Boinapally    Telangana Rashtra Samithi    50179    NO
4    AP    NIZAMABAD        Madhu Yaskhi Goud    Indian National Congress    Bigala Ganesh Gupta    Telangana Rashtra Samithi    59007    NO
5    AP    ZAHIRABAD        Syed Yousuf Ali    Telangana Rashtra Samithi    Suresh Kumar Shetkar    Indian National Congress    12423    NO
6    AP    MEDAK        Vijaya Shanthi .M    Telangana Rashtra Samithi    Narendranath .C    Indian National Congress    7513    NO
7    AP    MALKAJGIRI        Sarvey Sathyanarayana    Indian National Congress    Bheemsen.T    Telugu Desam    45684    NO
8    AP    SECUNDRABAD        Anjan Kumar Yadav M    Indian National Congress    Bandaru Dattatreya    Bharatiya Janata Party    143695    NO
9    AP    HYDERABAD        Asaduddin Owaisi    All India Majlis-E-Ittehadul Muslimeen    Zahid Ali Khan    Telugu Desam    74507    NO
10    AP    CHELVELLA        Jaipal Reddy Sudini    Indian National Congress    A.P.Jithender Reddy    Telugu Desam    18032    NO
11    AP    MAHBUBNAGAR        Devarakonda Vittal Rao    Indian National Congress    K. Chandrasekhar Rao    Telangana Rashtra Samithi    4782    NO
12    AP    NAGARKURNOOL        Dr. Manda Jagannath    Indian National Congress    Guvvala Balaraju    Telangana Rashtra Samithi    31833    NO
13    AP    NALGONDA        Gutha Sukender Reddy    Indian National Congress    Suravaram Sudhakar Reddy    Communist Party of India    68461    NO
14    AP    BHONGIR         Komatireddy Raj Gopal Reddy    Indian National Congress    Nomula Narsimhaiah    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    75636    NO
15    AP    WARANGAL        Rajaiah Siricilla    Indian National Congress    Ramagalla Parameshwar    Telangana Rashtra Samithi    97708    NO
16    AP    MAHABUBABAD         P. Balram    Indian National Congress    Kunja Srinivasa Rao    Communist Party of India    67553    NO
17    AP    KHAMMAM         Nama Nageswara Rao    Telugu Desam    Renuka Chowdhury    Indian National Congress    102505    NO
18    AP    ARUKU         Kishore Chandra Suryanarayana Deo Vyricherla    Indian National Congress    Midiyam Babu Rao    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    90318    NO
19    AP    SRIKAKULAM        Killi Krupa Rani    Indian National Congress    Yerrnnaidu Kinjarapu    Telugu Desam    49013    NO
20    AP    VIZIANAGARAM        Jhansi Lakshmi Botcha    Indian National Congress    Appalanaidu Kondapalli    Telugu Desam    41954    NO
21    AP    VISAKHAPATNAM        Daggubati Purandeswari    Indian National Congress    Palla Srinivasa Rao    Praja Rajyam Party    21581    NO
22    AP    ANAKAPALLI        Sabbam Hari    Indian National Congress    Allu Aravind    Praja Rajyam Party    30239    NO
23    AP    KAKINADA        M.M.Pallamraju    Indian National Congress    Chalamalasetty Sunil    Praja Rajyam Party    32934    NO
24    AP    AMALAPURAM         G.V.Harsha Kumar    Indian National Congress    Pothula Prameela Devi    Praja Rajyam Party    30060    NO
25    AP    RAJAHMUNDRY        Aruna Kumar Vundavalli    Indian National Congress    M. Murali Mohan    Telugu Desam    15135    NO
26    AP    NARSAPURAM        Bapiraju Kanumuru    Indian National Congress    Gubbala Tammaiah    Praja Rajyam Party    71888    NO
27    AP    ELURU         Kavuri Sambasiva Rao    Indian National Congress    Maganti Venkateswara Rao(Babu)    Telugu Desam    36019    NO
28    AP    MACHILIPATNAM         Konakalla Narayana Rao    Telugu Desam    Badiga Ramakrishna    Indian National Congress    1866    NO
29    AP    VIJAYAWADA        Lagadapati Raja Gopal    Indian National Congress    Vamsi Mohan Vallabhaneni    Telugu Desam    30685    NO
30    AP    GUNTUR        Rayapati Sambasiva Rao     Indian National Congress    Madala Rajendra    Telugu Desam    18978    NO
31    AP    NARASARAOPET        Balashowry Vallabhaneni    Indian National Congress    Modugula Venugopala Reddy    Telugu Desam    3988    NO
32    AP    BAPATLA         Panabaka Lakshmi    Indian National Congress    Malyadri Sriram    Telugu Desam    43089    NO
33    AP    ONGOLE         Magunta Srinivasulu Reddy    Indian National Congress    Madduluri Malakondaiah Yadav    Telugu Desam    38947    NO
34    AP    NANDYAL        S.P.Y.Reddy    Indian National Congress    Nasyam Mohammed Farook    Telugu Desam    16735    NO
35    AP    KURNOOL        Kotla Jaya Surya Prakash Reddy    Indian National Congress    B.T.Naidu    Telugu Desam    61274    NO
36    AP    ANANTAPUR        Anantha Venkata Rami Reddy    Indian National Congress    Kalava Srinivasulu    Telugu Desam    59410    NO
37    AP    HINDUPUR        Kristappa Nimmala    Telugu Desam    P Khasim Khan    Indian National Congress    13186    NO
38    AP    KADAPA        Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy    Indian National Congress    Palem Srikanth Reddy    Telugu Desam    156168    NO
39    AP    NELLORE        Mekapati Rajamohan Reddy    Indian National Congress    Vanteru Venu Gopala Reddy    Telugu Desam    42407    NO
40    AP    TIRUPATI         Chinta Mohan    Indian National Congress    Varla Ramaiah    Telugu Desam    17462    NO
41    AP    RAJAMPET        Annayyagari Sai Prathap    Indian National Congress    Ramesh Kumar Reddy Reddappagari    Telugu Desam    62762    NO
42    AP    CHITTOOR         Naramalli Sivaprasad    Telugu Desam    Thippeswamy M    Indian National Congress    8806    NO
1    AR    ARUNACHAL WEST        Takam Sanjoy    Indian National Congress    Kiren Rijiju    Bharatiya Janata Party    20798    NO
2    AR    ARUNACHAL EAST        Ninong Ering    Indian National Congress    Lowangcha Wanglat    Arunachal Congress    57975    NO
1    AS    KARIMGANJ        Rajesh Mallah    Assam United Democratic Front    Lalit Mohan Suklabaidya    Indian National Congress    37542    NO
2    AS    SILCHAR        Kabindra Purkayastha    Bharatiya Janata Party    Badruddin Ajmal    Assam United Democratic Front    15243    NO
3    AS    AUTONOMOUS DISTRICT        Biren Singh Engti    Indian National Congress    Elwin Teron    Autonomous State Demand Committee    71819    NO
4    AS    DHUBRI        Badruddin Ajmal    Assam United Democratic Front    Anwar Hussain    Indian National Congress    161394    NO
5    AS    KOKRAJHAR        Sansuma Khunggur Bwiswmuthiary    Bodaland Peoples Front    Urkhao Gwra Brahma    Independent    165034    NO
6    AS    BARPETA        Ismail Hussain    Indian National Congress    Bhupen Ray    Asom Gana Parishad    2974    NO
7    AS    GAUHATI        Bijoya Chakravarty    Bharatiya Janata Party    Capt. Robin Bordoloi    Indian National Congress    2092    NO
8    AS    MANGALDOI        Ramen Deka    Bharatiya Janata Party    Madhab Rajbangshi    Indian National Congress    40759    NO
9    AS    TEZPUR        Joseph Toppo    Asom Gana Parishad    Moni Kumar Subba    Indian National Congress    22778    NO
10    AS    NOWGONG        Rajen Gohain    Bharatiya Janata Party    Anil Raja    Indian National Congress    54992    NO
11    AS    KALIABOR        Dip Gogoi    Indian National Congress    Gunin Hazarika    Asom Gana Parishad    115587    NO
12    AS    JORHAT        Bijoy Krishna Handique    Indian National Congress    Kamakhya Tasa    Bharatiya Janata Party    63749    NO
13    AS    DIBRUGARH        Sima Ghosh    Independent    Lakhi Charan Swansi    Independent    13171    NO
14    AS    LAKHIMPUR        Ranee Narah    Indian National Congress    Dr. Arun Kr. Sarma    Asom Gana Parishad    22689    NO
1    BR    VALMIKI NAGAR        Baidyanath Prasad Mahto    Janata Dal (United)    Fakhruddin    Independent    92894    NO
2    BR    PASCHIM CHAMPARAN        Dr. Sanjay Jaiswal    Bharatiya Janata Party    Prakash Jha    Lok Jan Shakti Party    27380    NO
3    BR    PURVI CHAMPARAN        Radha Mohan Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Akhilesh Prasad Singh    Rashtriya Janata Dal    16852    NO
4    BR    SHEOHAR        Rama Devi    Bharatiya Janata Party    Sitaram Singh    Rashtriya Janata Dal    20138    NO
5    BR    SITAMARHI        Arjun Roy    Janata Dal (United)    Samir Kumar Mahaseth    Indian National Congress    58330    NO
6    BR    MADHUBANI        Hukmadeo Narayan Yadav    Bharatiya Janata Party    Abdulbari Siddiki    Rashtriya Janata Dal    14813    NO
7    BR    JHANJHARPUR        Mangani Lal Mandal    Janata Dal (United)    Devendra Prasad Yadav    Rashtriya Janata Dal    15645    NO
8    BR    SUPAUL        Vishwa Mohan Kumar    Janata Dal (United)    Ranjeet Ranjan    Indian National Congress    156716    NO
9    BR    ARARIA        Pradeep Kumar Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Zakir Hussain Khan    Lok Jan Shakti Party    990    NO
10    BR    KISHANGANJ        Mohammad Asrarul Haque    Indian National Congress    Syed Mahmood Ashraf    Janata Dal (United)    23819    NO
11    BR    KATIHAR        Nikhil Kumar Choudhary    Bharatiya Janata Party    Shah Tariq Anwar    Nationalist Congress Party    25043    NO
12    BR    PURNIA        Uday Singh Alias Pappu Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Shanti Priya    Independent    45055    NO
13    BR    MADHEPURA        Sharad Yadav    Janata Dal (United)    Prof. Ravindra Charan Yadav    Rashtriya Janata Dal    63004    NO
14    BR    DARBHANGA        Kirti Azad    Bharatiya Janata Party    Md. Ali Ashraf Fatmi    Rashtriya Janata Dal    10506    NO
15    BR    MUZAFFARPUR        Captain Jai Narayan Prasad Nishad    Janata Dal (United)    Bhagwanlal Sahni    Lok Jan Shakti Party    22358    NO
16    BR    VAISHALI        Raghuvansh Prasad Singh    Rashtriya Janata Dal    Vijay Kumar Shukla    Janata Dal (United)    16884    NO
17    BR    GOPALGANJ         Purnmasi Ram    Janata Dal (United)    Anil Kumar    Rashtriya Janata Dal    14206    NO
18    BR    SIWAN        Om Prakash Yadav    Independent    Hena Shahab    Rashtriya Janata Dal    46540    NO
19    BR    MAHARAJGANJ        Prabhu Nath Singh    Janata Dal (United)    Uma Shanaker Singh    Rashtriya Janata Dal    3826    NO
20    BR    SARAN        Lalu Prasad    Rashtriya Janata Dal    Rajiv Pratap Rudy    Bharatiya Janata Party    12043    NO
21    BR    HAJIPUR         Ram Sundar Das    Janata Dal (United)    Ram Vilas Paswan    Lok Jan Shakti Party    25499    NO
22    BR    UJIARPUR        Aswamedh Devi    Janata Dal (United)    Alok Kumar Mehta    Rashtriya Janata Dal    3919    NO
23    BR    SAMASTIPUR         Maheshwar Hazari    Janata Dal (United)    Ram Chandra Paswan    Lok Jan Shakti Party    16617    NO
24    BR    BEGUSARAI        Dr. Monazir Hassan    Janata Dal (United)    Shatrughna Prasad Singh    Communist Party of India    7134    NO
25    BR    KHAGARIA        Dinesh Chandra Yadav    Janata Dal (United)    Ravindar Kr. Rana    Rashtriya Janata Dal    111954    NO
26    BR    BHAGALPUR        Syed Shahnawaz Hussain    Bharatiya Janata Party    Shakuni Choudhary    Rashtriya Janata Dal    51019    NO
27    BR    BANKA        Digvijay Singh    Independent    Jai Prakesh Narain Yadav    Rashtriya Janata Dal    1717    NO
28    BR    MUNGER        Rajiv Ranjan Singh Alias Lalan Singh    Janata Dal (United)    Ram Badan Roy    Rashtriya Janata Dal    93963    NO
29    BR    NALANDA        Kaushalendra Kumar    Janata Dal (United)    Satish Kumar    Lok Jan Shakti Party    57221    NO
30    BR    PATNA SAHIB        Shatrughan Sinha    Bharatiya Janata Party    Vijay Kumar    Rashtriya Janata Dal    149553    NO
31    BR    PATALIPUTRA        Ranjan Prasad Yadav    Janata Dal (United)    Lalu Prasad    Rashtriya Janata Dal    18071    NO
32    BR    ARRAH        Meena Singh    Janata Dal (United)    Rama Kishore Singh    Lok Jan Shakti Party    32291    NO
33    BR    BUXAR        Lal Muni Choubey    Bharatiya Janata Party    Jagada Nand Singh    Rashtriya Janata Dal    5884    NO
34    BR    SASARAM         Meira Kumar    Indian National Congress    Muni Lal    Bharatiya Janata Party    7236    NO
35    BR    KARAKAT        Mahabali Singh    Janata Dal (United)    Kanti Singh    Rashtriya Janata Dal    15062    NO
36    BR    JAHANABAD         Jagdish Sharma    Janata Dal (United)    Surendra Prasad Yadav    Rashtriya Janata Dal    9210    NO
37    BR    AURANGABAD        Sushil Kumar Singh    Janata Dal (United)    Shakil Ahmad Khan    Rashtriya Janata Dal    27551    NO
38    BR    GAYA         Hari Manjhi    Bharatiya Janata Party    Ramji Manjhi    Rashtriya Janata Dal    58906    NO
39    BR    NAWADA        Bhola Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Veena Devi    Lok Jan Shakti Party    4582    NO
40    BR    JAMUI         Bhudeo Choudhary    Janata Dal (United)    Shyam Rajak    Rashtriya Janata Dal    19419    NO
1    GA    NORTH GOA        Shripad Yesso Naik    Bharatiya Janata Party    Jitendra Raghuraj Deshprabhu    Nationalist Congress Party    6353    NO
2    GA    SOUTH GOA        Cosme Francisco Caitano Sardinha    Indian National Congress    Adv. Narendra Keshav Sawaikar    Bharatiya Janata Party    12516    YES
1    GJ    KACHCHH        Jat Poonamben Veljibhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    Danicha Valjibhai Punamchandra    Indian National Congress    69187    NO
2    GJ    BANASKANTHA        Gadhvi Mukeshkumar Bheiravdanji    Indian National Congress    Chaudhary Haribhai Parathibhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    10317    NO
3    GJ    PATAN        Jagdish Thakor    Indian National Congress    Rathod Bhavsinhbhai Dahyabhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    27015    NO
4    GJ    MAHESANA        Patel Jayshreeben Kanubhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    Patel Jivabhai Ambalal    Indian National Congress    22003    YES
5    GJ    SABARKANTHA        Chauhan Mahendrasinh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Mistry Madhusudan    Indian National Congress    17160    NO
6    GJ    GANDHINAGAR        L.K.Advani    Bharatiya Janata Party    Patel Sureshkumar Chaturdas (Suresh Patel)    Indian National Congress    134558    NO
7    GJ    AHMEDABAD EAST        Harin Pathak    Bharatiya Janata Party    Babaria Dipakbhai Ratilal    Indian National Congress    89547    NO
8    GJ    AHMEDABAD WEST        Dr. Solanki Kiritbhai Premajibhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    Parmar Shailesh Manharlal    Indian National Congress    91127    NO
9    GJ    SURENDRANAGAR        Mer Laljibhai Chaturbhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    Koli Patel Somabhai Gandalal    Indian National Congress    1273    NO
10    GJ    RAJKOT        Kuvarjibhai Mohanbhai Bavalia    Indian National Congress    Kirankumar Valjibhai Bhalodia (Patel)    Bharatiya Janata Party    13362    NO
11    GJ    PORBANDAR        Radadiya Vitthalbhai Hansrajbhai    Indian National Congress    Khachariya Mansukhbhai Shamjibhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    38342    NO
12    GJ    JAMNAGAR        Ahir Vikrambhai Arjanbhai Madam    Indian National Congress    Mungra Rameshbhai Devrajbhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    2463    NO
13    GJ    JUNAGADH        Solanki Dinubhai Boghabhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    Barad Jashubhai Dhanabhai    Indian National Congress    13759    NO
14    GJ    AMRELI        Kachhadia Naranbhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    Nilaben Virjibhai Thummar    Indian National Congress    37317    NO
15    GJ    BHAVNAGAR        Rajendrasinh Ghanshyamsinh Rana (Rajubhai Rana)    Bharatiya Janata Party    Gohilmahavirsinhbhagirathsinh    Indian National Congress    13964    NO
16    GJ    ANAND        Solanki Bharatbhai Madhavsinh    Indian National Congress    Patel Dipakbhai Chimanbhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    67318    NO
17    GJ    KHEDA        Chauhan Devusinh Jesingbhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    Dinsha Patel    Indian National Congress    4973    NO
18    GJ    PANCHMAHAL        Chauhan Prabhatsinh Pratapsinh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Vaghela Shankarsinh Laxmansinh    Indian National Congress    2081    NO
19    GJ    DAHOD        Dr. Prabha Kishor Taviad    Indian National Congress    Damor Somjibhai Punjabhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    58536    NO
20    GJ    VADODARA        Balkrishna Khanderao Shukla (Balu Shukla)    Bharatiya Janata Party    Gaekwad Satyajitsinh Dulipsinh    Indian National Congress    136028    YES
21    GJ    CHHOTA UDAIPUR        Rathwa Ramsingbhai Patalbhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    Rathwa Naranbhai Jemlabhai    Indian National Congress    13493    NO
22    GJ    BHARUCH        Mansukhbhai Dhanjibhai Vasava    Bharatiya Janata Party    Umerji Ahmed Ugharatdar (Aziz Tankarvi)    Indian National Congress    31846    NO
23    GJ    BARDOLI        Chaudhari Tusharbhai Amrasinhbhai    Indian National Congress    Vasava Riteshkumar Amarsinh    Bharatiya Janata Party    59463    NO
24    GJ    SURAT        Shrimati Darshana Vikram Jardosh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Gajera Dhirubhai Haribhai    Indian National Congress    74798    NO
25    GJ    NAVSARI        C. R. Patil    Bharatiya Janata Party    Dhansukha Rajput    Indian National Congress    118558    NO
26    GJ    VALSAD        Kishanbhai Vestabhai Patel    Indian National Congress    Patel Dhirubhai Chhaganbhai (Dr. D.C.Patel)    Bharatiya Janata Party    7169    NO
1    HR    AMBALA        Selja    Indian National Congress    Rattan Lal Kataria    Bharatiya Janata Party    14925    NO
2    HR    KURUKSHETRA        Naveen Jindal    Indian National Congress    Ashok Kumar Arora    Indian National Lok Dal    118729    NO
3    HR    SIRSA        Ashok Tanwar    Indian National Congress    Dr. Sita Ram    Indian National Lok Dal    35877    NO
4    HR    HISAR        Bhajan Lal S/O Kheraj    Haryana Janhit Congress (BL)    Sampat Singh    Indian National Lok Dal    24443    NO
5    HR    KARNAL        Arvind Kumar Sharma    Indian National Congress    Maratha Virender Verma    Bahujan Samaj Party    62190    NO
6    HR    SONIPAT        Jitender Singh    Indian National Congress    Kishan Singh Sangwan    Bharatiya Janata Party    148409    NO
7    HR    ROHTAK        Deepender Singh    Indian National Congress    Nafe Singh Rathee    Indian National Lok Dal    445736    NO
8    HR    BHIWANI-MAHENDRAGARH        Shruti Choudhry    Indian National Congress    Ajay Singh Chautala    Indian National Lok Dal    25647    NO
9    HR    GURGAON        Inderjit Singh    Indian National Congress    Zakir Hussain    Bahujan Samaj Party    86438    NO
10    HR    FARIDABAD        Avtar Singh Bhadana    Indian National Congress    Ramchander Bainda    Bharatiya Janata Party    49661    NO
1    HP    KANGRA        Dr. Rajan Sushant    Bharatiya Janata Party    Chander Kumar    Indian National Congress    24368    NO
2    HP    MANDI        Virbhadra Singh    Indian National Congress    Maheshwar Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    13997    YES
3    HP    HAMIRPUR        Anurag Singh Thakur    Bharatiya Janata Party    Narinder Thakur    Indian National Congress    72732    NO
4    HP    SHIMLA        Virender Kashyap    Bharatiya Janata Party    Dhani Ram Shandil    Indian National Congress    29568    NO
1    JK    BARAMULLA        Sharief Ud Din Shariq    Jammu & Kashmir National Conference    Mohammad Dilawar Mir    Jammu & Kashmir Peoples Democratic Party    46361    NO
2    JK    SRINAGAR        Farooq Abdullah    Jammu & Kashmir National Conference    Iftikhar Hussain Ansari    Jammu & Kashmir Peoples Democratic Party    30242    NO
3    JK    ANANTNAG        Mirza Mehboob Beg    Jammu & Kashmir National Conference    Peer Mohd Hussain    Jammu & Kashmir Peoples Democratic Party    373    NO
4    JK    LADAKH        Hassan Khan    Independent    Asgar Ali Karbalaie    Independent    7513    NO
5    JK    UDHAMPUR        Ch. Lal Singh    Indian National Congress    Dr. Nirmal Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    13394    NO
6    JK    JAMMU        Madan Lal Sharma    Indian National Congress    Lila Karan Sharma    Bharatiya Janata Party    118165    NO
1    KA    CHIKKODI        Katti Ramesh Vishwanath    Bharatiya Janata Party    Prakash Babanna Hukkeri    Indian National Congress    55287    YES
2    KA    BELGAUM        Angadi Suresh Channabasappa    Bharatiya Janata Party    Amarsinh Vasantrao Patil    Indian National Congress    118687    NO
3    KA    BAGALKOT        Gaddigoudar P.C.    Bharatiya Janata Party    J.T.Patil    Indian National Congress    35446    NO
4    KA    BIJAPUR        Ramesh Chandappa Jigajinagi    Bharatiya Janata Party    Prakash Kubasing Rathod    Indian National Congress    42404    YES
5    KA    GULBARGA        Mallikarjun Kharge    Indian National Congress    Revunaik Belamgi    Bharatiya Janata Party    13404    NO
6    KA    RAICHUR        Pakkirappa.S.    Bharatiya Janata Party    Raja Venkatappa Naik    Indian National Congress    30636    YES
7    KA    BIDAR        N.Dharam Singh    Indian National Congress    Gurupadappa Nagmarpalli    Bharatiya Janata Party    19342    NO
8    KA    KOPPAL        Shivaramagouda Shivanagouda    Bharatiya Janata Party    Basavaraj Rayareddy    Indian National Congress    81789    NO
9    KA    BELLARY        J. Shantha    Bharatiya Janata Party    N.Y. Hanumanthappa    Indian National Congress    2243    YES
10    KA    HAVERI        Udasi Shivkumar Chanabasappa    Bharatiya Janata Party    Saleem Ahamed    Indian National Congress    87920    NO
11    KA    DHARWAD        Pralhad Joshi    Bharatiya Janata Party    Kunnur Manjunath Channappa    Indian National Congress    137376    NO
12    KA    UTTARA KANNADA        Anantkumar Hegde    Bharatiya Janata Party    Alva Margaret    Indian National Congress    22769    YES
13    KA    DAVANAGERE        Mallikarjuna S.S.    Indian National Congress    Siddeswara G.M.    Bharatiya Janata Party    6103    NO
14    KA    SHIMOGA        B.Y. Raghavendra    Bharatiya Janata Party    S. Bangarappa    Indian National Congress    52694    NO
15    KA    UDUPI CHIKMAGALUR        D.V.Sadananda Gowda    Bharatiya Janata Party    K.Jayaprakash Hegde    Indian National Congress    17154    NO
16    KA    HASSAN        H. D. Devegowda    Janata Dal (Secular)    K. H. Hanume Gowda    Bharatiya Janata Party    191514    NO
17    KA    DAKSHINA KANNADA        Nalin Kumar Kateel    Bharatiya Janata Party    Janardhana Poojary    Indian National Congress    40420    YES
18    KA    CHITRADURGA        Janardhana Swamy    Bharatiya Janata Party    Dr. B Thippeswamy    Indian National Congress    107373    NO
19    KA    TUMKUR        G.S. Basavaraj    Bharatiya Janata Party    Muddahanumegowda S.P.    Janata Dal (Secular)    59288    NO
20    KA    MANDYA        N Cheluvaraya Swamy @ Swamygowda    Janata Dal (Secular)    M H Ambareesh    Indian National Congress    23437    NO
21    KA    MYSORE        Adagur H Vishwanath    Indian National Congress    C.H.Vijayashankar    Bharatiya Janata Party    7691    YES
22    KA    CHAMARAJANAGAR        R.Dhruvanarayana    Indian National Congress    A.R.Krishnamurthy    Bharatiya Janata Party    11470    NO
23    KA    BANGALORE RURAL        H.D.Kumaraswamy    Janata Dal (Secular)    C. P. Yogeeshwara    Bharatiya Janata Party    130275    NO
24    KA    BANGALORE NORTH        D. B. Chandre Gowda    Bharatiya Janata Party    C. K. Jaffer Sharief    Indian National Congress    49448    NO
25    KA    BANGALORE CENTRAL        P. C. Mohan    Bharatiya Janata Party    H.T.Sangliana    Indian National Congress    24385    NO
26    KA    BANGALORE SOUTH        Ananth Kumar    Bharatiya Janata Party    Krishna Byre Gowda    Indian National Congress    37612    NO
27    KA    CHIKKBALLAPUR        M.Veerappa Moily    Indian National Congress    C.Aswathanarayana    Bharatiya Janata Party    17697    NO
28    KA    KOLAR        K.H.Muniyappa    Indian National Congress    D.S.Veeraiah    Bharatiya Janata Party    23006    YES
1    KL    KASARAGOD        P Karunakaran    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Shahida Kamal    Indian National Congress    64427    NO
2    KL    KANNUR        K. Sudhakaran    Indian National Congress    K.K Ragesh    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    43151    YES
3    KL    VADAKARA        Mullappally Ramachandran    Indian National Congress    Adv. P. Satheedevi    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    56186    YES
4    KL    WAYANAD        M.I. Shanavas    Indian National Congress    Advocate. M. Rahmathulla    Communist Party of India    153439    NO
5    KL    KOZHIKODE        M.K. Raghavan    Indian National Congress    Adv. P.A. Mohamed Riyas    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    838    NO
6    KL    MALAPPURAM        E. Ahamed    Muslim League Kerala State Committee    T.K. Hamza    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    115569    NO
7    KL    PONNANI        E.T. Muhammed Basheer    Muslim League Kerala State Committee    Dr. Hussain Randathani    Independent    84478    NO
8    KL    PALAKKAD        M.B. Rajesh    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Satheesan Pacheni    Indian National Congress    1820    NO
9    KL    ALATHUR         P.K Biju    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    N.K Sudheer    Indian National Congress    20960    NO
10    KL    THRISSUR        P C Chacko    Indian National Congress    C N Jayadevan    Communist Party of India    25421    NO
11    KL    CHALAKUDY        K.P. Dhanapalan    Indian National Congress    Adv. U.P Joseph    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    71679    NO
12    KL    ERNAKULAM        Prof. K V Thomas    Indian National Congress    Sindhu Joy    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    11790    NO
13    KL    IDUKKI        Adv. P.T Thomas    Indian National Congress    Adv. K. Francis George    Kerala Congress    74796    NO
14    KL    KOTTAYAM        Jose K.Mani (Karingozheckal)    Kerala Congress (M)    Adv. Suresh Kurup    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    66170    NO
15    KL    ALAPPUZHA        K.C Venugopal    Indian National Congress    Dr. K.S Manoj    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    57791    NO
16    KL    MAVELIKKARA         Kodikkunnil Suresh    Indian National Congress    R.S Anil    Communist Party of India    48240    NO
17    KL    PATHANAMTHITTA        Anto Antony Punnathaniyil    Indian National Congress    Adv.K.Anantha Gopan    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    111206    NO
18    KL    KOLLAM        N.Peethambarakurup    Indian National Congress    P.Rajendran    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    17531    NO
19    KL    ATTINGAL        Adv. A Sampath    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Prof.G Balachandran    Indian National Congress    17660    NO
20    KL    THIRUVANANTHAPURAM        Shashi Tharoor    Indian National Congress    Adv. P Ramachandran Nair    Communist Party of India    100045    NO
1    MP    MORENA        Narendra Singh Tomar    Bharatiya Janata Party    Ramniwas Rawat    Indian National Congress    96255    NO
2    MP    BHIND        Ashok Argal    Bharatiya Janata Party    Dr. Bhagirath Prasad    Indian National Congress    8086    NO
3    MP    GWALIOR        Yashodhara Raje Scindia    Bharatiya Janata Party    Ashok Singh    Indian National Congress    21923    NO
4    MP    GUNA        Jyotiraditya Madhavrao Scindia    Indian National Congress    Dr.Narottam Mishra    Bharatiya Janata Party    189578    NO
5    MP    SAGAR        Bhupendra Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Aslam Sher Khan    Indian National Congress    131168    NO
6    MP    TIKAMGARH        Virendra Kumar    Bharatiya Janata Party    Ahirwar Vrindavan    Indian National Congress    41862    NO
7    MP    DAMOH        Shivraj Bhaiya    Bharatiya Janata Party    Chandrabhan Bhaiya    Indian National Congress    55747    NO
8    MP    KHAJURAHO        Jeetendra Singh Bundela    Bharatiya Janata Party    Raja Paterya    Indian National Congress    28332    NO
9    MP    SATNA        Ganesh Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Sukhlal Kushwaha    Bahujan Samaj Party    377    NO
10    MP    REWA        Deoraj Singh Patel    Bahujan Samaj Party    Sunder Lal Tiwari    Indian National Congress    3644    NO
11    MP    SIDHI        Govind Prasad Mishra    Bharatiya Janata Party    Indrajeet Kumar    Indian National Congress    44915    NO
12    MP    SHAHDOL        Rajesh Nandini Singh    Indian National Congress    Narendra Singh Maravi    Bharatiya Janata Party    13415    NO
13    MP    JABALPUR        Rakesh Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Advocate Rameshwar Neekhra    Indian National Congress    106003    YES
14    MP    MANDLA        Basori Singh Masram    Indian National Congress    Faggan Singh Kulaste    Bharatiya Janata Party    62726    NO
15    MP    BALAGHAT        K. D. Deshmukh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Vishveshwar Bhagat    Indian National Congress    40898    NO
16    MP    CHHINDWARA        Kamal Nath    Indian National Congress    Marot Rao Khavase    Bharatiya Janata Party    74134    NO
17    MP    HOSHANGABAD        Uday Pratap Singh    Indian National Congress    Rampal Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    17542    NO
18    MP    VIDISHA        Sushma Swaraj    Bharatiya Janata Party    Choudhary Munabbar Salim    Samajwadi Party    375074    NO
19    MP    BHOPAL        Kailash Joshi    Bharatiya Janata Party    Surendra Singh Thakur    Indian National Congress    30764    NO
20    MP    RAJGARH        Narayansingh Amlabe    Indian National Congress    Lakshman Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    24856    NO
21    MP    DEWAS        Sajjan Singh Verma    Indian National Congress    Thavarchand Gehlot    Bharatiya Janata Party    16084    NO
22    MP    UJJAIN        Guddu Premchand    Indian National Congress    Dr. Satyanarayan Jatiya    Bharatiya Janata Party    15841    NO
23    MP    MANDSOUR        Meenakshi Natrajan    Indian National Congress    Dr. Laxminarayan Pandey    Bharatiya Janata Party    26817    NO
24    MP    RATLAM        Kantilal Bhuria    Indian National Congress    Dileepsingh Bhuria    Bharatiya Janata Party    57668    NO
25    MP    DHAR        Gajendra Singh Rajukhedi    Indian National Congress    Mukam Singh Kirade    Bharatiya Janata Party    2012    NO
26    MP    INDORE        Sumitra Mahajan (Tai)    Bharatiya Janata Party    Satynarayan Patel    Indian National Congress    11365    NO
27    MP    KHARGONE        Makansingh Solanki (Babuji)    Bharatiya Janata Party    Balaram Bachchan    Indian National Congress    34175    NO
28    MP    KHANDWA        Arun Subhashchandra Yadav    Indian National Congress    Nandkumar Sing Chauhan Nandu Bhaiya    Bharatiya Janata Party    49081    NO
29    MP    BETUL        Jyoti Dhurve    Bharatiya Janata Party    Ojharam Evane    Indian National Congress    97317    NO
1    MH    NANDURBAR         Gavit Manikrao Hodlya    Indian National Congress    Gavit Sharad Krushnrao    Samajwadi Party    13952    NO
2    MH    DHULE        Amarishbhai Rasiklal Patel    Indian National Congress    Sonawane Pratap Narayanrao    Bharatiya Janata Party    4220    NO
3    MH    JALGAON        A.T. Nana Patil    Bharatiya Janata Party    Adv. Vasantrao Jivanrao More    Nationalist Congress Party    96020    NO
4    MH    RAVER        Haribhau Madhav Jawale    Bharatiya Janata Party    Adv. Ravindra Pralhadrao Patil    Nationalist Congress Party    28692    NO
5    MH    BULDHANA        Jadhav Prataprao Ganpatrao    Shivsena    Shingane Dr.Rajendra Bhaskarrao    Nationalist Congress Party    30565    NO
6    MH    AKOLA        Dhotre Sanjay Shamrao    Bharatiya Janata Party    Ambedkar Prakash Yashwant    Bharipa Bahujan Mahasangha    59331    NO
7    MH    AMRAVATI         Adsul Anandrao Vithoba    Shivsena    Gawai Rajendra Ramkrushna    Republican Party of India    33563    NO
8    MH    WARDHA        Datta Meghe    Indian National Congress    Suresh Ganpatrao Waghmare    Bharatiya Janata Party    121938    NO
9    MH    RAMTEK         Wasnik Mukul Balkrishna    Indian National Congress    Tumane Krupal Balaji    Shivsena    16465    NO
10    MH    NAGPUR         Muttemwar Vilasrao Baburaoji    Indian National Congress    Purohit Banwarilal Bhagwandas    Bharatiya Janata Party    7078    NO
11    MH    BHANDARA – GONDIYA        Patel Praful Manoharbhai    Nationalist Congress Party    Nanabhau Falgunrao Patole    Independent    119604    NO
12    MH    GADCHIROLI-CHIMUR        Kowase Marotrao Sainuji    Indian National Congress    Ashok Mahadeorao Nete    Bharatiya Janata Party    4795    NO
13    MH    CHANDRAPUR        Ahir Hansaraj Gangaram    Bharatiya Janata Party    Pugalia Naresh    Indian National Congress    7044    NO
14    MH    YAVATMAL-WASHIM        Bhavana Gawali (Patil)    Shivsena    Harising Rathod    Indian National Congress    114    NO
15    MH    HINGOLI         Subhash Bapurao Wankhede    Shivsena    Suryakanta Jaiwantrao Patil    Nationalist Congress Party    73569    NO
16    MH    NANDED        Khatgaonkar Patil Bhaskarrao Bapurao    Indian National Congress    Sambhaji Pawar    Bharatiya Janata Party    74975    NO
17    MH    PARBHANI        Adv. Dudhgaonkar Ganeshrao Nagorao    Shivsena    Warpudkar Suresh Ambadasrao    Nationalist Congress Party    30356    NO
18    MH    JALNA        Danve Raosaheb Dadarao    Bharatiya Janata Party    Dr. Kale Kalyan Vaijinathrao    Indian National Congress    9143    NO
19    MH    AURANGABAD        Chandrakant Khaire    Shivsena    Uttamsingh Rajdharsingh Pawar    Indian National Congress    18142    NO
20    MH    DINDORI         Chavan Harishchandra Deoram    Bharatiya Janata Party    Zirwal Narhari Sitaram    Nationalist Congress Party    37347    YES
21    MH    NASHIK        Sameer Bhujbal    Nationalist Congress Party    Godse Hemant Tukaram    Maharashtra Navnirman sena    22032    NO
22    MH    PALGHAR         Jadhav Baliram Sukur    Bahujan Vikas Aaghadi    Adv. Chintaman Vanga    Bharatiya Janata Party    12360    NO
23    MH    BHIWANDI        Taware Suresh Kashinath    Indian National Congress    Patil Jagannath Shivram    Bharatiya Janata Party    41364    YES
24    MH    KALYAN        Anand Prakash Paranjape    Shivsena    Davkhare Vasant Shankarrao    Nationalist Congress Party    21049    NO
25    MH    THANE        Dr.Sanjeev Ganesh Naik    Nationalist Congress Party    Chaugule Vijay Laxman    Shivsena    49020    NO
26    MH    MUMBAI NORTH        Sanjay Brijkishorlal Nirupam    Indian National Congress    Ram Naik    Bharatiya Janata Party    10054    NO
27    MH    MUMBAI NORTH WEST        Ad.Kamat Gurudas Vasant    Indian National Congress    Gajanan Kirtikar    Shivsena    33261    NO
28    MH    MUMBAI NORTH EAST        Sanjay Dina Patil    Nationalist Congress Party    Kirit Somaiya    Bharatiya Janata Party    2415    NO
29    MH    MUMBAI NORTH CENTRAL        Dutt Priya Sunil    Indian National Congress    Mahesh Ram Jethmalani    Bharatiya Janata Party    157401    NO
30    MH    MUMBAI SOUTH CENTRAL        Eknath M. Gaikwad    Indian National Congress    Suresh Anant Gambhir    Shivsena    69714    NO
31    MH    MUMBAI SOUTH        Deora Milind Murli    Indian National Congress    Bala Nandgaonkar    Maharashtra Navnirman sena    54220    NO
32    MH    RAIGAD        Anant Geete    Shivsena    Barrister A.R. Antulay    Indian National Congress    115119    NO
33    MH    MAVAL        Babar Gajanan Dharmshi    Shivsena    Pansare Azam Fakeerbhai    Nationalist Congress Party    60796    NO
34    MH    PUNE        Kalmadi Suresh    Indian National Congress    Anil Shirole    Bharatiya Janata Party    20225    NO
35    MH    BARAMATI        Supriya Sule    Nationalist Congress Party    Kanta Jaysing Nalawade    Bharatiya Janata Party    188399    NO
36    MH    SHIRUR        Adhalrao Shivaji Dattatray    Shivsena    Vilas Vithoba Lande    Nationalist Congress Party    140719    NO
37    MH    AHMADNAGAR         Gandhi Dilipkumar Mansukhlal    Bharatiya Janata Party    Kardile Shivaji Bhanudas    Nationalist Congress Party    42474    NO
38    MH    SHIRDI        Wakchaure Bhausaheb Rajaram    Shivsena    Athawale Ramdas Bandu    Republican Party of India (A)    132640    NO
39    MH    BEED        Munde Gopinathrao Pandurang    Bharatiya Janata Party    Kokate Ramesh Baburao (Adaskar)    Nationalist Congress Party    70369    NO
40    MH    OSMANABAD        Patil Padamsinha Bajirao    Nationalist Congress Party    Gaikwad Ravindra Vishwanath    Shivsena    17017    NO
41    MH    LATUR         Awale Jaywant Gangaram    Indian National Congress    Gaikwad Sunil Baliram    Bharatiya Janata Party    241    NO
42    MH    SOLAPUR         Shinde Sushilkumar Sambhajirao    Indian National Congress    Adv. Bansode Sharad Maruti    Bharatiya Janata Party    99585    NO
43    MH    MADHA        Pawar Sharadchandra Govindrao    Nationalist Congress Party    Deshmukh Subhash Sureshchandra    Bharatiya Janata Party    243142    NO
44    MH    SANGLI        Pratik Prakashbapu Patil    Indian National Congress    Ajitrao Shankarrao Ghorpade    Independent    43746    NO
45    MH    SATARA        Bhonsle Shrimant Chh. Udyanraje Pratapsinhmaharaj    Nationalist Congress Party    Purushottam Bajirao Jadhav    Shivsena    297515    NO
46    MH    RATNAGIRI – SINDHUDURG        Dr.Nilesh Narayan Rane    Indian National Congress    Suresh Prabhakar Prabhu    Shivsena    46750    NO
47    MH    KOLHAPUR        Sadashivrao Dadoba Mandlik     Independent    Chhatrapati Sambhajiraje Shahu    Nationalist Congress Party    36524    NO
48    MH    HATKANANGLE        Shetti Raju Alias Devappa Anna    Swabhimani Paksha    Mane Nivedita Sambhajirao    Nationalist Congress Party    63028    NO
1    MN    INNER MANIPUR        Dr. Thokchom Meinya    Indian National Congress    Moirangthem Nara    Communist Party of India    33321    NO
2    MN    OUTER MANIPUR        Thangso Baite    Indian National Congress    Mani Charenamei    Peoples Democratic Alliance    10586    NO
1    ML    SHILLONG        Vincent H Pala    Indian National Congress    John Filmore Kharshiing    United Democratic Party    107832    NO
2    ML    TURA         Agatha K. Sangma    Nationalist Congress Party    Debora C. Marak    Indian National Congress    17945    NO
1    MZ    MIZORAM        C.L.Ruala    Indian National Congress    Dr. H. Lallungmuana    Independent    96238    NO
1    NL    NAGALAND        C.M. Chang    Nagaland Peoples Front    K. Asungba Sangtam    Indian National Congress    422134    NO
1    OR    BARGARH        Sanjay Bhoi    Indian National Congress    Dr. Hamid Hussain    Biju Janata Dal    39632    NO
2    OR    SUNDARGARH         Jual Oram    Bharatiya Janata Party    Hemanand Biswal    Indian National Congress    6161    NO
3    OR    SAMBALPUR        Amarnath Pradhan    Indian National Congress    Rohit Pujari    Biju Janata Dal    26282    NO
4    OR    KEONJHAR         Yashbant Narayan Singh Laguri    Biju Janata Dal    Dhanurjaya Sidu    Indian National Congress    49221    NO
5    OR    MAYURBHANJ         Laxman Tudu    Biju Janata Dal    Sudam Marndi    Jharkhand Mukti Morcha    17259    NO
6    OR    BALASORE        Srikant Kumar Jena    Indian National Congress    Arun Dey    Nationalist Congress Party    10300    NO
7    OR    BHADRAK         Arjun Charan Sethi    Biju Janata Dal    Ananta Prasad Sethi    Indian National Congress    24187    NO
8    OR    JAJPUR         Mohan Jena    Biju Janata Dal    Amiya Kanta Mallik    Indian National Congress    36000    NO
9    OR    DHENKANAL        Tathagata Satpathy    Biju Janata Dal    Chandra Sekhar Tripathi    Indian National Congress    87929    NO
10    OR    BOLANGIR        Kalikesh Narayan Singh Deo    Biju Janata Dal    Narasingha Mishra    Indian National Congress    24022    NO
11    OR    KALAHANDI        Bhakta Charan Das    Indian National Congress    Subash Chandra Nayak    Biju Janata Dal    59795    NO
12    OR    NABARANGPUR         Pradeep Kumar Majhi    Indian National Congress    Domburu Majhi    Biju Janata Dal    25904    NO
13    OR    KANDHAMAL        Rudramadhab Ray    Biju Janata Dal    Ashok Sahu    Bharatiya Janata Party    57091    NO
14    OR    CUTTACK        Bhartruhari Mahtab    Biju Janata Dal    Bibhuti Bhusan Mishra    Indian National Congress    94756    NO
15    OR    KENDRAPARA         Baijayant Panda    Biju Janata Dal    Ranjib Biswal    Indian National Congress    27810    NO
16    OR    JAGATSINGHPUR         Bibhu Prasad Tarai    Communist Party of India    Rabindra Kumar Sethy    Indian National Congress    30229    NO
17    OR    PURI        Pinaki Misra    Biju Janata Dal    Braja Kishore Tripathy    Bharatiya Janata Party    81737    NO
18    OR    BHUBANESWAR        Prasanna Kumar Patasani    Biju Janata Dal    Santosh Mohanty    Indian National Congress    96043    NO
19    OR    ASKA        Nityananda Pradhan    Biju Janata Dal    Ramachandra Rath    Indian National Congress    94869    NO
20    OR    BERHAMPUR        Sidhant Mohapatra    Biju Janata Dal    Chandra Sekhar Sahu    Indian National Congress    23753    NO
21    OR    KORAPUT         Jayaram Pangi    Biju Janata Dal    Giridhar Gamang    Indian National Congress    42161    NO
1    PB    GURDASPUR        Partap Singh Bajwa    Indian National Congress    Vinod Khanna    Bharatiya Janata Party    1998    NO
2    PB    AMRITSAR        Navjot Singh Sidhu    Bharatiya Janata Party    Om Parkash Soni    Indian National Congress    9057    NO
3    PB    KHADOOR SAHIB        Dr. Rattan Singh Ajnala    Shiromani Akali Dal    Rana Gurjeet Singh    Indian National Congress    28869    NO
4    PB    JALANDHAR        Mohinder Singh Kaypee    Indian National Congress    Hans Raj Hans    Shiromani Akali Dal    36445    NO
5    PB    HOSHIARPUR        Santosh Chowdhary    Indian National Congress    Som Parkash    Bharatiya Janata Party    643    NO
6    PB    ANANDPUR SAHIB        Ravneet Singh    Indian National Congress    Dr. Daljit Singh Cheema    Shiromani Akali Dal    50363    NO
7    PB    LUDHIANA        Manish Tewari    Indian National Congress    Gurcharan Singh Galib    Shiromani Akali Dal    89676    NO
8    PB    FATEHGARH SAHIB        Sukhdev Singh    Indian National Congress    Charanjit Singh Atwal    Shiromani Akali Dal    34299    NO
9    PB    FARIDKOT        Paramjit Kaur Gulshan    Shiromani Akali Dal    Sukhwinder Singh Danny    Indian National Congress    68461    NO
10    PB    FEROZPUR        Sher Singh Ghubaya    Shiromani Akali Dal    Jagmeet Singh Brar    Indian National Congress    30853    NO
11    PB    BATHINDA        Harsimrat Kaur Badal    Shiromani Akali Dal    Raninder Singh    Indian National Congress    99521    NO
12    PB    SANGRUR        Vijay Inder Singla    Indian National Congress    Sukhdev Singh Dhindsa    Shiromani Akali Dal    42789    NO
13    PB    PATIALA        Preneet Kaur    Indian National Congress    Prem Singh Chandumajra    Shiromani Akali Dal    95502    NO
1    RJ    GANGANAGAR        Bharat Ram Meghwal    Indian National Congress    Nihal Chand    Bharatiya Janata Party    140668    NO
2    RJ    BIKANER        Arjun Ram Meghwal    Bharatiya Janata Party    Rewat Ram Panwar    Indian National Congress    19575    NO
3    RJ    CHURU        Ram Singh Kaswan    Bharatiya Janata Party    Rafique Mandelia    Indian National Congress    9525    NO
4    RJ    JHUNJHUNU        Sheesh Ram Ola    Indian National Congress    Dr Dasrath Singh Shekhawat    Bharatiya Janata Party    65321    NO
5    RJ    SIKAR        Mahadev Singh    Indian National Congress    Subhash Maharia    Bharatiya Janata Party    33819    NO
6    RJ    JAIPUR RURAL        Lal Chand Kataria    Indian National Congress    Rao Rajendra Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    45487    NO
7    RJ    JAIPUR        Mahesh Joshi    Indian National Congress    Ghanshyam Tiwari    Bharatiya Janata Party    3628    NO
8    RJ    ALWAR        Jitendra Singh    Indian National Congress    Dr.Kiran Yadav    Bharatiya Janata Party    149251    NO
9    RJ    BHARATPUR        Ratan Singh    Indian National Congress    Khemchand    Bharatiya Janata Party    80625    NO
10    RJ    KARAULI-DHOLPUR        Khiladi Lal Bairwa    Indian National Congress    Dr Manoj Rajoria    Bharatiya Janata Party    27752    NO
11    RJ    DAUSA        Kirodi Lal    Independent    Qummer Rubbani    Independent    23539    NO
12    RJ    TONK-SAWAI MADHOPUR        Namo Narain    Indian National Congress    Kirori Singh Bainsla    Bharatiya Janata Party    472    NO
13    RJ    AJMER        Sachin Pilot    Indian National Congress    Kiran Maheshwari    Bharatiya Janata Party    76135    YES
14    RJ    NAGAUR        Dr. Jyoti Mirdha    Indian National Congress    Bindu Chaudhary    Bharatiya Janata Party    155185    NO
15    RJ    PALI        Badri Ram Jakhar    Indian National Congress    Pusp Jain    Bharatiya Janata Party    171757    NO
16    RJ    JODHPUR        Chandresh Kumari    Indian National Congress    Jaswant Singh Bisnoi    Bharatiya Janata Party    98259    YES
17    RJ    BARMER        Harish Choudhary    Indian National Congress    Manvendra Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    119106    NO
18    RJ    JALORE        Devji Patel    Bharatiya Janata Party    Buta Singh    Independent    29177    NO
19    RJ    UDAIPUR        Raghuvir Singh Meena    Indian National Congress    Mahaveer Bhagora    Bharatiya Janata Party    165021    NO
20    RJ    BANSWARA        Tarachand Bhagora    Indian National Congress    Hakaru Maida    Bharatiya Janata Party    199418    YES
21    RJ    CHITTORGARH        (Dr.)girija Vyas    Indian National Congress    Shrichand Kriplani    Bharatiya Janata Party    65731    NO
22    RJ    RAJSAMAND        Gopal Singh    Indian National Congress    Rasa Singh Rawat    Bharatiya Janata Party    38178    NO
23    RJ    BHILWARA        Dr. C. P. Joshi    Indian National Congress    Vijayendra Pal Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    135368    NO
24    RJ    KOTA        Ijyaraj Singh    Indian National Congress    Shyam Sharma    Bharatiya Janata Party    68106    NO
25    RJ    JHALAWAR-BARAN        Dushyant Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Urmila Jain “bhaya”    Indian National Congress    25503    NO
1    SK    SIKKIM        Prem Das Rai    Sikkim Democratic Front    Kharananda Upreti    Indian National Congress    48955    NO
1    TN    THIRUVALLUR         Venugopal.P    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Gayathri.S    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    27607    NO
2    TN    CHENNAI NORTH        Elangovan T.K.S    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Pandian. D    Communist Party of India    28385    NO
3    TN    CHENNAI SOUTH        Rajendran C    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Bharathy R.S.    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    12962    NO
4    TN    CHENNAI CENTRAL        Dayanidhi Maran    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Mogamed Ali Jinnah S.M.K.    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    24352    NO
5    TN    SRIPERUMBUDUR        Baalu T R    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Moorthy A K    Pattali Makkal Katchi    8222    NO
6    TN    KANCHEEPURAM         Viswanathan.P    Indian National Congress    Ramakrishnan.Dr.E    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    7297    NO
7    TN    ARAKKONAM        Jagathrakshakan    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Velu R    Pattali Makkal Katchi    103407    NO
8    TN    VELLORE        Abdulrahman    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Vasu L K M B    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    107393    NO
9    TN    KRISHNAGIRI        Sugavanam. E.G.    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Nanjegowdu. K.    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    45858    NO
10    TN    DHARMAPURI        Thamaraiselvan. R    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Senthil. R. Dr.    Pattali Makkal Katchi    107130    NO
11    TN    TIRUVANNAMALAI        Venugopal.D    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Guru (A) Gurunathan. J    Pattali Makkal Katchi    110998    NO
12    TN    ARANI        Krishnasamy M    Indian National Congress    Subramaniyan N    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    78457    NO
13    TN    VILUPPURAM        Anandan M    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Swamidurai K    Viduthalai Chiruthaigal Katch    9108    NO
14    TN    KALLAKURICHI        Sankar Adhi    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Dhanaraju K    Pattali Makkal Katchi    105958    NO
15    TN    SALEM        Semmalai S    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Thangkabalu K V    Indian National Congress    41509    NO
16    TN    NAMAKKAL        Gandhiselvan.S    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Vairam Tamilarasi.V    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    87495    NO
17    TN    ERODE        Ganeshamurthi.A.    Marumalarchi Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Elangovan.E.V.K.S.    Indian National Congress    45254    NO
18    TN    TIRUPPUR        Sivasami C    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Kharventhan S K    Indian National Congress    85966    NO
19    TN    NILGIRIS         Raja A    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Krishnan C    Marumalarchi Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    75810    NO
20    TN    COIMBATORE        Prabhu.R    Indian National Congress    Natarajan.P.R.    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    41048    NO
21    TN    POLLACHI        Sugumar.K    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Shanmugasundaram.K    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    45431    NO
22    TN    DINDIGUL        Chitthan N S V    Indian National Congress    Baalasubramani P    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    54347    YES
23    TN    KARUR        Tambidurai.M    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Pallanishamy. K.C.    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    31070    NO
24    TN    TIRUCHIRAPPALLI        Kumar.P    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Sarubala.R.Thondaiman    Indian National Congress    5681    NO
25    TN    PERAMBALUR        Napoleon,D.    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Balasubramanian,K.K.    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    66551    NO
26    TN    CUDDALORE         Alagiri S    Indian National Congress    Sampath M C    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    23136    NO
27    TN    CHIDAMBARAM         Thirumaavalavan, Thol    Viduthalai Chiruthaigal Katch    Ponnuswamy,E    Pattali Makkal Katchi    86277    NO
28    TN    MAYILADUTHURAI        Manian O.S    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Mani Shankar Aiyar    Indian National Congress    36854    NO
29    TN    NAGAPATTINAM         Vijayan A K S    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Selvaraj M    Communist Party of India    30273    NO
30    TN    THANJAVUR        Palanimanickam.S.S    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Durai.Balakrishnan    Marumalarchi Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    101124    NO
31    TN    SIVAGANGA        Raja Kannappan R.S.    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Chidambaram P    Indian National Congress    490    NO
32    TN    MADURAI        Alagiri M.K    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Mohan P    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    140985    NO
33    TN    THENI         Aaron Rashid.J.M    Indian National Congress    Thanga Tamilselvan    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    5503    NO
34    TN    VIRUDHUNAGAR        Manicka Tagore    Indian National Congress    Vaiko    Marumalarchi Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    15764    NO
35    TN    RAMANATHAPURAM        Sivakumar @ J.K. Ritheesh. K    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Sathiamoorthy. V    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    56352    NO
36    TN    THOOTHUKKUDI        Jeyadurai.S.R    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Cynthia Pandian.Dr    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    76671    NO
37    TN    TENKASI         Lingam P    Communist Party of India    Vellaipandi G    Indian National Congress    34677    NO
38    TN    TIRUNELVELI        Ramasubbu S    Indian National Congress    Annamalai K    All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    20948    NO
39    TN    KANNIYAKUMARI        Helen Davidson J    Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam    Radhakrishnan P    Bharatiya Janata Party    63826    NO
1    TR    TRIPURA WEST        Khagen Das    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Sudip Roy Barman    Indian National Congress    241235    NO
2    TR    TRIPURA EAST        Baju Ban Riyan    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Diba Chandra Hrangkhawl    Indian National Congress    291209    NO
1    UP    SAHARANPUR        Jagdish Singh Rana    Bahujan Samaj Party    Rasheed Masood    Samajwadi Party    36681    NO
2    UP    KAIRANA        Tabassum Begum    Bahujan Samaj Party    Hukum Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    14047    NO
3    UP    MUZAFFARNAGAR        Kadir Rana    Bahujan Samaj Party    Anuradha Chaudhary    Rashtriya Lok Dal    21002    NO
4    UP    BIJNOR        Sanjay Singh Chauhan    Rashtriya Lok Dal    Shahid Siddiqui    Bahujan Samaj Party    10372    NO
5    UP    NAGINA        Yashvir Singh    Samajwadi Party    Ram Kishan Singh    Bahujan Samaj Party    11920    NO
6    UP    MORADABAD        Mohammed Azharuddin    Indian National Congress    Kunwar Sarvesh Kumar Alias Rakesh    Bharatiya Janata Party    24445    NO
7    UP    RAMPUR        Jaya Prada Nahata    Samajwadi Party    Begum Noor Bano Urf Mehtab Zamani Begum    Indian National Congress    12093    NO
8    UP    SAMBHAL        Dr. Shafiqur Rahman Barq    Bahujan Samaj Party    Iqbal Mehmood    Samajwadi Party    19762    NO
9    UP    AMROHA        Devendra Nagpal    Rashtriya Lok Dal    Mehboob Ali    Samajwadi Party    39398    NO
10    UP    MEERUT        Rajendra Agarwal    Bharatiya Janata Party    Malook Nagar    Bahujan Samaj Party    3674    NO
11    UP    BAGHPAT        Ajit Singh    Rashtriya Lok Dal    Mukesh Sharma    Bahujan Samaj Party    63382    NO
12    UP    GHAZIABAD        Rajnath Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Surendra Prakash Goel    Indian National Congress    43627    NO
13    UP    GAUTAM BUDDH NAGAR        Surendra Singh Nagar    Bahujan Samaj Party    Mahesh Kumar Sharma    Bharatiya Janata Party    26730    NO
14    UP    BULANDSHAHR        Kamlesh    Samajwadi Party    Ashok Kumar Pradhan    Bharatiya Janata Party    14776    NO
15    UP    ALIGARH        Zafar Alam    Samajwadi Party    Raj Kumari Chauhan    Bahujan Samaj Party    12277    NO
16    UP    HATHRAS        Sarika Singh    Rashtriya Lok Dal    Rajendra Kumar    Bahujan Samaj Party    20754    NO
17    UP    MATHURA        Jayant Chaudhary    Rashtriya Lok Dal    Shyam Sunder Sharma    Bahujan Samaj Party    35239    NO
18    UP    AGRA        Kunwar Chand (Vakil)    Bahujan Samaj Party    Dr. Ramshankar    Bharatiya Janata Party    3836    NO
19    UP    FATEHPUR SIKRI        Raj Babbar    Indian National Congress    Seema Upadhyay    Bahujan Samaj Party    10025    NO
20    UP    FIROZABAD        Akhilesh Yadav    Samajwadi Party    Prof. S.P. Singh Baghel    Bahujan Samaj Party    52555    NO
21    UP    MAINPURI        Mulayam Singh Yadav    Samajwadi Party    Vinay Shakya    Bahujan Samaj Party    93137    NO
22    UP    ETAH        Kalyan Singh R O Madholi    Independent    Kunwar Devendra Singh Yadav    Bahujan Samaj Party    102812    NO
23    UP    BADAUN        Dharmendra Yadav    Samajwadi Party    Dharam Yadav Urf D. P. Yadav    Bahujan Samaj Party    12579    NO
24    UP    AONLA        Menka Gandhi    Bharatiya Janata Party    Dharmendra Kumar    Samajwadi Party    1217    NO
25    UP    BAREILLY        Praveen Singh Aron    Indian National Congress    Santosh Gangwar    Bharatiya Janata Party    9439    NO
26    UP    PILIBHIT        Feroze Varun Gandhi    Bharatiya Janata Party    V. M. Singh    Indian National Congress    224196    NO
27    UP    SHAHJAHANPUR        Mithlesh    Samajwadi Party    Sunita Singh    Bahujan Samaj Party    43831    NO
28    UP    KHERI        Zafar Ali Naqvi    Indian National Congress    Ajay Kumar    Bharatiya Janata Party    16020    NO
29    UP    DHAURAHRA        Kunwar Jitin Prasad    Indian National Congress    Rajesh Kumar Singh Alias Rajesh Verma    Bahujan Samaj Party    96823    NO
30    UP    SITAPUR        Kaisar Jahan    Bahujan Samaj Party    Mahendra Singh Verma    Samajwadi Party    19638    NO
31    UP    HARDOI        Usha Verma    Samajwadi Party    Ram Kumar Kuril    Bahujan Samaj Party    87402    NO
32    UP    MISRIKH        Ashok Kumar Rawat    Bahujan Samaj Party    Shyam Prakash    Samajwadi Party    22999    NO
33    UP    UNNAO        Annutandon    Indian National Congress    Arunshankarshukla    Bahujan Samaj Party    195269    NO
34    UP    MOHANLALGANJ        Sushila Saroj    Samajwadi Party    Jai Prakash    Bahujan Samaj Party    66348    NO
35    UP    LUCKNOW        Lal Ji Tandon    Bharatiya Janata Party    Rita Bahuguna Joshi    Indian National Congress    31090    NO
36    UP    RAE BARELI        Sonia Gandhi    Indian National Congress    R.S.Kushwaha    Bahujan Samaj Party    276054    NO
37    UP    AMETHI        Rahul Gandhi    Indian National Congress    Asheesh Shukla    Bahujan Samaj Party    157511    NO
38    UP    SULTANPUR        Dr.Sanjay Singh    Indian National Congress    Mohd.Tahir    Bahujan Samaj Party    69185    NO
39    UP    PRATAPGARH        Rajkumari Ratna Singh    Indian National Congress    Prof. Shivakant Ojha    Bahujan Samaj Party    6346    NO
40    UP    FARRUKHABAD        Naresh Chandra Agrawal    Bahujan Samaj Party    Salman Khursheed    Indian National Congress    5472    NO
41    UP    ETAWAH        Premdas    Samajwadi Party    Gaurishanker    Bahujan Samaj Party    43513    NO
42    UP    KANNAUJ        Akhilesh Yadav    Samajwadi Party    Dr. Mahesh Chandra Verma    Bahujan Samaj Party    110828    NO
43    UP    KANPUR        Sri Prakash Jaiswal    Indian National Congress    Satish Mahana    Bharatiya Janata Party    14161    NO
44    UP    AKBARPUR        Rajaram Pal    Indian National Congress    Anil Shukla Warsi    Bahujan Samaj Party    30075    NO
45    UP    JALAUN        Ghansyam Anuragi    Samajwadi Party    Tilak Chandra Ahirwar    Bahujan Samaj Party    7332    NO
46    UP    JHANSI        Pradeep Kumar Jain (Aditya)    Indian National Congress    Ramesh Kumar Sharma    Bahujan Samaj Party    7228    NO
47    UP    HAMIRPUR        Vijay Bahadur Singh    Bahujan Samaj Party    Siddha Gopal Sahu    Indian National Congress    13663    NO
48    UP    BANDA        R. K. Singh Patel    Samajwadi Party    Bhairon Prasad Mishra    Bahujan Samaj Party    26245    NO
49    UP    FATEHPUR         Rakesh Sachan    Samajwadi Party    Mahendra Prasad Nishad    Bahujan Samaj Party    22816    NO
50    UP    KAUSHAMBI        Shailendra Kumar    Samajwadi Party    Girish Chandra Pasi    Bahujan Samaj Party    16569    NO
51    UP    PHULPUR        Kapil Muni Karwariya    Bahujan Samaj Party    Shyama Charan Gupta    Samajwadi Party    13881    NO
52    UP    ALLAHABAD        Kunwar Rewati Raman Singh Alias Mani Ji    Samajwadi Party    Ashok Kumar Bajpai    Bahujan Samaj Party    17435    NO
53    UP    BARABANKI        P.L.Punia    Indian National Congress    Kamala Prasad Rawat    Bahujan Samaj Party    147335    NO
54    UP    FAIZABAD        Nirmal Khatri    Indian National Congress    Mitrasen    Samajwadi Party    41691    NO
55    UP    AMBEDKAR NAGAR        Rakesh Pandey    Bahujan Samaj Party    Shankhlal Majhi    Samajwadi Party    8227    NO
56    UP    BAHRAICH        Kamal Kishor    Indian National Congress    Lal Mani Prasad    Bahujan Samaj Party    41205    NO
57    UP    KAISERGANJ        Brijbhushan Sharan Singh    Samajwadi Party    Dr Lalta Prasad Mishra Alias Dr L P Mishra    Bharatiya Janata Party    27873    NO
58    UP    SHRAWASTI        Vinay Kumar Alias Vinnu    Indian National Congress    Rizvan Zaheer    Bahujan Samaj Party    38796    NO
59    UP    GONDA        Beni Prasad Verma    Indian National Congress    Kirti Vardhan Singh (Raja Bhaiya)    Bahujan Samaj Party    22898    NO
60    UP    DOMARIYAGANJ        Jagdambika Pal    Indian National Congress    Jai Pratap Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    21356    NO
61    UP    BASTI        Arvind Kumar Chaudhary    Bahujan Samaj Party    Raj Kishor Singh    Samajwadi Party    77981    NO
62    UP    SANT KABIR NAGAR        Bhisma Shankar Alias Kushal Tiwari    Bahujan Samaj Party    Bhal Chandra Yadav    Samajwadi Party    17218    NO
63    UP    MAHARAJGANJ        Harsh Vardhan    Indian National Congress    Ganesh Shanker Pandey    Bahujan Samaj Party    52122    NO
64    UP    GORAKHPUR        Adityanath    Bharatiya Janata Party    Vinay Shankar Tiwari    Bahujan Samaj Party    70171    NO
65    UP    KUSHI NAGAR        Ku. Ratanjeet Pratap Narayan Singh    Indian National Congress    Swami Prasad Maurya    Bahujan Samaj Party    10593    NO
66    UP    DEORIA        Gorakh Prasad Jaiswal    Bahujan Samaj Party    Shri Prakash Mani Tripathi    Bharatiya Janata Party    16718    NO
67    UP    BANSGAON        Kamlesh Paswan    Bharatiya Janata Party    Shree Nath Ji    Bahujan Samaj Party    22382    NO
68    UP    LALGANJ        Dr. Baliram    Bahujan Samaj Party    Neelam Sonkar    Bharatiya Janata Party    38531    NO
69    UP    AZAMGARH        Ramakant Yadav    Bharatiya Janata Party    Akbar Ahmad Dumpy    Bahujan Samaj Party    36914    NO
70    UP    GHOSI        Dara Singh Chauhan    Bahujan Samaj Party    Arshad Jamal Ansari    Samajwadi Party    17965    NO
71    UP    SALEMPUR        Ramashankar Rajbhar    Bahujan Samaj Party    Dr. Bhola Pandey    Indian National Congress    4923    NO
72    UP    BALLIA        Neeraj Shekhar    Samajwadi Party    Sangram Singh Yadav    Bahujan Samaj Party    41103    NO
73    UP    JAUNPUR        Dhananjay Singh    Bahujan Samaj Party    Paras Nath Yadava    Samajwadi Party    53859    NO
74    UP    MACHHLISHAHR        Tufani Saroj    Samajwadi Party    Kamla Kant Gautam (K.K. Gautam)    Bahujan Samaj Party    19050    NO
75    UP    GHAZIPUR        Radhey Mohan Singh    Samajwadi Party    Afzal Ansari    Bahujan Samaj Party    50237    NO
76    UP    CHANDAULI        Ramkishun    Samajwadi Party    Kailash Nath Singh Yadav    Bahujan Samaj Party    10919    NO
77    UP    VARANASI        Dr. Murli Manohar Joshi    Bharatiya Janata Party    Mukhtar Ansari    Bahujan Samaj Party    5750    NO
78    UP    BHADOHI        Gorakhnath    Bahujan Samaj Party    Chhotelal Bind    Samajwadi Party    12980    NO
79    UP    MIRZAPUR        Bal Kumar Patel    Samajwadi Party    Anil Kumar Maurya    Bahujan Samaj Party    8519    NO
80    UP    ROBERTSGANJ        Pakauri Lal    Samajwadi Party    Ram Chandra Tyagi    Bahujan Samaj Party    46930    NO
1    WB    COOCH BEHAR        Nripendra Nath Roy    All India Forward Bloc    Arghya Roy Pradhan    All India Trinamool Congress    37085    NO
2    WB    ALIPURDUARS        Manohar Tirkey    Revolutionary Socialist Party    Paban Kumar Lakra    All India Trinamool Congress    112516    NO
3    WB    JALPAIGURI        Mahendra Kumar Roy    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Barma Sukhbilas    Indian National Congress    67529    NO
4    WB    DARJEELING        Jaswant Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Jibesh Sarkar    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    271267    NO
5    WB    RAIGANJ        Deepa Dasmunsi    Indian National Congress    Bireswar Lahiri    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    68682    NO
6    WB    BALURGHAT        Prasanta Kumar Majumdar    Revolutionary Socialist Party    Biplab Mitra    All India Trinamool Congress    1610    NO
7    WB    MALDAHA UTTAR        Mausam Noor    Indian National Congress    Sailen Sarkar    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    18758    NO
8    WB    MALDAHA DAKSHIN        Abu Hasem Khan Choudhury    Indian National Congress    Abdur Razzaque    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    126935    NO
9    WB    JANGIPUR        Pranab Mukherjee    Indian National Congress    Mriganka Sekhar Bhattacharya    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    61761    NO
10    WB    BAHARAMPUR        Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury    Indian National Congress    Pramothes Mukherjee    Revolutionary Socialist Party    68254    NO
11    WB    MURSHIDABAD        Abdul Mannan Hossain    Indian National Congress    Anisur Rahaman Sarkar    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    11288    NO
12    WB    KRISHNANAGAR        Tapas Paul    All India Trinamool Congress    Jyotirmoyee Sikdar    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    50892    NO
13    WB    RANAGHAT        Sucharu Ranjan Haldar    All India Trinamool Congress    Basudeb Barman    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    48444    NO
14    WB    BANGAON        Gobinda Chandra Naskar    All India Trinamool Congress    Asim Bala    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    15248    NO
15    WB    BARRACKPORE        Dinesh Trivedi    All India Trinamool Congress    Tarit Baran Topdar    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    36729    NO
16    WB    DUM DUM        Saugata Ray    All India Trinamool Congress    Amitava Nandy    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    3651    NO
17    WB    BARASAT        Kakali Ghosh Dastidar    All India Trinamool Congress    Sudin Chattopadhyay    All India Forward Bloc    29999    NO
18    WB    BASIRHAT        Sk. Nurul Islam    All India Trinamool Congress    Ajay Chakraborty    Communist Party of India    4259    NO
19    WB    JOYNAGAR        Dr. Tarun Mondal    Independent    Nimai Barman    Revolutionary Socialist Party    41657    NO
20    WB    MATHURAPUR        Choudhury Mohan Jatua    All India Trinamool Congress    Animesh Naskar    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    6717    NO
21    WB    DIAMOND HARBOUR        Somendra Nath Mitra    All India Trinamool Congress    Samik Lahiri    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    69116    NO
22    WB    JADAVPUR        Kabir Suman    All India Trinamool Congress    Sujan Chakraborty    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    24147    NO
23    WB    KOLKATA DAKSHIN        Mamata Banerjee    All India Trinamool Congress    Rabin Deb    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    137046    NO
24    WB    KOLKATA UTTAR        Sudip Bandyopadhyay    All India Trinamool Congress    Md. Salim    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    64971    NO
25    WB    HOWRAH        Ambica Banerjee    All India Trinamool Congress    Swadesh Chakrabortty    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    10672    NO
26    WB    ULUBERIA        Sultan Ahmed    All India Trinamool Congress    Hannan Mollah    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    53703    NO
27    WB    SRERAMPUR        Kalyan Banerjee    All India Trinamool Congress    Santasri Chatterjee    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    92670    NO
28    WB    HOOGHLY        Dr. Ratna De(Nag)    All India Trinamool Congress    Rupchand Pal    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    56711    NO
29    WB    ARAMBAGH        Malik Sakti Mohan    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Sambhu Nath Malik    Indian National Congress    144361    NO
30    WB    TAMLUK        Adhikari Suvendu    All India Trinamool Congress    Lakshman Chandra Seth    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    16735    NO
31    WB    KANTHI        Adhikari Sisir Kumar    All India Trinamool Congress    Prasanta Pradhan    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    36085    NO
32    WB    GHATAL        Gurudas Dasgupta    Communist Party of India    Nure Alam Chowdhury    All India Trinamool Congress    62938    NO
33    WB    JHARGRAM        Pulin Bihari Baske    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Amrit Hansda    Indian National Congress    109497    NO
34    WB    MEDINIPUR        Prabodh Panda    Communist Party of India    Dipak Kumar Ghosh    All India Trinamool Congress    32890    NO
35    WB    PURULIA        Narahari Mahato    All India Forward Bloc    Shantiram Mahato    Indian National Congress    5978    NO
36    WB    BANKURA        Acharia Basudeb    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Subrata Mukherjee    Indian National Congress    44697    NO
37    WB    BISHNUPUR        Susmita Bauri    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Seuli Saha    All India Trinamool Congress    54371    NO
38    WB    BARDHAMAN PURBA        Anup Kumar Saha    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Ashoke Biswas    All India Trinamool Congress    52048    NO
39    WB    BURDWAN – DURGAPUR        Sk. Saidul Haque    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Nargis Begam    Indian National Congress    79822    NO
40    WB    ASANSOL        Bansa Gopal Chowdhury    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Ghatak Moloy    All India Trinamool Congress    46638    NO
41    WB    BOLPUR        Doctor Ram Chandra Dome    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    Asit Kumar Mal    Indian National Congress    76596    NO
42    WB    BIRBHUM        Satabdi Roy    All India Trinamool Congress    Braja Mukherjee    Communist Party of India (Marxist)    15936    NO
1    CG    SARGUJA        Murarilal Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    Bhanu Pratap Singh    Indian National Congress    113866    NO
2    CG    RAIGARH        Vishnu Deo Sai    Bharatiya Janata Party    Hridayaram Rathiya    Indian National Congress    41920    NO
3    CG    JANJGIR-CHAMPA        Shrimati Kamla Devi Patle    Bharatiya Janata Party    Dr.Shivkumar Dahariya    Indian National Congress    35284    NO
4    CG    KORBA        Charan Das Mahant    Indian National Congress    Karuna Shukla    Bharatiya Janata Party    10348    NO
5    CG    BILASPUR        Dilip Singh Judev    Bharatiya Janata Party    Dr.Renu Jogi    Indian National Congress    18186    NO
6    CG    RAJNANDGAON        Madhusudan Yadav    Bharatiya Janata Party    Devwrat Singh    Indian National Congress    91638    NO
7    CG    DURG        Saroj Pandey    Bharatiya Janata Party    Pradeep Choubey    Indian National Congress    3397    NO
8    CG    RAIPUR        Ramesh Bais    Bharatiya Janata Party    Bhupesh Baghel    Indian National Congress    28680    NO
9    CG    MAHASAMUND        Chandulal Sahu (Chandu Bhaiya)    Bharatiya Janata Party    Motilal Sahu    Indian National Congress    12100    NO
10    CG    BASTAR        Baliram Kashyap    Bharatiya Janata Party    Shankar Sodi    Indian National Congress    63828    NO
11    CG    KANKER        Sohan Potai    Bharatiya Janata Party    Smt. Phoolo Devi Netam    Indian National Congress    18247    NO
1    JH    RAJMAHAL        Devidhan Besra    Bharatiya Janata Party    Hemlal Murmu    Jharkhand Mukti Morcha    3694    NO
2    JH    DUMKA        Shibu Soren    Jharkhand Mukti Morcha    Sunil Soren    Bharatiya Janata Party    8319    NO
3    JH    GODDA        Nishikant Dubey    Bharatiya Janata Party    Furkan Ansari    Indian National Congress    18747    NO
4    JH    CHATRA        Inder Singh Namdhari    Independent    Dhiraj Prasad Sahu    Indian National Congress    16178    NO
5    JH    KODARMA        Babulal Marandi    Jharkhand Vikas Morcha (Prajatantrik)    Raj Kumar Yadav    Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist) (Liberation)    38742    NO
6    JH    GIRIDIH        Ravindra Kumar Pandey    Bharatiya Janata Party    Saba Ahmad    Jharkhand Vikas Morcha (Prajatantrik)    61580    NO
7    JH    DHANBAD        Chandrashekhar Dubey    Indian National Congress    Pashupati Nath Singh    Bharatiya Janata Party    4456    NO
8    JH    RANCHI        Ram Tahal Choudhary    Bharatiya Janata Party    Subodh Kant Sahay    Indian National Congress    9420    NO
9    JH    JAMSHEDPUR        Arjun Munda    Bharatiya Janata Party    Suman Mahato    Jharkhand Mukti Morcha    57892    NO
10    JH    SINGHBHUM        Madhu Kora    Independent    Barkuwar Gagrai    Bharatiya Janata Party    84088    NO
11    JH    KHUNTI        Karia Munda    Bharatiya Janata Party    Neil Tirkey    Indian National Congress    29812    NO
12    JH    LOHARDAGA        Chamra Linda    Independent    Sudarshan Bhagat    Bharatiya Janata Party    2916    NO
13    JH    PALAMAU        Kameshwar Baitha    Jharkhand Mukti Morcha    Ghuran Ram    Rashtriya Janata Dal    4812    NO
14    JH    HAZARIBAGH        Yashwant Sinha    Bharatiya Janata Party    Saurabh Narain Singh    Indian National Congress    9161    NO
1    UK    TEHRI GARHWAL        Vijay Bahuguna    Indian National Congress    Jaspal Rana    Bharatiya Janata Party    45804    NO
2    UK    GARHWAL        Satpal Maharaj    Indian National Congress    Lt. Gen(Retd) Tejpal Singh Rawat P.V.S.M, V.S.M    Bharatiya Janata Party    17257    NO
3    UK    ALMORA        Pradeep Tamta    Indian National Congress    Ajay Tamta    Bharatiya Janata Party    6848    NO
4    UK    NAINITAL-UDHAMSINGH NAGAR        K.C. Singh Baba    Indian National Congress    Bachi Singh Rawat    Bharatiya Janata Party    78365    NO
5    UK    HARDWAR        Harish Rawat    Indian National Congress    Swami Yatindranand Giri    Bharatiya Janata Party    85040    NO
1    AN    ANDAMAN & NICOBAR ISLANDS        Shri. Bishnu Pada Ray    Bharatiya Janata Party    Shri. Kuldeep Rai Sharma    Indian National Congress    3618    NO
1    CH    CHANDIGARH        Pawan Kumar Bansal    Indian National Congress    Satya Pal Jain    Bharatiya Janata Party    58967    YES
1    DN    DADAR & NAGAR HAVELI        Patel Natubhai Gomanbhai    Bharatiya Janata Party    Delkar Mohanbhai Sanjibhai    Indian National Congress    618    YES
1    DD    DAMAN & DIU        Lalubhai Patel    Bharatiya Janata Party    Dahyabhai Vallabhbhai Patel    Indian National Congress    24838    YES
1    DL    CHANDNI CHOWK        Kapil Sibal    Indian National Congress    Vijender Gupta    Bharatiya Janata Party    200710    YES
2    DL    NORTH EAST DELHI        Jai Prakash Agarwal    Indian National Congress    B.L.Sharma Prem    Bharatiya Janata Party    138816    NO
3    DL    EAST DELHI        Sandeep Dikshit    Indian National Congress    Chetan Chauhan    Bharatiya Janata Party    129779    NO
4    DL    NEW DELHI        Ajay Makan    Indian National Congress    Vijay Goel    Bharatiya Janata Party    134979    NO
5    DL    NORTH WEST DELHI        Krishna Tirath    Indian National Congress    Meera Kanwaria    Bharatiya Janata Party    176846    NO
6    DL    WEST DELHI        Mahabal Mishra    Indian National Congress    Prof. Jagdish Mukhi    Bharatiya Janata Party    129010    NO
7    DL    SOUTH DELHI        Ramesh Kumar    Indian National Congress    Ramesh Bidhuri    Bharatiya Janata Party    75232    NO
1    LD    LAKSHADWEEP        Muhammed Hamdulla Sayeed A.B    Indian National Congress    Dr. P. Pookunhikoya    Nationalist Congress Party    2198    YES
1    PY    PUDUCHERRY        Narayanasamy    Indian National Congress    Ramadass. M    Pattali Makkal Katchi    86301    NO

Well done Sonia-Rahul! Two hours before polls close today, I am willing to predict a big victory for you (but, please, try to get your economics right, and also, you must get Dr Singh a Lok Sabha seat if he is to be PM)

It is now coming up to be 3 pm Indian Standard Time on May 13, the last day of India’s 2009 General Elections, and there are two hours left for the polls to close.   I am happy to predict a big victory for the Congress Party, and Sonia Gandhi and her son Rahul will deserve congratulations for it.

How the victory takes shape is, I think, by their having won the median voter on both the economic and the secular-communal axes of Indian politics.  (See my 2008 published graph on the Median Voter Model in Indian politics, available elsewhere here).

I have met Sonia Gandhi once, in December 1991 at her home, where I gave her a tape of her husband’s conversations with me during the first Gulf War in 1991.   Her son and I met momentarily in her husband’s office in 1990-1991 but I do not recall any conversation.   I have had nothing to do with her Government.   Dr Manmohan Singh and I have met twice, once in Paris in the autumn of 1973 and once in Washington in September 1993; on the latter occasion, I was introduced to him and his key aides by Siddhartha Shankar Ray as the person on whose laptop the Congress manifesto of 1991 had been composed for Rajiv, something described elsewhere here.   (I also gave him then a copy of the published book that emerged from the University of  Hawaii perestroika-for-India project, Foundations of India’s Political Economy: Towards an Agenda for the 1990s, edited by myself and WE James.)  On the former occasion,  Dr Singh had kindly acceded to my father’s request to visit our then-home to advise me on economics before I started as a freshman undergraduate at the London School of Economics.

In May 2004 I was interviewed by BBC television in England and I praised the UPA in prospect — in comparison  to the horrors of the Vajpayee-Advani regime (including my personal experience of it, when their Education Minister had sent an astrology-believing acolyte to supposedly run a scientific/technical institute).

Since 2005, especially in the columns of The Statesman, I have dispensed rational criticism of the UPA Government as harshly as I have criticised the BJP/RSS and the Communists.  Principally, I believe they have got  some (perhaps most) much of their  economics (quite badly) wrong as well as their jurisprudence and foreign policy; they have also been willingly under the influence of the powerful organised lobbies and interest groups that populate our capital cities.

Even so, I think there is a large electoral victory in prospect for the Congress, and I send them my early congratulations.  They have done enough by way of political rhetoric and political reality to maintain or enhance their vote-share; their oppositions on either side have both failed badly. The BJP may make some marginal gains especially in Bihar but they have generally done enough to lose the day.  The CPM too will lose popularity especially in Bengal, and will never progress until they fire their JNU economists which they are never going to do.

So, Sonia-Rahul, well done!

But please try to improve your economics.

And, also, you simply must get Dr Manmohan Singh a seat in the Lok Sabha if he is to be PM — Ambedkar and Nehru and all their generation did not specify that India’s PM must be from the Lok Sabha because it was something totally OBVIOUS.

Subroto Roy, Kolkata

Postscript: Someone at a website has referred to my prediction above and remarked: “Perhaps the good doc is aware of the money in play”. The answer is no, I have absolutely no special information about any “money in play” on any side. My prediction is based on a layman’s observation of the campaign, as well as more specialised analysis of past voting data from the EC. In an earlier post, I pointed out the BJP had gotten some 17 million fewer votes than the Congress in 2004, and I asked if they had done enough to get enough of a net change in their favour. The answer I think is that they have not done so. To the contrary, I think there will be a quite large net change in favour of Congress thanks to a better-run and better-led campaign. Of course it is just a prediction that may be found to be incorrect.
SR

India’s 2009 General Elections: 543 Matrices to Help Ordinary Citizens Audit the Election Commission’s Vote-Tallies

I do not know if anyone in India audits or checks the Election Commission’s arithmetic and procedures.   Certainly the EC seems to leave a great deal to be desired by its slowness, its high-handedness and its obscurity/lack of transparency.   I have said previously that this may be a result of obsolescent technology and management and organisation — problems that may be common across many departments of the Government of India and our State Governments.

Here then are the elements of  a tool for use of ordinary citizens which may allow everyone to check the arithmetic involved in the EC’s counting of those hundreds of millions of votes all of us have cast in the 2009 General Elections.

On the vertical axis is supposed to be the list, by Parliamentary Constituency, of all 8,070 candidates who have contested the polls to the 15th Lok Sabha.

On the horizontal axis is supposed to be a series of 543 lists of Assembly Segments for each Constituency.  Please note that the horizontal axis has had to be truncated for lack of space after only ten such segments;  this covers the vast majority of Constituencies but there are a dozen or so in Goa, J&K, Arunachal, Manipur, Mizoram, Nagaland, Tripura which are not complete as they each have many more than 10.

So altogether here are the elements of a series of 543 matrices, one for each Lok Sabha Constituency, which may help ordinary citizens engage in a process of themselves auditing the EC’s declared results.

Or, at the very least, the 543 matrices would act as a score-card, and in this nation of cricket-fans, everyone loves a score-card.

(The text below will have to be adjusted appropriately to get the right format, columns etc.)

Subroto Roy, Kolkata

SIRPUR-1     ASIFABAD-5     KHANAPUR-6     ADILABAD-7     BOATH-8     NIRMAL-9
MUDHOLE-10
S01-1-AP-ADILABAD     1ADE TUKARAM     BJP
2KOTNAK RAMESH     INC
3RATHOD RAMESH     TDP
4RATHOD SADASHIV NAIK     BSP
5MESRAM NAGO RAO     PRAP
6ATHRAM LAXMAN RAO     IND
7GANTA PENTANNA     IND
8NETHAVAT RAMDAS     IND
9BANKA SAHADEVU     IND
CHENNUR-2     BELLAMPALLY-3     MANCHERIAL-4     DHARMAPURI-22     RAMAGUNDAM-23
MANTHANI-24     PEDDAPALLE-25
S01-2-AP-PEDDAPALLE     1GAJJELA SWAMY     BSP
2GOMASA SRINIVAS     TRS
3MATHANGI NARSIAH     BJP
4DRGVIVEKANAND     INC
5AREPELLI DAVID RAJU     PRAP
6KRISHNA SABBALI     MCPI(S)
7AMBALA MAHENDAR     IND
8A KAMALAMMA     IND
9GORRE RAMESH     IND
10NALLALA KANUKAIAH     IND
11B MALLAIAH     IND
12K RAJASWARI     IND
13D RAMULU     IND
14GVINAY KUMAR     IND
15SLAXMAIAH     IND
KARIMNAGAR-26     CHOPPADANDI-27     VEMULAWADA-28     SIRCILLA-29
MANAKONDUR-30     HUZURABAD-31     HUSNABAD-32
S01-3-AP-KARIMNAGAR     1CHANDUPATLA JANGA REDDY     BJP
2PONNAM PRABHAKAR     INC
3VINOD KUMAR BOINAPALLY     TRS
4VIRESHAM NALIMELA     BSP
5RAGULA RAMULU     RPI(A)
6LINGAMPALLI SRINIVAS REDDY     MCPI(S)
7VELICHALA RAJENDER RAO     PRAP
8T SRIMANNARAYANA     PPOI
9K PRABHAKAR     IND
10KORIVI VENUGOPAL     IND
11BARIGE GATTAIAH YADAV     IND
12GADDAM RAJI REDDY     IND
13PANAKANTI SATISH KUMAR     IND
14PEDDI RAVINDER     IND
15B SURESH     IND
ARMUR-11     BODHAN-12     NIZAMABAD (URBAN)-17     NIZAMABAD (RURAL)-18
BALKONDA-19     KORATLA-20     JAGTIAL-21
S01-4-AP-NIZAMABAD     1DR BAPU REDDY     BJP
2BIGALA GANESH GUPTA     TRS
3MADHU YASKHI GOUD     INC
4YEDLA RAMU     BSP
5DUDDEMPUDI SAMBASIVA RAO CHOUDARY     LSP
6PVINAY KUMAR     PRAP
7DR VSATHYANARAYANA MURTHY     PPOI
8S SUJATHA     TPPP
9AARIS MOHAMMED     IND
10KANDEM PRABHAKAR     IND
11GADDAM SRINIVAS     IND
12RAPELLY SRINIVAS     IND
JUKKAL-13     BANSWADA-14     YELLAREDDY-15     KAMAREDDY-16     NARAYANKHED-35
ANDOLE-36     ZAHIRABAD-38
S01-5-AP-ZAHIRABAD     1CHENGAL BAGANNA     BJP
2MVISHNU MUDIRAJ     BSP
3SYED YOUSUF ALI     TRS
4SURESH KUMAR SHETKAR     INC
5BENJAMIN RAJU     IJP
6MALKAPURAM SHIVA KUMAR     PRAP
7MALLESH RAVINDER REDDY     LSP
8CHITTA RAJESHWAR RAO     IND
9POWAR SINGH HATTI SINGH     IND
10BASAVA RAJ PATIL     IND
SIDDIPET-33     MEDAK-34     NARSAPUR-37     SANGAREDDY-39     PATANCHERU-40
DUBBAK-41     GAJWEL-42
S01-6-AP-MEDAK     1NARENDRANATH C     INC
2P NIROOP REDDY     BJP
3VIJAYA SHANTHI M     TRS
4Y SHANKAR GOUD     BSP
5KOVURI PRABHAKAR     PPOI
6KHAJA QUAYUM ANWAR     PRAP
7D YADESHWAR     BSP(AP)
8K SUDHEER REDDY     LSP
9KUNDETI RAVI     IND
MEDCHAL-43     MALKAJGIRI-44     QUTHBULLAPUR-45     KUKATPALLY-46     UPPAL-47
LAL BAHADUR NAGAR-49     SECUNDERABAD CANTT.-71
S01-7-AP-MALKAJGIRI     1NALLU INDRASENA REDDY     BJP
2MBABU RAO PADMA SALE     BSP
3BHEEMSENT     TDP
4SARVEY SATYANARAYANA     INC
5SDKRISHNA MURTHY     TPPP
6TDEVENDER GOUD     PRAP
7NARENDER KUMBALA     BPD
8PRATHANI RAMAKRISHNA     RKSP
9LION C FRANCIS MJF     SP
10N V RAMA REDDY     PPOI
11DRLAVU RATHAIAH     LSP
12KANTE KANAKAIAH GANGAPUTHRA     IND
13KOYAL KAR BHOJARAJ     IND
14CHENURU VENKATA SUBBA RAO     IND
15JAJULA BHASKAR     IND
16LTCOL RETD DUSERLA PAPARAIDU     IND
17MDMANSOORALI     IND
18SVICTOR     IND
19KSRINIVASA RAJU     IND
MUSHEERABAD-57     AMBERPET-59     KHAIRATABAD-60     JUBILEE HILLS-61     SANATH
NAGAR-62     NAMPALLI-63     SECUNDRABAD-70
S01-8-AP-SECUNDRABAD     1ANJAN KUMAR YADAV M     INC
2BANDARU DATTATREYA     BJP
3M D MAHMOOD ALI     TRS
4M VENKATESH     BSP
5SRINIVASA SUDHISH RAMBHOTLA     TDP
6ABDUS SATTAR MUJAHED     MUL
7IMDAD JAH     ANC
8P DAMODER REDDY     PPOI
9DR DASOJU SRAVAN KUMAR     PRAP
10S DEVAIAH     TPPP
11CVL NARASIMHA RAO     LSP
12DR POLISHETTY RAM MOHAN     SAP
13MOHD OSMAN QURESHEE     AJBP
14SHIRAZ KHAN     UWF
15ASEERVADAM LELLAPALLI     IND
16AMBATI KRISHNA MURTHY     IND
17B GOPALA KRISHNA     IND
18DEVI DAS RAO GHODKE     IND
19BABER ALI KHAN     IND
20M BHAGYA MATHA     IND
21CH MURAHARI     IND
22G RAJAIAH     IND
23K SRINIVASA CHARI     IND
MALAKPET-58     KARWAN-64     GOSHAMAHAL-65     CHARMINAR-66
CHANDRAYANGUTTA-67     YAKUTPURA-68     BAHDURPURA-69
S01-9-AP-HYDERABAD     1ZAHID ALI KHAN     TDP
2P LAXMAN RAO GOUD     INC
3SATISH AGARWAL     BJP
4SAMY MOHAMMED     BSP
5ASADUDDIN OWAISI     AIMIM
6S GOPAL SINGH     ABJS
7TAHER KAMAL KHUNDMIRI     JD(S)
8FATIMA A     PRAP
9P VENKATESWARA RAO     PPOI
10D SURENDER     TPPP
11ALKASARY MOULLIM MOHSIN HUSSAIN     IND
12ALTAF AHMED KHAN     IND
13MA QUDDUS GHORI     IND
14ZAHID ALI KHAN     IND
15MA BASITH     IND
16MD OSMAN     IND
17B RAVI YADAV     IND
18NL SRINIVAS     IND
19MA SATTAR     IND
20D SADANAND     IND
21SYED ABDUL GAFFTER     IND
22SARDAR SINGH     IND
23MA HABEEB     IND
MAHESHWARAM-50     RAJENDRANAGAR-51     SERILINGAMPALLY-52     CHEVELLA-53
PARGI-54     VICARADAB-55     TANDUR-56
S01-10-AP-CHELVELLA     1JAIPAL REDDY SUDINI     INC
2APJITHENDER REDDY     TDP
3BADDAM BAL REDDY     BJP
4CSRINIVAS RAO     BSP
5KASANI GNANESHWAR     MANP
6KUMMARI GIRI     PPOI
7DASARA SARALA DEVI     MCPI(S)
8DRBRAGHUVEER REDDY     LSP
9SAMA SRINIVASULU     GRIP
10SMALLA REDDY     IND
11GMALLESHAM GOUD     IND
12RAMESHWARAM JANGAIAH     IND
13LAXMINARAYANA     IND
14VENKATRAM NAIK     IND
15SAYAMOOLA NARSIMULU     IND
KODANGAL-72     NARAYANPET-73     MAHBUBNAGAR-74     JADCHERLA-75
DEVARKADRA-76     MAKTHAL-77     SHADNAGAR-84
S01-11-AP-MAHBUBNAGAR     1KUCHAKULLA YADAGIRI REDDY     BJP
2K CHANDRASEKHAR RAO     TRS
3DEVARAKONDA VITTAL RAO     INC
4PALEM SUDARSHAN GOUD     BSP
5ABDUL KAREEM KHAJA MOHAMMAD     LSP
6ASIRVADAM     GRIP
7KOLLA VENKATESH MADIGA     TPPP
8GUNDALA VIJAYALAKSHMI     PPOI
9B BALRAJ GOUD     MANP
10MUNISWAMYCR     SJP(R)
11USHAN SATHYAMMA     IND
12USAIN RANGAMMA     IND
13YETTI CHINNA YENKAIAH     IND
14YETTI LINGAIAH     IND
15KANDUR KURMAIAH     IND
16KARRE JANGAIAH     IND
17GANGAPURI RAVINDAR GOUD     IND
18GAJJA NARSIMULU     IND
19CHENNAMSETTY DASHARATHA RAMULU HOLEA DASARI     IND
20MA JABBAR     IND
21DEPALLY MAISAIAH     IND
22DEPALLY SAYANNA     IND
23K NARSIMULU     IND
24NAGENDER REDDY K     IND
25PANDU     IND
26BUDIGA JANGAM LAXMAMMA     IND
27MOHAMMAD GHOUSE MOINUDDIN     IND
28MALA JANGILAMMA     IND
29RAJESH NAIK     IND
30RAIKANTI RAMADAS MADIGA     IND
31V VENKATESHWARLU     IND
32B SEENAIAH GOUD     IND
WANAPARTHY-78     GADWAL-79     ALAMPUR-80     NAGARKURNOOL-81     ACHAMPET-82
KALWAKURTHY-83     KOLLAPUR-85
S01-12-AP-NAGARKURNOOL     1GUVVALA BALARAJU     TRS
2TANGIRALA PARAMJOTHI     BSP
3DR MANDA JAGANNATH     INC
4DR T RATNAKARA     BJP
5DEVANI SATYANARAYANA     PRAP
6SPFERRY ROY     PPOI
7G VIDYASAGAR     LSP
8ANAPOSALA VENKATESH     IND
9N KURUMAIAH     IND
10BUDDULA SRINIVAS     IND
11AV SHIVA KUMAR     IND
12SIRIGIRI MANNEM     IND
13HANUMANTHU     IND
DEVARAKONDA-86     NAGARJUNA SAGAR-87     MIRYALGUDA-88     HUZURNAGAR-89
KODAD-90     SURYAPET-91     NALGONDA-92
S01-13-AP-NALGONDA     1GUTHA SUKENDER REDDY     INC
2NAZEERUDDIN     BSP
3VEDIRE SRIRAM REDDY     BJP
4SURAVARAM SUDHAKAR REDDY     CPI
5A NAGESHWAR RAO     PPOI
6PADURI KARUNA     PRAP
7DAIDA LINGAIAH     IND
8MD NAZEEMUDDIN     IND
9BOLUSANI KRISHNAIAH     IND
10BOLLA KARUNAKAR     IND
11MARRY NEHEMIAH     IND
12YALAGANDULA RAMU     IND
13KVSRINIVASA CHARYULU     IND
14SHAIK AHMED     IND
IBRAHIMPATNAM-48     MUNUGODE-93     BHONGIR-94     NAKREKAL-95
THUNGATHURTHY-96     ALAIR-97     JANGOAN-98
S01-14-AP-BHONGIR     1KOMATIREDDY RAJ GOPAL REDDY     INC
2CHINTHA SAMBA MURTHY     BJP
3NOMULA NARSIMHAIAH     CPM
4SIDDHARTHA PHOOLEY     BSP
5CHANDRA MOULI GANDAM     PRAP
6PALLA PRABHAKAR REDDY     PPOI
7RACHA SUBHADRA REDDY     LSP
8GUMMI BAKKA REDDY     IND
9POOSA BALA KISHAN BESTA     IND
10PERUKA ANJAIAH     IND
11MAMIDIGALLA JOHN BABU     IND
12MEDI NARSIMHA     IND
13RUPANI RAMESH VADDERA     IND
14SANGU MALLAYYA     IND
15SIRUPANGI RAMULU     IND
GHANPUR (STATION)-99     PALAKURTHI-100     PARKAL-104     WARANGAL WEST-105
WARANGAL EAST-106     WARDHANAPET-107     BHUPALPALLE-108
S01-15-AP-WARANGAL     1JAYAPAL V     BJP
2DOMMATI SAMBAIAH     TDP
3RAJAIAH SIRICILLA     INC
4RAMAGALLA PARAMESHWAR     TRS
5LALAIAH P     BSP
6ONTELA MONDAIAH     PPOI
7DR CHANDRAGIRI RAJAMOULY     PRAP
8BALLEPU VENKAT NARSINGA RAO     LSP
9KANNAM VENKANNA     IND
10KRISHNADHI SRILATHA     IND
11SOMAIAH GANAPURAM     IND
12DAMERA MOGILI     IND
13DUBASI NARSING     IND
14PAKALA DEVADANAM     IND
15D SREEDHAR RAO     IND
DORNAKAL-101     MAHABUBABAD-102     NARSAMPET-103     MULUG-109
PINAPAKA-110     YELLANDU-111     BHADRACHELAM-119
S01-16-AP-MAHABUBABAD     1KUNJA SRINIVASA RAO     CPI
2GUMMADI PULLAIAH     BSP
3B DILIP         BJP
4P BALRAM     INC
5DT NAIK     PRAP
6PODEM SAMMAIAH     PPOI
7BANOTH MOLCHAND     LSP
8KALTHI VEERASWAMY     IND
9KECHELA RANGA REDDY     IND
10DATLA NAGESWAR RAO     IND
11PADIGA YERRAIAH     IND
12P SATYANARAYANA     IND
KHAMMAM-112     PALAIR-113     MADIRA-114     WYRA-115     SATHUPALLI-116
KOTHAGUDEM-117     ASWARAOPETA-118
S01-17-AP-KHAMMAM     1KAPILAVAI RAVINDER     BJP
2THONDAPU VENKATESWARA RAO     BSP
3NAMA NAGESWARA RAO     TDP
4RENUKA CHOWDHURY     INC
5JALAGAM HEMAMALINI     PRAP
6JUPELLI SATYANARAYANA     LSP
7MANUKONDA RAGHURAM PRASAD     PPOI
8SHAIK MADAR SAHEB     TPPP
9AVULA VENKATESWARLU     IND
10CHANDA LINGAIAH     IND
11DANDA LINGAIAH     IND
12BANOTH LAXMA NAIK     IND
13MALLAVARAPU JEREMIAH     IND
PALAKONDA-129     KURUPAM-130     PARVATHIPURAM-131     SALUR-132     ARAKU
VALLEY-147     PADERU-148     RAMPACHODAVARAM-172
S01-18-AP-ARUKU     1KISHORE CHANDRA SURYANARAYANA DEO VYRICHERLA     INC
2KURUSA BOJJAIAH     BJP
3GADUGU BALLAYYA DORA     RJD
4MIDIYAM BABU RAO     CPM
5LAKE RAJA RAO     BSP
6MEENAKA SIMHACHALAM     PRAP
7VADIGALA PENTAYYA     LSP
8APPA RAO KINJEDI     IND
9ARIKA GUMPA SWAMY     IND
10ILLA RAMI REDDY     IND
11JAYALAKSHMI SHAMBUDU     IND
ICHCHAPURAM-120     PALASA-121     TEKKALI-122     PATHAPATNAM-123
SRIKAKULAM-124     AMADALAVALASA-125     NARASANNAPETA-127
S01-19-AP-SRIKAKULAM     1YERRNNAIDU KINJARAPU     TDP
2KILLI KRUPA RANI     INC
3TANKALA SUDHAKARA RAO     BSP
4DUPPALA RAVINDARA BABU     BJP
5KALYANI VARUDU     PRAP
6NANDA PRASADA RAO     PPOI
ETCHERLA-126     RAJAM-128     BOBBILI-133     CHEEPURUPALLE-134
GAJAPATHINAGARAM-135     NELLIMARLA-136     VIZIANAGARAM-137
S01-20-AP-VIZIANAGARAM     1APPALA NAIDU KONDAPALLI     TDP
2GOTTAPU CHINAMNAIDU     BSP
3JHANSI LAXMI BOTCHA     INC
4SANYASI RAJU PAKALAPATI     BJP
5KIMIDI GANAPATHI RAO     PRAP
6LUNKARAN JAIN     PPOI
7DATTLA SATYA APPALA SIVANANDA RAJU     LSP
8VENKATA SATYA NARAYANA RAGHUMANDA     BSSP
9MAHESWARA RAO VARRI     IND
SRUNGAVARAPUKOTA-138     BHIMLI-139     VISAKHAPATNAM EAST-140
VISAKHAPATNAM SOUTH-141     VISAKHAPATNAM NORTH-142     VISAKHAPATNAM
WEST-143     GAJUWAKA-144
S01-21-AP-VISAKHAPATNAM     1IMAHMED     BSP
2DAGGUBATI PURANDESWARI     INC
3DRMVVSMURTHI     TDP
4DVSUBBARAO     BJP
5PALLA SRINIVASA RAO     PRAP
6BETHALA KEGIYA RANI     BSP(AP)
7DBHARATHI     PPOI
8DVRAMANA VASU MASTER     TPPP
9RAMESH LANKA     BHSASP
10MTVENKATESWARALU     LSP
11APPARAO GOLAGANA     IND
12BANDAM VENKATA RAO YADAV     IND
13YADDANAPUDI RANGARAO     IND
14YALAMANCHILI PRASAD     IND
15RANGARAJU KALIDINDI     IND
CHODAVARAM-145     MADUGULA-146     ANAKAPALLE-149     PENDURTHI-150
ELAMANCHILI-151     PAYAKARAOPET-152     NARSIPATNAM-153
S01-22-AP-ANAKAPALLI     1APPA RAO KIRLA     BJP
2NOOKARAPU SURYA PRAKASA RAO     TDP
3BHEEMISETTI NAGESWARARAO     RJD
4VENKATA RAMANA BABU PILLA     BSP
5SABBAM HARI     INC
6ALLU ARAVIND     PRAP
7PULAMARASETTI VENKATA RAMANA     PPOI
8BOYINA NAGESWARA RAO     JD(U)
9NANDA GOPAL GANDHAM     IND
10PATHALA SATYA RAO     IND
TUNI-154     PRATHIPADU-155     PITHAPURAM-156     KAKINADA RURAL-157
PEDDAPURAM-158     KAKINADA CITY-160     JAGGAMPETA-171
S01-23-AP-KAKINADA     1DOMMETI SUDHAKAR     BSP
2MMPALLAMRAJU     INC
3BIKKINA VISWESWARA RAO     BJP
4VASAMSETTY SATYA     TDP
5ALURI VIJAYA LAKSHMI     LSP
6UDAYA KUMAR KONDEPUDI     TPPP
7GALI SATYAVATHI     RPI
8GIDLA SIMHACHALAM     RDMP
9CHALAMALASETTY SUNIL     PRAP
10NAMALA SATYANARAYANA     RDHP
11NPALLAMRAJU     AJBP
12BUGATHA BANGARRAO     CPI(ML)(L)
13AKAY SURYANARAYANA     IND
14CHAGANTI SURYA NARAYANA MURTHY     IND
15DANAM LAZAR BABU     IND
16BADAMPUDI BABURAO     IND
RAMACHANDRAPURAM-161     MUMMIDIVARAM-162     AMALAPURAM-163     RAZOLE-164
GANNAVARAM-165     KOTHAPETA-166     MANDAPETA-167
S01-24-AP-AMALAPURAM     1KOMMABATTULA UMA MAHESWARA RAO     BJP
2GEDDAM SAMPADA RAO     BSP
3DOCTOR GEDELA VARALAKSHMI     TDP
4GVHARSHA KUMAR     INC
5AKUMARTHI SURYANARAYANA     TPPP
6KIRAN KUMAR BINEPE     PBHP
7PVCHAKRAVARTHI     RPI(KH)
8POTHULA PRAMEELA DEVI     PRAP
9BHEEMARAO RAMJI MUTHABATHULA     PPOI
10MASA RAMADASU     RDMP
11YALANGI RAMESH     IND
ANAPARTHY-159     RAJANAGARAM-168     RAJAHMUNDRY CITY-169     RAJAMUNDRY
RURAL-170     KOVVUR-173     NIDADAVOLE-174     GOPALAPURAM-185
S01-25-AP-RAJAHMUNDRY     1ARUNA KUMAR VUNDAVALLI     INC
2M MURALI MOHAN     TDP
3VAJRAPU KOTESWARA RAO     BSP
4SOMU VEERRAJU     BJP
5UPPALAPATI VENKATA KRISHNAM RAJU     PRAP
6DATLA RAYA JAGAPATHI RAJU     PPOI
7DR PALADUGU CHANDRA MOULI     LSP
8MEDAPATI PAPIREDDY     TPPP
9MEDA SRINIVAS     RPC(S)
10PARAMATA GANESWARA RAO     IND
11MUSHINI RAMAKRISHNA RAO     IND
12VASAMSETTY NAGESWARA RAO     IND
13SANABOINA SUBHALAKSHMI     IND
ACHANTA-175     PALACOLE-176     NARASAPURAM-177     BHIMAVARAM-178     UNDI-179
TANUKU-180     TADEPALLIGUDEM-181
S01-26-AP-NARSAPURAM     1KALIDINDI VISWANADHA RAJU     BSP
2THOTA SITA RAMA LAKSHMI     TDP
3BAPIRAJU KANUMURU     INC
4BHUPATHIRAJU SRINIVASA VARMA     BJP
5ALLURI YUGANDHARA RAJU     PPOI
6GUBBALA TAMMAIAH     PRAP
7NAVUNDRU RAJENDRA PRASAD     BHSASP
8M V R RAJU     RDMP
9MANORAMA SANKU     LSP
10KALIDINDI BHIMARAJU     IND
UNGUTURU-182     DENDULURU-183     ELURU-184     POLAVARAM-186
CHINTALAPUDI-187     NUZVID-189     KAIKALUR-192
S01-27-AP-ELURU     1KAVURI SAMBASIVA RAO     INC
2KODURI VENKATA SUBBA RAJU     BJP
3PILLELLLI SUNIL     BSP
4MAGANTI VENKATESWARA RAOBABU     TDP
5YVSV PRASADA RAO YERNENI PRASADA RAO     PPOI
6KOLUSU PEDA REDDAIAH YADAV     PRAP
7SAVANAPUDI NAGARAJU     MCPI(S)
8SIRIKI SRINIVAS     RDMP
9KASI NAIDU KAMMILI     IND
10TANUKU SEKHAR     IND
11DODDA KAMESWARA RAO     IND
12DOWLURI GOVARDHAN     IND
GANNAVARAM-190     GUDIVADA-191     PEDANA-193     MACHILIPATNAM-194
AVANIGADDA-195     PAMARRU-196     PENAMALURU-197
S01-28-AP-MACHILIPATNAM     1KONAKALLA NARAYANA RAO     TDP
2CHIGURUPATI RAMALINGESWARA RAO     BSP
3BADIGA RAMAKRISHNA     INC
4BHOGADI RAMA DEVI     BJP
5KOPPULA VENKATESWARA RAO     LSP
6CHENNAMSETTI RAMACHANDRAIAH     PRAP
7YARLAGADDA RAMAMOHANA RAO     BHSASP
8VARA LAKSHMI KONERU     PPOI
9GV NAGESWARA RAO     IND
10YENDURI SUBRAMANYESWA RAO  MANI     IND
TIRUVURU-188     VIJAYWADA WEST-198     VIJAYAWADA CENTRAL-199     VIJAYAWADA
EAST-200     MYLAVARAM-201     NANDIGAMA-202     JAGGAYYAPETA-203
S01-29-AP-VIJAYAWADA     1LAGADAPATI RAJA GOPAL     INC
2LAKA VENGALA RAO     BJP
3VAMSI MOHAN VALLABHANENI     TDP
4SISTLA NARASIMHA MURTHY     BSP
5DEVINENI KISHORE KUMAR     LSP
6RAGHAVA RAO JAKKA     PPOI
7RAJIV CHANUMOLU     PRAP
8APPIKATLA JAWAHAR     IND
9KRISHNA MURTHY SUNKARA     IND
10JAKKA TARAKA MALLIKHARJUNA RAO     IND
11DEVERASETTY RAVINDRA BABU     IND
12DEVIREDDY RAVINDRANATHA REDDY     IND
13PERUPOGU VENKATESWARA RAO     IND
14BAIPUDI NAGESWARA RAO     IND
15BOPPA VENKATESWARA RAO     IND
16BOLISETTY HARIBABU     IND
17VEERLA SANJEEVA RAO     IND
18VENKATA RAO P     IND
19SENAPATHI CHIRANJEEVI     IND
20SHAIK MASTAN     IND
TADIKONDA-205     MANGALAGIRI-206     PONNUR-207     TENALI-210
PRATHIPADU-212     GUNTUR WEST-213     GUNTUR EAST-214
S01-30-AP-GUNTUR     1MALLELA BABU RAO     BSP
2RAJENDRA MADALA     TDP
3YADLAPATI SWARUPARANI     BJP
4SAMBASIVA RAO RAYAPATI     INC
5AMANULLA KHAN     LSP
6KOMMANABOINA LAKSHMAIAH     RDHP
7THOTA CHANDRA SEKHAR     PRAP
8YARRAKULA TULASI RAM YADAV     SP
9VELAGAPUDI LAKSHMANA RAO     PPOI
10SRINIVASA RAO THOTAKURA     AJBP
PEDAKURAPADU-204     CHILAKALURIPET-215     NARASARAOPET-216
SATTENPALLI-217     VINUKONDA-218     GURUZALA-219     MACHERLA-220
S01-31-AP-NARASARAOPET     1BALASHOWRY VALLABHANENI     INC
2BEJJAM RATNAKARA RAO     BSP
3VENUGOPALA REDDY MODUGULA     TDP
4VALLEPU KRUPA RAO     BJP
5SAI PRASAD EDARA     BHSASP
6GANUGAPENTA UTTAMA REDDY     LSP
7SHAIK SYED SAHEB     PRAP
8SG MASTAN VALI     PPOI
9ATCHALA NARASIMHA RAO     IND
10ANNAMRAJU VENUGOPALA MADHAVA RAO     IND
11KATAMARAJU NALAGORLA     IND
12SRINIVASA REDDY KESARI     IND
13YAMPATI VEERANJANEYA REDDY     IND
14RAMADUGU VENKATA SUBBA RAO     IND
VEMURU-208     REPALLE-209     BAPATLA-211     PARCHUR-223     ADDANKI-224
CHIRALA-225     SANTHANUTHALAPADU-226
S01-32-AP-BAPATLA     1DARA SAMBAIAH     BSP
2PANABAKA LAKSHMI     INC
3BATTULA ROSAYYA     BJP
4MALYADRI SRIRAM     TDP
5GARIKAPATI SUDHAKAR     RDMP
6NUTHAKKI RAMA RAO     PRAP
7GUDIPALLI SATHYA BABUJI     IND
8GORREMUCHU CHINNA RAO     IND
9GOLLA BABU RAO     IND
10DEVARAPALLI BUJJI BABU     IND
YERRAGONDAPALEM-221     DARSI-222     ONGOLE-227     KONDAPI-229
MARKAPURAM-230     GIDDALUR-231     KANIGIRI-232
S01-33-AP-ONGOLE     1MANDAVA VASUDEVA     BJP
2MADDULURI MALAKONDAIAH YADAV     TDP
3MAGUNTA SRINIVASULU REDDY     INC
4CHALUVADI SRINIVASARAO     PPOI
5DRNARAYANAM RADHA DEVI     LSP
6PIDATHALA SAI KALPANA     PRAP
7SHAIK SHAJAHAN     UWF
8GARRE RAMAKRISHNA     IND
9DAMA MOHANA RAO     IND
10NALAMALAPU LAKSHMINARASAREDDY     IND
11YATHAPU KONDAREDDY     IND
ALLAGADDA-253     SRISAILAM-254     NANDIKOTKUR-255     PANYAM-257
NANDYAL-258     BANAGANAPALLE-259     DHONE-260
S01-34-AP-NANDYAL     1NASYAM MOHAMMED FAROOK     TDP
2SMOHAMMED ISMAIL     BSP
3SPYREDDY     INC
4ABDUL SATTAR  G     BCUF
5PICHHIKE NARENDRA DEV     RKSP
6BHUMA VENKATA NAGI REDDY     PRAP
7RAMA JAGANNADHA REDDY TAMIDELA     LSP
8SADHU VEERA VENKATA RAMANAIAH     RDMP
9AMBATI RAMESWARA REDDY     IND
10KARTHER PANCHARATNAM     IND
11BPKAMBAGIRI SWAMY     IND
12GALI RAMA SUBBA REDDY     IND
13AUFAROOQ     IND
14GBALASWAMY     IND
15TMAHESH NAIDU     IND
16BVRAMI REDDY     IND
17BRLREDDY     IND
18VENNUPUSA VENKATESHWARA REDDY     IND
19SINGAM VENKATESHWARA REDDY     IND
20TSRINUVASULU     IND
21VSESHI REDDY     IND
KURNOOL-256     PATTIKONDA-261     KODUMUR-262     YEMMIGANUR-263
MANTRALAYAM-264     ADONI-265     ALUR-266
S01-35-AP-KURNOOL     1KOTLA JAYA SURYA PRAKASH REDDY     INC
2GADDAM RAMAKRISHNA     BSP
3BTNAIDU     TDP
4RAVI SUBRAMANYAM KA     BJP
5JALLI VENKATESH     LSP
6DRDANDIYA KHAJA PEERA     PRAP
7BNAGA JAYA CHANDRA REDDY     RDMP
8DRPRPARAMESWAR REDDY     PPOI
9DEVI RAMALINGAPPA     IND
10VV RAMANA     IND
11RAJU         IND
RAYADURG-267     URAVAKONDA-268     GUNTAKAL-269     TADPATRI-270
SINGANAMALA-271     ANANTAPUR URBAN-272     KALYANDURG-273
S01-36-AP-ANANTAPUR     1ANANTHA VENKATA RAMI REDDY     INC
2AMBATI RAMA KRISHNA REDDY     BJP
3KALAVA SRINIVASULU     TDP
4GADDALA NAGABHUSHANAM     BSP
5AMARNATH     LSP
6KRUSHNAPURAM GAYATHRI DEVI     CPI(ML)(L)
7MANSOOR     PRAP
8G HARI         PPOI
9T CHANDRA SEKHAR     IND
10DEVELLA MURALI     IND
11K P NARAYANA SWAMY     IND
12J C RAMANUJULA REDDY     IND
RAPTADU-274     MADAKASIRA-275     HINDUPUR-276     PENUKONDA-277
PUTTAPARTHI-278     DHARMAVARAM-279     KADIRI-280
S01-37-AP-HINDUPUR     1KRISTAPPA NIMMALA     TDP
2P KHASIM KHAN     INC
3NARESH CINE ACTOR     BJP
4BSPSREERAMULU     BSP
5KADAPALA SREEKANTA REDDY     PRAP
6NIRANJAN BABU K     LSP
7S MUSKIN VALI     PPOI
8K JAKEER     IND
9B NAGABHUSHANA RAO     IND
10P PRASAD PEETLA PRASAD     IND
BADVEL-243     KADAPA-245     PULIVENDLA-248     KAMALAPURAM-249
JAMMALAMADUGU-250     PRODDATUR-251     MYDUKUR-252
S01-38-AP-KADAPA     1JAMBAPURAM MUNI REDDY     BSP
2YS JAGAN MOHAN REDDY     INC
3PALEM SRIKANTH REDDY     TDP
4VANGALA SHASHI BHUSHAN REDDY     BJP
5KASIBHATLA SAINATH SARMA     RDHP
6N KISHORE KUMAR REDDY     JD(S)
7KUNCHAM VENKATA SUBBA REDDY     RRS
8DR KHALEEL BASHA     PRAP
9GAJJALA RAMA SUBBA REDDY     PPOI
10GUDIPATI PRASANNA KUMAR     LSP
11C GOPI NARASIMHA REDDY     JD(U)
12CHINNAPA REDDY KOMMA     BJSH
13Y SEKHARA REDDY     RPI(A)
14S ALI SHER     IND
15THIMMAPPAGARI VENKATA SIVA REDDY     IND
16V NARENDRA     IND
17S RAJA MADIGA     IND
18YELLIPALAM RAMESH REDDY     IND
19SIVANARAYANA REDDY CHADIPIRALLA     IND
20J SUBBARAYUDU     IND
KANDUKUR-228     KAVALI-233     ATMAKUR-234     KOVUR-235     NELLORE CITY-236
NELLORE RURAL-237     UDAYAGIRI-242
S01-39-AP-NELLORE     1S PADMA NAGESWARA RAO     BSP
2BATHINA NARASIMHA RAO     BJP
3MEKAPATI RAJAMOHAN REDDY     INC
4VANTERU VENU GOPALA REDDY     TDP
5JANA RAMACHANDRAIAH     PRAP
6VEMURI BHASKARA RAO     LSP
7SIDDIRAJU SATYANARAYANA     PPOI
8KARIMULLA     IND
9MUCHAKALA CHANDRA SEKHAR YADAV     IND
10VENKATA BHASKAR REDDY DIRISALA     IND
11SYED HAMZA HUSSAINY     IND
SARVEPALLI-238     GUDUR-239     SULLURPETA-240     VENKATAGIRI-241
TIRUPATI-286     SRIKALAHASTI-287     SATYAVEEDU-288
S01-40-AP-TIRUPATI     1CHINTA MOHAN     INC
2VARLA RAMAIAH     TDP
3NVENKATASWAMY     BJP
4JUVVIGUNTA VENKATESWARLU     LSP
5DEGALA SURYANARAYANA     PPOI
6DHANASEKHAR GUNDLURU     RPI(A)
7VARAPRASADA RAO V     PRAP
8OREPALLI VENKATA KRISHNA PRASAD     IND
9KATTAMANCHI PRABAKHAR     IND
10YALAVADI MUNIKRISHNAIAH     IND
RAJAMPET-244     KODUR-246     RAYACHOTI-247     THAMBALLAPALLE-281
PILERU-282     MADANAPALLE-283     PUNGANUR-284
S01-41-AP-RAJAMPET     1ANNAYYAGARI SAI PRATHAP     INC
2ALLAPUREDDY HARINATHA REDDY     BJP
3RAMESH KUMAR REDDY REDDAPPAGARI     TDP
4SUNKARA SREENIVAS     BSP
5DR ARAVA VENKATA SUBBA REDDY MBBSDCH     PPOI
6ADI NARAYANA REDDY V     BHSASP
7NAGESWARA RAO EDAGOTTU     LSP
8DA SRINIVAS     PRAP
9SHAIK AMEEN PEERAN     ANC
10ASADI VENKATADRI     IND
11INDRA PRAKASH     IND
12KASTHURI OBAIAH NAIDU     IND
13B KRISHNAPPA     IND
14PULA RAGHU     IND
15HAJI MOHAMMAD AZAM     IND
CHANDRAGIRI-285     NAGARI-289     GANGADHARA NELLORE-290     CHITTOOR-291
PUTHALAPATTU-292     PALAMANER-293     KUPPAM-294
S01-42-AP-CHITTOOR     1JAYARAM DUGGANI     BSP
2THIPPESWAMY M     INC
3NARAMALLI SIVAPRASAD     TDP
4BSIVAKUMAR     BJP
5A AMARNADH     RKSP
6TALARI MANOHAR     PRAP
7G VENKATACHALAM     LSP
LUMLA-1     TAWANG-2     MUKTO-3     DIRANG-4     KALAKTANG-5
THRIZINO-BURAGAON-6     BOMDILA-7     BAMENG-8     CHAYANG TAJO-9     SEPPA EAST-10
S02-1-AR-ARUNACHAL WEST     1KIREN RIJIJU     BJP
2TAKAM SANJOY     INC
3TABA TAKU     LB
4SUBU KECHI     IND
TUTING YINGKIONG-34     PANGIN-35     NARI-KOYU-36     PASIGHAT WEST-37
PASIGHAT EAST-38     MEBO-39     MARIYANG-GEKU-40     ANINI-41     DAMBUK-42     ROING-43
S02-2-AR-ARUNACHAL EAST     1LOWANGCHA WANGLAT     AC
2NINONG ERING     INC
3TAPIR GAO     BJP
4DR SAMSON BORANG     PPA
RATABARI-1     PATHERKANDI-2     KARIMGANJ NORTH-3     KARIMGANJ SOUTH-4
BADARPUR-5     HAILAKANDI-6     KATLICHERRA-7     ALGAPUR-8
S03-1-AS-KARIMGANJ     1RAJESH MALLAH     AUDF
2LALIT MOHAN SUKLABAIDYA     INC
3SUDHANGSHU DAS     BJP
4UTTAM NOMOSUDRA     IND
5JOY DAS     IND
6DEBASISH DAS     IND
7PROBHASH CH SARKAR     IND
8BIJON ROY     IND
9BIJOY MALAKAR     IND
10MALATI ROY     IND
11MILON SINGHA     IND
12RANJAN NAMASUDRA     IND
13RAJESH CHANDRA ROY     IND
14SITAL PRASAD DUSAD     IND
15HIMANGSHU KUMAR DAS     IND
SILCHAR-9     SONAI-10     DHOLAI-11     UDHARBOND-12     LAKHIPUR-13
BORKHOLA-14     KATIGORAH-15
S03-2-AS-SILCHAR     1KABINDRA PURKAYASTHA     BJP
2DIPAK BHATTACHARJEE     CPM
3BADRUDDIN AJMAL     AUDF
4SONTOSH MOHAN DEV     INC
5KANTIMOY DEB     IND
6CHANDAN RABIDAS     IND
7JAYANTA MALLICK     IND
8JOY SUNDAR DAS     IND
9NAGENDRA CHANDRA DAS     IND
10NAZRUL HAQUE MAZARBHUIYAN     IND
11NABADWIP DAS     IND
12PIJUSH KANTI DAS     IND
13MANISH BHATTACHARJEE     IND
14YOGENDRA KUMAR SINGH     IND
15SUBIR DEB     IND
16SUMIT ROY     IND
HAFLONG-16     BOKAJAN-17     HOWRAGHAT-18     DIPHU-19     BAITHALANGSO-20
S03-3-AS-AUTONOMOUS DISTRICT     1KULENDRA DAULAGUPU     BJP
2BIREN SINGH ENGTI     INC
3HIDDHINATH RONGPI     NCP
4ELWIN TERON     ASDC
5DR JAYANTA RONGPI     CPI(ML)(L)
6KABON TIMUNGPI     IND
MANKACHAR-21     SALMARA SOUTH-22     DHUBRI-23     GAURIPUR-24     GOLOKGANJ-25
BILASIPARA WEST-26     BILASIPARA EAST-27     GOALPARA EAST-37     GOALPARA
WEST-38     JALESWAR-39
S03-4-AS-DHUBRI     1ANWAR HUSSAIN     INC
2BADRUDDIN AJMAL     AUDF
3ARUN DAS     RWS
4ALOK SEN     SP
5SOLEMAN ALI     IND
6SHAHJAHAN ALI     IND
7SOLEMAN KHANDAKER     IND
8TRIPTI KANA MAZUMDAR CHOUDHURY     IND
9NUR MAHAMMAD     IND
10MINHAR ALI MANDAL     IND
GOSSAIGAON-28     KOKRAJHAR WEST-29     KOKRAJHAR EAST-30     SIDLI-31
BIJNI-33     SORBHOG-40     BHABANIPUR-41     TAMULPUR-58     BARAMA-62     CHAPAGURI-63
S03-5-AS-KOKRAJHAR     1SABDA RAM RABHA     AGP
2SANSUMA KHUNGGUR BWISWMUTHIARY     BOPF
3URKHAO GWRA BRAHMA     IND
BONGAIGAON-32     ABHAYAPURI NORTH-34     ABHAYAPURI SOUTH-35
PATACHARKUCHI-42     BARPETA-43     JANIA-44     BAGHBAR-45     SARUKHETRI-46
CHENGA-47     DHARMAPUR-61
S03-6-AS-BARPETA     1ABDUS SAMAD AHMED     AUDF
2MD AMIR ALI     RJD
3ISMAIL HUSSAIN     INC
4DURGESWAR DEKA     CPM
5BHUPEN RAY     AGP
6ABU CHAND MAHMMAD     RPI(A)
7ABDUL KADDUS     SP
8KANDARPA LAHKAR     RVNP
9MD DILIR KHAN     MUL
10MUIJ UDDIN MAHMUD     LJP
11ABDUL KADER     IND
12GOLAP HUSSAIN MAZUMDER     IND
13DEWAN JOYNAL ABEDIN     IND
14BHADRESWAR DAS     IND
DUDHNOI-36     BOKO-48     CHHAYGAON-49     PALASBARI-50     JALUKBARI-51
DISPUR-52     GAUHATI EAST-53     GAUHATI WEST-54     HAJO-55     BARKHETRI-60
S03-7-AS-GAUHATI     1AKSHAY RAJKHOWA     NCP
2BIJOYA CHAKRAVARTY     BJP
3CAPT ROBIN BORDOLOI     INC
4SONABOR ALI     AUDF
5AMBU BORA     RCPI(R)
6DEEPAK KALITA     SP
7SHIMANTA BRAHMA     RWS
8AMIT BARUA     IND
9KAZI NEKIB AHMED     IND
10DEVA KANTA RAMCHIARY     IND
11BRIJESH ROY     IND
12RINA GAYARY DAS     IND
KAMALPUR-56     RANGIA-57     NALBARI-59     PANERY-64     KALAIGAON-65
SIPAJHAR-66     MANGALDOI-67     DALGAON-68     UDALGURI-69     MAZBAT-70
S03-8-AS-MANGALDOI     1BADIUJ ZAMAL     AUDF
2MADHAB RAJBANGSHI     INC
3RAMEN DEKA     BJP
4DINA NATH DAS     BOPF
5PARVEEN SULTANA     AIMF
6RABINDRA NATH HAZARIKA     JMM
7RATUL KUMAR CHOUDHURY     SP
8LANKESWAR ACHARJYA     RDMP
9LUCYMAI BASUMATARI     RSPS
10AROON BAROOA     IND
11PRODEEP KUMAR DAIMARY     IND
12BHUPENDRA NATH KAKATI     IND
13MANOJ KUMAR DEKA     IND
DHEKIAJULI-71     BARCHALLA-72     TEZPUR-73     RANGAPARA-74     SOOTEA-75
BISWANATH-76     BEHALI-77     GOHPUR-78     BIHPURIA-109
S03-9-AS-TEZPUR     1JITEN SUNDI     CPM
2DEBA ORANG     AUDF
3MONI KUMAR SUBBA     INC
4JOSEPH TOPPO     AGP
5ARUN KUMAR MURMOO     BVM
6PARASHMONI SINHA     JMM
7JUGANANDA HAZARIKA     SP
8RUBUL SARMA     CPI(ML)(L)
9REGINOLD V JOHNSON     RSPS
10KALYAN KUMAR DEORI BHARALI     IND
11DANIEL DAVID JESUDAS     IND
12MD NAZIR AHMED     IND
13DR PRANAB KR DAS     IND
14PRASANTA BORO     IND
15RUDRA PARAJULI     IND
JAGIROAD-79     MORIGAON-80     LAHARIGHAT-81     RAHA-82     NAGAON-86
BARHAMPUR-87     JAMUNAMUKH-90     HOJAI-91     LUMDING-92
S03-10-AS-NOWGONG     1ANIL RAJA     INC
2RAJEN GOHAIN     BJP
3SIRAJ UDDIN AJMAL     AUDF
4PHEIROIJAM IBOMCHA SINGH     AIFB
5BIPIN SAIKIA     RDMP
6BIREN DAS     RWS
7BHUPEN CHANDRA MUDOI     RPI(A)
8LIAQAT HUSSAIN     LJP
9ASHIT DUTTA     IND
10NAZRUL HAQUE MAZARBHUIYAN     IND
11PUSPA KANTA BORA     IND
12BIMALA PRASAD TALUKDAR     IND
13HERAMBA MOHAN PANDIT     IND
DHING-83     BATADRABA-84     RUPAHIHAT-85     SAMAGURI-88     KALIABOR-89
BOKAKHAT-93     SARUPATHAR-94     GOLAGHAT-95     KHUMTAI-96     DERGAON-97
S03-11-AS-KALIABOR     1GUNIN HAZARIKA     AGP
2DIP GOGOI     INC
3SIRAJ UDDIN AJMAL     AUDF
4KAMAL HAZARIKA     IND
5PAUL NAYAK     IND
6PRADEEP DUTTA     IND
7BINOD GOGOI     IND
8MRIDUL BARUAH     IND
JORHAT-98     TITABAR-100     MARIANI-101     TEOK-102     AMGURI-103
NAZIRA-104     MAHMORA-105     SONARI-106     THOWRA-107     SIVASAGAR-108
S03-12-AS-JORHAT     1KAMAKHYA TASA     BJP
2DRUPAD BORGOHAIN     CPI
3BIJOY KRISHNA HANDIQUE     INC
4ABINASH KISHORE BORAH     RWS
5BIREN NANDA     JMM
6NAVAPROKASH SONOWAL     IND
7RAJ KUMAR DOWARAH     IND
8SUJIT SAHU     IND
MORAN-115     DIBRUGARH-116     LAHOWAL-117     DULIJAN-118     TINGKHONG-119
NAHARKATIA-120     TINSUKIA-122     DIGBOI-123     MARGHERITA-124
S03-13-AS-DIBRUGARH     1SRI PABAN SINGH GHATOWAR     INC
2SRI ROMEN CH BORTHAKUR     NCP
3SRI RATUL GOGOI     CPI
4SRI SARBANANDA SONOWAL     AGP
5SRI GONGARAM KAUL     CPI(ML)(L)
6NIHARIKA BORPATRA GOHAIN GOGOI     JMM
7IMTIAZ HUSSAIN     IND
8FRANCIS DHAN     IND
9LAKHI CHARAN SWANSI     IND
10SIMA GHOSH     IND
MAJULI-99     NAOBOICHA-110     LAKHIMPUR-111     DHAKUAKHANA-112
DHEMAJI-113     JONAI-114     CHABUA-121     DOOMDOOMA-125     SADIYA-126
S03-14-AS-LAKHIMPUR     1DR ARUN KR SARMA     AGP
2BHOGESWAR DUTTA     CPI
3RANEE NARAH     INC
4GANGADHAR DUTTA     SHS
5DEBNATH MAJHI     CPI(ML)(L)
6PRAN JYOTI BORPATRA GOHAIN     RWS
7MINU BURAGOHAIN     SP
8RATNESWAR GOGOI     AIFB
9LALIT MILI     RDMP
10SONAMONI DAS     LJP
11ASAP SUNDIGURIA     IND
12PRASHANTA GOGOI     IND
13BHUMIDHAR HAZARIKA     IND
14RANOJ PEGU     IND
15RABIN DEKA     IND
VALMIKI NAGAR-1     RAMNAGAR-2     NARKATIAGANJ-3     BAGAHA-4     LAURIYA-5
SIKTA-9
S04-1-BR-VALMIKI NAGAR     1DILIP VERMA     NCP
2BAIDYANATH PRASAD MAHTO     JD(U)
3MANAN MISHRA     BSP
4MOHAMMAD SHAMIM AKHTAR     INC
5RAGHUNATH JHA     RJD
6BIRENDRA PRASAD GUPTA     CPI(ML)(L)
7SHAILENDRA KUMAR GARHWAL     LTSD
8AMBIKA SINGH     IND
9UMESH         IND
10DEORAJ RAM     IND
11FAKHRUDDIN     IND
12MAGISTER YADAV     IND
13MANOHAR MANOJ     IND
14RAMASHANKAR PRASAD     IND
15RAKESH KUMAR PANDEY     IND
16SATYANARAIN YADAV     IND
NAUTAN-6     CHANPATIA-7     BETTIAH-8     RAXAUL-10     SUGAULI-11     NARKATIA-12
S04-2-BR-PASCHIM CHAMPARAN     1ANIRUDH PRASAD ALIAS SADHU YADAV     INC
2PRAKASH JHA     LJP
3RAMASHRAY SINGH     CPM
4SHAMBHU PRASAD GUPTA     BSP
5DR SANJAY JAISWAL     BJP
6FAIYAZUL AZAM     JD(S)
7MANOJ KUMAR     RDMP
8SYED SHAMIM AKHTAR     LTSD
9NAFIS AHAMAD     IND
10SHRIMAN MISHRA     IND
11SYED IRSHAD AKHTER     IND
HARSIDHI-13     GOVINDGANJ-14     KESARIA-15     KALYANPUR-16     PIPRA-17
MOTIHARI-19
S04-3-BR-PURVI CHAMPARAN     1AKHILESH PRASAD SINGH     RJD
2ARVIND KUMAR GUPTA     INC
3GAGANDEO YADAV     BSP
4RADHA MOHAN SINGH     BJP
5RAMCHANDRA PRASAD     CPI
6UMESH KUMAR SINGH     SJP(R)
7NAGENDRA SAHANI     LTSD
8SURESH KUMAR RAJAK     IJP
9SURESH KUMAR RAI     BJKVP
10JHAGARU MAHATO     IND
11PARASNATHPANDEY     IND
12MD MURTUJA ANSARI ALIAS DR LAL     IND
MADHUBAN-18     CHIRAIA-20     DHAKA-21     SHEOHAR-22     RIGA-23     BELSAND-30
S04-4-BR-SHEOHAR     1MD ANWARUL HAQUE     BSP
2MD TANVEER ZAFAR     CPI
3RAMA DEVI     BJP
4LOVELY ANAND     INC
5SITARAM SINGH     RJD
6ARUN SAH     BLPGL
7BASDEO SAH     IJP
8SHATRUGHNA SAHU     BJJD
9AJAY KUMAR PANDEY     IND
10CHANDRIKA PRASAD     IND
11MOHAMMAD FIROZ AHAMAD     IND
12MOHSIN     IND
13YOGENDRA RAM     IND
14RAM ASHISH MAHTO     IND
15SUNIL SINGH     IND
BATHNAHA-24     PARIHAR-25     SURSAND-26     BAJPATTI-27     SITAMARHI-28
RUNISAIDPUR-29
S04-5-BR-SITAMARHI     1ARJUN ROY     JD(U)
2MAYA SHANKAR SHARAN     BSP
3SAMIR KUMAR MAHASETH     INC
4SITARAM YADAV     RJD
5S ABU DAUJANA     LTSD
6CHITARANJAN GIRI     RPP
7MOHAMMAD AFZAL PAINTHER     ANC
8SHANKAR SINHA     RSP
9CHANDRIKA PRASAD     IND
10ZAHID         IND
11DINESH PRASAD     IND
12PAPPU KUMAR MISHRA     IND
13MUKESH KUMAR GUPTA     IND
14RAVINDRA KUMAR     IND
15RAM KISHORE PRASAD     IND
16SONE LAL SAH     IND
HARLAKHI-31     BENIPATTI-32     BISFI-35     MADHUBANI-36     KEOTI-86     JALE-87
S04-6-BR-MADHUBANI     1ABDULBARI SIDDIKI     RJD
2LAXMANKANT MISHRA     BSP
3DR SHAKEEL AHAMAD     INC
4HUKM DEO NARAYAN YADAV     BJP
5DR HEMCHANDRA JHA     CPI
6MINTU KUMAR SINGH     JGP
7MISHRI LAL YADAV     RKJP
8RAMCHANDRA YADAV     KSVP
9RAM SAGAR SAHANI     IJP
10MD ZINNUR     IND
11RAVINDRA THAKUR     IND
12RAJESHWAR YADAV     IND
13SANJAY KUMAR MAHTO     IND
14HARIBHUSHAN THAKUR BACHOL     IND
KHAJAULI-33     BABUBARHI-34     RAJNAGAR-37     JHANJHARPUR-38     PHULPARAS-39
LAUKAHA-40
S04-7-BR-JHANJHARPUR     1KRIPANATH PATHAK     INC
2GAURI SHANKAR YADAV     BSP
3DEVENDRA PRASAD YADAV     RJD
4MANGANI LAL MANDAL     JD(U)
5DR KIRTAN PRASAD SINGH     LTSD
6YOGNATH MANDAL     CPI(ML)(L)
7OM PRAKASH     IND
8NATHUNI YADAV     IND
9FIROZ ALAM     IND
10VIVEKA NAND JHA     IND
11SHANKAR PRASAD     IND
NIRMALI-41     PIPRA-42     SUPAUL-43     TRIBENIGANJ-44     CHHATAPUR-45
SINGHESHWAR-72
S04-8-BR-SUPAUL     1ASHOK MAHTO     BSP
2BALRAM SINGH YADAV     CPM
3RANJEET RANJAN     INC
4VISHWA MOHAN KUMAR     JD(U)
5SURYA NARAYAN YADAV     LJP
6NARAYAN MANDAL     SHS
7MANJU DEVI     IJP
8SHARVAN KUMAR CHOUDHARY     JD(S)
9SURESH PRASAD MEHTA     LTSD
10ARBIND KUMAR     IND
11ASHOK PANKAJ     IND
12BHIM KUMAR GUPTA     IND
13RAMCHANDRA PRASAD SINGH     IND
14RAMDEO SHARMA     IND
15VIJAY KUMAR CHOUDHARY     IND
16SURESH KUMAR AZAD     IND
NARPATGANJ-46     RANIGANJ-47     FORBESGANJ-48     ARARIA-49     JOKIHAT-50
SIKTI-51
S04-9-BR-ARARIA     1ZAKIR HUSSAIN KHAN     LJP
2PRADEEP KUMAR SINGH     BJP
3RAJA RAMAN BHASKAR     BSP
4DR SHAKEEL AHMAD KHAN     INC
5AYAJUDIN     RKJP
6KAMALI DEVI     CPI(ML)(L)
7NASIM AHMAD GHAZI     RJJM
8ABDUL GAFOOR     IND
9ABDUL WAHAB     IND
10OM PRAKASH     IND
11KANHAIYA KUMAR DAS     IND
12DINESH RATHOUR     IND
13NAND LAL PASWAN     IND
14NITYA NAND BISHWAS     IND
15PRAMOD SINGH YADAV     IND
16PRINCE VICTOR     IND
17LAXMI SADA     IND
18VIJAY SAH     IND
19SANJAY KUMAR JHA     IND
20MD SAJJAD     IND
21SATYA NARAYAN WRITER     IND
22SADA NAND CHOUDHARY     IND
23SADHANA DEVI     IND
24SUKDEO PASWAN     IND
25MOHAMMED SAIFUR RAB     IND
BAHADURGANJ-52     THAKURGANJ-53     KISHANGANJ-54     KOCHADHAMAN-55
AMOUR-56     BAISI-57
S04-10-BR-KISHANGANJ     1ZUBAIR ALAM     BSP
2TASLEEM UDDIN     RJD
3MOHAMMAD ASRARUL HAQUE     INC
4SYED MAHMOOD ASHRAF     JD(U)
5TAMAJUL ALI     BJJD
6MOHAMMAD KHASHIUR RAHMAN     SJP(R)
7MOHAMMAD NISSAR ALAM     JMM
8RAJIT PODAR     ABAS
9ABDUL RAJJAK URF KAL     IND
10ABHINAV MODI     IND
11ASGAR MALIK     IND
12CHOTAY LAL MAHTO     IND
13MD TASLIMUDDIN     IND
14VISHWANATH KEJRIWAL     IND
15SIKANDER SINGH     IND
KATIHAR-63     KADWA-64     BALRAMPUR-65     PRANPUR-66     MANIHARI-67
BARARI-68
S04-11-BR-KATIHAR     1AHMAD ASHFAQUE KARIM     LJP
2NIKHIL KUMAR CHOUDHARY     BJP
3MADAN MOHAN NISHAD     BSP
4SHAH TARIQ ANWAR     NCP
5OM PRAKASH PODDAR     BJJD
6MAHBOOB ALAM     CPI(ML)(L)
7MUNNI DEVI     ABJS
8RAJESH GURNANI     LTSD
9CHANDU MURMU     IND
10PHOOLO DEVI     IND
11BABU LAL MARANDI     IND
12MANOJ PARASAR     IND
13MOHAMMAD HAMID MUBARAK     IND
14RAJGIRI SINGH     IND
15SUNIL KUMAR CHOUDHARY     IND
16HIMRAJ SINGH     IND
KASBA-58     BANMANKHI-59     RUPAULI-60     DHAMDAHA-61     PURNIA-62     KORHA-69
S04-12-BR-PURNIA     1UDAY SINGH ALIAS PAPPU SINGH     BJP
2NAVEEN KUMAR SINGH     BSP
3SHANKAR JHA     LJP
4ANIL KUMAR BHARTI     RVNP
5ASHOK KUMAR SAH     JMM
6IRSHAD AHMAD KHAN     LTSD
7MADHAVI SARKAR     CPI(ML)(L)
8MD AISUR RAHMAN     IND
9ABDUL SATTAR     IND
10ALIMUDDIN ANSARI     IND
11UPENDRA NATH SAGAR     IND
12KAUSHALYA DEVI     IND
13JAGDISH PRASAD YADAV     IND
14JIVACHH PASWAN     IND
15DEEP NARAYAN SINGH     IND
16PRAMOD NARAYAN PODDAR     IND
17VIJAY KUMAR SAH     IND
18SHANTI PRIYA     IND
19SHIEKH AKBAR ALI     IND
20SUNIL KUMAR     IND
ALAMNAGAR-70     BIHARIGANJ-71     MADHEPURA-73     SONBARSA-74     SAHARSA-75
MAHISHI-77
S04-13-BR-MADHEPURA     1OMPRAKASH NARAYAN     CPI
2DRTARA NAND SADA     INC
3PROF RAVINDRA CHARAN YADAV     RJD
4BINOD KUMAR JHA     BSP
5SHARAD YADAV     JD(U)
6DHANOJ KUMAR TANTI     RVNP
7RAVINDRA KUMAR     RSWD
8RAJO SAH     LTSD
9NKSINGH     SAP
10KARPURI RISHIDEO     IND
11KISHOR KUMAR     IND
12TIRO SHARAMA     IND
13DHRUVA KUMAR GUPTA     IND
14PRASANN KUMAR     IND
15BALWANT GADHWAL     IND
16MAHADEO YADAV     IND
17SAAKAR SURESH YADAV     IND
GORA BAURAM-79     BENIPUR-80     ALINAGAR-81     DARBHANGA RURAL-82
DARBHANGA-83     BAHADURPUR-85
S04-14-BR-DARBHANGA     1AJAY KUMAR JALAN     INC
2MD ALI ASHRAF FATMI     RJD
3KIRTI AZAD     BJP
4YUGESHWAR SAHNI     BSP
5KUMARI SURESHWARI     RMEP
6MD KHURSHID ALAM     AD
7DURGANAND MAHAVIR NAYAK     BJJD
8MD NIZAMUDDIN     IJP
9SATYANARAYAN MUKHIA     CPI(ML)(L)
10ABDUR RAHIM     IND
11GOVIND ACHARAY     IND
12BHARAT YADAV     IND
13LALBAHADUR YADAV     IND
14PROF HARERAM ACHARAY     IND
GAIGHAT-88     AURAI-89     BOCHAHA-91     SAKRA-92     KURHANI-93
MUZAFFARPUR-94
S04-15-BR-MUZAFFARPUR     1CAPTAIN JAI NARAYAN PRASAD NISHAD     JD(U)
2BHAGWANLAL SAHNI     LJP
3VINITA VIJAY     INC
4SAMEER KUMAR     BSP
5JITENDRA YADAV     CPI(ML)(L)
6DINESH KUMAR KUSHWAHA     RKSP
7DEVENDRA RAKESH     BJKVP
8NEELU SINGH     PSS
9MAHENDRA PRASAD     RPP
10MITHILESH KUMAR     RASED
11MOHAMMAD SHAMIM     RDMP
12MD RAHAMTULLAHA     ABJS
13RAM DAYAL RAM     AIFB
14REYAJ AHMAD ATISH     JGP
15MD SALEEM     RVNP
16ASHOK KUMAR LALAN     IND
17AHMAD RAZA     IND
18GEORGE FERNANDES     IND
19TARKESHWAR PASWAN     IND
20VIJENDRA CHAUDHARY     IND
21VINOD PASWAN     IND
22SHAMBHU SAHNI     IND
23SADANAND KISHORE THAKUR     IND
24SYED ALAMDAR HUSSAIN     IND
MINAPUR-90     KANTI-95     BARURAJ-96     PAROO-97     SAHEBGANJ-98
VAISHALI-125
S04-16-BR-VAISHALI     1RAGHUVANSH PRASAD SINGH     RJD
2VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA     JD(U)
3SHANKAR MAHTO     BSP
4HIND KESRI YADAV     INC
5PUNAMRI DEVI     UWF
6PRAMOD KUMAR SHARMA     BJKVP
7BADRI PASWAN     RKSP
8BALAK NATH SAHANI     IJP
9LALJI KUMAR RAKESH     RASED
10BINOD PANDIT     LPSP
11INDARDEO RAI     IND
12JITENDRA PRASAD     IND
BAIKUNTHPUR-99     BARAULI-100     GOPALGANJ-101     KUCHAIKOTE-102
BHOREY-103     HATHUA-104
S04-17-BR-GOPALGANJ     1ANIL KUMAR     RJD
2JANAK RAM     BSP
3PURNMASI RAM     JD(U)
4RAMAI RAM     INC
5MADHU BHARTI     LTSD
6RAM KUMAR MANJHI     SBSP
7RAMASHANKAR RAM     RJJM
8SATYADEO RAM     CPI(ML)(L)
9ASHA DEVI     IND
10DINANATH MANJHI     IND
11DHARMENDRA KUMAR HAZRA     IND
12BANITHA BAITHA     IND
13RAJESH KUMAR RAM     IND
14RAM SURAT RAM     IND
15SHAMBHU DOM     IND
16SURENDRA PASWAN     IND
SIWAN-105     ZIRADEI-106     DARAULI-107     RAGHUNATHPUR-108     DARAUNDHA-109
BARHARIA-110
S04-18-BR-SIWAN     1PARASH NATH PATHAK     BSP
2BRISHIN PATEL     JD(U)
3VIJAY SHANKER DUBEY     INC
4HENA SHAHAB     RJD
5AMAR NATH YADAV     CPI(ML)(L)
6ASWANI KR VERMA     IJP
7MADHURI PANDAY     SJTP
8LAL BABU TIWARI     RKSP
9UMESH TIWARY     IND
10OM PRAKASH YADAV     IND
11NIDHI KIRTI     IND
12PRABHU NATH MALI     IND
13DR MUNESHWAR PRASAD     IND
14RAJENDRA KUMAR     IND
15SHAMBHU NATH PRASAD     IND
GORIYAKOTHI-111     MAHARAJGANJ-112     EKMA-113     MANJHI-114     BANIAPUR-115
TARAIYA-116
S04-19-BR-MAHARAJGANJ     1UMA SHANAKER SINGH     RJD
2TARKESHWAR SINGH     INC
3PRABHU NATH SINGH     JD(U)
4RAVINDRA NATH MISHRA     BSP
5RAMESH SINGH KUSHWAHA     LTSD
6SATYENDRA KR SAHANI     CPI(ML)(L)
7GAUTAM PRASAD     IND
8DHURENDRA RAM     IND
9NAYAN PRASAD     IND
10PRADEEP MANJHI     IND
11BANKE BIHARI SINGH     IND
12RAJESH KUMAR SINGH     IND
13BREENDA PATHAK     IND
MARHAURA-117     CHAPRA-118     GARKHA-119     AMNOUR-120     PARSA-121
SONEPUR-122
S04-20-BR-SARAN     1RAJIV PRATAP RUDY     BJP
2LALU PRASAD     RJD
3SALIM PERWEZ     BSP
4SANTOSH PATEL     LTSD
5SOHEL AKHATAR     BMF
6KUMAR BALRAM SINGH     IND
7DHUPENDRA SINGH     IND
8RAJKUMAR RAI     IND
9RAJAN HRISHIKESH CHANDRA     IND
10RAJARAM SAHANI     IND
11LAL BABU RAY     IND
12SHEO DAS SINGH     IND
HAJIPUR-123     LALGANJ-124     MAHUA-126     RAJA PAKAR-127     RAGHOPUR-128
MANHAR-129
S04-21-BR-HAJIPUR     1DASAI CHOUDHARY     INC
2MAHESHWAR DAS     BSP
3RAM VILAS PASWAN     LJP
4RAM SUNDAR DAS     JD(U)
5DINESH CHANDRA BHUSHAN     LTSD
6NAND LAL PASWAN     IND
7PRATIMA KUMARI     IND
8RAJENDRA KUMAR PASWAN     IND
9RAM TIRTH PASWAN     IND
10VISHWA VIJAY KUMAR VIDHYARTHI     IND
11SANJAY PASHWAN     IND
PATEPUR-130     UJIARPUR-134     MORWA-135     SARAIRANJAN-136
MOHIUDDINNAGAR-137     BIBHUTPUR-138
S04-22-BR-UJIARPUR     1ASWAMEDH DEVI     JD(U)
2ALOK KUMAR MEHTA     RJD
3RAMDEO VERMA     CPM
4VIJAYWANT KUMAR CHOUDHARY     BSP
5SHEEL KUMAR ROY     INC
6CHANDRA DEO ROY     SLP(L)
7JAI NARAYAN SAH     BJKVP
8JITENDRA KUMAR ROY     SHS
9TOSHAN SAH     RPP
10MD TAUKIR     SAP
11MASSOD HASSAN     MUL
12RAMNATH SINGH     RSWD
13ARJUN SAHNI     IND
14PRADEEP KUMAR     IND
15BRAJESH KUMAR NIRALA     IND
16MANSOOR     IND
17MOHAN PAUL     IND
18MOHAMMAD KURBAN     IND
19RATAN SAHNI     IND
20RAM SAGAR MAHTO     IND
21SANJAY KUMAR JHA     IND
22SUJIT KUMAR BHAGAT     IND
KUSHESHWAR ASTHAN-78     HAYAGHAT-84     KALYANPUR-131     WARISNAGAR-132
SAMASTIPUR-133     ROSERA-139
S04-23-BR-SAMASTIPUR     1DR ASHOK KUMAR     INC
2MAHESWER HAZARI     JD(U)
3RAM CHANDRA PASWAN     LJP
4BINDESHWAR PASWAN     BSP
5UPENDRA PASWAN     LTSD
6JEEBACHH PASWAN     CPI(ML)(L)
7RANDHIR PASWAN     IND
8RAJA RAM DAS     IND
9REKHA KUMARI     IND
10SHIVCHANDRA PASWAN     IND
11SATISH MAHTO     IND
CHERIA BARIARPUR-141     BACHHWARA-142     TEGHRA-143     MATIHANI-144
SAHEBPUR KAMAL-145     BEGUSARAI-146     BAKHRI-147
S04-24-BR-BEGUSARAI     1ANIL CHAUDHARY     LJP
2AMITA BHUSHAN     INC
3CHANDRASHEKHAR MAHTO     BSP
4DR MONAZIR HASSAN     JD(U)
5SHATRUGHAN PRASAD SINGH     CPI
6KISHORI PRASHAD MAHTO     LTSD
7RAM SAH     RPP
8AMIYA KASHYAP BIKKI     IND
9ARUN KUMAR     IND
10ASHOK SAH     IND
11DILIP KUMAR     IND
12NARENDRA KUMAR SINGH ALIAS BOGO SINGH     IND
13NARAYAN PRASAD HISARIYA     IND
14RANJEET PASWAN     IND
15RADHA RAMAN PASWAN     IND
16RAM DAYAL BHARTI     IND
17RAM NARESH PRASAD SINGH     IND
18RAMSHRAYA NISHAD     IND
19SAJJAN CHAUDHARY     IND
SIMRI BAKHTIARPUR-76     HASANPUR-140     ALAULI-148     KHAGARIA-149
BELDAUR-150     PARBATTA-151
S04-25-BR-KHAGARIA     1ASARFI PRASAD MEHTA     BSP
2CHOUDHARY MEHBOOB ALI KAISER     INC
3DINESH CHANDRA YADAV     JD(U)
4RAVINDAR KR RANA     RJD
5PAWAN KUMAR SUMAN     ABDBM
6BABLOO PASWAN     NNP
7BHARAT KUMAR YADAV     KVSP
8LAL BAHADUR HIMALAYA     RDMP
9HARI NANDAN SINGH     SJP(R)
10GULAB RAJ     IND
11NAIMUDDIN     IND
12NEHA CHAUHAN     IND
13PRADUMNA KUMAR     IND
14MANJU KUMARI     IND
15RAM NANDAN YADAV     IND
16SANGRAM KUMAR     IND
17SANJAY YADAV     IND
18SURESH PODDAR     IND
BIHPUR-152     GOPALPUR-153     PIRPAINTI-154     KAHALGAON-155
BHAGALPUR-156     NATHNAGAR-158
S04-26-BR-BHAGALPUR     1AJIT SHARMA     BSP
2SHAKUNI CHOUDHARY     RJD
3SADANAND SINGH     INC
4SUBODH ROY     CPM
5SYED SHAHNAWAZ HUSSAIN     BJP
6DAYA RAM MANDAL     BHJAP
7DEEPAK RAM     BSP(K)
8NARESH MANDAL     RPP
9MD IZRAIL     LTSD
10RAMAN SAH     BJJD
11RAM VILASH PASWAN     RWS
12SRINARAYAN GAUSWAMI     IJP
13AMIT KUMAR JHA     IND
14ANAND KUMAR JAIN     IND
15INDRADEO KUMAR SINGH     IND
16DINESH YADAV     IND
17DR N K YADAV     IND
18RATAN KUMAR MANDAL     IND
19RAVI SHANKAR SINGH     IND
20LADDU     IND
21SIKANDAR TANTI     IND
SULTANGANJ-157     AMARPUR-159     DHURAIYA-160     BANKA-161     KATORIA-162
BELHAR-163
S04-27-BR-BANKA     1GRIDHARI YADAV     INC
2JAI PRAKESH NARAIN YADAV     RJD
3DAMODAR RAWAT     JD(U)
4MUKESH KUMAR SINGH     BSP
5SANJAY KUMAR     CPI
6ANIL KUMAR ALIAS ANIL GUPTA     JVM
7AMRESHWAR KUMAR     JGP
8ARVIND KUMAR SAH     RPP
9KEDAR PRASAD SINGH     SJP(R)
10MAHBOOB ALAM ANSARI     BMF
11RAJENDRA PANDIT NETAJEE     JMM
12VIVEKA NAND JHA     RDMP
13CP SINHA     LTSD
14DIGVIJAY SINGH     IND
15NARAYAN RAM     IND
16MOHD HUMAYUN     IND
MUNGER-165     JAMALPUR-166     SURYAGARHA-167     LAKHISARAI-168     MOKAMA-178
BARH-179
S04-28-BR-MUNGER     1MANNU MAHTO     BSP
2RAJIV RANJAN SINGH ALIAS LALAN SINGH     JD(U)
3RAM BADAN ROY     RJD
4RAM LAKHAN SINGH     INC
5KUNDAN KUMAR     BJJD
6PRAMOD KUMAR SINGH     ABDBM
7BIPIN KUMAR PASWAN     NBNP
8RAMENDRA MOHAN RAJESH     RSWD
9LOKNATH KUSHWAHA     BMF
10UCHIT KUMAR     IND
11UMA SHANKAR BHAGAT ALIAS TUNTUN BHAIYA     IND
12NARESH MAHTO     IND
13PRAMOD KUMAR     IND
14BRAHMANAND MANDAL     IND
15RAJENDRA PRASAD SINGH     IND
16RADHIKA RAMAN SINGH     IND
17RAMDEO SINGH YADAV     IND
18SHANKAR LAL CHOKHANI     IND
19SHAILENDRA KUMAR     IND
20SURYODAY PASWAN     IND
ASTHAWAN-171     BISHARSHARIF-172     RAJGIR-173     ISLAMPUR-174     HILSA-175
NALANDA-176     HARNAUT-177
S04-29-BR-NALANDA     1KAUSHALENDRA KUMAR     JD(U)
2DEV KISHORE RAI     BSP
3RAMSWAROOP PRASAD     INC
4SATISH KUMAR     LJP
5ANIL SINGH     LTSD
6AMAR KANT SAH     RPP
7UJJWAL KANT HUNKAR     MUL
8DEVENDRA PRATAP     EKSP
9PRIYRANJAN KUMAR     BJJD
10RANJEET KUMAR     BPD
11REKHA KUMARI     AD
12VIJAY KUMAR     JPS
13VINOD KUMAR PATEL     LM
14SHASHI YADAV     CPI(ML)(L)
15SAUDAGAR RAM     BSKP
16HARICHARAN PRASAD     BMF
17ARUN KUMAR     IND
18KAPIL DEO SINGH     IND
19KUMAR RAJESH     IND
20KAUSHAL KUMAR KAUSHALENDRA SINHA     IND
21CHANDRAMANI KUMAR MANI     IND
22JITENDRA KUMAR     IND
23NARESH PASWAN     IND
24SANTOSH KUMAR     IND
25SARYUG PRASAD SAHASTH     IND
BAKHTIARPUR-180     DIGHA-181     BANKIPUR-182     KUMHRARH-183     PATNA
SAHIB-184     FATWAH-185
S04-30-BR-PATNA SAHIB     1VIJAY KUMAR     RJD
2SHATRUGHAN SINHA     BJP
3SHEKHAR SUMAN     INC
4ON MASUMI     LTSD
5DR DIWAKER TEJASWI     BUDM
6RAM NARAYAN RAI     CPI(ML)(L)
7HASSAN FAIZI HASHMI     ANC
8ANJANI KUMAR     IND
9KUMAR RAJIV     IND
10DEEPAK KUMAR SINGH     IND
11PANKAJ KUMAR SHARMA     IND
12PRAMOD KUMAR GUPTA     IND
13RAM BHAJAN SINGH NISHAD     IND
14VIDHAN CHANDRA RANA     IND
15SANJAY VERMA     IND
16HEMANT KUMAR SINGH     IND
DANAPUR-186     MANER-187     PHULWARI-188     MASAURHI-189     PALIGANJ-190
BIKRAM-191
S04-31-BR-PATALIPUTRA     1RANJAN PRASAD YADAV     JD(U)
2LALU PRASAD     RJD
3VIJAY SINGH YADAV     INC
4HARENDRA KUMAR PATEL     BSP
5KIRAN DEVI     RKJP
6KUNDAN KUMAR     RWS
7DR KRISHNADHAR SINGH     BJKD
8PANCHA DEVI     JGP
9PRABHUNATH YADAV     IJP
10MOHAMMAD AFTAB ALAM     LTSD
11MOHAMMAD SADRUDDIN     AIFB
12RAMESHWAR PRASAD     CPI(ML)(L)
13HASAN MANZOOR HASHMI     ANC
14AWADHESH SHARMA     IND
15DURGESH NANDAN SINGH     IND
16SUNIL KUMAR SINGH     IND
SANDESH-192     BARHARA-193     ARRAH-194     AGIAON-195     TARARI-196
JAGDISHPUR-197     SHAHPUR-198
S04-32-BR-ARRAH     1MEENA SINGH     JD(U)
2RAMA KISHORE SINGH     LJP
3REETA SINGH     BSP
4HARIDWAR PRASAD SINGH     INC
5AJIT PRASAD MEHTA     JKM
6ARUN SINGH     CPI(ML)(L)
7BHARAT BHUSAN PANDEY     ABJS
8RAMADHAR SINGH     SHS
9SAMBHU PRASAD SHARMA     AIFB
10SANTOSH KUMAR     RDMP
11SATYA NARAYAN YADAV     RASED
12SAIYAD GANIUDDIN HAIDER     ANC
13ASHOK KUMAR SINGH     IND
14BHARAT SINGH SAHYOGI     IND
15MAHESH RAM     IND
16SOBH NATH SINGH     IND
BARHAMPUR-199     BUXAR-200     DUMRAON-201     RAJPUR-202     RAMGARH-203
DINARA-210
S04-33-BR-BUXAR     1KAMLA KANT TIWARY     INC
2JAGADA NAND SINGH     RJD
3LAL MUNI CHOUBEY     BJP
4SHYAM LAL SINGH KUSHWAHA     BSP
5MOKARRAM HUSSAIN     SBSP
6MOHAN SAH     BJJD
7RAJENDRA SINGH MAURYA     LTSD
8DR VIJENDRA NATH UPADHYAY     SHS
9SHYAM BIHARI BIND     JPS
10SATYENDRA OJHA     AD
11SUDAMA PRASAD     CPI(ML)(L)
12SURESH WADEKAR     RPI
13KAMLESH CHOUDHARY     IND
14JAI SINGH YADAV     IND
15DADAN SINGH     IND
16PRATIBHA DEVI     IND
17PHULAN PANDIT     IND
18RAJENDRA PASWAN     IND
19LALLAN RUPNARAIN PATHAK     IND
20SHIV CHARAN YADAV     IND
21SUNIL KUMAR DUBEY     IND
22SURENDRA KUMAR BHARTI     IND
MOHANIA-204     BHABUA-205     CHAINPUR-206     CHENARI-207     SASARAM-208
KARGAHAR-209
S04-34-BR-SASARAM     1GANDHI AZAD     BSP
2MEIRA KUMAR     INC
3MUNI LAL     BJP
4LALAN PASWAN     RJD
5DUKHI RAM     CPI(ML)(L)
6BABBAN CHAUDHARY     LTSD
7BALIRAM RAM     PMSP
8BHOLA PRASAD     IJP
9RADHA DEBI     AD
10RAM NAGINA RAM     RKJP
11RAM YADI RAM     RPI
12PRAMOD KUMAR     IND
13BHARAT RAM     IND
14MUNIYA DEBI     IND
15RAM PRAVESH RAM     IND
16SURENDRA RAM     IND
NOKHA-211     DEHRI-212     KARAKAT-213     GOH-219     OBRA-220     NABINAGAR-221
S04-35-BR-KARAKAT     1AWADHESH KUMAR SINGH     INC
2UPENDRA KUMAR SHARMA     BSP
3KANTI SINGH     RJD
4MAHABALI SINGH     JD(U)
5AJAY KUMAR     RPI(A)
6JYOTI RASHMI     RSWD
7MUDREEKA YADAV     AD
8RAJ KISHOR MISRA     AJSP
9RAJA RAM SINGH     CPI(ML)(L)
10MDSHAMIULLAH MANSOORI     SSD
11ERABDUL SATAR     IND
12AMAVAS RAM     IND
13PRO KAMTA PRASAD YADAV     IND
14GIRISH NARAYAN SINGH     IND
15SATISH PANDEY     IND
16HARI PRASAD SINGH     IND
ARWAL-214     KURTHA-215     JAHANABAD-216     GHOSI-217     MAKHDUMPUR-218
ATRI-233
S04-36-BR-JAHANABAD     1DR ARUN KUMAR     INC
2JAGDISH SHARMA     JD(U)
3RAMADHAR SHARMA     BSP
4SURENDRA PRASAD YADAV     RJD
5AYASHA KHATUN     LTSD
6PROF JAI RAM PRASAD SINGH     SSD
7TARA GUPTA     RPP
8MAHANAND PRASAD     CPI(ML)(L)
9RAMASRAY PRASAD SINGH     RLD
10MD SAHABUDDIN JAHAN     BSKP
11SHRAVAN KUMAR     LM
12SADHU SINHA     AIFB
13SYED AKBAR IMAM     ABAS
14AJAY KUMAR VERMA     IND
15ABHAY KUMAR ANIL     IND
16DR ARBIND KUMAR     IND
17ARVIND PRASAD SINGH     IND
18UPENDRA PRASAD     IND
19JAGDISH YADAV     IND
20PRIKSHIT SINGH     IND
21PRABHAT KUMAR RANJAN     IND
22RANJIT SHARMA     IND
23RAKESHWAR KISHOR     IND
24SIYA RAM PRASAD     IND
25SUMIRAK SINGH     IND
KUTUMBA-222     AURANGABAD-223     RAFIGANJ-224     GURUA-225     IMAMGANJ-227
TIKARI-231
S04-37-BR-AURANGABAD     1ARCHANA CHANDRA     BSP
2NIKHIL KUMAR     INC
3SHAKIL AHMAD KHAN     RJD
4SUSHIL KUMAR SINGH     JD(U)
5ANIL KUMAR SINGH     RSWD
6AMERIKA MAHTO     SSD
7RAM KUMAR MEHTA     LTSD
8VIJAY PASWAN     BSKP
9ASLAM ANSARI     IND
10INDRA DEO RAM     IND
11UDAY PASWAN     IND
12PUNA DAS     IND
13RANJEET KUMAR     IND
14RAJENDRA YADAV     IND
15RAMSWARUP PRASAD YADAV     IND
16SANTOSH KUMAR     IND
SHERGHATI-226     BARACHATTI-228     BODH GAYA-229     GAYA TOWN-230
BELAGANJ-232     WAZIRGANJ-234
S04-38-BR-GAYA     1KALAWATI DEVI     BSP
2RAMJI MANJHI     RJD
3SANJIV PRASAD TONI     INC
4HARI MANJHI     BJP
5DILIP PASWAN     NBNP
6NIRANJAN KUMAR     CPI(ML)(L)
7RAJESH KUMAR     LTSD
8RAMDEV ARYA PAAN     ABJS
9AMAR NATH PRASAD     IND
10KRISHNA CHOUDHARY     IND
11KAIL DAS     IND
12DIPAK PASWAN     IND
13RAM KISHORE PASWAN     IND
14RAMU PASWAN     IND
15SHIV SHANKAR KUMAR     IND
16SHYAM LAL MANJHI     IND
BARBIGHA-170     RAJAULI-235     HISUA-236     NAWADA-237     GOBINDPUR-238
WARSALIGANJ-239
S04-39-BR-NAWADA     1GANESH SHANKAR VIDYARTHI     CPM
2BHOLA SINGH     BJP
3MASIH UDDIN     BSP
4VEENA DEVI     LJP
5SUNILA DEVI     INC
6UMAKANT RAHI     SSD
7KAILASH PAL     BSKP
8VIDHYAPATI SINGH     LTSD
9SURENDRA KUMAR CHAUDHARY     SBSP
10AKHILESH SINGH     IND
11ANIL MEHTA     IND
12KAUSHAL YADAV     IND
13CHANCHALA DEVI     IND
14DURGA PRASAD DHAR     IND
15NAVIN KUMAR VERMA     IND
16RAJ KISHOR RAJ     IND
17RAJ BALLABH PRASAD     IND
18RAJENDRA VISHAL     IND
19RAJENDRA SINGH     IND
20SHAMBHU PRASAD     IND
21SUNIL KUMAR     IND
TARAPUR-164     SHEIKHPURA-169     SIKANDRA-240     JAMUI-241     JHAJHA-242
CHAKAI-243
S04-40-BR-JAMUI     1ASHOK CHOUDHARY     INC
2GAJADHAR RAJAK     CPI
3BHAGWAN DAS     BSP
4BHUDEO CHOUDHARY     JD(U)
5SHYAM RAJAK     RJD
6ARJUN MANJHI     JGP
7UPENDRA RAVIDAS     SAP
8OM PRAKASH PASWAN     LTSD
9GULAB CHANDRA PASWAN     RKJP
10NUNDEO MANJHI     JVM
11PRASADI PASWAN     JMM
12SUBHASH PASWAN     STPI
13KAPILDEO DAS     IND
14JAY SEKHAR MANJHI     IND
15PAPPU RAJAK     IND
16YOGENDRA PASWAN     IND
17VIJAY PASWAN     IND
18BILAKSHAN RAVIDAS     IND
19SARYUG PASWAN     IND
MANDREM-1     PERNEM-2     BICHOLIM-3     TIVIM-4     MAPUSA-5     SIOLIM-6
SALIGAO-7     CALANGUTE-8     PORVORIM-9     ALDONA-10
S05-1-GA-NORTH GOA     1CHRISTOPHER FONSECA     CPI
2JITENDRA RAGHURAJ DESHPRABHU     NCP
3RAUT PANDURANG DATTARAM     MAG
4SHRIPAD YESSO NAIK     BJP
5UPENDRA CHANDRU GAONKAR     SHS
6NARACINVA SURYA SALGAONKAR     IND
7MARTHA D SOUZA     IND
PONDA-21     SIRODA-22     MARCAIM-23     MORMUGAO-24     VASCO-DA-GAMA-25
DABOLIM-26     CORTALIM-27     NUVEM-28     CURTORIM-29     FATORDA-30
S05-2-GA-SOUTH GOA     1COSME FRANCISCO CAITANO SARDINHA     INC
2ADV NARENDRA KESHAV SAWAIKAR     BJP
3ADV RAJU MANGESHKAR ALIAS RAJENDRA NAIK     CPI
4ROHIDAS HARICHANDRA BORKAR     SGF
5MATANHY SALDANHA     UGDP
6DIAS JAWAHAR     IND
7DERICK DIAS     IND
8FRANCISCO ANTONIO JOAO DE PHILOMENO FERNANDES     IND
9MULLA SALIM     IND
10SALUNKE SMITA PRAVEEN     IND
11HAMZA KHAN     IND
ABDASA-1     MANDVI-2     BHUJ-3     ANJAR-4     GANDHIDHAM-5     RAPAR-6     MORBI-65
S06-1-GJ-KACHCHH     1JAT POONAMBEN VELJIBHAI     BJP
2DANICHA VALJIBHAI PUNAMCHANDRA     INC
3NAMORI MOHANBHAI LADHABHAI     BSP
4CHAUHAN MOTILAL DEVJIBHA     LPSP
5DR TINA MAGANBHAI PARMAR     BNJD
6DUNGARIYA BHARMALBHAI NARANBHAI     SP
7PARMAR MUKESHBHAI MANDANBHAI     IJP
8BADIYA RAMESH GANGJI     RKSP
9KANJI ABHABHAI MAHESHWARI     IND
10GARVA ASMAL THAKARSHI     IND
11GOVIND JIVABHAI DAFADA     IND
12MAHESHWARI GANGJI DAYABHAI     IND
13MAHESHWARI DHANJIBHAI KARSHANBHAI     IND
14MANGALIYA LILBAI JIVANBHAI     IND
15MUNSHI BHURALAL KHIMJIBHAI     IND
16VANZARA HIRABEN DALPATBHAI     IND
17SARESA NANJI BHANJIBHAI     IND
VAV-7     THARAD-8     DHANERA-9     DANTA-10     PALANPUR-12     DEESA-13
DEODAR-14
S06-2-GJ-BANASKANTHA     1GADHVI MUKESHKUMAR BHAIRAVDANJI     INC
2CHETANBHAI KALABHAI SOLANKI     BSP
3CHAUDHARI HARIBHAI PARATHIBHAI     BJP
4AMRUTBHAI LAKHUBHAI PATELFOSI     MJP
5KATARIYA HASMUKHBHAI RAVJIBHAI     LSWP
6LODHA ISHVARBHAI MAHADEVBHAI     ABJS
7KARNAVAT YOGESHKUMAR BHIKHABHAI     IND
8PARSANI MAHMAD SIKANDAR JALALBHAI     IND
9PUROHIT ASHOKBHAI CHHAGANBHAI     IND
10MAJIRANA BHOPAJI AASHAJI     IND
11ROOTHAR LEBUJI PARBATJI     IND
12SHARDABEN BHIKHABHAI PARMAR     IND
13SAVJIBHAI PATHUBHAI RAJGOR     IND
14SIPAI AAIYUBBHAI IBRAHIMBHAI     IND
15SHRIMALI ASHOKBHAI BALCHANDBHAI     IND
VADGAM-11     KANKREJ-15     RADHANPUR-16     CHANASMA-17     PATAN-18
SIDHPUR-19     KHERALU-20
S06-3-GJ-PATAN     1KHOKHAR MAHEBOOBKHAN RAHEMATKHAN     BSP
2JAGDISH THAKOR     INC
3BAROT SANJAYBHAI MAGANBHAI     NCP
4RATHOD BHAVSINHBHAI DAHYABHAI     BJP
5PATAVAT MAHAMMADBHAI SHARIFBHAI     SP
6PATEL NARANBHAI PRAGDASBHAI     MJP
7RAVAL BHURABHAI MOTIBHAI     BNJD
8KANUBHAI BHURABHAI MAHESHVARI MANDOVARA     IND
9CHAUDHARY KIRTIKUMAR JESANGBHAI     IND
10CHAUDHARY MANSINHBHAI MANABHAI     IND
11JUDAL GANESHBHAI MEGHRAJBHAI     IND
12PATEL DILIPKUMAR LILACHAND     IND
13PATEL MANORBHAI VIRAMDAS     IND
14PATEL RAMESHBHAI GOVINDBHAI     IND
15BRAHMAKSHATRIY NIRUPABEN NATVARLAL     IND
16RAJPUT JAGATSINH SAMANTSING     IND
UNJHA-21     VISNAGAR-22     BECHARAJI-23     KADI-24     MAHESANA-25
VIJAPUR-26     MANSA-37
S06-4-GJ-MAHESANA     1ZALA RUDRADATTSINH VANRAJSINH     BSP
2PATEL JAYSHREEBEN KANUBHAI     BJP
3PATEL JIVABHAI AMBALAL     INC
4THAKOR AMARSINH RAMSINH BABUJI     MJP
5DR P C PATEL MBBS MD     BRP
6BABUBHAI ISHWARBHAI PRAJAPATI     VHS
7CHAVDA SHANKARJI BADARJI     IND
8THAKOR RAMANJI SHIVAJI     IND
9NAYEE KOKILABEN MANUBHAI ALIAS MAHENDRABHAI     IND
10PATEL JIVRAMBHAI HIRDAS     IND
11PATEL MANOJKUMAR BAHECHARDAS     IND
12PATEL LALJIBHAI KESHAVLAL     IND
HIMATNAGAR-27     IDAR-28     KHEDBRAHMA-29     BHILODA-30     MODASA-31
BAYAD-32     PRANTIJ-33
S06-5-GJ-SABARKANTHA     1CHAUHAN MAHENDRASINH     BJP
2MISTRY MADHUSUDAN     INC
3RAMLAVAT VIKRAMSINH LAXMANSINH     BSP
4KADARI MOLANA RIYAZ     SP
5PARMAR MINABA DIPSINH     IJP
6SINHALI DASHRATH CHANDULAL     CPI(ML)(L)
7CHAUHAN MAHENDRASINH PADAMSINH     IND
8TRIVEDI BALKRUSHN PRANLAL     IND
9PATEL KANTIBHAI KHUSHALBHAI     IND
10PATEL DANABHAI BECHARBHAI     IND
11RATHOD SABIRMIYA AMIRMIYA     IND
12SOLANKI CHHAGANBHAI KEVALABHAI     IND
GANDHINAGAR NORTH-36     KALOL-38     SANAND-40     GHATLODIA-41     VEJALPUR-42
NARANPURA-45     SABARMATI-55
S06-6-GJ-GANDHINAGAR     1LKADVANI     BJP
2PATEL SURESHKUMAR CHATURDAS SURESH PATEL     INC
3RAKESH PANDEY     BSP
4ASHOKKUMAR ISHVARBHAI PATEL     BNJD
5KHALIFA SAMSUDDIN NASIRUDDIN JUGNU     LSWP
6TRIVEDI SUNILBHAI MANUBHAI     MJP
7FIROZ DEHLVI     AIMF
8MEMON FATAMABEN FARUKBHAI     IJP
9KALPESHKUMAR RAJANIKANT MODI     IND
10THAKUR RAKESHBHAI RAJDEVSINGH     IND
11PATEL SIDDHESH DINESHBHAI     IND
12PARIKH HETA KUMARPAL     IND
13BRAHMBHATT SANJAYBHAI AMARKUMAR     IND
14MAKWANA ANILKUMAR SOMABHAI     IND
15DRMALLIKA SARABHAI     IND
16MAHANTSHRI DHARAMDASBAPU     IND
17RAHUL CHIMANBHAI MEHTA     IND
18VAGHELA SUKHDEVSINH PARBATSINH     IND
19SHAH MUKESH     IND
DEHGAM-34     GANDHINAGAR SOUTH-35     VATVA-43     NIKOL-46     NARODA-47
THAKKARBAPA NAGAR-48     BAPUNAGAR-49
S06-7-GJ-AHMEDABAD EAST     1PATEL BHOLABHAI VALJIBHAI KAKDIYA     NCP
2BABARIYA DIPAKBHAI RATILAL     INC
3VIRUBHAI N VANZARA     BSP
4HARIN PATHAK     BJP
5PATEL PRAVIN RAMBHAI     MJP
6PREMHARI RAMESHCHANDRA SHARMA     NLHP
7BHATT SANJIV INDRAVADAN     BNJD
8RAJPUT RANJEETSINGH RAMSHANKARSINH     IJP
9RAJPUT SANJITKUMAR RADHAKRISHNASINH     SP
10DR N T SENGAL     LSWP
11HASRATH JAYRAM PAGARE     RSPS
12KHODABHAI LALJIBHAI DESAI     IND
13THAKKAR PARESHBHAI RASIKLAL     IND
14PATEL BHAVINBHAI AMRUTBHAI     IND
15BUDHDHPRIYA JASVANT SOMABHAI     IND
16MAURYA RAJESH HARIRAM     IND
17SHARMA ANILKUMAR BRIJENDRABHAI     IND
18SHARMA BRIJESHKUMAR UJAGARLAL     IND
ELLISBRIDGE-44     AMRAIWADI-50     DARIAPUR-51     JAMALPUR – KHADIA-52
MANINAGAR-53     DANILIMDA-54     ASARWA-56
S06-8-GJ-AHMEDABAD WEST     1PARMAR SHAILESH MANHARLAL     INC
2DR PRAVIN S SOLANKI     BSP
3DR SOLANKI KIRITBHAI PREMJIBHAI     BJP
4PARMAR MOHANBHAI KARSHANBHAI     LPSP
5MAKWANA ISHWARBHAI DHANABHAI     LJP
6VIJAYKUMAR MANJIBHAI VADHER     AIMF
7SAVLE BHIKA FULA     RPI(A)
8SHIRSATH VEDUBHAI KAUTIKBHAI     IJP
9SANKHALIYA NARENDRASINH MANSINH     LSWP
10CHAUHAN PRAHLADBHAI NATTHUBHAI     IND
11VANZARA DALPATBHAI KHIMABHAI     IND
12VORA RATNABEN DAHYABHAI     IND
13SHAH ISHWARBHAI KHANDAS     IND
14SOLANKI KANTIBHAI HEMABHAI     IND
15SOLANKI RAMESHBHAI DANABHAI     IND
16SOLANKI VITTHALBHAI MAGANBHAI     IND
VIRAMGAM-39     DHANDHUKA-59     DASADA-60     LIMBDI-61     WADHWAN-62
CHOTILA-63     DHRANGADHRA-64
S06-9-GJ-SURENDRANAGAR     1KOLI PATEL SOMABHAI     INC
2PATEL MOHANBHAI DAHYABHAI     BSP
3MER LALJIBHAI CHATURBHAI     BJP
4JAGRUTIBEN BABULAL GADA SHAH     MJP
5DHAVANIYA BACHUBHAI CHHAGANBHAI     LPSP
6PATADIYA KHIMJIBHAI HARAJIVANBHAI     KKJHS
7VAGHELA SATUBHA KANUBHA     ABJS
8KORDIA ALTAFBHAI VALIBHAI     IND
9JADAV BHAGWANBHAI MATHURBHAI     IND
10DABHI MOHANBHAI TULSHIBHAI     IND
11DERVALIA MEDHABHAI KALABHAI     IND
12NAYAKPRA HITESH BHAGVANGIBHAI     IND
13PATEL ASHOKKUMAR CHIMANLAL     IND
14BHARATBHAI RAMNIKLAL MAKWANA     IND
15BHATIYA NARANBHAI KEHARBHAI     IND
16UKABHAI AMARABHAI MAKWANA     IND
17MER MAVJIBHAI KUKABHAI     IND
18RABA HARSURBHAI RAMBHAI     IND
19SAVUKIYA LALJIBHAI MOHANLAL     IND
20SOLANKI KARSHANBHAI JIVABHAI     IND
TANKARA-66     WANKANER-67     RAJKOT EAST-68     RAJKOT WEST-69     RAJKOT
SOUTH-70     RAJKOT RURAL-71     JASDAN-72
S06-10-GJ-RAJKOT     1KIRANKUMAR VALJIBHAI BHALODIA PATEL     BJP
2KUVARJIBHAI MOHANBHAI BAVALIA     INC
3DHEDHI DALEECHANDBHAI LIRABHAI PATEL     BSP
4SUDHIR JOSHI     CPM
5KUBAVAT BABUDAS CHHAGANDAS     ABJS
6GOKALBHAI KHODABHAI PARMAR     LPSP
7JASVANTBHAI RANCHHODBHAI SABHAYA     SP
8JADEJA SATUBHA AMARSANG     NSCP
9NARENDRASINH TAPUBHA JADEJA     RKSP
10BABULAL DEVJIBHAI GHAVA     LJP
11VEKARIA ALPESHBHAI KESHUBHAI     MJP
12AJITSINH HARISINH JADEJA     IND
13ARVINDBHAI JADAVJIBHAI RATHOD     IND
14KESHUBHAI DHANJIBHAI VEKARIYA     IND
15CHAVDA LAKHMANBHAI DEVJIBHAI     IND
16DR ZAKIRHUSEN MATHAKIYA     IND
17DUDHATRA MUKUNDBHAI GOVINDBHAI     IND
18NAYANBHAI HASHMUKHBHAI UPADHYAY     IND
19PRAVINBHAI MEGHJIBHAI DENGADA     IND
20BHIKHABHAI KURJIBHAI SADADIYA     IND
21MULTANI SUBHANBHAI POPATBHAI     IND
22RABARI MOMAIYABHAI ALABHAI     IND
23DRRAJESHKUMAR SHANTIBHAI MAKADIA PATEL     IND
24VEKARIYA PRAGJIBHAI NATHUBHAI     IND
25SAROLA GEETABEN MANJIBHAI     IND
26HARSODA MAHESH HIRABHAI     IND
27HIRABHAI GORDHANBHAI CHANGELA     IND
GONDAL-73     JETPUR-74     DHORAJI-75     PORBANDAR-83     KUTIYANA-84
MANAVADAR-85     KESHOD-88
S06-11-GJ-PORBANDAR     1KHACHARIYA MANSUKHBHAI SHAMJIBHAI     BJP
2CHANDRAVADIYA MEHULKUMAR KARSANBHAI     BSP
3RADADIYA VITTHALBHAI HANSRAJBHAI     INC
4JADEJA NATHABHAI JIVABHAI     IJP
5PATOLIYA MANOJBHAI SAMJIBHAI     IND
6BHATT NITINBHAI VRUJLAL     IND
7RAJENDRA AMRUTLAL PARMAR     IND
KALAVAD-76     JAMNAGR RURAL-77     JAMNAGAR NORTH-78     JAMNAGAR SOUTH-79
JAMJODHPUR-80     KHAMBHALIA-81     DWARKA-82
S06-12-GJ-JAMNAGAR     1AHIR VIKRAMBHAI ARJANBHAI MADAM     INC
2CHAVDA JAYSUKHBHAI TRIKAMBHAI     BSP
3MUNGRA RAMESHBHAI DEVRAJBHAI     BJP
4CHAUHAN DINESHBHAI KALABHAI     RPI(A)
5JADEJA HITENDRASINH JAYVANTSINH     RKSP
6MANHARBHAI KACHARABHAI RATHOD     RSP(S)
7DR VASANTBHAI MANILAL SANGHAVI     ABJS
8VADHER CHANDUBHA MANUBHA     MJP
9GOJIYA VIRABHAI MALDEBHAI     IND
10CHAVDA DEVAYATBHAI JIVABHAI     IND
11DOSANI IDRISBHAI ISMAILBHAI     IND
12DEVGANA GAURIBEN MOHANBHAI     IND
13DHARMENDRABHAI MAGANLAL PATEL     IND
14NOYDA MAMAD NATHUBHAI     IND
15PADHIYAR GOVINDBHAI LALJIBHAI     IND
16PARMAR BHURALAL MEGHJIBHAI     IND
17POPATPUTRA RAFIK ABUBAKAR     IND
18BHAGAD SALIM OSMAN     IND
19MAHESHBHAI PARSOTAMBHAI VADI     IND
20VYAS RAJESH SHIVSHANKAR     IND
21SACHADA HABIBBHAI ISHABHAI     IND
22SAGATHIYA VINODBHAI VIRJIBHAI     IND
JUNAGADH-86     VISAVADAR-87     MANGROL-89     SOMNATH-90     TALALA-91
KODINAR-92     UNA-93
S06-13-GJ-JUNAGADH     1BARAD JASHUBHAI DHANABHAI     INC
2SOLANKI DINUBHAI BOGHABHAI     BJP
3KUNJADIYA VALLABHBHAI RAMBHAI     ABMSD
4CHANDULAL BHANUBHAI DHADUK CHANDRESHBHAI     MJP
5DANGAR BRIJESH RAMBHAI     RWS
6BHUT ASHOKBHAI BHIMJIBHAI     RSP(S)
7MAHIDA CHANDRASINH HAMIRBHAI     RPI(A)
8HUSENKHAN SARVARKHAN PATHAN     SP
9HETALKUMAR NAROTAMBHAI THUMBAR     BNJD
10KAMALIYA VASHRAMBHAI PUNJABHAI     IND
11DR KOYANI BHARATKUMAR KANJIBHAI     IND
12CHAND MOHAMAD YUSUF UMARBHAI     IND
13PARMAR SAVJIBHAI BHIKHABHAI     IND
14VALA VIRAMBHAI NATHUBHAI     IND
15SEVRA BACHUBHAI KALABHAI     IND
16HARILAL RANCHHODBHAI CHAUHAN     IND
DHARI-94     AMRELI-95     LATHI-96     SAVARKUNDLA-97     RAJULA-98     MAHUVA-99
GARIADHAR-101
S06-14-GJ-AMRELI     1KACHHADIA NARANBHAI     BJP
2NILABEN VIRJIBHAI THUMMAR     INC
3DBBHAROLA     BSP
4MADHUBHAI BHUVA     NCP
5KASVALA JAYSUKHABHAI LALJIBHAI     LSWP
6BARAIYA CHANDRAKANT RAMJIBHAI CHANDU PATEL     SP
7MAKAVANA SAMATBHAI BHIKHABHAI     RKSP
8RAMESH GOHIL     MJP
9ASLALIYA CHANDUBHAI RANABHAI     IND
10KHOKHAR GULMAHMAD ISMILE     IND
11GOHIL RAMBHAI JINABHAI     IND
12NILABEN THUMAR     IND
13RAMESHBHAI JASHABHAI PARMAR     IND
14VALJIBHAI LALLUBHAI SHIROYA     IND
15SANGANI RAMESHBHAI KANUBHAI     IND
16SUKHADIA NATHALAL V     IND
TALAJA-100     PALITANA-102     BHAVNAGAR RURAL-103     BHAVNAGAR EAST-104
BHAVNAGAR WEST-105     GADHADA-106     BOTAD-107
S06-15-GJ-BHAVNAGAR     1GOHILMAHAVIRSINHBHAGIRATHSINH     INC
2RANA RAJENDRASINH GHANSHYAMSINH     BJP
3BORICHA VALJIBHAI BAGHABHAI     BSP
4ATUL HARSHADRAI PANDYA     BNJD
5GOHIL NANAJIBHAI MADHABHAI     RPI(A)
6ZADAFIA GORDHANBHAI PRAGJIBHAI     MJP
7DABHI DEVJIBHAI MEGHABHAI     SJP(R)
8YADAVKOLI TULSHIBHAI RAMJIBHAI     SP
9SAPARIA DINESH NANUBHAI     LPSP
10KATARIA ZINABHAI NAGAJIBHAI     IND
11CHUDASAMA MEPABHAI MAVJIBHAI     IND
12CHAUHAN DHIRUBHAI KARSHANBHAI     IND
13NARESHBHAI NANAJIBHAI SONANI     IND
14PUNANI MUKESHBHI MAGANBHAI     IND
15MISOLANKI     IND
16HARIN RAMNIKLAL MAKWANA     IND
KHAMBHAT-108     BORSAD-109     ANKLAV-110     UMRETH-111     ANAND-112
PETLAD-113     SOJITRA-114
S06-16-GJ-ANAND     1PATEL DIPAKBHAI CHIMANBHAI     BJP
2PARMAR BABUBHAI BECHARBHAI     NCP
3SOLANKI BHARATBHAI MADHAVSINH     INC
4PARMAR HITENDRASINH MOHANSINH     SP
5RATHOD HIMMATBHAI MOHANHAI     IJP
6SAMIRBHAI GIRISHBHAI PATEL     SVPP
7CHAVDA KAUSHIKKMAR RAJIVBHAI     IND
8DAVE AMRISHBHAI VADILAL     IND
9PATEL JAYESHBHAI ARVINDBHAI     IND
10BHARATBHAI VINUBHAI BHOI     IND
11MALEK GULAMMAHMMED ABDULKARIM     IND
12LALJIBHAI GANESHJI PUROHIT     IND
13LEELABEN RAVJIBHAI PARMAR     IND
14SAIYED MAHEBUBALI HUSAINMIYA     IND
15SOLANKI BHARAT BABUBHAI     IND
DASKROI-57     DHOLKA-58     MATAR-115     NADIAD-116     MEHMEDABAD-117
MAHUDHA-118     KAPADVANJ-120
S06-17-GJ-KHEDA     1CHAUHAN DEVUSINH JESINGBHAI     BJP
2CHAUHAN RATANSINH UDESINH     BSP
3DINSHA PATEL     INC
4DODIYA HEMALSINH DAJIBHAI ALIAS DODIYA BATUKSINH     MJP
5ALPESHSINH SURUBHA VAGHELA     IND
6CHRISTI VASANTBHAI OTABHAI     IND
7KHALIFA ZAKIRHUSEN GULAMNABI     IND
8PATEL BHARATKUMAR VISHNUBHAI     IND
9SHEKH TAUFIKHUSEN GULAMRASUL     IND
THASRA-119     BALASINOR-121     LUNAWADA-122     SHEHRA-124     MORVA HADAF-125
GODHRA-126     KALOL-127
S06-18-GJ-PANCHMAHAL     1CHAUHAN PRABHATSINH PRATAPSINH     BJP
2BAROT PRAKASHKUMAR MANEKLAL     BSP
3VAGHELA SHANKERSINH LAXMANSINH     INC
4MANSURI MUKHTYAR MOHAMAD     ABMSD
5SHAIKH KALIM ALATIF     LJP
SANTRAMPUR-123     FATEPURA-129     JHALOD-130     LIMKHEDA-131     DAHOD-132
GARBADA-133     DEVGADBARIA-134
S06-19-GJ-DAHOD     1KATARA SINGJIBHAI JALJIBHAI     CPM
2KALARA RAMSINGBHAI NANJIBHAI     BSP
3DAMOR SOMJIBHAI PUNJABHAI     BJP
4DR PRABHA KISHOR TAVIAD     INC
5MEDA KALSINHBHAI TAJSINHBHAI     NCP
6PARMAR DINESHBHAI NAGJIBHAI     IJP
7KCMUNIA ADVOCATE     SP
SAVLI-135     VAGHODIA-136     VADODARA CITY-141     SAYAJIGUNJ-142
AKOTA-143     RAOPURA-144     MANJALPUR-145
S06-20-GJ-VADODARA     1GAEKWAD SATYAJITSINH DULIPSINH     INC
2PUROHIT VINAYKUMAR RAMANBHAI     BSP
3BALKRISHNA KHANDERAO SHUKLA BALU SHUKLA     BJP
4GIRISHBHAI MADHAVLAL BHAVSAR     IND
5THAVARDAS AMULRAI CHOITHANI     IND
6TAPAN DASGUPTA TAPANBHAI     IND
7VASAVA HARILAL SHANABHAI     IND
HALOL-128     CHHOTA UDAIPUR-137     JETPUR-138     SANKHEDA-139     DABHOI-140
PADRA-146     NANDOD-148
S06-21-GJ-CHHOTA UDAIPUR     1BHIL PRAKASHBHAI SOMABHAI     BSP
2RATHWA NARANBHAI JEMLABHAI     INC
3RATHWA RAMSINGBHAI PATALBHAI     BJP
4VASAVABHIL VITTHALBHAI VENIBHAI     IND
KARJAN-147     DEDIAPADA-149     JAMBUSAR-150     VAGRA-151     JHAGADIA-152
BHARUCH-153     ANKLESHWAR-154
S06-22-GJ-BHARUCH     1UMERJI AHMED UGHARATDAR AZIZ TANKARVI     INC
2PANDEY SANATKUMAR RAJARAM     BSP
3BALVANTSINH VIJAYSINH PARMAR     NCP
4MANSUKHBHAI DHANJIBHAI VASAVA     BJP
5KANAKSINH MANGROLA     SP
6NARENDRASINH RANDHIRSINH VASHI     LSWP
7PATEL NARESHKUMAR BHAGVANBHAI NARESH PATEL     MJP
8PATEL MEHRUNNISHA VALLI ADAM     LJP
9VASAVA CHHOTUBHAI AMARSINHBHAI     JD(U)
10SURESHBHAI GORDHANBHAI VASAVA     ABJS
11GOHIL HEMANTKUMAR JERAMBHAI     IND
12DILIPKUMAR GULSINGBHAI VASAVA     IND
13PATEL THAKORBHAI CHANDULAL     IND
14LAKDAWALA SHAKIL AHEMAD     IND
15LAD MAHIPATBHAI MAGANBHAI     IND
MANGROL-156     MANDVI-157     KAMREJ-158     BARDOLI-169     MAHUVA-170
VYARA-171     NIZAR-172
S06-23-GJ-BARDOLI     1GAMIT RANJANBEN CHIMANBHAI     BSP
2CHAUDHARI TUSHARBHAI AMRASINHBHAI     INC
3PATEL SONABEN BHIKHUBHAI     CPI
4VASAVA RITESHKUMAR AMARSINH     BJP
5CHAUDHARI KAMLESHBHAI PRABHUBHAI     JD(U)
6PATEL VIJAYKUMAR HARIBHAI     MJP
7RATHOD PRAVINBHAI BHULABHAI     SP
8ARJUNBHAI BHALJIBHAI CHAUDHARI     IND
9GAMIT THAKORBHAI MANEKJIBHAI     IND
10GAMIT SUMANBHAI NARSINHBHAI     IND
11RATHOD SUKABHAI MANGABHAI     IND
12VASAVA PRAVINSINH JAGATSINH     IND
OLPAD-155     SURAT EAST-159     SURAT NORTH-160     VARACHHA ROAD-161
KARANJ-162     KATARGAM-166     SURAT WEST-167
S06-24-GJ-SURAT     1AJAYKUMAR DINESHBHAI PATEL     BSP
2GAJERA DHIRUBHAI HARIBHAI     INC
3SHRIMATI DARSHANA VIKRAM JARDOSH     BJP
4PATEL KANUBHAI HARIBHAI     LSWP
5PRAJAPATI MUKESHBHAI AMBALIYA     LPSP
6FAKIRBHAI CHAUHAN     MJP
7BATHVAR NARESHBHAI NANJIBHAI     RPI(A)
8SHASHIKANT KAPURE     RPIE
9SURESHBHAI CHHAGANBHAI CHOTALIYA     RKSP
10NAGMAL PRABHAKARBHAI SOMABHAI     IND
11PATEL SAVITABEN CHHAGANBHAI     IND
12PYARELAL BHARTI     IND
13PROF BAJPAI RAKESH R     IND
14MAKVANA ANANDBHAI KESHAVBHAI KOLI     IND
15MOHAMMAD AIYUB ABDUL RAHEMAN SHAIKH     IND
LIMBAYAT-163     UDHNA-164     MAJURA-165     CHORYASI-168     JALALPORE-174
NAVSARI-175     GANDEVI-176
S06-25-GJ-NAVSARI     1DHANSUKHA RAJPUT     INC
2NAIK YOGESHKUMAR THAKORBHAI     NCP
3C R PATIL     BJP
4SHAILESHBHAI BISHESWAR SHRIVASTAV     BSP
5AAZADKUMAR CHATURBHAI PATEL     SVPP
6YADAV GANGAPRASAD LALANBHAI     MJP
7KANUBHAI DEVJIBHAI SUKHADIA     IND
8JASHAVANTBHAI DALPATBHAI PANCHAL ADVOCATE     IND
9TARUNBHAI CHAMPAKBHAI PATEL     IND
10PATEL PRAVINCHANDRA MANILAL     IND
11RATHOD GOVINDBHAI LAXMANBHAI RIKSHAWALA     IND
12VARANKAR KAMALBEN KASHIRAM     IND
13SHATRUDHANDAS OMKARDAS SUGAT BAIRAGI     IND
14SATYAJIT JAYANTILAL SHETH     IND
DANGS-173     VANSDA-177     DHARAMPUR-178     VALSAD-179     PARDI-180
KAPRADA-181     UMBERGAON-182
S06-26-GJ-VALSAD     1KISHANBHAI VESTABHAI PATEL     INC
2GAVLI CHHAGANBHAI PILUBHAI     BSP
3PATEL DHIRUBHAI CHHAGANBHAI DR DCPATEL     BJP
4PANKAJKUMAR PARABHUBHAI PATEL     ADSP
5BHOYE NAYNESHBHAI MADHUBHAI     SP
6VARALI LAXMANBHAI CHHAGANBHAI     CPI(ML)(L)
7PATEL RAMBHAI KOYABHAI     IND
KALKA-1     PANCHKULA-2     NARAINGARH-3     AMBALA CANTT.-4     AMBALA CITY-5
MULANA-6     SADHAURA-7     JAGADHRI-8     YAMUNANAGAR-9
S07-1-HR-AMBALA     1CHANDER PAL     BSP
2RATTAN LAL KATARIA     BJP
3SELJA         INC
4DALVIR SINGH     HJCBL
5HEM RAJ     LJP
6AMAR SINGH     IND
7NARINDER KUMAR     IND
RADAUR-10     LADWA-11     SHAHBAD-12     THANESAR-13     PEHOWA-14     GUHLA-15
KALAYAT-16     KAITHAL-17     PUNDRI-18
S07-2-HR-KURUKSHETRA     1ASHOK KUMAR ARORA     INLD
2GURDYAL SINGH SAINI     BSP
3NAVEEN JINDAL     INC
4JASWANT SINGH CHEEMA     HJCBL
5PARDHAN CHAND CHAUHAN     SP
6DR ASHWINI SHARMA HRITTWAL     IND
7ATAM PARKASH     IND
8TARSEM LAL     IND
9YASH PAL     IND
10RAN SINGH     IND
11VIRENDER SINGH     IND
12VISHNU BHAGWAN AGGARWAL     IND
13SUNEETA DHARIWAL     IND
14SUBHASH MAHENDRA     IND
NARWANA-38     TOHANA-39     FATEHABAD-40     RATIA-41     KALAWALI-42
DABWALI-43     RANIA-44     SIRSA-45     ELLENABAD-46
S07-3-HR-SIRSA     1ASHOK TANWAR     INC
2RAJESH KUMAR     BSP
3COMRADE RAM KUMAR     CPM
4DR SITA RAM     INLD
5RAJ KUMAR NAGAR     JKNPP
6RAJENDRA PRASAD     HJCBL
7SWARN SINGH     RASJP
8HANS RAJ     RPI
9JAIBIR SINGH     IND
10DESRAJ     IND
11NARENDER PAL     IND
12PAWAN KUMAR     IND
13PUSHPA RANI     IND
14VAZIR SINGH     IND
15SHANKER LAL     IND
UCHANA KALAN-37     ADAMPUR-47     UKLANA-48     NARNAUND-49     HANSI-50
BARWALA-51     HISAR-52     NALWA-53     BAWANI KHERA-59
S07-4-HR-HISAR     1JAI PARKASH     INC
2RAM DAYAL     BSP
3SAMPAT SINGH     INLD
4KARAN SINGH     BRPP
5KRISHAN KUMAR SO HARIRAM     RASJP
6GULAB SINGH     NELU
7JANG BAHADUR     BHBP
8BHAJAN LAL SO KHERAJ     HJCBL
9ROSHAN LAL     IJP
10SATPAL     SMBHP
11SATPAL SINGH     LJP
12ANUP         IND
13MEHTA ANOOP KUMAR     IND
14AZAD SINGH     IND
15UMRAV SINGH     IND
16KULDEEP SINGH     IND
17KULWANT SINGH     IND
18ARYA KRISHAN     IND
19KRISHAN KUMAR SO GOPI RAM     IND
20CHHOTU RAM SO KIRTA RAM     IND
21CHHOTU RAM SO LADHU RAM     IND
22JAGDISH CHANDER ASIJA     IND
23JAG RAM     IND
24JOGENDER KUMAR     IND
25DEVI LAL     IND
26DEVENDER     IND
27NAND KISHOR     IND
28PARVESH     IND
29BHAJAN LAL SO DHARAMPAL     IND
30BHATERI     IND
31MANU DIGVIJAY SINGH     IND
32RAJ KUMAR     IND
33RAJENDER     IND
34ROHTAS     IND
35SHAMSHER     IND
36SHARVAN KUMAR     IND
37SANJAY KUMAR     IND
38SANDEEP     IND
NILOKHERI-19     INDRI-20     KARNAL-21     GHARAUNDA-22     ASSANDH-23     PANIPAT
RURAL-24     PANIPAT CITY-25     ISRANA-26     SAMALKHA-27
S07-5-HR-KARNAL     1ARVIND KUMAR SHARMA     INC
2MAM CHAND     CPI
3MARATHA VIRENDER VERMA     BSP
4IDSWAMI     BJP
5KALPANA SINGH     RPI(A)
6PREM KUMAR     SHS
7MANOJ KUMAR KASHYAP     VAJP
8DR RAMESH CHHABRA     HJCBL
9RAJIV AHUJA     SP
10RAM PAL     RASAP
11HAWA SINGH     RASJP
12ANOOP SINGH     IND
13ASHOK KUMAR     IND
14DUSHYANT KUMAR     IND
15NARENDER SAROHA     IND
16BALWAN SINGH RUHAL     IND
17MUKESH KUMARI     IND
18RAMESH SINGLA     IND
19LAL SINGH KASHYAP     IND
20SHIV PARSAD     IND
21SANJEEV     IND
22ARYA SUSHIL GARG     IND
23SUSHIL GURJAR SIRSI     IND
GANAUR-28     RAI-29     KHARKHAUDA-30     SONIPAT-31     GOHANA-32     BARODA-33
JULANA-34     SAFIDON-35     JIND-36
S07-6-HR-SONIPAT     1KISHAN SINGH SANGWAN     BJP
2JITENDER SINGH     INC
3DEVRAJ DEEWAN     BSP
4SUKHBIR SINGH     NCP
5PT UMESH SHARMA     HJCBL
6OM PARKASH MEHTA     BHC
7KRISHAN KUMAR     LJP
8GEJENDER     KKJHS
9JYOTI PARKASH     SP
10MADANGOPAL     RDMP
11RAJ PAL     CPIMLL
12RAJENDER SINGH     UWF
13ROHTASH REDHU     SMBHP
14SUSHILA     JCP
15DALBIR SINGH     IND
16SANT DHARAMVIR CHOTIWALA     IND
17BALWAN KASHYAP     IND
18BIJENDER KUMAR     IND
19RAJESH KHAN MACHHRI     IND
20DR VEERENDER ARYAVRAT     IND
21SHIV NARAYAN     IND
MEHAM-60     GARHI SAMPLA-KILOI-61     ROHTAK-62     KALANAUR-63
BAHADURGARH-64     BADLI-65     JHAJJAR-66     BERI-67     KOSLI-73
S07-7-HR-ROHTAK     1DEEPENDER SINGH     INC
2NAFE SINGH RATHEE     INLD
3RAJ KUMAR     BSP
4KRISHAN MURTI     HJCBL
5RAJBIR         IJP
6SUDESH     RPI(A)
7SUDESH KUMAR AGGARWAL     SMBHP
8ANUP SINGH MATANHEL     IND
9ASHOK         IND
10ASHA NAND     IND
11KARAN SINGH     IND
12GORAV     IND
13JASMER     IND
14JASVIR ARYA     IND
15RISHAL SINGH     IND
16SATYAWAN RANGA     IND
LOHARU-54     BADHRA-55     DADRI-56     BHIWANI-57     TOSHAM-58     ATELI-68
MAHENDRAGARH-69     NARNAUL-70     NANGAL CHAUDHRY-71
S07-8-HR-BHIWANI-MAHENDRAGARH     1AJAY SINGH CHAUTALA     INLD
2ANIL KAUSHIK     NCP
3VIKRAM SINGH     BSP
4SHRUTI CHOUDHRY     INC
5JAI SINGH     IJP
6NARENDER SINGH     HJCBL
7NEELKANWAL  NEELAM AGGARWAL     SMBHP
8MAHENDER SINGH     BHBP
9VED PRAKASH     NSSP
10SAROJ YADAV     SP
11HANSRAJ     RPI(A)
12AJAY SINGH     IND
13ABHAY SINGH     IND
14JAIMAL SINGH     IND
15DHARMENDER SINGH     IND
16DR PURAN MAL SHARMA     IND
17PYARELAL     IND
18BIRENDER SINGH     IND
19MANMOHAN SINGH     IND
20ENGINEER MAHABIR SINGH YADAV     IND
21RAJ KUMAR     IND
22RAJESH KUMAR SO BRIJ LAL     IND
23RAJESH KUMAR SO HAWA SINGH     IND
24LAXMI NARAYAN ASEEJA     IND
25VINOD KUMAR     IND
26SHRICHAND     IND
27SURENDER     IND
28SURESH KUMAR     IND
29HARISH KUMAR     IND
BAWAL-72     REWARI-74     PATAUDI-75     BADSHAHPUR-76     GURGAON-77     SOHNA-78
NUH-79     FEROZEPUR JHIRKA-80     PUNAHANA-81
S07-9-HR-GURGAON     1INDERJIT SINGH     INC
2ZAKIR HUSSAIN     BSP
3DINESH CHANDER YADAV     NCP
4SUDHA         BJP
5ISHPAL SINGH TOMER     RDMP
6NARVIR SINGH     HJCBL
7PRABHU LAL BATRA     RASAP
8BUDH RAM     JKM
9YASHPAL     LJP
10RAMESH KUMAR     JKNPP
11SATEESH KUMAR SINGH     SMBHP
12SUNIL YADAV     SP
13AMAR MOHMMAD     IND
14KUSHESHWAR BHAGAT     IND
15JAGAN     IND
16NAZIR AHMED     IND
17NARESH YADAV     IND
18NAVEEN     IND
19BALWANT SINGH AGGARWAL     IND
20BIMLA DEVI     IND
21MANBIR SINGH     IND
22RAKESH     IND
23SATBEER SINGH KUNDU     IND
24SATINDER SINGH THAKRAN     IND
HATHIN-82     HODAL-83     PALWAL-84     PRITHLA-85     FARIDABAD NIT-86
BADKHAL-87     BALLABHGARH-88     FARIDABAD-89     TIGAON-90
S07-10-HR-FARIDABAD     1AVTAR SINGH BHADANA     INC
2CHETAN SHARMA     BSP
3RAMCHANDER BAINDA     BJP
4GAJENDER PRATAP BHADANA     AIFB(S)
5CHANDER BHATIA     HJCBL
6DEVINDER     JJJKMC
7NISAR AHMED     RND
8BABU LAL     JUP
9MUKESH KUMAR JOSHI     HYRP
10REKHA SINGH     SMBHP
11LATA RANI     SP
12SUBHASH     RWS
13SURAJ BHAN     RJAP
14AVTAR SINGH     IND
15TEEKA RAM HOODA     IND
16BRIJ BHUSHAN     IND
17YASH PAL NAGAR     IND
18SAMSUDDIN     IND
19SAHI RAM RAWAT     IND
20DR K P SINGH     IND
21SUKHBIR SINGH     IND
22SUNDER SINGH     IND
23HARSH BHATIA     IND
CHURAH-1     CHAMBA-3     DALHOUSIE-4     BHATTIYAT-5     NURPUR-6     INDORA-7
FATEHPUR-8     JAWALI-9     JAWALAMUKHI-12     JAISINGHPUR-13
S08-1-HP-KANGRA     1CHANDER KUMAR     INC
2COLNARINDER SINGH PATHANIA     BSP
3DR RAJAN SUSHANT     BJP
4KESHAB     LJP
5JOGINDER SINGH     SHS
6NIRMLA SHARMA     RWS
7KAPIL KUMAR CHAUDHARY     IND
8DHANI RAM     IND
9PARTAP SINGH     IND
10ROSHAN LAL     IND
BHARMOUR-2     LAHAUL & SPITI-21     MANALI-22     KULLU-23     BANJAR-24
ANNI-25     KARSOG-26     SUNDERNAGAR-27     NACHAN-28     SERAJ-29
S08-2-HP-MANDI     1ONKAR SHAD     CPM
2MAHESHWAR SINGH     BJP
3LALA RAM     BSP
4VIRBHADRA SINGH     INC
5HOOKAM CHAND SHASTRI     RWS
6SHAN MOHAMMAD     IND
DEHRA-10     JASWAN-PRAGPUR-11     DHARAMPUR-32     BHORANJ-36     SUJANPUR-37
HAMIRPUR-38     BARSAR-39     NADAUN-40     CHINTPURNI-41     GAGRET-42
S08-3-HP-HAMIRPUR     1ANURAG SINGH THAKUR     BJP
2NARINDER THAKUR     INC
3MANGAT RAM SHARMA     BSP
4PANKAJ KATNA     SHS
5MALKIAT SINGH     RRD
6RAJ KUMAR     RWS
7DR RAJENDER SHARMA     IND
8ER SANDEEP SHARMA     IND
ARKI-50     NALAGARH-51     DOON-52     SOLAN-53     KASAULI-54     PACHHAD-55
NAHAN-56     SRI RENUKAJI-57     PAONTA SAHIB-58     SHILLAI-59
S08-4-HP-SHIMLA     1DHANI RAM SHANDIL     INC
2VIRENDER KASHYAP     BJP
3SOM NATH     BSP
4GURNAM SINGH CHANDEL     SP
5BRIJ LAL     SHS
6ROOP RAM     IND
7SHURVEER SINGH     IND
KARNAH-1     KUPWARA-2     LOLAB-3     HANDWARA-4     LANGATE-5     URI-6
RAFIABAD-7     SOPORE-8     GUREZ-9     BANDIPORA-10
S09-1-JK-BARAMULLA     1SHARIEF UD DIN SHARIQ     JKN
2GH MUSTAFA KASANA     BSP
3MOHAMMAD IQBAL JAN     JKNPP
4MOHAMMAD DILAWAR MIR     JKPDP
5ZAKIR HUSSAIN SHEIKH     LJP
6SAJAD GANI LONE     JPC
7ASHIQ HUSSAIN GANIE     BCDP
8GH AHMAD MALLA     AIFB
9GH RASOOL BHAT     ANC
10GULAM RASOOL SHAH     JKANC
11GH NABI PARRAY     RPI(A)
12GH MOHMAD SAMOON     IND
13GOWSIA BASHIR     IND
KANGAN-16     GANDERBAL-17     HAZRATBAL-18     ZADIBAL-19     EIDGAH-20
KHANYAR-21     HABBA KADAL-22     AMIRA KADAL-23     SONAWAR-24     BATMALOO-25
S09-2-JK-SRINAGAR     1IFTIKHAR HUSSAIN ANSARI     JKPDP
2AVTAR KRISHAN PANDITA     BJP
3FAROOQ ABDULLAH     JKN
4MOHAMMAD ASHRAF KHAN     BSP
5BILAL AHMAD BHAT     SAP
6KHALIDA BEGUM     JKANC
7ZAHIR ABBAS BHATTI     AIFB(S)
8ABDUL RASHID LONE     RPI(A)
9MUSHTAQ AHMAD     RKSP
10NISSAR AHMAD AHANGAR     BSKRP
11SYED MUJTABA HUSSAIN BUKHARI     IND
12ASHIQ HUSSAIN BHAT     IND
13MEHBOOBA SHAHDAB     IND
14MOHAMMAD AHSAN MIR     IND
15MOHAMMAD ALYAS KUMAR     IND
TRAL-31     PAMPORE-32     PULWAMA-33     RAJPORA-34     WACHI-35     SHOPIAN-36
NOORABAD-37     KULGAM-38     HOM SHALI BUGH-39     ANANTNAG-40
S09-3-JK-ANANTNAG     1PEER MOHD HUSSAIN     JKPDP
2MOHD SIDIQ KHAN     BJP
3MIRZA MEHBOOB BEG     JKN
4NISAR AHMAD KHAN     BSP
5ASIF JEELANI     AIFB
6BASHIR AHMAD KHAN     RNSP
7BASHIR AHMAD MALIK     JKANC
8FAYAZ AHMAD BHAT     SP
9MUSHTAQ AHMAD GANIE     IJP
10MOHD RAFIQ WANI     LJP
11RAJIV MAHAJAN     IND
12GH MOHIUDDIN SHAH     IND
13NAZIR AHMAD BHAT     IND
NUBRA-47     LEH-48     KARGIL-49     ZANSKAR-50
S09-4-JK-LADAKH     1PHUNTSOG NAMGYAL     INC
2GHULAM MURTAZA     JKPDP
3ASGAR ALI KARBALAIE     IND
4THINLESS ANGMO     IND
5HASSAN KHAN     IND
KISHTWAR-51     INDERWAL-52     DODA-53     BHADERWAH-54     RAMBAN-55
BANIHAL-56     GULAB GARH-57     REASI-58     GOOL ARNAS-59     UDHAMPUR-60
S09-5-JK-UDHAMPUR     1ADREES AHMAD TABBASUM     CPI
2BALBIR SINGH     JKPDP
3PROF BHIM SINGH     JKNPP
4RAKESH WAZIR     BSP
5CH LAL SINGH     INC
6DR NIRMAL SINGH     BJP
7BODH RAJ     BCDP
8RAJESH MANCHANDA     RKSP
9KANCHAN SHARMA     BHBP
10MASTER WILLIAM GILL     AIFB
11ATUL SHARMA     IND
12DEV RAJ     IND
13MOHD YOUSUF     IND
14NARESH DOGRA     IND
SAMBA-68     VIJAY PUR-69     NAGROTA-70     GANDHI NAGAR-71     JAMMU EAST-72
JAMMU WEST-73     BISHNAH-74     RANBIR SINGH PURA-75     SUCHET GARH-76     MARH-77
S09-6-JK-JAMMU     1STARLOK SINGH     JKPDP
2HUSSAIN ALI     BSP
3LILA KARAN SHARMA     BJP
4MADAN LAL SHARMA     INC
5UDAY CHAND     DGPP
6SURJIT SINGH G SITARA     RKSP
7SANT RAM     BHBP
8SANJEEV KUMAR MANMOTRA     LJP
9QARI ZAHIR ABBAS BHATTI     AIFB
10ABDUL MAJEED MALIK     BCDP
11ASHOK KUMAR     IND
12BALWAN SINGH     IND
13PARAS RAM POONCHI     IND
14RAMESH CHANDER SHARMA     IND
15SATISH POONCHI     IND
16SANJAY KUMAR     IND
17SHAKEELA BANO     IND
18LABHA RAM GANDHI     IND
19CH MUSHTAQ HUSSAIN CHOUHAN     IND
20NARESH DOGRA     IND
21HILAL AHMED BAIG     IND
NIPPANI-1     CHIKKODI-SADALGA-2     ATHANI-3     KAGWAD-4     KUDACHI-5
RAYBAG-6     HUKKERI-7     YEMKANMARDI-10
S10-1-KA-CHIKKODI     1KATTI RAMESH VISHWANATH     BJP
2PRAKASH BABANNA HUKKERI     INC
3SHIVANAND WANTAMURI SIDDAMALLAPPA     BSP
4BANASHANKARI BHIMAPPA ITTAPPA     IND
5MALLAPPA MARUTI KHATANVE     IND
6YASHWANT MANOHAR SUTAR     IND
7SHAILA SURESH KOLI     IND
ARABHAVI-8     GOKAK-9     BELGAUM UTTAR-11     BELGAUM DAKSHIN-12     BELGAUM
RURAL-13     BAILHONGAL-16     SAUNDATTI YELLAMMA-17     RAMDURG-18
S10-2-KA-BELGAUM     1AMARSINH VASANTRAO PATIL     INC
2ANGADI SURESH CHANNABASAPPA     BJP
3A B PATIL     JD(S)
4RAMANAGOUDA SIDDANGOUDA PATIL     BSP
5ALLAPPA RAMAPPA PATIL     IND
6KASTURI BASANAGOUDA BHAVI     IND
7MOHAN H GADIWADDAR     IND
8RAMCHANDRA MAREPPA TORGALCHALAWADI     IND
9VIJAYKUMAR JEENDATTA UPADHYE     IND
10HANAJI ASHOK PANDU     IND
MUDHOL-19     TERDAL-20     JAMKHANDI-21     BILGI-22     BADAMI-23     BAGALKOT-24
HUNGUND-25     NARGUND-68
S10-3-KA-BAGALKOT     1GADDIGOUDAR PC     BJP
2JTPATIL     INC
3FAROOQ PAKALI     BSP
4BASAVARAJ KALAKAPPA PUJAR     NCP
5PARASHURAM JALAGAR     PPOI
6KADECHUR KALLAPPA REVANASIDDAPPA     IND
7GADADANNAVAR RAMESH BHIMAPPA     IND
8CHINCHOLI SANTOSHAKUMAR SAHEBAGOUDA     IND
9PANDIT SHIVAPPA BODALI     IND
10BADASHAH RAJESAB MUJAWAR     IND
11BABU RAMAREDDY RAMESH     IND
12BANDIWADDAR CHANDRASHEKHAR HANAMANT     IND
13MANOHAR HA     IND
14SHANKAR BHIMAPPA TELI     IND
15SANNAGOUDAR GURURAJ SATTYAPPAGOUDA     IND
16SANGMESH GURUPADAPPA BHAVIKATTI     IND
17HIREMATH RENUKARADHYA SHARANAYYA     IND
MUDDEBIHAL-26     DEVAR HIPPARGI-27     BASAVANA BAGEVADI-28
BABALESHWAR-29     BIJAPUR CITY-30     NAGTHAN-31     INDI-32     SINDGI-33
S10-4-KA-BIJAPUR     1ALMELKAR VILASABABU BASALINGAPPA     JD(S)
2KANAMADI SUDHAKAR MALLESH     BSP
3PRAKASH KUBASING RATHOD     INC
4RAMESH CHANDAPPA JIGAJINAGI     BJP
5NARASAPPA TIPPANNA BANDIWADDAR     SKP
6LAMANI CHANDRAKANT RUPASING     LJP
7ARAKERI NIRMALA SRINIVAS     IND
8CHALAWADI RAMANNA     IND
9SEVALAL SOMASHEKAR PURAPPA     IND
10HARIJAN AMBANNA TUKARAM     IND
AFZALPUR-34     JEVARGI-35     GURMITKAL-39     CHITTAPUR-40     SEDAM-41
GULBARGA RURAL-43     GULBARGA DAKSHIN-44     GULBARGA UTTAR-45
S10-5-KA-GULBARGA     1BABU HONNA NAIK     JD(S)
2MALLIKARJUN KHARGE     INC
3MAHADEV B DHANNI     BSP
4REVUNAIK BELAMGI     BJP
5DR K T PALUSKAR     PRCP
6RAVIKUMAR SHALIMANI SEDAM     ANC
7SHANKER KODLA     JD(U)
8SHANKAR JADHAV     BHPP
9HV DIWAKAR     IND
10SHIVAKUMAR  KOLLUR     IND
SHORAPUR-36     SHAHAPUR-37     YADGIR-38     RAICHUR RURAL-53     RAICHUR-54
MANVI-55     DEVADURGA-56     LINGSUGUR-57
S10-6-KA-RAICHUR     1KDEVANNA NAIK     JD(S)
2PAKKIRAPPAS     BJP
3RAJA VENKATAPPA NAIK     INC
4SHIVAKUMAR     BSP
5COM II VHMASTER     IND
6COMRADE VMUDUKAPPA NAYAK     IND
7RMUDUKAPPA NAYAK     IND
8KSOMASHEKHAR     IND
CHINCHOLI-42     ALAND-46     BASAVAKALYAN-47     HOMNABAD-48     BIDAR SOUTH-49
BIDAR-50     BHALKI-51     AURAD-52
S10-7-KA-BIDAR     1GURUPADAPPA NAGMARPALLI     BJP
2JAGANNATHRJAMADAR     BSP
3NDHARAM SINGH     INC
4SUBHASH TIPPANNA NELGE     JD(S)
5ADVOCATE MOULVI ZAMEERUDDIN     NDEP
6BHASKAR BABU PATERPALLI     ICSP
7SHRAVAN SANGONDA BHANDE     RSPS
8SUBHASH CHANDRA GKHAPATE     LJP
9AMRUTHAPPAMD     IND
10MD ARSHAD AHMED ANSARI     IND
11KHAJA SAMEEUDDIN KHAJA MOINUDDIN     IND
12JADHAV VENKAT RAO GYANOBA RAO     IND
13DONGAPURE SHANT KUMAR     IND
14DEVENDRAPPA SANGRAMAPPA PATIL     IND
15NARSAPPA MUTHANGI     IND
16PARMESHWAR RAMCHANDRA     IND
17PASHAMIYA ESMAIL SAB     IND
18BASWARAJ PAILWAN OKALLI     IND
19MANJILE MIYYA PEER SAB QURESH     IND
20MD OSMAN ALI LAKHPATI     IND
21MUFTI SHAIKH ABDUL GAFFAR QASMI     IND
22YEVATE PATIL SHRIMANTH     IND
23YASHWANTH NARSING     IND
24SHIVARAJ TIMMANNA BOKKE     IND
25SAMEEUDDIN BANDELI     IND
26SURESH SWAMY TALGHATKER     IND
27SYED QUBUL ULLA HUSSIANI SAJID     IND
SINDHANUR-58     MASKI-59     KUSHTAGI-60     KANAKAGIRI-61     GANGAWATI-62
YELBURGA-63     KOPPAL-64     SIRUGUPPA-92
S10-8-KA-KOPPAL     1ANSARI IQBAL     JD(S)
2BASAVARAJ RAYAREDDY     INC
3SHIVAPUTRAPPA GUMAGERA     BSP
4SHIVARAMAGOUDA SHIVANAGOUDA     BJP
5ZAKEER     LJP
6BASAVARAJ KARADI WADDARAHATTI     JD(U)
7BHARADWAJ     CPI(ML)(L)
8JESHWARAPPA     IND
9UPPAR HANUMANTAPPA VEERAPPA KESARAHATTI     IND
10GOUSIA BEGUM     IND
11TCHAKRAVARTI NAYAK     IND
12CHANDRASHEKAR     IND
13NAJEER HUSAIN     IND
14COMRADE DHPUJAR     IND
15MAREMMA YANKAPPA     IND
16SHARABHAYYA HIREMATH     IND
17SHIVAKUMAR NAVALI SIDDAPPA TONTAPUR     IND
18HANDI RAFIQ SAB     IND
HADAGALLI-88     HAGARIBOMMANAHALLI-89     VIJAYANAGARA-90     KAMPLI-91
BELLARY-93     BELLARY CITY-94     SANDUR-95     KUDLIGI-96
S10-9-KA-BELLARY     1T NAGENDRA     BSP
2J SHANTHA     BJP
3NY HANUMANTHAPPA     INC
4CHOWDAPPA     CPI(ML)(L)
5D GANGANNA     IND
6B RAMAIAH     IND
7A RAMANJANAPPA     IND
SHIRAHATTI-65     GADAG-66     RON-67     HANGAL-82     HAVERI-84     BYADGI-85
HIREKERUR-86     RANIBENNUR-87
S10-10-KA-HAVERI     1ASHOKAPPA MALLAPPA JAVALI     NCP
2UDASI SHIVAKUMAR CHANABASAPPA     BJP
3IGAL DILLPPA KARIYAPPA     BSP
4SHIVAKUMARGOUDA SHIDDALINGANGOUDA PATIL     JD(S)
5SALEEM AHAMAD     INC
6KRISHNAJI RAGHAVENDRARAO OMKAR     ABHM
7PRABHU K PATIL     JD(U)
8ALLABAX TIMMAPUR     IND
9JAGADEESH YANKAPPA DODDAMANI     IND
10FAKKIRESH SHAMBHU BIJAPUR     IND
11KNBADIGER     IND
12BASAVARAJ SHANKRAPPA DESAI     IND
NAVALGUND-69     KUNDGOL-70     DHARWAD-71     HUBLI-DHARWAD-EAST-72
HUBLI-DHARWAD-CENTRAL-73     HUBLI-DHARWAD- WEST-74     KALGHATGI-75
SHIGGAON-83
S10-11-KA-DHARWAD     1KASHIMSAB MULLA     BSP
2KUNNUR MANJUNATH CHANNAPPA     INC
3TALAKALLAMATH MAHESH GURUPADAYYA     NCP
4PRALHAD JOSHI     BJP
5HANMANTSA CHANDRAKANTSA NIRANJAN     JD(U)
6ALI MSANDIMANI     IND
7ASHOK VISHNUSA BADDI     IND
8IBRAHIM KALLIMANI     IND
9GURUPADAGOUDA VENKANAGOUDA PATIL     IND
10ZAMEER KHAN     IND
11J BHASKAR     IND
12BASANAGOUDA MUDIGOUDA HANASI     IND
13BASAVARAJ RAMANNA BALANNAVAR     IND
14BAGWAN NASIR PAPULSAB     IND
15RAMACHANDRA KALINGAPPA MAHAR     IND
16SHANKARAPPA GURUSHIDDAPPA YADAVANNAVAR     IND
KHANAPUR-14     KITTUR-15     HALIYAL-76     KARWAR-77     KUMTA-78     BHATKAL-79
SIRSI-80     YELLAPUR-81
S10-12-KA-UTTARA KANNADA     1ANANTKUMAR HEGDE     BJP
2ALVA MARGARET     INC
3HADAPAD BASAVARAJ DUNDAPPA     BSP
4V D HEGADE     JD(S)
5ELISH KOTIYAL     JD(U)
6D M GURAV     SHS
7ABDUL RASHEED SHAIKH     IND
8UDAY BABU KHALVADEKAR     IND
9KHAZI RAHMATULLA ABDUL WAHAB     IND
10L P M NAIK     IND
11YASHWANT TIMMANNA NIPPANIKAR     IND
JAGALUR-103     HARAPANAHALLI-104     HARIHAR-105     DAVANAGERE NORTH-106
DAVANAGERE SOUTH-107     MAYAKONDA-108     CHANNAGIRI-109     HONNALI-110
S10-13-KA-DAVANAGERE     1KB KALLERUDRESHAPPA     JD(S)
2MALLIKARJUN SS     INC
3SIDDESWARA GM     BJP
4DR HIDAYATHUR RAHMAN KHAN     BSP
5IDLI RAMAPPA     CPI(ML)(L)
6SUDESH GM     AIJMK
7ARUNDI NINGAPPA     IND
8ALUR MG SWAMY     IND
9INAYAT ALI KHAN     IND
10H ESWARAPPA BOVI     IND
11HM EHSANULLA PATEL     IND
12H K KENCHVEERAPPA HEBBALU     IND
13S CHANDRASHEKARAPPA     IND
14JAYANNA ITAGI     IND
15H NAGARAJ PALEGARA     IND
16M NAGARAJAPPA     IND
17LS MALLIKARJUN     IND
18MARUTHI H     IND
19YOGESHWARA RAO SINDHE     IND
20RAMESH HULI     IND
21B RAJASHEKHARAYYA     IND
22DRRAJU C     IND
23LOKANAGOWDA PATIL     IND
24VEERESH T     IND
25DR SRIDHARA UDUPA     IND
26G N SIDDESH     IND
27SUBHAN KHAN     IND
28B GNANA PRAKASH     IND
SHIMOGA RURAL-111     BHADRAVATI-112     SHIMOGA-113     TIRTHAHALLI-114
SHIKARIPURA-115     SORAB-116     SAGAR-117     BYNDOOR-118
S10-14-KA-SHIMOGA     1J JAYAPPA     BSP
2S BANGARAPPA     INC
3BY RAGHAVENDRA     BJP
4C MURUGAN     AIJMK
5AKHIL AHMED     IND
6DS ESHWARAPPA     IND
7UMESHKUMAR S     IND
8N DINESH KUMAR     IND
9MAINUDDINMS     IND
10MANJAPPA S     IND
11MP SRIDHAR BYNDOOR     IND
12HS SHEKARAPPA     IND
KUNDAPURA-119     UDUPI-120     KAPU-121     KARKAL-122     SRINGERI-123
MUDIGERE-124     CHIKMAGALUR-125     TARIKERE-126
S10-15-KA-UDUPI CHIKMAGALUR     1KJAYAPRAKASH HEGDE     INC
2RADHA SUNDARESH     CPI
3DVSADANANDA GOWDA     BJP
4JSTEVEN MENEZES     BSP
5COMRADEUMESH KUMAR     IND
6KGANAPATHI SHETTIGAR     IND
7VINAYAK MALLYA     IND
8DR SRIDHARA UDUPA     IND
9SRINIVAS POOJARY     IND
KADUR-127     SHRAVANABELAGOLA-193     ARSIKERE-194     BELUR-195     HASSAN-196
HOLENARASIPUR-197     ARKALGUD-198     SAKLESHPUR-199
S10-16-KA-HASSAN     1A P AHAMED     BSP
2H D DEVEGOWDA     JD(S)
3B SHIVRAMU     INC
4K H HANUME GOWDA     BJP
5AIJAZ AHMED FAROOQI     IND
6KURUBARA KALENAHALLI KOVI BABANNA     IND
7KODIHALLI CHANDRASHEKAR     IND
8DEVARAJA P B     IND
9DANDORA VIJAYAKUMAR     IND
10M MAHESH HARSHA     IND
11RAJANI NARAYANAGOWDA     IND
12K D REVANNA     IND
13B C VIJAYAKUMARA     IND
BELTHANGADY-200     MOODABIDRI-201     MANGALORE CITY NORTH-202     MANGALORE
CITY SOUTH-203     MANGALORE-204     BANTVAL-205     PUTTUR-206     SULLIA-207
S10-17-KA-DAKSHINA KANNADA     1ALEKKADI GIRISH RAI     BSP
2JANARDHANA POOJARY     INC
3NALIN KUMAR KATEEL     BJP
4BMADHAVA     CPM
5VICHARAWADI ANANDA GATTY     IND
6DRTHIRUMALA RAYA HALEMANE     IND
7MOHAMMED SALI     IND
8K RAMA BHAT URIMAJALU     IND
9VASUDEVA GOWDA M P     IND
10DRUPSHIVANANDA     IND
11SUBRAHMANYA KUMAR KUNTIKANAMATA     IND
MOLAKALMURU-97     CHALLAKERE-98     CHITRADURGA-99     HIRIYUR-100
HOSADURGA-101     HOLALKERE-102     SIRA-136     PAVAGADA-137
S10-18-KA-CHITRADURGA     1JANARDHANA SWAMY     BJP
2M JAYANNA     BSP
3DR B THIPPESWAMY     INC
4M RATHNAKAR     JD(S)
5SHASHISHEKAR NAIK     RJD
6M KUMBAIAH     IND
7GANESHA     IND
8K H DURGASIMHA     IND
9RAMACHANDRA     IND
10B SUJATHA     IND
11HANUMANTHAPPA TEGNOOR     IND
CHIKNAYAKANHALLI-128     TIPTUR-129     TURUVEKERE-130     TUMKUR CITY-132
TUMKUR RURAL-133     KORATAGERE-134     GUBBI-135     MADHUGIRI-138
S10-19-KA-TUMKUR     1ASHOK         BSP
2P KODANDARAMAIAH     INC
3GS BASAVARAJU     BJP
4SP MUDDAHANUMEGOWDA     JD(S)
5SREE GOWRISHANKARA SWAMIGALU     SP
6DR NAGARAJA     IND
7G NAGENDRA     IND
8NIRANJANA CS     IND
9MOHAMED KHASIM     IND
10SHASIBHUSHANA     IND
MALAVALLI-186     MADDUR-187     MELUKOTE-188     MANDYA-189
SHRIRANGAPATTANA-190     NAGAMANGALA-191     KRISHNARAJPET-192
KRISHNARAJANAGARA-211
S10-20-KA-MANDYA     1M H AMBAREESH     INC
2M KRISHNAMURTHY     BSP
3N CHELUVARAYA SWAMY  SWAMYGOWDA     JD(S)
4L R SHIVARAMEGOWDA     BJP
5KOWDLE CHANNAPPA     JD(U)
6JOHNSON CHINNAPPAN     AIJMK
7K S PUTTANNAIAH     SKP
8H S RAMANNA     PPOI
9S BALASUBRAMANIAN     IND
10VENKATESH R     IND
11SHAKUNTHALA     IND
12SHAMBHULINGEGOWDA     IND
MADIKERI-208     VIRAJPET-209     PIRIYAPATNA-210     HUNSUR-212
CHAMUNDESHWARI-215     KRISHNARAJA-216     CHAMARAJA-217     NARASIMHARAJA-218
S10-21-KA-MYSORE     1ADAGUR H VISHWANATH     INC
2BAJIVIJAYA     JD(S)
3CHVIJAYASHANKAR     BJP
4SYED NIZAM ALI     BSP
5ARSHADULLA SHARIFF     BPJP
6DREKESHAMMA     RDMP
7PPARASHIVAMURTHY     RKSP
8LEELAVATHIM     PPOI
9RAFEEQ     IND
10PNSRINATHPATHRIKE     IND
11SANTHOSH KUMARP     IND
12MVSANTHOSH KUMAR     IND
HEGGADADEVANKOTE-213     NANJANGUD-214     VARUNA-219     T.NARASIPUR-220
HANUR-221     KOLLEGAL-222     CHAMARAJANAGAR-223     GUNDLUPET-224
S10-22-KA-CHAMARAJANAGAR     1ARKRISHNAMURTHY     BJP
2RDHRUVANARAYANA     INC
3NMAHESH     BSP
4MSHIVANNAKOTE     JD(S)
5MKKEMPASIDDAIAH     SP
6CHOWDAHALLY JAVARAIAH     CPI(ML)(L)
7RJAGADISH NAIK     BSC
8KCSHIVANANDA     JD(U)
9PURUSHOTHAMAR     IND
10BHEEMAIAH     IND
11PBYOGENDRA     IND
12RAMESHM     IND
13MCRAJANNA     IND
14SUBBAIAH     IND
KUNIGAL-131     RAJARAJESHWARINAGAR-154     BANGALORE SOUTH-176
ANEKAL-177     MAGADI-182     RAMANAGARAM-183     KANAKAPURA-184     CHANNAPATNA-185
S10-23-KA-BANGALORE RURAL     1HDKUMARASWAMY     JD(S)
2TEJASVINI GOWDA     INC
3MOHAMED HAFEEZ ULLAH     BSP
4C P YOGEESHWARA     BJP
5CTHOPAIAH     JD(U)
6I VENKATESWARA REDDY     PPOI
7AGNISHREENIVAS     IND
8DKUMARASWAMY     IND
9KUMARASWAMY C     IND
10KRISHNAPPA     IND
11YCHINNAPPA     IND
12A CHOWRAPPA     IND
13DR K PADMARAJAN     IND
14KPUTTAMADEGOWDA     IND
15TMMANCHEGOWDA     IND
K.R.PURA-151     BYATARAYANAPURA-152     YESHVANTHAPURA-153
DASARAHALLI-155     MAHALAKSHMI LAYOUT-156     MALLESHWARAM-157     HEBBAL-158
PULAKESHINAGAR-159
S10-24-KA-BANGALORE NORTH     1D B CHANDRE GOWDA     BJP
2C K JAFFER SHARIEF     INC
3PADMAA K BHAT     BSP
4R SURENDRA BABU     JD(S)
5M TIPPUVARDHAN     BPJP
6ANCHAN KHANNA     IND
7KANYA KUMAR     IND
8G S KUMAR     IND
9C KRISHNAMURTHY     IND
10B K CHANDRA     IND
11T R CHANDRAHASA     IND
12ABDUL JALEEL     IND
13ZAFER MOHIUDDIN     IND
14JOSEPH SOLOMON     IND
15L NAGARAJ     IND
16V PRASANNA KUMAR     IND
17H PILLAIAH     IND
18T B MADWARAJA     IND
19MEER LAYAQ HUSSAIN     IND
20K A MOHAN     IND
21S M RAJU     IND
22L LAKSHMAIAH     IND
23MU VENKATESHAIAH     IND
24VENKATESA SETTY     IND
25H A SHIVAKUMAR     IND
26K SATHYANARAYANA     IND
27SYED AKBAR BASHA     IND
28N HARISH GOWDA     IND
SARVAGNANAGAR-160     C.V. RAMAN NAGAR-161     SHIVAJINAGAR-162     SHANTI
NAGAR-163     GANDHI NAGAR-164     RAJAJI NAGAR-165     CHAMRAJPET-168
MAHADEVAPURA-174
S10-25-KA-BANGALORE CENTRAL     1ZAMEER AHMED KHAN BZ     JD(S)
2P C MOHAN     BJP
3VIJAY RAJA SINGH     BSP
4HTSANGLIANA     INC
5IFTHAQUAR ALI BHUTTO     ANC
6JDELANGOVAN     IJP
7S M KRISHNA     BPJP
8B KRISHNA PRASAD     PTSS
9AS PAUL     AIJMK
10DC PRAKASH     KTMK
11KPRABHAKARA REDDY     KCVP
12TKPREMKUMAR     PPOI
13ABHIMANI NARENDRA     IND
14MA ASHWATHA NARAYANA SETTY     IND
15K UMA         IND
16UMASHANKAR     IND
17KSSIYENGAR     IND
18BMKRISHNAREDDY     IND
19SKODANDARAM     IND
20CVGIDDAPPA     IND
21ACHANDRASHEKAR     IND
22JAYARAMA     IND
23KNARASIMHA     IND
24BK NARAYANA SWAMY     IND
25PPARTHIBAN     IND
26MEER LAYAQ HUSSAIN     IND
27BMOHAN VELU     IND
28R RAJ         IND
29E RAMAKRISHNAIAH     IND
30KHRAMALINGAREDDY     IND
31VIJAYA BHASKAR N     IND
32DRD RVENKATESH GOWDA     IND
33SHAFFI AHMED     IND
34SN SHARMA     IND
35SHASHIKUMAR AR     IND
36KSHIVARAMANNA     IND
37SHAIK BAHADUR     IND
GOVINDRAJ NAGAR-166     VIJAY NAGAR-167     CHICKPET-169     BASAVANAGUDI-170
PADMANABA NAGAR-171     B.T.M LAYOUT-172     JAYANAGAR-173     BOMMANAHALLI-175
S10-26-KA-BANGALORE SOUTH     1ANANTH KUMAR     BJP
2KRISHNA BYRE GOWDA     INC
3NAHEEDA SALMA S     BSP
4PROFRADHAKRISHNA     JD(S)
5BMGOVINDRAJ NAIK     ABHM
6PJOHNBASCO     AIJMK
7VATAL NAGARAJ     KCVP
8BSHIVARAMAPPA     PPOI
9ABHIMAANI NARENDRA     IND
10KHADER ALI KHAN     IND
11GANESH HANUMANTARAO MOKHASHI     IND
12CAPT GR GOPINATH     IND
13KCJANARDHAN     IND
14DRJAYALAKSHMIHG     IND
15KMNARAYANA     IND
16MADESHC     IND
17MURALIDHARADJ     IND
18RAVI KUMARAT     IND
19SUGANDHARAJE URS     IND
20SANTHOSH MINB     IND
GAURIBIDANUR-139     BAGEPALLI-140     CHIKKABALLAPUR-141     YELAHANKA-150
HOSAKOTE-178     DEVANAHALLI-179     DODDABALLAPUR-180     NELAMANGALA-181
S10-27-KA-CHIKKBALLAPUR     1CASWATHANARAYANA     BJP
2CRMANOHAR     JD(S)
3MVEERAPPA MOILY     INC
4HENNURU LAKSHMINARAYANA     BSP
5MRAMAKRISHNAIAH     PPOI
6MVENKATESH     BPJP
7HRSHIVAKUMAR     LJP
8KRISHNAMURTHY T     IND
9KSCHANDRASHEKARA RAO AZAD     IND
10LNAGARAJ     IND
11GNARAYANAPPA     IND
12ANBACHEGOWDA     IND
13GBMUTHUKUMAR     IND
14MMUNIVENKATAIAH     IND
15MRAMESH     IND
16RAVI GOKRE     IND
17GN RAVI     IND
18KVENKATAREDDY     IND
19BSHIVARAJA     IND
20YASIDDALINGEGOWDA     IND
SIDLAGHATTA-142     CHINTAMANI-143     SRINIVASPUR-144     MULBAGAL-145     KOLAR
GOLD FIELD-146     BANGARAPET-147     KOLAR-148     MALUR-149
S10-28-KA-KOLAR     1GCHANDRANNA     JD(S)
2KHMUNIYAPPA     INC
3NMUNISWAMY     BSP
4LAKSHMI SHANMUGAM     NCP
5DSVEERAIAH     BJP
6KRDEVARAJA     RDMP
7BMKRISHNAPPA     IND
8MRGANTAPPA     IND
9PVCHANGALARAYAPPA     IND
10PCHANDRAPPA     IND
11VJAYARAMA     IND
12JAYARAMAPPA     IND
13NAGARATHNA M     IND
14MNAGARAJA     IND
15NARAYANASWAMY     IND
16KNARAYANASWAMY     IND
17CKMUNIYAPPA     IND
18MRAVI KUMAR     IND
19MVENKATASWAMY     IND
20KVENKATESH     IND
21SRINIVASA TO     IND
22SRINIVASA P     IND
MANJESHWAR-1     KASARAGOD-2     UDUMA-3     KANHANGAD-4     TRIKARIPUR-5
PAYYANNUR-6     KALLIASSERI-7
S11-1-KL-KASARAGOD     1P KARUNAKARAN     CPM
2KHMADHAVI     BSP
3SHAHIDA KAMAL     INC
4K SURENDRAN     BJP
5ABBAS MUTHALAPPARA     IND
6MOHAN NAYAK     IND
7PK RAMAN     IND
TALIPARAMBA-8     IRIKKUR-9     AZHIKODE-10     KANNUR-11     DHARMADAM-12
MATTANNUR-15     PERAVOOR-16
S11-2-KL-KANNUR     1PP KARUNAKARAN MASTER     BJP
2KK BALAKRISHNAN NAMBIAR     BSP
3KK RAGESH     CPM
4K SUDHAKARAN     INC
5PI CHANDRASEKHARAN     THPI
6JOHNSON ALIAS SUNNY AMBATT     IND
7K RAGESH SO JANARDHANAN     IND
8PATTATHIL RAGHAVAN     IND
9K SUDHAKARAN KAVINTE ARIKATH     IND
THALASSERY-13     KUTHUPARAMBA-14     VADAKARA-20     KUTTIADI-21
NADAPURAM-22     QUILANDY-23     PERAMBRA-24
S11-3-KL-VADAKARA     1ADVK NOORUDHEEN MUSALIAR     BSP
2MULLAPPALLY RAMACHANDRAN     INC
3KP SREESAN     BJP
4ADV P SATHEEDEVI     CPM
5TP CHANDRASEKHARAN     IND
6NAROTH RAMACHANDRAN     IND
7PSATHIDEVI PALLIKKAL     IND
8SATHEEDEVI     IND
MANANTHAVADY-17     SULTHANBATHERY-18     KALPETTA-19     THIRUVANMBADI-32
ERNAD-34     NILAMBUR-35     WANDOOR-36
S11-4-KL-WAYANAD     1K MURALEEDHARAN     NCP
2RAJEEV JOSEPH     BSP
3C VASUDEVAN MASTER     BJP
4MI SHANAVAS     INC
5ADVOCATE M RAHMATHULLA     CPI
6KALLANGODAN ABDUL LATHEEF     IND
7CLETUS     IND
8DR NALLA THAMPY THERA     IND
9ADVOCATE SHANAVAS MALAPPURAM     IND
10SHANAVAS MANAKULANGARA PARAMBIL     IND
11SUNNY PONNAMATTOM     IND
12MP RAHMATH     IND
13RAHMATHULLA POOLADAN     IND
BALUSSERI-25     ELATHUR-26     KOZHIKODE NORTH-27     KOZHIKODE SOUTH-28
BEYPORE-29     KUNNAMANGALAM-30     KODUVALLY-31
S11-5-KL-KOZHIKODE     1AK ABDUL NASAR     BSP
2ADV PA MOHAMED RIYAS     CPM
3V MURALEEDHARAN     BJP
4MK RAGHAVAN     INC
5ADV P KUMARANKUTTY     IND
6K MUHAMMED RIYAS     IND
7P MUHAMMED RIYAS     IND
8PA MOHAMMED RIYAS     IND
9MUDOOR MUHAMMED HAJI     IND
10K RAGHAVAN     IND
11P RAMACHANDRAN NAIR     IND
12M RAGHAVAN     IND
13VINOD K     IND
14ADV SABI JOSEPH     IND
15DR DSURENDRANATH     IND
16RIYAS         IND
KONDOTTY-33     MANJERI-37     PERINTHALMANNA-38     MANKADA-39
MALAPPURAM-40     VENGARA-41     VALLIKKUNNU-42
S11-6-KL-MALAPPURAM     1ADVEA ABOOBACKER     BSP
2ADV N ARAVINDAN     BJP
3E AHAMED     MUL
4TK HAMSA     CPM
TIRURANGADI-43     TANUR-44     TIRUR-45     KOTTAKKAL-46     THAVANUR-47
PONNANI-48     THRITHALA-49
S11-7-KL-PONNANI     1K JANACHANDRAN MASTER     BJP
2PK MUHAMMED     BSP
3ET MUHAMMED BASHEER     MUL
4ABDUREHMAN     IND
5DR AZAD     IND
6PULLANI GOVINDAN     IND
7DR HUSSAIN RANTATHANI     IND
8HUSSAIN EDAYATH     IND
9HUSSAIN KADAIKKAL     IND
10HUSSAIN PERICHAYIL     IND
11HUSSAIN     IND
12DR HUSSAIN     IND
13K SADANANDAN     IND
PATTAMBI-50     SHORANUR-51     OTTAPPALAM-52     KONGAD-53     MANNARKKAD-54
MALAMPUZHA-55     PALAKKAD-56
S11-8-KL-PALAKKAD     1ABDUL RAZAK MOULAVI     NCP
2CHANDRAN V     BSP
3CK PADMANABHAN     BJP
4MB RAJESH     CPM
5SATHEESAN PACHENI     INC
6A AROKIASAMY     IND
7MR MURALI     IND
8NV RAJESH     IND
9VIJAYAN AMBALAKKAD     IND
10SATHEESAN EV     IND
TARUR-57     CHITTUR-58     NEMMARA-59     ALATHUR-60     CHELAKKARA-61
KUNNAMKULAM-62     WADAKKANCHERY-65
S11-9-KL-ALATHUR     1PK BIJU     CPM
2M BINDU TEACHER     BJP
3DR G SUDEVAN     BSP
4NK SUDHEER     INC
5K GOPALAKRISHNAN     CPI(ML)(L)
6BIJU KK     IND
7PC BIJU     IND
8CK RAMAKRISHNAN     IND
9KK SUDHIR     IND
GURUVAYOOR-63     MANALUR-64     OLLUR-66     THRISSUR-67     NATTIKA-68
IRINJALAKUDA-70     PUTHUKKAD-71
S11-10-KL-THRISSUR     1P C CHACKO     INC
2C N JAYADEVAN     CPI
3ADV JOSHY THARAKAN     BSP
4REMA REGUNANDAN     BJP
5AJAYAN KUTTIKAT     JD(U)
6K ARUN KUMAR     IND
7KUNJAN PULAYAN     IND
8E A JOSEPH     IND
9N K RAVI     IND
10P C SAJU     IND
11ADV N HARIHARAN NAIR     IND
KAIPAMANGALAM-69     CHALAKUDY-72     KODUNGALLUR-73     PERUMBAVOOR-74
ANGAMALY-75     ALUVA-76     KUNNATHUNAD-84
S11-11-KL-CHALAKUDY     1ADV UP JOSEPH     CPM
2KP DHANAPALAN     INC
3MUTTAM ABDULLA     BSP
4ADVKV SABU     BJP
5HAMSA KALAPARAMBATH     LJP
6JOHNNY K CHEEKU     IND
7JOSE MAVELI     IND
8UP JOSE     IND
9DR PS BABU     IND
10TS NARAYANAN MASTER     IND
11CA HASEENA     IND
KALAMASSERY-77     PARAVUR-78     VYPEEN-79     KOCHI-80     THRIPPUNITHURA-81
ERNAKULAM-82     THRIKKAKARA-83
S11-12-KL-ERNAKULAM     1PROF K V THOMAS     INC
2AN RADHAKRISHNAN     BJP
3SHERIF MOHAMMED     BSP
4SINDHU JOY     CPM
5SAJU THOMAS     LJP
6MARY FRANCIS MOOLAMPILLY     IND
7VISWAMBARAN     IND
8SAJI THURUTHIKUNNEL     IND
9SINDHU KS     IND
10SINDHU JAYAN     IND
MUVATTUPUZHA-86     KOTHAMANGALAM-87     DEVIKULAM-88     UDUMBANCHOLA-89
THODUPUZHA-90     IDUKKI-91     PEERUMADE-92
S11-13-KL-IDUKKI     1ADV PT THOMAS     INC
2ADV K FRANCIS GEORGE     KEC
3ADV BIJU M JOHN     BSP
4SREENAGARI RAJAN     BJP
5VASUDEVAN     VCK
6ADV CHITTOOR RAJAMANNAR     IND
7JOSE KUTTIYANY     IND
8KANCHIYAR PEETHAMBARAN     IND
9BABY         IND
10M A SOOSAI     IND
PIRAVOM-85     PALA-93     KADUTHURUTHY-94     VAIKOM-95     ETTUMANOOR-96
KOTTAYAM-97     PUTHUPPALLY-98
S11-14-KL-KOTTAYAM     1JOSE KMANI     KEC(M)
2ADV NARAYANAN NAMBOOTHIRI     BJP
3ADV SURESH KURUP     CPM
4SPENCER MARKS     BSP
5ADV JAIMON THANKACHAN     SWJP
6ANTO P JOHN     IND
7JUNO JOHN BABY     IND
8JOSE         IND
9JOSE MATHEW     IND
10JOSE K MANI     IND
11BABU         IND
12KT MATHEW     IND
13MINI K PHILIP     IND
14MS RAVEENDRAN     IND
15K RAJAPPAN     IND
16SASIKUTTAN VAKATHANAM     IND
17SURESH NB KURUP     IND
18SURESHKUMAR K     IND
19SURESHKUMAR TR     IND
20SURESH KURUMBAN     IND
AROOR-102     CHERTHALA-103     ALAPPUZHA-104     AMBALAPPUZHA-105
HARIPAD-107     KAYAMKULAM-108     KARUNAGAPPALLY-116
S11-15-KL-ALAPPUZHA     1DR KS MANOJ     CPM
2KC VENUGOPAL     INC
3KS PRASAD     BSP
4PJ KURIAN     JD(U)
5S SEETHILAL     IND
6SONY J KALYANKUMAR     IND
CHANGANASSERY-99     KUTTANAD-106     MAVELIKKARA-109     CHENGANNUR-110
KUNNATHUR-118     KOTTARAKKARA-119     PATHANAPURAM-120
S11-16-KL-MAVELIKKARA     1RS ANIL     CPI
2KODIKKUNNIL SURESH     INC
3DR ND MOHAN     BSP
4PM VELAYUDHAN     BJP
5ANIL KUMAR     IND
6KS SASIKALA     IND
7SOORANAD SUKUMARAN     IND
KANJIRAPPALLY-100     POONJAR-101     THIRUVALLA-111     RANNI-112
ARANMULA-113     KONNI-114     ADOOR-115
S11-17-KL-PATHANAMTHITTA     1ANANTHA GOPAN     CPM
2ANTO ANTONY     INC
3KARUNAKARAN NAIR     BSP
4MANI CKAPPEN     NCP
5RADHAKRISHNA MENON     BJP
6KUNJU PILLAI     CPI(ML)(L)
7ANTO         IND
8JYOTHISH MR     IND
9THAMBI     IND
10NIRANAM RAJAN     IND
11PUSHPANGADAN     IND
12MATHEW PAREY     IND
CHAVARA-117     PUNALUR-121     CHADAYAMANGALAM-122     KUNDARA-123
KOLLAM-124     ERAVIPURAM-125     CHATHANNOOR-126
S11-18-KL-KOLLAM     1ADVT K M JAYANANDAN     BSP
2NPEETHAMBARAKURUP     INC
3VAYAKKAL MADHU     BJP
4PRAJENDRAN     CPM
5ADVANU SASI     IND
6KRISHNAMMAL     IND
7K A JOHN     IND
8NPEETHAMBARAKURUP     IND
9SPRADEEP KUMAR     IND
10SRADHAKRISHNAN     IND
11RZAKIEER HUSSAIN     IND
VARKALA-127     ATTINGAL-128     CHIRAYINKEEZHU-129     NEDUMANGAD-130
VAMANAPURAM-131     ARUVIKKARA-136     KATTAKKADA-138
S11-19-KL-ATTINGAL     1PROFG BALACHANDRAN     INC
2THOTTAKKADU SASI     BJP
3ADV A SAMPATH     CPM
4J SUDHAKARAN     BSP
5SREENATH     SHS
6JAYAKUMAR     IND
7BALACHANDRAN     IND
8BALACHNDRAN C P     IND
9MURALI KUMAR     IND
10J VIJAYAKUMAR     IND
11VIVEKANANDAN     IND
12SHAMSUDEEN     IND
13SAJIMON     IND
14SAIFUDEEN M     IND
KAZHAKOOTTAM-132     VATTIYOOUKAVU-133     THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-134
NEMOM-135     PARASSALA-137     KOVALAM-139     NEYYATTINKARA-140
S11-20-KL-THIRUVANANTHAPURAM     1P K KRISHNA DAS     BJP
2MPGANGADHARAN     NCP
3DRA NEELALOHITHADASAN NADAR     BSP
4ADV P RAMACHANDRAN NAIR     CPI
5SHASHI THAROOR     INC
6AJITHKUMARK     AITC
7JAIN WILSON     BSA
8G ASHOKAN     IND
9TGEORGE     IND
10DILEEP     IND
11UNAHURMIRAN PEERU MOHAMMED     IND
12PRATHAPAN     IND
13MOHANAN JOSHWA     IND
14SASI  JANAKI SADAN     IND
15SASI  KALAPURAKKAL     IND
16SHAJAR KHAN     IND
SHEOPUR-1     VIJAYPUR-2     SABALGARH-3     JOURA-4     SUMAWALI-5     MORENA-6
DIMANI-7     AMBAH-8
S12-1-MP-MORENA     1JUGAL KISHOR PIPPAL     CPM
2NARENDRA SINGH TOMAR     BJP
3BALVEER SINGH DANDOTIYA     BSP
4AD BAIJNATH KUSHWAHA     SP
5RAMNIWAS RAWAT     INC
6ANITA HITENDRA CHOUDHARY     BHBP
7DEVENDRA SINGH SIKARWAR     AIFB
8RAMBABU SINGH PARIHAR     LJP
9VISHANLAL AGARWAL GOKAL MP     SVSP
10UTTAM SINGH MITTAL     IND
11USHA RAWAT     IND
12KALAWATI RAMESH ARGAL     IND
13GANDRV     IND
14JOGENDR     IND
15DHALLU ALLAHBAKSH     IND
16NARENDRA SINGH     IND
17MAHESH JATAV     IND
18MAHESH SINGH JATAV     IND
19RAJVEER SINGH     IND
20RAMNIWAS KUSHWAH     IND
21RAM SEWAK     IND
22VIJAY KUMAR     IND
23VIVEK APTE     IND
24SATYENDRA JAIN SHAMMI     IND
ATER-9     BHIND-10     LAHAR-11     MEHGAON-12     GOHAD-13     SEWDA-20
BHANDER-21     DATIA-22
S12-2-MP-BHIND     1ASHOK ARGAL     BJP
2NAND KISHOR KORI     SP
3DR BHAGIRATH PRASAD     INC
4DRRAHUL     BSP
5TULSIRAM DHANUK THEKEDAR     IVD
6SHANKAR LAL VERMA     BHBP
7SHRIRAM RAHUL     BMM
8RJJATAV     IND
9BHAGIRATH     IND
10RAMSEVAK MORYA     IND
11LALARAM     IND
12VEERENDRA KUMAR GOYAL     IND
13SHAILENDRA SINGH ALIAS KALLU     IND
GWALIOR RURAL-14     GWALIOR-15     GWALIOR EAST-16     GWALIOR SOUTH-17
BHITARWAR-18     DABRA-19     KARERA-23     POHARI-24
S12-3-MP-GWALIOR     1AJAB SINGH KUSHWAH     BSP
2ASHOK SINGH     INC
3YASHODHARA RAJE SCINDIA     BJP
4AVTAR SINGH     LJP
5GAUTAM SINGH RAJPUT KUSHWAH     RSMD
6DEVENDRA BHARGAVA ADVOCATE     ABHM
7PANKAJ GOSWAMI     BHBP
8RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA     IJP
9DR RAM GOPAL ADVOCATE     RPI(A)
10LAKHPAT SINGH KIRAR     ASP
11ANAND KUMAR     IND
12ANAND SINGH KUSHWAH RAMAYNE     IND
13ALOK JOSHI     IND
14KAPTAN SINGH MASTER     IND
15KOMAL ANURAGI     IND
16JAGADISH GOBARA     IND
17DEEPAK KUMAR BANSAL RANGWALE     IND
18PADAM SINGH DHAKAD     IND
19YASMIN KHAN     IND
20RAJESH KUMAR SHARMA     IND
21RAM RATAN KUSHWAH     IND
22SAEED KHAN DABBU     IND
23SHRIKRISHNA ALIAS SIRIYA     IND
SHIVPURI-25     PICHHORE-26     KOLARAS-27     BAMORI-28     GUNA-29     ASHOK
NAGAR-32     CHANDERI-33     MUNGAOLI-34
S12-4-MP-GUNA     1JYOTIRADITYA MADHAVRAO SCINDIA     INC
2DRNAROTTAM MISHRA     BJP
3LOKPAL LODHI     BSP
4ABDUL RASHEED     AD
5MANIRAM RAM JATAV     LJP
6LALU URF ATAL LAL     BHBP
7ANIL DWIVEDI     IND
8PTASHOK SHARMA BADE BHAIYA     IND
9ISHLAM KHAN RAIAN     IND
10KISHORILAL CHAURASIYA GUNA WALE     IND
11KRISHNA KANT CHAUBEY PAPPU MAHARAJ     IND
12MAHADEV PRASAD TIWARI     IND
13PMAHESH CHANDRA SHASHTRI     IND
14MOHAMMD IRSHADA QUAZI     IND
15LAKHAN LAL     IND
16VIJAY KUMAR JAIN     IND
17SUMAN SINGH SIKARWAR ADVOCATE     IND
18HAJARI LAL KOTIA RATHOR     IND
BINA-35     KHURAI-36     SURKHI-37     NARYOLI-40     SAGAR-41     KURWAI-146
SIRONJ-147     SHAMSHABAD-148
S12-5-MP-SAGAR     1ASLAM SHER KHAN     INC
2AHIRWAR NARESH BOUDHA     BSP
3GOURI SINGH YADAV     SP
4BHUPENDRA SINGH     BJP
5ARVIND DANGI     PRSP
6DHAN SINGH AHIRWAR     LJP
7VINOD DIWAR GOUND     GGP
8SIDHARTH BOUDHA AHIRWAR     RPI(A)
9SANJAY BHAI ADVOCATE RAVIDASI     GMS
10ASHOK MISHRA     IND
11GOMAT SINGH MAHARAJ SINGH DANGI     IND
12RAMKISHAN RAMA     IND
TIKAMGARH-43     JATARA-44     PRITHVIPUR-45     NIWARI-46     KHARGAPUR-47
MAHARAJPUR-48     CHHATARPUR-51     BIJAWAR-52
S12-6-MP-TIKAMGARH     1AHIRWAR VRINDAVAN     INC
2CHINTAMAN KORI RAMPURIYA     SP
3GD         BSP
4VIRENDRA KUMAR     BJP
5AHIRWAR JAGDISH PRASAD     LJP
6AHIRWAR RAMSWAROOP     RSMD
7VISHAN LAL BASHNKAR     PRSP
8AHIRWAR GYADIN     IND
9KAMLAPAT KUMHAR     IND
10KHARGA PRASAD     IND
11CHAMAN LAL     IND
12DAYARAM     IND
13PARWAT LAL     IND
14RAMCHARAN AHIRWAR     IND
15LAXMI PRASAD AHIRWAR     IND
16VRINDAVAN AHIRWAR     IND
17SHRIPAT SHIKSHAK     IND
DEORI-38     REHLI-39     BANDA-42     MALHARA-53     PATHARIYA-54     DAMOH-55
JABERA-56     HATTA-57
S12-7-MP-DAMOH     1AHIR KAMLA YADAV     SP
2CHANDRABHAN BHAIYA     INC
3SHIVRAJ BHAIYA     BJP
4KASHIRAM ALIAS KAMLESH DHURVE     GMS
5BHAGIRATH KURMI     RDMP
6MANOJ DEVALIYA     BJBP
7SHIVRAJ BHAIYA     SVSP
8HARIRAM THAKUR     GGP
9GAFFAR ALI     IND
10GOPAL BHAIYA     IND
11CHANDRABHAN BHAIYA JATASHANKAR COLONY DAMOH     IND
12CHANDRABHAN BHAIYA PARSORIA NAHAR     IND
13JAYANT BHAIYA     IND
14JANKI PRASAD     IND
15NANNE LAL     IND
16RAMPHOOL DAHAYAT     IND
17VIJAY SINGH RAJPOOT     IND
18SHIVRAJ BHAIYA BADE THAKUR     IND
19SHIV RAJ ALIAS BADE BHAIYA     IND
20SHIVRAJ SINGH NAYAKHEDA APPCHAND     IND
21SHIVRAJ SINGH BANDA     IND
CHANDLA-49     RAJNAGAR-50     PAWAI-58     GUNNAOR-59     PANNA-60
VIJAYRAGHAVGARH-92     MURWARA-93     BAHORIBAND-94
S12-8-MP-KHAJURAHO     1JAYAWANT SINGH     SP
2JEETENDRA SINGH     BJP
3RAJA PATERYA     INC
4SEWA LAL PATEL     BSP
5M SHAKIL     GMS
6SAROJ BACHCHAN NAYAK     JD(U)
7SURYA BHAN SINGH YADAV GURUJI     AIFB
8AKEEL KHAN     IND
9AKANCHHA JAIN     IND
10KRISHNA SHARAN SINGH RAJA BHAIYA     IND
11NARENDRA KUMAR     IND
12RAJENDRA AHIRWAR     IND
13RAM NATH LODHI     IND
14SHABNAM MAUSI     IND
15SHUKL SITARAM     IND
CHITRAKOOT-61     RAIGAON-62     SATNA-63     NAGOD-64     MAIHAR-65
AMARPATAN-66     RAMPUR-BAGHELAN-67
S12-9-MP-SATNA     1GANESH SINGH     BJP
2PT RAJARAM TRIPATHI     SP
3SUKHLAL KUSHWAHA     BSP
4SUDHIR SINGH TOMAR     INC
5ONKAR SINGH     ABHKP
6GIRJA SINGH PATEL     AD
7CHHOTELAL SINGH GOND     GMS
8PRAMILA     RPI(A)
9B BALLABH CHARYA     AIC
10RAJESH SINGH BAGHEL     GGP
11SHOBHNATH SEN     LJP
12SUNDERLAL CHAUDHARI     IJP
13ASHOK KUMAR KUSHWAHA     IND
14ASHOK KUSHWAHA     IND
15CHHOTELAL     IND
16BHAIYALAL URMALIYA     IND
17MANISH KUMAR JAIN     IND
18MUNNI KRANTI     IND
19RAMVISHWAS BASORE     IND
20RAM SAJIVAN     IND
21RAMAYAN CHAUDHARI     IND
SIRMOUR-68     SEMARIYA-69     TEONTHAR-70     MAUGANJ-71     DEOTALAB-72
MANGAWAN-73     REWA-74     GURH-75
S12-10-MP-REWA     1CHANDRA MANI TRIPATHI     BJP
2DEORAJ SINGH PATEL     BSP
3PUSHPRAJ SINGH     SP
4SUNDER LAL TIWARI     INC
5BADRI PRASAD KUSHWAHA     AD
6RAMKISHAN NIRAT SAKET     RPI(A)
7RAMAYAN PRASAD PATEL     YVP
8VIMALA SONDHIA     LJP
9SALMA         AIFB
10MD AKEEL KHAN BACHCHA BHAI     IND
11JAIKARAN SAKET     IND
12BRAHMDUTTMISHRA ALIAS CHHOTE MURAITHA     IND
13SUKHENDRA PRATAP     IND
14SUNDAR LAL     IND
15HIRALAL VISHWAKARMA     IND
CHURHAT-76     SIDHI-77     SIHAWAL-78     CHITRANGI-79     SINGRAULI-80
DEVSAR-81     DHAUHANI-82     BEOHARI-83
S12-11-MP-SIDHI     1ASHOK KUMAR SHAH     BSP
2INDRAJEET KUMAR     INC
3GOVIND PRASAD MISHRA     BJP
4MANIK SINGH     SP
5LOLAR SINGH URETI     GMS
6VEENA SINGH NETI     GGP
7BABOOLAL JAISWAL     IND
8MADAN MOHAN JAISWAL ADVOCATE     IND
9MAHENDRA BHAIYA DIKSHIT     IND
10RAMAKANT PANDEY MALAIHNA     IND
11VEENA SINGH VEENA DIDI     IND
JAISINGHNAGAR-84     JAITPUR-85     KOTMA-86     ANUPPUR-87     PUSHPRAJGARH-88
BANDHAVGARH-89     MANPUR-90     BARWARA-91
S12-12-MP-SHAHDOL     1CHANDRA PRATAP SINGH BABA SAHAB     SP
2NARENDRA SINGH MARAVI     BJP
3MANOHAR SINGH MARAVI     BSP
4RAJESH NANDINI SINGH     INC
5SADAN SINGH BHARIA     CPI
6KRISHN PAL SINGH PAVEL     LJP
7GANPAT GOND     GMS
8RAM RATAN SINGH PAVLE     GGP
PATAN-95     BARGI-96     JABALPUR PURBA-97     JABALPUR UTTAR-98     JABALPUR
CANTT.-99     JABALPUR PASCHIM-100     PANAGAR-101     SIHORA-102
S12-13-MP-JABALPUR     1AZIZ QURESHI     BSP
2ASHOK KUMAR SHARMA     SP
3RAKESH SINGH     BJP
4ADVOCATE RAMESHWAR NEEKHRA     INC
5MEERCHAND PATEL KACHHVAHA     RPI
6RAVI MAHOBIA KUNDAM     GGP
7RAJKUMARI SINGH     LJP
8HARI SINGH MARAVI     GMS
9DR MUKESH MEHROTRA     IND
10RAKESH SONKAR PRAMUKH DHAI AKSHAR     IND
11SUNIL PATEL     IND
SHAHPURA-103     DINDORI-104     BICHHIYA-105     NIWAS-106     MANDLA-107
KEOLARI-116     LAKHNADON-117     GOTEGAON-118
S12-14-MP-MANDLA     1JALSO DHURWEY     BSP
2FAGGAN SINGH KULASTE     BJP
3BASORI SINGH MASRAM     INC
4UDAL SINGH DHURWEY     LKSP
5JHANK SINGH KUSHRE     GGP
6PREM SINGH MARAVI     GMS
7BHAGAT SINGH VARKEDE     LJP
8MANESHWARI NAIK     RPI(A)
9SUNITA NETI     RDMP
10CHANDRA SHEKHAR DHURWEY     IND
11CHAMBAL SING MARAWEE     IND
12DEV SINGH BHALAVI     IND
13SHIVCHARAN UIKEY     IND
14SAHDEO PRASAD MARAVI     IND
BAIHAR-108     LANJI-109     PARASWADA-110     BALAGHAT-111     WARASEONI-112
KATANGI-113     BARGHAT-114     SEONI-115
S12-15-MP-BALAGHAT     1AJAB LAL     BSP
2KISHOR SAMRITE     SP
3KANKAR MUNJARE     RJD
4K D DESHMUKH     BJP
5VISHVESHWAR BHAGAT     INC
6KALPANA GOPAL WASNIK     RPI(A)
7DARBU SINGH UIKEY     GMS
8BHAIYA BALKRISHNA     GGP
9ADVOCATE AZHAR UL ALIM     IND
10ANJU ASHOK UIKEY     IND
11GOVARDHAN PATLE URF HITLAR     IND
12JITENDRA MESHRAM     IND
13DHANESHWAR LILHARE     IND
14NYAZMIR KHAN     IND
15POORANLAL LODHI     IND
16MANSINGH BISEN     IND
17SANDEEP SANTRAM     IND
18SHRIRAM THAKUR     IND
JUNNARDEO-122     AMARWARA-123     CHURAI-124     SAUNSAR-125     CHHINDWARA-126
PARASIA-127     PANDHURNA-128
S12-16-MP-CHHINDWARA     1KAMAL NATH     INC
2MAROT RAO KHAVASE     BJP
3RAO SAHEB SHINDE     BSP
4JOGILAL IRPACHI     JMM
5PARDHESHI HARTAPSAH TIRKAM     GMS
6BALVEER SINGH YADAV     RKSP
7RAMKISHAN PAL     RPI(A)
8SATAP SHA UIKEY     GGP
9ABDUL SHAMAD KHAN     IND
10AMRITLAL PATHAK RAGHUVAR     IND
11ASHARAM DEHARIYA     IND
12KAMALNATH MAYAWADIPARASIA     IND
13GANARAM UIKEY     IND
14AZAD CHANDRASHEKHER PANDOLE SAMAJ SEVAK     IND
15JAGDISH BAIS     IND
16TULSIRAM SURYAWANSHI     IND
17DUARAM UIKEY     IND
18DHANPAL BHALAVI     IND
19DHANRAJ JAMBHATKAR     IND
20NARESH KUMAR YUVNATI     IND
21NIKHILESH DHURVEY     IND
22PITRAM UIKEY     IND
23PRAVINDRA NAURATI     IND
24MANMOHAN SHAH BATTI     IND
25RK MARKAM     IND
26SHOAIB KHAN     IND
27SUKMAN INVATI     IND
28SUBHASH SHUKLA     IND
NARSINGPUR-119     TENDUKHEDA-120     GADARWARA-121     SEONI-MALWA-136
HOSHANGABAD-137     SOHAGPUR-138     PIPARIYA-139     UDAIPURA-140
S12-17-MP-HOSHANGABAD     1UDAY PRATAP SINGH     INC
2ADVBMKAUSHIK     BSP
3HAJAEE SYID MUEEN UDDIN     SP
4RAMPAL SINGH     BJP
5DINESH KUMAR AHIRWAR     IND
6BHARAT KUMAR CHOUREY     IND
7MOHAMMD ABDULLA     IND
8RAKHI GUPTA     IND
9RAMPAL     IND
10SUDAMA PRASAD     IND
BHOJPUR-141     SANCHI-142     SILWANI-143     VIDISHA-144     BASODA-145
BUDHNI-156     ICHHAWAR-158     KHATEGAON-173
S12-18-MP-VIDISHA     1DRPREMSHANKAR SHARMA     BSP
2CHOUDHARY MUNABBAR SALIM     SP
3SUSHMA SWARAJ     BJP
4BHAI MUNSHILAL SILAWAT     RPI(A)
5RAMGOPAL MALVIYA     RDMP
6HARBHAJAN JANGRE     LJP
7GANESHRAM LODHI     IND
8RAJESHWAR SINGH YADAV RAO     IND
BERASIA-149     BHOPAL UTTAR-150     NARELA-151     BHOPAL DAKSHIN-
PASCHIM-152     BHOPAL MADHYA-153     GOVINDPURA-154     HUZUR-155     SEHORE-159
S12-19-MP-BHOPAL     1ER ASHOK NARAYAN SINGH     BSP
2KAILASH JOSHI     BJP
3MHOD MUNAWAR KHAN KAUSAR     SP
4SURENDRA SINGH THAKUR     INC
5ASHOK PAWAR     PRSP
6AHIRWAR LAKHANLAL PURVI     RPI(A)
7KARAN KUMAR KAROSIA URF KARAN JEEJA     GGP
8RADHESHYAM KULASTE     GMS
9RAMDAS GHOSLE     RPI(D)
10SANJEEV SINGHAL     SVSP
11ANIL SINGH     IND
12AMAR SINGH     IND
13KAPIL DUBEY     IND
14D C GUJARKAR     IND
15DARSHAN SINGH RATHORE     IND
16BRAJENDRA CHATURVEDI URF GAPPU CHATURVEDI     IND
17DR MAHESH YADAV AMAN GANDHI     IND
18MUKESH SEN     IND
19MEHDI SIR     IND
20RAJESH KUMAR YADAV     IND
21RAM SAHAY YATRI SHRIVASTAVA URF RASHTRAVADI YATRI     IND
22SHAHNAWAZ     IND
23SHIV NARAYAN SINGH BAGWARE     IND
CHACHOURA-30     RAGHOGARH-31     NARSINGHGARH-160     BIAORA-161
RAJGARH-162     KHILCHIPUR-163     SARANGPUR-164     SUSNER-165
S12-20-MP-RAJGARH     1NARAYANSINGH AMLABE     INC
2LAKSHMAN SINGH     BJP
3SHIVNARAYAN AHIRWAR     BSP
4RAJESH RATELIYA     LJP
5SHYAM SUNDER RATHI     SHS
6INDER SING LODHI     IND
7BALBIR CHOUDHARY PATRAKAR     IND
8LAXMAN VERMA     IND
9LAXMANSINGH AAMDOR     IND
ASHTA-157     AGAR-166     SHAJAPUR-167     SHUJALPUR-168     KALAPIPAL-169
SONKATCH-170     DEWAS-171     HATPIPLIYA-172
S12-21-MP-DEWAS     1THAVARCHAND GEHLOT     BJP
2BHAGIRATH PARIHAR     BSP
3SAJJAN SINGH VERMA     INC
4DR GANGARAM JOGCHAND     LJP
5JORAVAR SINGH DUDI     PRSP
6BALRAM SUKHRAM KALYANE     RWS
7JAYRAM SOLANKI     IND
8THAVARSINGH     IND
9PRO BS MALVIYA     IND
10MOHAN SIH MALVIYA     IND
NAGADA-KHACHROD-212     MAHIDPUR-213     TARANA-214     GHATIYA-215     UJJAIN
UTTAR-216     UJJAIN DAKSHIN-217     BADNAGAR-218     ALOT-223
S12-22-MP-UJJAIN     1GUDDU PREMCHAND     INC
2BABOOLAL THAWALIYA     BSP
3DR SATYANARAYAN JATIYA     BJP
4MADANLAL RAJORA     LJP
5ASHOK NARAYAN     IND
6INDARALAL VARMA     IND
7DINESH JATWA     IND
8LALCHAND BERWA GOME     IND
9SHIVKUMAR GAUR     IND
JAORA-222     MANDSOUR-224     MALHARGARH-225     SUWASRA-226     GAROTH-227
MANASA-228     NEEMUCH-229     JAWAD-230
S12-23-MP-MANDSOUR     1BHERULAL MALVIY BALAI     BSP
2MEENAKSHI NATRAJAN     INC
3DR LAXMINARAYAN PANDEY     BJP
4SHAIKH AZIZUDDEN QURAISHI     AIFB
5BANO BEE     BMSM
6KAILASH NARAYAN RATNAWAT     IND
7P DINESH NAGAR     IND
8HAJI NISAR AHMED CHOUDHARY     IND
9MOINUDDIN KHAN PATHAN     IND
10RAJENDRA SINGH GAUTAM     IND
11RAM DAYAL GUJRATI     IND
12LAXMINARAYAN BHAGIRATH PATIDAR     IND
ALIRAJPUR-191     JOBAT-192     JHABUA-193     THANDLA-194     PETLAWAD-195
RATLAM RURAL-219     RATLAM CITY-220     SAILANA-221
S12-24-MP-RATLAM     1KANTILAL BHURIA     INC
2JEEVANLAL     SP
3DILEEPSINGH BHURIA     BJP
4RAMESH SOLANKI     BSP
5UDAYSINGH MACHAR     RPI(A)
6KALUSINGH BHABHR     SHS
7JALAMSINGH PATEL     RDMP
8BHERUSING DAMOR     JD(U)
9BHADIYA DABAR     IND
10RAMESHWOR SINGAR     IND
SARDARPUR-196     GANDHWANI-197     KUKSHI-198     MANAWAR-199
DHARAMPURI-200     DHAR-201     BADNAWAR-202     DR.AMBEDKARNAGAR-MHOW-209
S12-25-MP-DHAR     1AJAY RAWAT     BSP
2GAJENDRASINGH RAJUKHEDI     INC
3MUKAMSINGH KIRADE     BJP
4JITENDRASINGH BAGHEL     GGP
5BAPUSINGH BAGHEL     RPI(A)
6RAM SINGH PATEL     SHS
7KARANSINGH     IND
8KHUMANSINGH BARIYA     IND
9BHIMA BHURIYA     IND
10MADAN BHAI AMLAWAR     IND
11HARIRAM PATEL DELMIWALA     IND
DEPALPUR-203     INDORE-1-204     INDORE-2-205     INDORE-3-206     INDORE-4-207
INDORE-5-208     RAU-210     SANWER-211
S12-26-MP-INDORE     1DR ANITA YADAV     SP
2RAHIM KHAN     BSP
3SATYNARAYAN PATEL     INC
4SUMITRA MAHAJAN TAI     BJP
5SANJAY SINGH BHADORIYA PAPPU     RJD
6MOHAN CHOUHAN MALVIYA     PRSP
7RADHESHYAM MUKATI     LPSP
8RAMSINGH     RPIE
9SAMADHAN NAIK     RPI(A)
10AJIT KUMAR JAIN PATWA     IND
11GAJENDRA SINGH GAUR     IND
12GHANSHYAM CHANDEL     IND
13CHINTAN TRIVEDI     IND
14NAND KISHORE SONI     IND
15PARMANAND METHARAM TOLANI     IND
16S R MANDLOI     IND
17VISHNU DAS     IND
18SHIKHAR CHAND PATODI JAIN     IND
MAHESHWAR-183     KASRAWAD-184     KHARGONE-185     BHAGWANPURA-186
SENDHAWA-187     RAJPUR-188     PANSEMAL-189     BADWANI-190
S12-27-MP-KHARGONE     1BHAI KIRNSINGH BADOLE KIRESH     CPI
2DRBARDE     BSP
3BALARAM BACHCHAN     INC
4MAKNSINGH SOLANKI BABUJI     BJP
5SAKHARAM VERMA     GGP
6GAJANAN AAPSING BRAHMANE     IND
7DONGER     IND
8DAYARAM GHISYA     IND
9FIFASINGH THAKUR     IND
10BHAGWAN CHOTHIYA     IND
11RAMESHVAR DOGAREEYA RAWAT     IND
BAGALI-174     MANDHATA-175     KHANDWA-177     PANDHANA-178     NEPANAGAR-179
BURHANPUR-180     BHIKANGAON-181     BADWAH-182
S12-28-MP-KHANDWA     1ARUN SUBHASHCHANDRA YADAV     INC
2HAJI ZAKIR HUSSAIN DURRANY ENGINEER     CPI
3NANDKUMAR SING CHAUHAN NANDU BHAIYA     BJP
4DADA SAHEB WAMANRAO SASANE     BSP
5NARGIS MOUSI     IJP
6HAJI NOORULLA     LJP
7MOHAN OJHA PARTE     GMS
8HABIB SURUR     MUL
9ABDUL GAFUR GUDDU PIRJI     IND
10NATHUSINGH CHAUHAN     IND
11NAHARSINH BHAI     IND
12RAVINDRA LAL PARE     IND
13BABA ABDUL HAMEED     IND
MULTAI-129     AMLA-130     BETUL-131     GHORADONGRI-132     BHAINSDEHI-133
TIMARNI-134     HARDA-135     HARSUD-176
S12-29-MP-BETUL     1OJHARAM EVANE     INC
2JYOTI DHURVE     BJP
3RAMA KAKODIA     BSP
4DR SUKHDEV SINGH CHOUHAN     SP
5KALLUSINGH UIKEY     GMS
6KADMU SINGH KUMARE KSKUMARE     GGP
7GULABRAV     RDMP
8MANGAL SINGH LOKHANDE     SWJP
9SUSHILKUMAR ALIS BALUBHAIYYA     RPI(A)
10IMRATLAL MARKAM     IND
11KAMAL SING     IND
12KADAKSHING VADIVA     IND
13KRISHNA GOPAL PARTE     IND
14MOTIRAM MAVASE     IND
15ADHIVAKTA SHANKAR PENDAM     IND
16SUNIL KUMAR KAWADE     IND
AKKALKUWA-1     SHAHADA-2     NANDURBAR-3     NAWAPUR-4     SAKRI-5     SHIRPUR-9
S13-1-MH-NANDURBAR     1GAVIT MANIKRAO HODLYA     INC
2NATAWADKAR SUHAS JYANT     BJP
3PADVI BABITA KARMSINGH     BSP
4KOKANI MANJULABAI SAKHARAM     BBM
5GAVIT SHARAD KRUSHNRAO     SP
6ABHIJIT AATYA VASAVE     IND
7KOLI RAJU RAMDAS     IND
DHULE RURAL-6     DHULE CITY-7     SINDKHEDA-8     MALEGAON CENTRAL-114
MALEGAON OUTER-115     BAGLAN-116
S13-2-MH-DHULE     1AMARISHBHAI RASIKLAL PATEL     INC
2RIZWAN MOAKBAR     BSP
3SONAWANE PRATAP NARAYANRAO     BJP
4ANIL ANNA GOTE     LKSGM
5ANSARI MOHD ISMAIL MOHD IBRAHIM     BMSM
6ARIF AHMED SHAIKH JAFHAR     NNP
7KAVAYATRISONKANYA THAKUR RAJANI BAGWAN     BBM
8NIHAL AHMED MOLVI MOHAMMED USMAN     JD(S)
9MD ISMAIL JUMMAN     IND
10KISHOR PITAMBAR AHIRE     IND
11GAZI ATEZAD AHMED MUBEEN AHMED KHAN     IND
12GAIKWAD PATIL BHUSHAN BAJIRAO     IND
13DADASO PANDITRAO PATIL KOKALEKAR     IND
14SHEVALE PATIL SANDEEP JIBHAU     IND
15SONAWANE PANDIT UTTAMRAO     IND
JALGAON CITY-13     JALGAON RURAL-14     AMALNER-15     ERANDOL-16
CHALISGAON-17     PACHORA-18
S13-3-MH-JALGAON     1AT NANA PATIL     BJP
2ADV MATIN AHMED     BSP
3ADV VASANTRAO JIVANRAO MORE     NCP
4ATMARAM SURSING JADHAV ENGG     KKJHS
5JADHAV NATTHU SHANKAR     BBM
6JANGALU DEVRAM SHIRSATH     HJP
7NANNAWARE CHAITANYA PANDIT     PRCP
8LAXMAN SHIVAJI SHIRSATH PATIL     KM
9ANIL PITAMBAR WAGH SIR     IND
10KANTILAL CHHAGAN NAIK BANJARA     IND
11WAGH SUDHAKAR ATMARAM     IND
12SHALIGRAM SHIVRAM MAHAJAN DEORE     IND
13SALIMODDIN ISAMODDIN SHEMISTARI     IND
CHOPDA-10     RAVER-11     BHUSAWAL-12     JAMNER-19     MUKTAINAGAR-20
MALKAPUR-21
S13-4-MH-RAVER     1PATIL SURESH CHINDHU     BSP
2ADV RAVINDRA PRALHADRAO PATIL     NCP
3HARIBHAU MADHAV JAWALE     BJP
4TELI SHAIKH ISMAIL HAJI HASAN     BBM
5BAPU SAHEBRAO SONAWANE     PRCP
6MARATHE BHIMRAO PARBAT     KM
7SHIVAVEER DNYANESHWAR VITTHAL AMALE URPH AMALE SARKAR     SVRP
8IQBAL ALAUDDIN TADVI     IND
9UTTAM KASHIRAM INGALE     IND
10KOLI SANTOSH GOKUL     IND
11FIRKE SURESH KACHARU EX ACP CRPF     IND
12MAKBUL FARID SK     IND
13MOHD MUNAWWAR MOHD HANIF     IND
14MORE HIRAMAN BHONAJI     IND
15DD WANI PHOTOGRAPHER DYNESHWAR DIWAKAR WANI     IND
16VIVEK SHARAD PATIL     IND
17SHAIKH RAMJAN SHAIKH KARIM     IND
18SUJATA IBRAHIM TADAVI     IND
19SANJAY PRALADH KANDELKAR     IND
BULDHANA-22     CHIKHLI-23     SINDKHED RAJA-24     MEHKAR-25     KHAMGAON-26
JALGAON (JAMOD)-27
S13-5-MH-BULDHANA     1JADHAV PRATAPRAO GANPATRAO     SHS
2DANDGE VASANTRAO SUGDEO     BSP
3SHINGNE DRRAJENDRA BHASKARRAO     NCP
4AMARDEEP BALASAHEB DESHMUKH     KM
5QURRASHI SKSIKANDAR SK SHAUKAT     DESEP
6GAJANAN RAJARAM SIRSAT     RSPS
7DHOKNE RAVINDRA TULSHRAMJI     BBM
8FERAN CHADRAHAS JAGDEO     ABHM
9GANESH ARJUN ZORE     IND
10TAYDE VITTHAL PANDHARI     IND
11DEVIDAS PIRAJI SARKATE     IND
12SY BILAL SY USMAN     IND
13BHARAT PUNJAJI SHINGANE     IND
14RAJESH NILKANTHRAO TATHE     IND
15RATHOD CHHAGAN BABULAL     IND
AKOT-28     BALAPUR-29     AKOLA WEST-30     AKOLA EAST-31     MURTIJAPUR-32
RISOD-33
S13-6-MH-AKOLA     1DHOTRE SANJAY SHAMRAO     BJP
2BABASAHEB DHABEKAR     INC
3ATIK AHAMAD GU JILANI     DESEP
4AMBEDKAR PRAKASH YASHWANT     BBM
5GANESH TULSHIRAM TATHE     KKJHS
6DIPAK SHRIRAM TIRAKE     RSPS
7AJABRAO UTTAMRAO BHONGADE     IND
8THAKURDAS GOVIND CHOUDHARI     IND
9MUJAHID KHAN CHAND KHAN     IND
10RAUT DEVIDAS ANANDRAO     IND
11WASUDEORAO KHADE GURUJI     IND
BADNERA-37     AMRAVATI-38     TEOSA-39     DARYAPUR-40     MELGHAT-41
ACHALPUR-42
S13-7-MH-AMRAVATI     1ADSUL ANANDRAO VITHOBA     SHS
2GANGADHAR GADE     BSP
3UGLE SUNIL NAMDEV     PRBP
4UBALE SHRIKRISHNA CHAMPATRAO     ARP
5KESHAV DASHARATH WANKHADE     KKJHS
6GAWAI RAJENDRA RAMKRUSHNA     RPI
7PRINCIPAL GOPICHAND SURYABHAN MESHRAM     RP(K)
8BARSE MANOHAR DAULATRAO     IUML
9SAU MAMATA VINAYAK KANDALKAR     AUDF
10DR HEMANTKUMAR RAMBHAU MAHURE     BBM
11AMOL DEVIDASRAO JADHAV     IND
12UMAK SHRIKRUSHNA SHYAMRAO     IND
13BANDU SAMPATRAO SANE BANDYA LS     IND
14BHAURAO SHRIRAM CHHAPANE     IND
15MITHUN HIRAMAN GAIKWAD     IND
16PROF MUKUND VITTHALRAO KHAIRE     IND
17DR RAJIV GULABRAO JAMTHE     IND
18RAJU MAHADEVRAO SONONE     IND
19VISHWANATH GOTUJI JAMNEKAR     IND
20SUDHAKAR VYANKAT RAMTEKE MAJI SAINIK     IND
21ADV SUDHIR HIRAMAN TAYADE     IND
22SUNIL PRABHU RAMTEKE     IND
DHAMAMGAON RAILWAY-36     MORSHI-43     ARVI-44     DEOLI-45     HINGANGHAT-46
WARDHA-47
S13-8-MH-WARDHA     1KANGALE BIPIN BABASAHEB     BSP
2DATTA MEGHE     INC
3SURESH GANPATRAO WAGHMARE     BJP
4DIWATE RAMESH MADHAORAO     KM
5NARAYANRAO RAMJI CHIDAM     GGP
6DR NITIN KESHORAO CHAVAN     PRBP
7PYARE SAHAB SHEIKH KARIM     DESEP
8BHOSE KAILAS VISHWASRAO     GMS
9ADV SURESH SHINDE     IJP
10SANGITA SUNIL ALIAS SONU KAMBLE     ARP
11ISHWARKUMAR SHANKARRAO GHARPURE     IND
12GUNWANT TUKARAMJI DAWANDE     IND
13JAGANNATH NILKANTHRAO RAUT     IND
14TAGADE VISHWESHWAR AWADHUTRAO     IND
15RAMTEKE PRAKASH BAKARAM     IND
16SARANG PRAKASHRAO YAWALKAR     IND
KATOL-48     SAVNER-49     HINGNA-50     UMRED-51     KAMTHI-58     RAMTEK-59
S13-9-MH-RAMTEK     1TUMANE KRUPAL BALAJI     SHS
2PRAKASHBHAU KISHAN TEMBHURNE     BSP
3WASNIK MUKUL BALKRISHNA     INC
4KUMBHARE SULEKHA NARAYAN     BREM
5DESHPANDE SANJAY SAOJI     HJP
6NAGARKAR PRASHANT HANSRAJ     BBM
7NANDKISHOR SADHUJI DONGRE     GGP
8BAGDE SUJEET WASUDEORAO     JD(S)
9PROF BORKAR PRADIP DARYAV     RP(K)
10MAYATAI CHAWRE UTWAL     SP
11VIKAS RAJARAM DAMLE     RPI(KH)
12SEEMA JEEVAN RAMTEKE     DESEP
13SANDIP SHESHRAO GAJBHIYE     GMS
14ASHISH ARUN NAGARARE     IND
15KHUSHAL UDARAMJI TUMANE     IND
16DHONE ANIL     IND
17ADV DUPARE ULHAS SHALIKRAM     IND
18BARWE MADHUKAR DOMAJI     IND
19ADV YUVRAJ ANANDRAOJI BAGDE     IND
20SURESH MANGALDAS BORKAR     IND
NAGPUR SOUTH WEST-52     NAGPUR SOUTH-53     NAGPUR EAST-54     NAGPUR
CENTRAL-55     NAGPUR WEST-56     NAGPUR NORTH-57
S13-10-MH-NAGPUR     1PUROHIT BANWARILAL BHAGWANDAS     BJP
2ENGINEER MANIKRAO VAIDYA     BSP
3MUTTEMWAR VILASRAO BABURAOJI     INC
4ARUN SHAMRAO JOSHI     ABHM
5KUMBHARE SULEKHA NARAYAN     BREM
6ADV GAJANAN SADASHIV KAWALE     RP(K)
7DILIP MANGAL MADAVI     GGP
8MEHMOOD KHAN RAHEEM KHAN     DESEP
9DR YASHWANT MANOHAR     BBM
10RAUT RAMESHCHANDRA     PRCP
11RAJESH SUKHDEV GAIKWAD     KKJHS
12ADV VASANTA UMRE     DPI
13SOMKUWAR VIJAY SITARAM     ARP
14AZIZUR REHMAN SHEIKH     IND
15ASHISH ARUN NAGRARE     IND
16ADV UPASHA BANSI TAYWADE     IND
17JAGDISH RAGHUNATH AMBADE     IND
18PRATIBHA UDAY KHAPARDE     IND
19PREMDAS RAMCHANDRA RAMTEKE     IND
20BARAPATRE CHANDRABHAN SOMAJI     IND
21BALASAHEB ALIAS PRAMOD RAMAJI SHAMBHARKAR     IND
22MOHAMAD HABIB REEZAVI     IND
23RAJESHKUMAR MOHANLAL PUGALIA     IND
24RAHUL MADHUKAR DESHMUKH     IND
25VIJAY DEVRAO DHAKATE     IND
26SUNIL GAYAPRASAD MISHRA     IND
27PROF DNYANESH WAKUDKAR     IND
TUMSAR-60     BHANDARA-61     SAKOLI-62     ARJUNI-MORGAON-63     TIRORA-64
GONDIYA-65
S13-11-MH-BHANDARA – GONDIYA     1GANVIR SHIVKUMAR NAGARCHI     CPI
2JAISWAL VIRENDRAKUMAR KASTURCHAND     BSP
3PATLE SHISHUPAL NATTHUJI     BJP
4PATEL PRAFUL MANOHARBHAI     NCP
5UNDIRWADE HEMANT JAGIVAN     PRCP
6JAMAIWAR SUNIL PARASRAM     RSPS
7PATHAN MUSHTAK LATIF     DESEP
8PRATIBHA VASANT PIMPALKAR     BBM
9WASNIK SUNIL MANIRAM     RP(K)
10UKEY CHINDHUJI LAKHAJI     IND
11GAJBHIYE BRAMHASWARUP BABURAO     IND
12GAJBHIYE RAJENDRA MAHADEO     IND
13ADV DHANANJAY SHAMLALJI RAJABHOJ     IND
14NANABHAU FALGUNRAO PATOLE     IND
15PATLE AKARSING SITARAM     IND
16PROF DR BHASKARRAO MAHADEORAO JIBHAKATE     IND
17MIRZA WAHIDBEG AHAMADBEG     IND
18YELE GANESHRAM SUKHRAM     IND
19RAHANGADALE MULCHAND OLGAN     IND
20DR RAMSAJIVAN KAWDU LILHARE     IND
21SADANAND SHRAWANJI GANVIR     IND
AMGAON-66     ARMORI-67     GADCHIROLI-68     AHERI-69     BRAHMAPURI-73
CHIMUR-74
S13-12-MH-GADCHIROLI-CHIMUR     1ASHOK MAHADEORAO NETE     BJP
2ATRAM RAJE SATYAWANRAO     BSP
3KOWASE MAROTRAO SAINUJI     INC
4NAMDEO ANANDRAO KANNAKE     CPI
5PROFFESOR KHANDALE KAWDU TULSHIRAM     KKJHS
6ADV DADMAL PRABHAKAR MAHAGUJI     PRBP
7PENDAM DIWAKAR GULAB     BBM
8PENDAM PURUSHOTTAM ZITUJI     DESEP
9VIJAY SURAJSING MADAVI     GGP
10JAMBHULE NARAYAN DINABAJI     IND
11DINESH TUKARAM MADAVI     IND
RAJURA-70     CHANDRAPUR-71     BALLARPUR-72     WARORA-75     WANI-76     ARNI-80
S13-13-MH-CHANDRAPUR     1AHIR HANSARAJ GANGARAM     BJP
2PUGALIA NARESH     INC
3ADV HAZARE DATTABHAU KRUSHNARAO     BSP
4KHARTAD LOMESH MAROTI     RWS
5KHOBRAGADE DESHAK GIRISHBABU     BBM
6CHATAP WAMAN SADASHIVRAO     STBP
7JAWED ABDUL KURESHI ALIAS PROF JAWED PASHA     JMM
8JITENDRA ADAKU RAUT     ABMP
9DANGE NATTHU BHAURAO     ARP
10PATHAN A RAZZAK KHAN HAYAT KHAN     SP
11MASRAM NIRANJAN SHIVRAM     GGP
12KALE DAMODHAR LAXMAN     IND
13QURESHI IKHALAQ MOHD YUSUF     IND
14GODE NARAYAN SHAHUJI     IND
15DEKATE BHASKAR PARASHRAM     IND
16MADHUKAR VITTHALRAO NISTANE     IND
17MESHRAM CHARANDAS JANGLUJI     IND
18RAMESH RAGHOBAJI TAJNE     IND
19VINOD DINANATH MESHRAM     IND
20VIRENDRA TARACHANDJI PUGLIA     IND
21SHATRUGHN VYANKATRAO SONPIMPLE     IND
22SANJAY NILKANTH GAWANDE     IND
23HIWARKAR SUDHIR MOTIRAMJI     IND
WASHIM-34     KARANJA-35     RALEGAON-77     YAVATMAL-78     DIGRAS-79     PUSAD-81
S13-14-MH-YAVATMAL-WASHIM     1YEDATKAR DILIP LAXMANRAO     BSP
2BHAVANA GAWALI PATIL     SHS
3HARISING RATHOD     INC
4UTTAM BHAGAJI KAMBLE     PRCP
5KURESHI SK MEHBUB SKFATTU     BBM
6KWAJA NASIRODDINE KHAN     DESEP
7GAJANAN KASHIRAM PATIL HEMBADE     KM
8DHAGE VITTHAL MAHADEV     RSPS
9MANIYAR YUNUS MAHMOOD ZAHMI     AUDF
10MOHMMAD KHAN AZIZ KHAN     SP
11ATHAWALE SADANAND PRALHADRAO     IND
12GAJANAN BURMAL DODWADE     IND
13NETAJI SITARAMJI KINAKE     IND
14NANDKISHOR NARAYANRAO THAKARE     IND
15PAWAR RAMESH GORSING     IND
16PURUSHOTTAM DOMAJI BHAJGAWRE     IND
17MADHUKAR SHIVDASPPA GORATE     IND
18MANOJ JANARDAN PATIL     IND
19MUKHADE SAU LALITARAI SUBHASHRAO     IND
20MESHRAM BANDU GANPAT     IND
21MOHD INAMURRAHIM MOHD MUSA     IND
22RAVINDRA ALIAS RAVIPAL MADHUKARRAO GANDHE     IND
23RAJKUMAR NARAYAN BHUJADALE     IND
24RATHOD DEVISING RAMA     IND
25SD VHIDODDIN SD KRIMODDIN     IND
26VISHNU KASINATH TAWKAR     IND
27SURESH BABAN PEDEKAR     IND
28SURESH BHIVA TARAL     IND
UMARKHED-82     KINWAT-83     HADGAON-84     BASMATH-92     KALAMNURI-93
HINGOLI-94
S13-15-MH-HINGOLI     1DR BD CHAVHAN     BSP
2SUBHASH BAPURAO WANDHEDE     SHS
3SURYAKANTA JAIWANTRAO PATIL     NCP
4UTTAMRAO DAGADUJI BHAGAT     PRCP
5AJAS NOORMINYA     DESEP
6NAIK MADHAVRAO BAHENARAO     BBM
7VINAYAK SHRIRAM BHISE     KM
8GUNDEKAR SANJAY ADELU     IND
9PATHAN SATTAR KASIMKHAN     IND
10PACHPUTE RAMPRASAD KISHANRAO     IND
11MD A MUJIM ANSARI A     IND
BHOKAR-85     NANDED NORTH-86     NANDED SOUTH-87     NAIGAON-89     DEGLUR-90
MUKHED-91
S13-16-MH-NANDED     1KHATGAONKAR PATIL BHASKARRAO BAPURAO     INC
2MD MAKBUL SALIM HAJI MD KHAJA     BSP
3SAMBHAJI PAWAR     BJP
4ALTAF AHMAD EAKBAL AHMAD     BBM
5KHADE SANJAY WAMANRAO     PRCP
6TIWARI RAMA BHAGIRAT     RSPS
7ADV CS BAHETI     JP
8MORE RAJESH EKNATHRAO     KM
9A RAEES A JABBAR     ANC
10SHINDE PREETI MADHUKAR     JSS
11SHUDHIR YASHWANT SURVE     KKJHS
12COM ASHOK NAGORAO GHAYALE     IND
13ANAND JADHAV HOTALKAR     IND
14KOREWAR BALAJI NARSING     IND
15JADHAV VISHNU MAROTI     IND
16NAVGHARE ANAND PANDURANG     IND
17NARAYAN SURYAVANSHI DOANGONKAR     IND
18PATHAN ZAFAR ALI KHAN MAHEMUD ALI KHAN     IND
19AIDS MAN PRAKASH TATERAO LANDGE     IND
20BHARANDE RAMCHANDRA GANGARAM     IND
21ADV RAMRAO PANDURANG WAGHMARE     IND
22HANMANTE VIJAY CHANDRAO     IND
JINTUR-95     PARBHANI-96     GANGAKHED-97     PATHRI-98     PARTUR-99
GHANSAWANGI-100
S13-17-MH-PARBHANI     1ADV DUDHGAONKAR GANESHRAO NAGORAO     SHS
2RAJSHRI BABASAHEB JAMAGE     BSP
3WARPUDKAR SURESH AMBADASRAO     NCP
4AJIM AHMED KHAN AJIJ KHAN     DESEP
5ASHOKRAO BABARAO AMBHORE     ANC
6KACHOLE MANAVENDRA SAWALARAM     STBP
7KALE VYANKATRAO BHIMRAO     KM
8NAMDEV LIMBAJI KACHAVE     KKJHS
9BHAND GANGADHAR SAKHARAM     BBM
10MULE BABAN DATTARAO     RSPS
11RUMALE TUKARAM DHONDIBA     PRCP
12SAYYAD EKRAMODDIN SAYYAD MUNIRODDIN     LVKP
13ASAD BIN ABDULLAHA BIN     IND
14JAMEEL AHMED SK AHMED     IND
15DR DESHMUKH KISHANRAO JANARDHANRAO EXSERVICEMAN     IND
16RATHOD RAMRAO DHANSING SIR     IND
17SHINDE LAXMAN EKANATH     IND
18SAMAR GORAKHNATH PAWAR     IND
19SALVE SUDHAKAR UMAJI     IND
JALNA-101     BADNAPUR-102     BHOKARDAN-103     SILLOD-104     PHULAMBRI-106
PAITHAN-110
S13-18-MH-JALNA     1DR KALE KALYAN VAIJINATHRAO     INC
2DANVE RAOSAHEB DADARAO     BJP
3RATHOD RAJPALSINH GABRUSINH     BSP
4AAPPASAHEB RADHAKISAN KUDHEKAR     KM
5KISAN BALVANTA BORDE     PRCP
6KHARAT ASHOK RAMRAO     BBM
7TAWAR KAILAS BHAUSAHEB     STBP
8DR DILAWAR MIRZA BAIG     IUML
9BHOJNE BABASAHEB SANGAM     RSPS
10MISAL TUKARAM BABURAOJI     SP
11RATNAPARKHE ARCHANA SUDHAKAR     RPIE
12SUBHASH FAKIRA SALVE     ANC
13SAYYAD MAKSUD NOOR     LJP
14KOLTE MANOJ NEMINATH     IND
15KHANDU HARISHCHANDRA LAGHANE     IND
16NADE DNYANESHWAR DAGDU     IND
17BABASAHEB PATIL SHINDE     IND
18SONWANE ASHOK VITTHAL     IND
19S HUSAIN AHEMAD     IND
KANNAD-105     AURANGABAD CENTRAL-107     AURANGABAD WEST-108     AURANGABAD
EAST-109     GANGAPUR-111     VAIJAPUR-112
S13-19-MH-AURANGABAD     1UTTAMSINGH RAJDHARSINGH PAWAR     INC
2CHANDRAKANT KHAIRE     SHS
3SAYYED SALIM SAYYED YUSUF     BSP
4JAHAGIRDAR MOHMAD AYUB GULAM     SP
5JYOTI RAMCHANDRA UPADHAYAY     BBM
6PANDURANG WAMANRAO NARWADE     PRCP
7BHIMSEN RAMBHAU KAMBLE     RPIE
8MANIK RAMU SHINDE     KM
9SHAIKH HARUN MALIK SAHEB     RSPS
10UTTAM MANIK KIRTIKAR     IND
11EJAZ KHAN BISMILLAH KHAN     IND
12KAZI MUSHIRODDIN TAJODDIN     IND
13KRISHNA DEVIDAS JADHAV     IND
14JADHAV TOTARAM GANPAT     IND
15JADHAV VISHNU SURYABHAN     IND
16JADHAV SUBHASH RUPCHAND     IND
17BANKAR MILIND RANUJI     IND
18SHANTIGIRIJI MOUNGIRIJI MAHARAJ     IND
19SHAIKH RAFIQ SHAIKH RAZZAK     IND
20SHAIKH SALIM PATEL WAHEGAONKAR     IND
21SAYYED RAUF SAYYED ZAMIR     IND
22SUBHASH KISANRAO PATIL JADHAV     IND
NANDGAON-113     KALWAN-117     CHANDVAD-118     YEVLA-119     NIPHAD-121
DINDORI-122
S13-20-MH-DINDORI     1GAVIT JEEVA PANDU     CPM
2GANGURDE DIPAK SHANKAR     BSP
3CHAVAN HARISHCHANDRA DEORAM     BJP
4ZIRWAL NARHARI SITARAM     NCP
5PAWAR SAMPAT WAMAN     BBM
6GANGURDE BALU KISAN     IND
7BHIKA HARISING BARDE     IND
8VIJAY NAMDEO PAWAR     IND
9SHANKAR DEORAM GANGUDE     IND
SINNAR-120     NASHIK EAST-123     NASHIK CENTRAL-124     NASHIK WEST-125
DEVLALI-126     IGATPURI-127
S13-21-MH-NASHIK     1GAIKWAD DATTA NAMDEO     SHS
2SAMEER BHUJBAL     NCP
3SHRIMAHANT SUDHIRDAS MAHARAJ     BSP
4KAILAS MADHUKAR CHAVAN     IJP
5GODSE HEMANT TUKARAM     MNS
6JADHAV NAMDEO BHIKAJI     BBM
7RAYATE VIJAY SAKHARAM  RAYATE SIR     HJP
8AD GULVE RAMNATH SANTUJI     IND
9DATTU GONYA GAIKWAD     IND
10PRAVINCHANDRA DATTARAM DETHE     IND
11BHARAT HIRMAN PARDESHI     IND
12RAJENDRA SAMPATRAO KADU     IND
DAHANU-128     VIKRAMGAD-129     PALGHAR-130     BOISAR-131     NALASOPARA-132
VASAI-133
S13-22-MH-PALGHAR     1KOM LAHANU SHIDVA     CPM
2ADV CHINTAMAN NAVSHA VANGA     BJP
3DALAVI BHASKAR LADKU     BSP
4SHINGADA DAMODAR BARKU     INC
5CHANDRAKANT BALU PHUPANE     BBM
6JADHAV BALIRAM SUKUR     BVA
7DR KASHIRAM MAHADU DHONDAGHA     IND
8PANDURANG JETHYA PARADHI     IND
BHIWANDI RURAL-134     SHAHAPUR-135     BHIWANDI WEST-136     BHIWANDI
EAST-137     KALYAN WEST-138     MURBAD-139
S13-23-MH-BHIWANDI     1TAWARE SURESH KASHINATH     INC
2PATIL JAGANNATH SHIVRAM     BJP
3VGPATIL     BSP
4AJIM GANI SHEKH     RKSP
5ISMAIL SHAIKH LATIF     KKJHS
6DEVRAJ KISAN MHATRE     MNS
7RR PATIL     SP
8MURTUZA MUZAFFAR SHAIKH     NNP
9SHASHIKANT MOTIRAM KATHORE     RSPS
10SHAIKH MEHBOOB BASHA VALI     BBM
11GURUNATH UNDRYA NAIK     IND
12DATTU GANAPAT BHOIR     IND
13MAHENDRA KERU WADHVINDE     IND
14MAHENDRA R MOHITE     IND
15VIKAS SAKHARAM NIKAM     IND
16VISHWANATH R PATIL     IND
AMBERNATH-140     ULHAS NAGAR-141     KALYAN EAST-142     DOMBIVALI-143     KALYAN
RURAL-144     MUMBRA-KALWA-149
S13-24-MH-KALYAN     1ANAND PRAKASH PARANJAPE     SHS
2KHAN KAMRUDDIN A GANI     BSP
3DAWKHARE VASANT SHANKARRAO     NCP
4AZAMI MUHAMMAD MAROOF NASIM     RSPS
5KHAN AYAD MOHAMMAD NEBAS ALI     IUML
6NARENDRA WAMAN MORE     PRBP
7VAISHALI DAREKARRANE     MNS
8ADVSSSALVE RETIRED JUDGE     BBM
9SAYYAD HASINA MOHAMMED NASEEM     NBNP
10HRUDHAYNATH BAPU WAGHODE ALIAS BALABHAU     KM
11ALOK SINGH CHOTELAL     IND
12GOVARDHAN CHANGO BHAGAT     IND
13DHANANJAY BAPPASAHEB JOGDAND     IND
14COM BABAN KAMBLE     IND
15BHANUSHALI LAXMINDAS VELJI     IND
16MOHHAMAD YUSUF FAROOKH KHAN     IND
17VADHVINDE MAHENDRA KERU     IND
18SHIRSE RAMSINGH UKHAJI     IND
19SIDDIQUE ASFAQUE ALI     IND
20SURESH RAM PANDAGALE     IND
MIRA BHAYANDAR-145     OVALA – MAJIWADA-146     KOPRI-PACHPAKHADI-147
THANE-148     AIROLI-150     BELAPUR-151
S13-25-MH-THANE     1AVANINDRA KUMAR TRIPATHI     BSP
2CHAUGULE VIJAY LAXMAN     SHS
3DRSANJEEV GANESH NAIK     NCP
4KAMLAKAR ANAND TAYDE     BBM
5JAIN SEEMA MAHENDRA     PRBP
6PATHAN JAVEED KAMIL KHAN     NNP
7PARAG HANUMANT NEWALKAR     KKJHS
8BERNARDSHAW DAVID NADAR     RP(K)
9MAHESH RATHI CHANAKYA     RVNP
10RAJAN RAJE     MNS
11SINGH RAJESH MUNNILAL     RSPS
12AHMAD AFJAL SHAIKH     IND
13KAMBLE SACHIN SHIRPAT     IND
14KUMAR K     IND
15KHAN FIROZ YUSUFKHAN     IND
16GAUD FAUJDAR RANGI     IND
17CHETAN PRAKASH JADHAV     IND
18JAIPRAKASH NARAYAN BHANDE     IND
19RD TAMBE     IND
20PARANJAPE DIPSHREE DEEPAK     IND
21PRAMOD INGALE     IND
22FREDI ALBERT BHANGA     IND
23MURLIDHAR KRUSNA PAWAR     IND
24MANGESH BHARAT KHADE     IND
25MOH RIZWAN ABDULLA PATEL     IND
26VIJAY CHAUGULE     IND
27VIDYADHAR LAXMAN JOSHI     IND
28VILAS DIPAK KHAMBE     IND
29SAYED SHAFIQ AHMED ZOIDI     IND
30SWATANTRA KUMAR PARMANAND ANAND     IND
BORIVALI-152     DAHISAR-153     MAGATHANE-154     KANDIVALI EAST-160
CHARKOP-161     MALAD WEST-162
S13-26-MH-MUMBAI NORTH     1RAM NAIK     BJP
2LAKHMENDRA KHURANA     BSP
3SANJAY BRIJKISHORLAL NIRUPAM     INC
4USMAN THIM     SP
5KAILAS KATHAJI CHAVAN     PRCP
6PARKAR SHIRISH LAXMAN     MNS
7RAMESH KUMAR R SINGH     SBSP
8RAJENDRA J THACKER     PRPI
9DR LEO REBELLO     BBM
10SANGEETA SHETTY LOKHANDE     PPIS
11AD ARUN R KEJRIWAL     IND
12KALYAN BHIMA GALPHADE     IND
13GOPAL RAGHUNATH JAMSANDEKAR     IND
14JAMNA PRASAD GANGAPRASAD PATEL     IND
15JAHIR HUSSEIN ABDUL GANI HAVALDAR     IND
16BHANDARI RAMESH SUKUR     IND
17MAHENDRA TUKARAM AHIRE     IND
18RAKESH D KUMAR     IND
19VASHRAMBHAI MOHANBHAI PATEL     IND
20SHYAM TIPANNA KURADE     IND
21SUBODH GIRDHARI RANJAN     IND
22SUBHASH PARSHURAM KHANVILKAR     IND
23SURENDRA AMBALAL PATEL     IND
JOGESHWARI EAST-158     DINDOSHI-159     GOREGAON-163     VERSOVA-164     ANDHERI
WEST-165     ANDHERI EAST-166
S13-27-MH-MUMBAI NORTH WEST     1ATHAR SIDDIQUI     BSP
2ADKAMAT GURUDAS VASANT     INC
3GAJANAN KIRTIKAR     SHS
4AGGARWAL RISHI DHARAMPAL     JGP
5ABU ASIM AZMI     SP
6JADHAV BHIKAJI GANGARAM     KKJHS
7THAKARE SHALINI JITENDRA     MNS
8TAWADE DILIP NARAYAN     AIFB
9PAWAR SUBHASH PANDURANG     PRCP
10VAIJANATH SANGRAM GAIKWAD     BBM
11ANITA RAMKRUSHAN RUPAWATE     IND
12KAMBLE SATISH KISAN     IND
13DAYANAND NIVRUTI KAMBLE     IND
14DHOTRE MARUTI YAMNAPPA     IND
15NINAD MANJARDEKAR     IND
16PRAMOD SITARAM KASURDE     IND
17BHATIA RIPUDAMAN SINGH     IND
18MOHAMMED RAFIQ ABDUL RAZAK SHAIKH     IND
19MAHADEV LIMBAJI GALPHADE     IND
20DR VIJAY BHAVE     IND
21SANTOSH PANDURANG CHAIKE     IND
MULUND-155     VIKHROLI-156     BHANDUP WEST-157     GHATKOPAR WEST-169
GHATKOPAR EAST-170     MANKHURD SHIVAJI NAGAR-171
S13-28-MH-MUMBAI NORTH EAST     1ASHOK CHANDRAPAL SINGH     BSP
2KIRIT SOMAIYA     BJP
3SANJAY DINA PATIL     NCP
4KOKARE SANJAY DHAKU     BBM
5MANISHA MUKESH GADE     KKJHS
6VISHWANATH DATTU PATIL     RSPS
7SHISHIR SHINDE     MNS
8JAYESH C MIRANI     IND
9TATVASAHEB REVDEKAR     IND
10DIKSHA JITENDRA JAGTAP     IND
11DHARMPAL BHAGWAN MESHRAM     IND
12NAMDEV TUKARAM SATHE     IND
13NARAYAN ANAND ROKADE     IND
14PANKAJBHAI SOMCHAND SHAH     IND
15PRAKASH D KAMBLE     IND
16SUNITA MOHAN TUPSOUNDARYA     IND
VILE PARLE-167     CHANDIVALI-168     KURLA-174     KALINA-175     VANDRE
EAST-176     VANDRE WEST-177
S13-29-MH-MUMBAI NORTH CENTRAL     1EBRAHIM SHAIKH     BSP
2DUTT PRIYA SUNIL     INC
3MAHESH RAM JETHMALANI     BJP
4JAYESH JASHWANTRAI BHAYANI     THPI
5BHOSALE NITIN GANGARAM     RPIE
6MOHAMAND RAFIQ QURESHI     NNP
7MOHD SHAHID     IBSP
8SHILPA ATUL SARPOTDAR     MNS
9SUREKHA PEVEKAR     RSPS
10ARORA RAKESH VISHWANATH     IND
11ASLAM HANIF KHOT     IND
12CHELJI S PATEL     IND
13TULSIDAS KRISHNADAS NAIR     IND
14COM DEVCHAND RANDIVE     IND
15MOHAMAD YAHIYA SIDDHIQUE     IND
16RAJKAMAL JAISINGH YADAV     IND
17WAGHMARE AATISH RAMCHANDRA     IND
18SUDHIR SHANKAR PARDESHI     IND
19SUHAS BHIKURAM TAMBE     IND
ANUSHAKTI NAGAR-172     CHEMBUR-173     DHARAVI-178     SION KOLIWADA-179
WADALA-180     MAHIM-181
S13-30-MH-MUMBAI SOUTH CENTRAL     1IQBAL MOHAMMAD SAYYAD     RJD
2EKNATH M GAIKWAD     INC
3BARVE PRAVIN RAMCHANDRA     BSP
4SURESH ANANT GAMBHIR     SHS
5DR AKALPITA PARANJPE     BUDM
6AD ANARYA PUNDALIK PAWAR     BBM
7KAMAL NARAYAN WAGHDARE     RP(K)
8KARAM HUSSAIN KHAN     NLHP
9KISHOR BHAGWAN JAGTAP     RSPS
10GARUD MILIND MADHAV MG     RPIE
11MOHHAMMED USMAN SHAIKH     BMSM
12RAJENDRA GANPAT JADHAV     PRCP
13SHWETA VIVEK PARULKAR     MNS
14KISHORKUMAR VASANTRAO JADHAV     IND
15TRIYOGINATH DUBEY     IND
16DILIP RAMCHANDRA GANDHI     IND
17MANOJ G SINGH     IND
18RAJU SAHEBRAO DALVI     IND
19ROHAN GAWRU TAMBE     IND
20LAYEEK AHMED ANSARI     IND
21VIKAS KUMAR     IND
22SHAHAJIRAO DHONDIBA THORAT     IND
23DR SAILEN KUMAR GHOSH     IND
WORLI-182     SHIVADI-183     BYCULLA-184     MALABAR HILL-185     MUMBA
DEVI-186     COLABA-187
S13-31-MH-MUMBAI SOUTH     1DEORA MILIND MURLI     INC
2MOHAN RAWALE     SHS
3MOHAMMAD ALI ABUBAKAR SHAIKH     BSP
4AVDHUT RAMCHANDRA BHISE     JD(S)
5CHIRAG KANTILAL JETHAVA     KKJHS
6FIROZ USMAN TINVALA     DESEP
7BALA NANDGAONKAR     MNS
8DRMONA KARTIK SHAH     PRPI
9MOHAMMED AMIR SHAIKH MONTU     RPI(D)
10AD RAJESH YASHVANT BHOSALE     PPOI
11SAYYED ATHER ALI     SP
12ASHOK SHANKAR AMBULKAR     IND
13KHIMJI CHIMAN MAKWANA     IND
14ADVOCATE FIROZ AHMED ANSARI     IND
15MIRA H SANYAL     IND
16MUKESH NEMICHAND JAIN     IND
17DR SHAIKH SHAHID AHMED     IND
18SAYYED SALIM SAYYED RAHIM     IND
19SURYAKANT KESHAV SHINGE     IND
20ZNYOSHO RASHTRAPATI     IND
PEN-191     ALIBAG-192     SHRIVARDHAN-193     MAHAD-194     DAPOLI-263
GUHAGAR-264
S13-32-MH-RAIGAD     1ANANT GEETE     SHS
2BARRISTER AR ANTULAY     INC
3MOHITE KIRAN BABURAO     BSP
4EKANATH ARJUN PATIL     RSPS
5ADV PRAVIN MADHUKAR THAKUR     IND
6DR SIDDHARTH PATIL     IND
7SUNIL BHASKAR NAIK     IND
PANVEL-188     KARJAT-189     URAN-190     MAVAL-204     CHINCHWAD-205
PIMPRI-206
S13-33-MH-MAVAL     1PANSARE AZAM FAKEERBHAI     NCP
2BABAR GAJANAN DHARMSHI     SHS
3MISHRA UMAKANT RAMESHWAR     BSP
4AYU DEEPALI NIVRUTTI CHAVAN     PRCP
5PRADIP PANDURANG KOCHAREKAR     RSPS
6ADVSHIVSHANKAR DATTATRAY SHINDE     KM
7ISHWAR DATTATRAY JADHAV     IND
8JAGANNATH PANDURANG KHARGE     IND
9DOLE BHIMRAJ NIVRUTTI     IND
10ADVOCATE TUKARAM WAMANRAO BANSODE     IND
11TANTARPALE GOPAL YASHWANTRAO     IND
12ADVOCATE PRAMOD MAHADEV GORE     IND
13BHAPKAR MARUTI SAHEBRAO     IND
14MAHENDRA PRABHAKAR TIWARI     IND
15BRO MANUAL DESOZA     IND
16YASHWANT NARAYAN DESAI     IND
17SHAKEEL RAJBHAI SHAIKH     IND
18HARIBHAU DADAJI SHINDE     IND
VADGAOL SHERI-208     SHIVAJINAGAR-209     KOTHRUD-210     PARVATI-212     PUNE
CANTONMENT-214     KASBA PETH-215
S13-34-MH-PUNE     1ANIL SHIROLE     BJP
2KALMADI SURESH     INC
3D S K ALIAS DSKULKARNI     BSP
4ARUN BHATIA     PG
5GULAB TATYA WAGHMODE     BBM
6BAGBAN JAVED KASIM     IUML
7VIKRAMADITYA OMPRAKASH DHIMAN     RSPS
8VINOD ANAND SINH     PTSS
9SHIROLE RANJEET SHRIKANT     MNS
10SAVITA HAJARE     PPOI
11SANGHARSH ARUN APTE     PRCP
12AJAY VASANT PAITHANKAR     IND
13ADAGALE BHAUSAHEB RAMCHANDRA     IND
14ASHOK GANPAT PALKHE ALIAS SUTAR     IND
15KAMTAM ISWAR SAMBHAYYA     IND
16KULKARNI KAUSTUBH SHASHIKANT     IND
17KHAN AMANULLA MOHMOD AL     IND
18KHAN NISSAR TAJ AHMAD     IND
19P K CHAVAN     IND
20CHOUDHARI SUNIL GULABRAO     IND
21CHOURE VILAS CHINTAMAN     IND
22TATYA ALIAS NARAYAN SHANKAR WAMBHIRE     IND
23TAMBOLI SHABBIR SAJJANBHAI     IND
24DATTATRAYA GANESH TALGERI     IND
25BAGADE SACHIN MARUTI     IND
26BALU ALIAS ANIL SHIROLE     IND
27BHARAT MANOHAR GAVALI     IND
28BHAGWAT RAGHUNATH KAMBLE     IND
29RAJENDRA BHAGAT ALIAS JITU BHAI     IND
30VIKRAM NARENDRA BOKE     IND
31SHINDE RAJENDRA BABURAO     IND
32SHAIKH ALTAF KARIM     IND
33SHRIKANT MADHUSUDAN JAGTAP     IND
34SARDESAI KISHORKUMAR RAGHUNATH     IND
35ADVSUBHASH NARHAR GODSE     IND
36SANTOSH ALIAS SOMNATH KALU PAWAR     IND
DAUND-199     INDAPUR-200     BARAMATI-201     PURANDAR-202     BHOR-203
KHADAKWASALA-211
S13-35-MH-BARAMATI     1KUDALEPATIL VIVEK ANANT     BSP
2KANTA JAYSING NALAWADE     BJP
3SUPRIYA SULE     NCP
4MAYAWATI AMAR CHITRE     BMSM
5SHELAR SANGEETA PANDURANG     KM
6SACHIN VITTHAL AHIRE     PRCP
7SAMPAT MARUTI TAKALE     RSPS
8GHORPADE SAVEETA ASHOK     IND
9TATYA ALIAS NARAYAN SHANKAR WAMBHIRE     IND
10TANTARPALE GOPAL YESHWANTRAO     IND
11DEEPAK SHANKAR BHAPKAR     IND
12BHIMA ANNA KADALE     IND
13MRUNALEENI JAYRAJ KAKADE     IND
14YOGESH SONABA RANDHEER     IND
15SHIVAJI JAYSING KOKARE     IND
16SURESH BABURAO VEER     IND
17SANGITA SHRIMAN BHUMKAR     IND
JUNNAR-195     AMBEGAON-196     KHED ALANDI-197     SHIRUR-198     BHOSARI-207
HADAPSAR-213
S13-36-MH-SHIRUR     1ADHALRAO SHIVAJI DATTATRAY     SHS
2ZAGADE YASHWANT SITARAM     BSP
3VILAS VITHOBA LANDE     NCP
4PALLAVI MOHAN HARSHE     PRCP
5SHELAR DNYANOBA SHRIPATI     RPPI
6SURESH MULCHAND KANKARIA MAMA     RSPS
7ABHANG KONDIBHAU BHIMAJI     IND
8KARANDE CHANGDEO NAMDEO     IND
9KALURAM RAGHUNATH TAPKIR     IND
10RAM DHARMA DAMBALE     IND
11LANDE VILAS MHATARBA     IND
SHEVGAON-222     RAHURI-223     PARNER-224     AHMEDNAGAR CITY-225
SHRIGONDA-226     KARJAT JAMKHED-227
S13-37-MH-AHMADNAGAR     1KARDILE SHIVAJI BHANUDAS     NCP
2KARBHARI WAMAN SHIRSAT ALIAS KV SHIRSAT     CPI
3GADAKH TUKARAM GANGADHAR     BSP
4GANDHI DILIPKUMAR MANSUKHLAL     BJP
5KAZI SAJID MUJIR     RPIE
6HAKE BHANUDAS KISAN     RSPS
7HOLE BHANUDAS NAMDEO     BBM
8ARUN KAHAR     IND
9AVINASH MALHARRAO GHODAKE     IND
10KHAIRE ARJUN DEORAO     IND
11GAIKWAD BALASAHEB RAMCHANDRA     IND
12NAUSHAD ANSAR SHAIKH     IND
13PROF MAHENDRA DADA SHINDE     IND
14RAUT EKNATH BABASAHEB     IND
15RAJIV APPASAHEB RAJALE     IND
AKOLE-216     SANGAMNER-217     SHIRDI-218     KOPARGAON-219     SHRIRAMPUR-220
NEVASA-221
S13-38-MH-SHIRDI     1KACHARU NAGU WAGHMARE     BSP
2WAKCHOURE BHAUSAHEB RAJARAM     SHS
3ATHAWALE RAMDAS BANDU     RPI
4DHOTRE SUCHIT CHINTAMANI     KM
5SATISH BALASAHEB PALGHADMAL     PRCP
6ADHAGALE RAJENDRA NAMDEV     IND
7KAMBALE RAMESH ANKUSH     IND
8GAIKWAD APPASAHEB GANGADHAR     IND
9BAGUL BALU DASHARATH     IND
10MEDHE PRAFULLAKUMAR MURLIDHAR     IND
11RAKSHE ANNASAHEB EKNATH     IND
12RUPWATE PREMANAND DAMODHAR     IND
13LODHE SHARAD LAXAMAN     IND
14WAGH GANGADHAR RADHAJI     IND
15VAIRAGHAR SUDHIR NATHA     IND
16SABALE ANIL DAMODHAR     IND
17SANDIP BHASKAR GOLAP     IND
GEORAI-228     MAJALGAON-229     BEED-230     ASHTI-231     KAIJ-232     PARLI-233
S13-39-MH-BEED     1KOKATE RAMESH BABURAO ADASKAR     NCP
2MASKE MACHHINDRA BABURAO     BSP
3MUNDE GOPINATHRAO PANDURANG     BJP
4KHALGE KACHRU SANTRAMJI     BBM
5GURAV KALYAN BHANUDAS     RKSP
6TATE ASHOK SANTRAM     ARP
7NIKALJE SHEELATAI MAHENDRA     PRCP
8PRAMOD ALIAS PARMESHWAR SAKHARAM MOTE     KM
9BABURAO NARAYANRAO KAGADE     ANC
10DR SHIVAJIRAO KISANRAO SHENDGE     RSPS
11KAMAL KONDIRAM NIMBALKAR     IND
12KAMBLE DEEPAK DYANOBA     IND
13KHAN SIKANDAR KHAN HUSSAIN KHAN     IND
14GUJAR KHAN MIRZA KHAN     IND
15ADVNATKAR RAMRAO SHESHRAO     IND
16PATHAN GAFARKHAN JABBARKHAN     IND
17MAHAMMAD AKARAM MAHAMMAD SALIMUDDIN BAGWAN     IND
18RAMESH VISHVANATH KOKATE     IND
19SAYYED MINHAJ ALI WAJED ALI PENDKHJUR WALE     IND
20SAYYED SALIM FATTU     IND
21SARDAR KHAN SULTANABABA     IND
AUSA-239     UMARGA-240     TULJAPUR-241     OSMANABAD-242     PARANDA-243
BARSHI-246
S13-40-MH-OSMANABAD     1GAIKWAD RAVINDRA VISHWANATH     SHS
2DIVAKAR YASHWANT NAKADE     BSP
3PATIL PADAMSINHA BAJIRAO     NCP
4JAGTAP BHAGWAN DADARAO     BBM
5TARKASE DHANANJAY MURLIDHAR     ABHM
6TAWADE PRAKASH TANAJIRAO     KM
7BANSODE GUNDERAO SHIVRAM     RSPS
8BABA FAIJODDIN SHAIKH     NELU
9BHOSLE REVAN VISHWANATH     JD(S)
10MUJAWAR SHAHABUDDIN NABIRASUL     PRCP
11RAJENDRA RANDITRAO HIPPERGEKAR     KKJHS
12ANGARSHA SALIM BABULAL     IND
13GAIKWAD UMAJI PANDURANG     IND
14CHAVAN BABU VITHOBA     IND
15CHANDANE PINTU PANDURANG     IND
16DADASAHEB SHANKARRAO JETITHOR     IND
17NITURE ARUN BHAURAO     IND
18PATEL HASHAM ISMAIL     IND
19PAWAR HARIDAS MANIKRAO     IND
20PATIL MAHADEO DNYANDEO     IND
21BALAJI BAPURAO TUPSUNDARE     IND
22ADV BHAUSAHEB ANIL BELURE BEMBLIKAR     IND
23MUNDHE PATRIL PADAMSINHA VIJAYSINHA     IND
24YEVATEPATIL SHRIMANT     IND
25SANDIPAN RAMA ZOMBADE     IND
LOHA-88     LATUR RURAL-234     LATUR CITY-235     AHMADPUR-236     UDGIR-237
NILANGA-238
S13-41-MH-LATUR     1AAWALE JAYWANT GANGARAM     INC
2GAIKWAD SUNIL BALIRAM     BJP
3ADV BABASAHEB SADSHIVRAO GAIKWAD     BSP
4ARAK ASHOK VIKRAM     KM
5VK ACHARYA     PRCP
6TM KAMBLE     RPI(D)
7GANNE TUKARAM RAMBHAU     JSS
8BANSODE RAGHUNATH WAGHOJI     PRBP
9BABURAO SATYAWAN POTBHARE     BBM
10RAMKUMAR RAIWADIKAR     SWJP
11SHRIKANT RAMRAO JEDHE     RSPS
12SASANE ATUL GANGARAM     ARP
13SAHEBRAO HARIBHAU WAGHMARE     KKJHS
14AAWCHARE VIJAYKUMAR BABRUWAN     IND
15KAMBLE BANSILAL RAMCHANDRA     IND
16NILANGEKAR AVINASH MADHUKARRAO     IND
17MANE GAJANAN PANDURANG     IND
18SANJAY KABIRDAS GAIKWAD     IND
MOHOL-247     SOLAPUR CITY NORTH-248     SOLAPUR CITY CENTRAL-249
AKKALKOT-250     SOLAPUR SOUTH-251     PANDHARPUR-252
S13-42-MH-SOLAPUR     1GAIKWAD PRAMOD RAMCHANDRA     BSP
2ADV BANSODE SHARAD MARUTI     BJP
3SHINDE SUSHILKUMAR SAMBHAJIRAO     INC
4ADV KASABEKAR SHRIDHAR LIMBAJI     RSPS
5RAJGURU NARAYAN YEDU     BBM
6LAXMIKANT CHANDRAKANT GAIKWAD     KKJHS
7NARAYANKAR RAJENDRA BABURAO     IND
8NITINKUMAR RAMCHANDRA KAMBLE ALIAS NITIN BANPURKAR     IND
9BANSODE UTTAM BHIMSHA     IND
10BANSODE RAHUL DATTU     IND
11MILIND MAREPPA MULE     IND
12VIKRAM UTTAM KASABE     IND
13VIJAYKUMAR BHAGWANRAO UGHADE     IND
KARMALA-244     MADHA-245     SANGOLE-253     MALSHIRAS-254     PHALTAN-255
MAN-258
S13-43-MH-MADHA     1DESHMUKH SUBHASH SURESHCHANDRA     BJP
2PAWAR SHARADCHANDRA GOVINDRAO     NCP
3RAHUL VITTHAL SARWADE     BSP
4AYU GAIKWAD SATISH SUGRAV     PRCP
5CHAVAN SUBHASH VITTHAL     BBM
6MAHADEO JAGANNATH JANKAR     RSPS
7RAMCHANDRA NARAYAN KACCHAVE     KKJHS
8SASTE KAKASAHEB MAHADEO     KM
9SOU NAGMANI KISAN JAKKAN     IND
10DRM D PATIL     IND
11BANSODE BALVEER DAGADU     IND
12BHANUDAS BHAGAWAN DEVAKATE     IND
13DR MAHADEO ABAJI POL     IND
14SURESH SHAMRAO GHADGE     IND
15DNYANESHWAR VITTHAL AMALE     IND
MIRAJ-281     SANGLI-282     PALUS-KADEGAON-285     KHANAPUR-286     TASGAON -
KAVATHE MAHANKAL-287     JAT-288
S13-44-MH-SANGLI     1PATEL MJAVED M YUSUF     BSP
2PRATIK PRAKASHBAPU PATIL     INC
3ASHOK DNYANU MANEBHAU     STBP
4MANOHAR BALKRISHNA KHEDKAR     BBM
5MAHADEV ANNA WAGHAMARE     RSPS
6AJITRAO SHANKARRAO GHORPADE     IND
7ANSARI SHABBIR AHEMED     IND
8GANPATI TUKARAM KAMBLE ALIAS GT KAMBLE     IND
9PANDHARE DATTATRAYA PANDURANG     IND
10KAVTHEKAR PRAVIN BHAGWAN KAVTHEKAR ALIAS JIVA MAHALE     IND
11MULANI BALEKHAN USMAN     IND
12VAGARE MARUTI MURA     IND
13SHAMRAO PIRAJI KADAM     IND
14SIDDESHWAR SHIVAPPA BHOSALE     IND
WAI-256     KOREGAON-257     KARAD NORTH-259     KARAD SOUTH-260     PATAN-261
SATARA-262
S13-45-MH-SATARA     1CHAVAN PRASHANT VASANT     BSP
2PURUSHOTTAM BAJIRAO JADHAV     SHS
3BHONSLE SHRIMANT CHH UDYANRAJE PRATAPSINHMAHARAJ     NCP
4BHAUSAHEB GANGARAM WAGH     RSPS
5ALANKRITA ABHIJIT AWADEBICHUKALE     IND
CHIPLUN-265     RATNAGIRI-266     RAJAPUR-267     KANKAVLI-268     KUDAL-269
SAWANTWADI-270
S13-46-MH-RATNAGIRI – SINDHUDURG     1DRNILESH NARAYAN RANE     INC
2PARULEKAR JAYENDRA SHRIPAD     BSP
3SURESH PRABHAKAR PRABHU     SHS
4AJAY ALIAS AABA DADA JADHAV     KKJHS
5RAJESH PUSUSHOTTAM SURVE     RSPS
6VILASRAO KHANVILKAR     ABHM
7SIRAJ ABDULLA KAUCHALI     BBM
8KHALAPE AKBAR MAHAMMAD     IND
9SURENDRA BORKAR     IND
CHANDGAD-271     RADHANAGARI-272     KAGAL-273     KOLHAPUR SOUTH-274
KARVIR-275     KOLHAPUR NORTH-276
S13-47-MH-KOLHAPUR     1KAMBLE SUHAS NIVRUTI     BSP
2CHHATRPATI SAMBHAJIRAJE SHAHU     NCP
3DEVANE VIJAY SHAMRAO     SHS
4KAMBLE MARUTI RAVELU     BBM
5CHOUGULE BHAI PT     IND
6DR NEELAMBARI RAMESH MANDAPE     IND
7SR TATYA PATIL     IND
8BAJRANG KRISHNA PATIL     IND
9MAHAMMADGOUS GULAB NADAF     IND
10SADASHIVRAO MANDLIK DADOBA     IND
SHAHUWADI-277     HATKANANGLE-278     ICHALKARANJI-279     SHIROL-280
ISLAMPUR-283     SHIRALA-284
S13-48-MH-HATKANANGLE     1KANADE ANILKUMAR MAHADEV     BSP
2MANE NIVEDITA SAMBHAJIRAO     NCP
3RAGHUNATH RAMCHANDRA PATIL     SHS
4PATIL UDAY PANDHARINATH     KM
5BABURAO OMANNA KAMBLE     RSPS
6MANE ARVIND BHIVA     BBM
7SHETTI RAJU ALIAS DEVAPPA ANNA     SWP
8ARUN ALIAS SHAM BAJARNAG BUCHADE     IND
9THORAT ANANDRAO TUKARAM     IND
10SURNIKE ANANDRAO VASANTRAO FOUJI BAPU     IND
KHUNDRAKPAM-1     HEINGANG-2     KHURAI-3     KSHETRIGAO-4     THONGJU-5
KEIRAO-6     ANDRO-7     LAMLAI-8     THANGMEIBAND-9     URIPOK-10
S14-1-MN-INNER MANIPUR     1DR THOKCHOM MEINYA     INC
2THOUNAOJAM CHAOBA     MPP
3MOIRANGTHEM NARA     CPI
4WAHENGBAM NIPAMACHA SINGH     BJP
5L KSHETRANI DEVI     RBCP
6ABDUL RAHMAN     IND
7NONGMAITHEM HOMENDRO SINGH     IND
HEIROK-33     WANGJING TENTHA-34     KHANGABOK-35     WABGAI-36     KAKCHING-37
HIYANGLAM-38     SUGNU-39     JIRIBAM-40     CHANDEL (ST)-41     TENGNOUPAL (ST)-42
S14-2-MN-OUTER MANIPUR     1THANGSO BAITE     INC
2D LOLI ADANEE     BJP
3LB SONA     NCP
4M JAMKHONGAM  M YAMKHONGAM HAOKIP     RJD
5THANGKHANGIN     LJP
6MANI CHARENAMEI     PDA
7VALLEY ROSE HUNGYO     IND
8MANGSHI ROSE MANGSHI HAOKIP     IND
9LAMLALMOI GANGTE     IND
NARTIANG-1     JOWAI-2     RALIANG-3     MOWKAIAW-4     SUTNGA SAIPUNG-5
KHLIEHRIAT-6     AMLAREM-7     MAWHATI-8     NONGPOH-9     JIRANG-10
S15-1-ML-SHILLONG     1DALINGTON DYMPEP     CPI
2JOHN FILMORE KHARSHIING     UDP
3VINCENT H PALA     INC
4P B M BASAIAWMOIT     HSPDP
5MARTLE NMUKHIM     MDP
6DENIS SIANGSHAI     IND
7TIEROD PASSAH     IND
KHARKUTTA-37     MENDIPATHAR-38     RESUBELPARA-39     BAJENGDOBA-40
SONGSAK-41     RONGJENG-42     WILLIAM NAGAR-43     RAKSAMGRE-44     TIKRIKILA-45
PHULBARI-46
S15-2-ML-TURA     1AGATHA K SANGMA     NCP
2DEBORA C MARAK     INC
3BOSTON MARAK     ACNC
4ARLENE N SANGMA     IND
HACHHEK-1     DAMPA-2     MAMIT-3     TUIRIAL-4     KOLASIB-5     SERLUI-6
TUIVAWL-7     CHALFILH-8     TAWI-9     AIZAWL NORTH – I-10
S16-1-MZ-MIZORAM     1LALAWMPUIA CHHANGTE     NCP
2CLRUALA     INC
3DR H LALLUNGMUANA     IND
4RUALPAWLA     IND
DIMAPUR-I-1     DIMAPUR-II-2     DIMAPUR-III-3     GHASPANI-I-4
GHASPANI-II-5     TENNING-6     PEREN-7     WESTERN ANGAMI-8     KOHIMA TOWN-9
NORTHERN ANGAMI-I-10
S17-1-NL-NAGALAND     1K ASUNGBA SANGTAM     INC
2CM CHANG     NPF
3DR RILANTHUNG ODYUO     AITC
PADAMPUR-1     BIJEPUR-2     BARGARH-3     ATTABIRA-4     BHATLI-5
BRAJARAJNAGAR-6     JHARSUGUDA-7
S18-1-OR-BARGARH     1RADHARANI PANDA     BJP
2SANJAY BHOI     INC
3SUNIL KUMAR AGRAWAL     BSP
4DR HAMID HUSSAIN     BJD
5NILADRI BEHARI PANDA     KOKD
6SURENDRA KUMAR AGRAWAL     IND
TALSARA-8     SUNDARGARH-9     BIRAMITRAPUR-10     RAGHUNATHPALI-11
ROURKELA-12     RAJGANGAPUR-13     BONAI-14
S18-2-OR-SUNDARGARH     1JUAL ORAM     BJP
2JEROM DUNGDUNG     BSP
3LIVNUS KINDO     JMM
4SALOMI MINZ     CPM
5HEMANANDA BISWAL     INC
6RAMA CHANDRA EKKA     JDP
7SAGAR SING MANKEE     KOKD
8DALESWAR MAJHI     IND
9MANSID EKKA     IND
KUCHINDA-15     RENGALI-16     SAMBALPUR-17     RAIRAKHOL-18     DEOGARH-19
CHHENDIPADA-62     ATHAMALLIK-63
S18-3-OR-SAMBALPUR     1AMARNATH PRADHAN     INC
2GOBINDA RAM AGARWAL     BSP
3ROHIT PUJARI     BJD
4SURENDRA LATH     BJP
5ASHOK KUMAR NAIK     KOKD
6BIJAYA KUMAR MAHANANDA     RPI
7MD ALI HUSSAIN     IND
TELKOI-20     GHASIPURA-21     ANANDAPUR-22     PATNA-23     KEONJHAR-24
CHAMPUA-25     KARANJIA-30
S18-4-OR-KEONJHAR     1ANANTA NAYAK     BJP
2DHANURJAYA SIDU     INC
3YASHBANT NARAYAN SINGH LAGURI     BJD
4LACHHAMAN MAJHI     JMM
5DR SUDARSHAN LOHAR     BSP
6CHITTA RANJAN MUNDA     IND
7DR FAKIR MOHAN NAIK     IND
JASHIPUR-26     SARASKANA-27     RAIRANGPUR-28     BANGRIPOSI-29     UDALA-31
BARIPADA-33     MORADA-34
S18-5-OR-MAYURBHANJ     1GAMHA SINGH     BSP
2DROUPADI MURMU     BJP
3LAXMAN TUDU     BJD
4LAXMAN MAJHI     INC
5SUDAM MARNDI     JMM
6LAXMISWAR TAMUDIA     SP
7SUNDAR MOHAN MAJHI     JDP
8DEVI PRASANNA BESRA     IND
9NARENDRA HANSDA     IND
10RAMESWAR MAJHI     IND
BADASAHI-32     JALESWAR-35     BHOGRAI-36     BASTA-37     BALASORE-38
REMUNA-39     NILGIRI-40
S18-6-OR-BALASORE     1ARUN JENA     JMM
2ARUN DEY     NCP
3MAHAMEGHA BAHAN AIRA KHARABELA SWAIN     BJP
4SHRADHANJALI PRADHAN     BSP
5SRIKANTA KUMAR JENA     INC
6DEBASISH RANJAN DASH     SAMO
7RAKESH RANJAN PATRA     JHKP
8GHASIRAM MOHANTA     IND
9LAXIMIKANTA BEHERA     IND
SORO-41     SIMULIA-42     BHANDARIPOKHARI-43     BHADRAK-44     BASUDEVPUR-45
DHAMNAGAR-46     CHANDABALI-47
S18-7-OR-BHADRAK     1ANANTA PRASAD SETHI     INC
2ARJUN CHARAN SETHI     BJD
3NITYANANDA JENA     BSP
4RATH DAS     BJP
5GOLAK PRASAD MALLIK     IND
6SUSANTA KUMAR JENA     IND
BINJHARPUR-48     BARI-49     BARCHANA-50     DHARMASALA-51     JAJPUR-52
KOREI-53     SUKINDA-54
S18-8-OR-JAJPUR     1AMIYA KANTA MALLIK     INC
2PARAMESWAR SETHI     BJP
3MOHAN JENA     BJD
4AJIT KUMAR JENA     SAMO
5BABULI MALLIK     OMM
6BHIMSEN BEHERA     JHKP
7UDAYA NATH JENA     IND
8KALANDI MALLIK     IND
DHENKANAL-55     HINDOL-56     KAMAKHYANAGAR-57     PARJANGA-58     PALLAHARA-59
TALCHER-60     ANGUL-61
S18-9-OR-DHENKANAL     1KRISHNA CHANDRA SAHOO     BSP
2CHANDRA SEKHAR TRIPATHY     INC
3TATHAGATA SATPATHY     BJD
4RUDRANARAYAN PANY     BJP
5PRIYABRATA GARNAIK     KS
BIRMAHARAJPUR-64     SONEPUR-65     LOISINGHA-66     PATNAGARH-67
BOLANGIR-68     TITLAGARH-69     KANTABANJI-70
S18-10-OR-BOLANGIR     1KALIKESH NARAYAN SINGH DEO     BJD
2NARASINGHA MISHRA     INC
3BALHAN SAGAR     BSP
4SANGITA KUMARI SINGH DEO     BJP
5DINGAR KUMBHAR     SAMO
NUAPADA-71     KHARIAR-72     LANJIGARH-77     JUNAGARH-78     DHARMGARH-79
BHAWANIPATNA-80     NARLA-81
S18-11-OR-KALAHANDI     1NAKULA MAJHI     BSP
2BIKRAM KESHARI DEO     BJP
3BHAKTA CHARAN DAS     INC
4SUBASH CHANDRA NAYAK     BJD
5PARAMESWAR KAND     SP
6BALARAM HOTA     CPI(ML)(L)
7DAMBARUDHARA SUNANI     IND
8MAHESWAR BHOI     IND
UMARKOTE-73     JHARIGAM-74     NABARANGPUR-75     DABUGAM-76     KOTPAD-142
MALKANGIRI-146     CHITRAKONDA-147
S18-12-OR-NABARANGPUR     1CHANDRADHWAJ MAJHI     BSP
2DOMBURU MAJHI     BJD
3PARSURAM MAJHI     BJP
4PRADEEP KUMAR MAJHI     INC
BALIGUDA-82     G. UDAYAGIRI-83     PHULBANI-84     KANTAMAL-85     BOUDH-86
DASPALLA-121     BHANJANAGAR-123
S18-13-OR-KANDHAMAL     1ASHOK SAHU     BJP
2PAULA BALIARSING     BSP
3RUDRAMADHAB RAY     BJD
4SUZIT KUMAR PADHI     INC
5NAKUL NAYAK     SP
6AJIT KUMAR NAYAK     IND
7KAMALA KANTA PANDEY     IND
8GHORABANA BEHERA     IND
9DEENABANDHU NAIK     IND
BARAMBA-87     BANKI-88     ATHAGARH-89     BARABATI-CUTTACK-90
CHOUDWAR-CUTTACK-91     CUTTACK SADAR-93     KHANDAPADA-120
S18-14-OR-CUTTACK     1ANADI SAHU     BJP
2GOPAL CHANDRA KAR     BSP
3BIBHUTI BHUSAN MISHRA     INC
4BHARTRUHARI MAHTAB     BJD
5KAPILA CHARAN MALL     BOP
6PRADIP ROUTRAY     KS
7DEBANANDA SINGH     IND
SALIPUR-94     MAHANGA-95     PATKURA-96     KENDRAPARA-97     AUL-98
RAJANAGAR-99     MAHAKALAPADA-100
S18-15-OR-KENDRAPARA     1JNANDEV BEURA     BJP
2RANJIB BISWAL     INC
3LENIN LENKA     BSP
4BAIJAYANT PANDA     BJD
5PRATAP CHANDRA JENA     SAMO
6PRAVAKAR NAYAK     KS
7RAMA KRUSHNA DASH     CPI(ML)(L)
8SARAT CHANDRA SWAIN     IND
NIALI-92     PARADEEP-101     TIRTOL-102     BALIKUDA-ERSAMA-103
JAGATSINGHPUR-104     KAKATPUR-105     NIMAPARA-106
S18-16-OR-JAGATSINGHPUR     1BAIDHAR MALLICK     BJP
2BIBHU PRASAD TARAI     CPI
3BIBHUTI BHUSAN MAJHI     BSP
4RABINDRA KUMAR SETHY     INC
5AKSHAYA KUMAR SETHI     SAMO
PURI-107     BRAMHAGIRI-108     SATYABADI-109     PIPILI-110     CHILIKA-118
RANPUR-119     NAYAGARH-122
S18-17-OR-PURI     1JITENDRA KUMAR SAHOO     BSP
2DEBENDRA NATH MANSINGH     INC
3PINAKI MISRA     BJD
4BRAJA KISHORE TRIPATHY     BJP
5KSHITISH BISWAL     CPI(ML)(L)
6SABYASACHI MOHAPATRA     KS
7PRABHAT KUMAR BADAPANDA     IND
JAYADEV-111     BHUBANESWAR CENTRAL (MADHYA)-112     BHUBANESWAR NORTH
(UTTAR)-113     EKAMRA-BHUBANESWAR-114     JATANI-115     BEGUNIA-116
KHURDA-117
S18-18-OR-BHUBANESWAR     1AKSHAYA KUMAR MOHANTY     BSP
2ARCHANA NAYAK     BJP
3PRASANNA KUMAR PATASANI     BJD
4SANTOSH MOHANTY     INC
5UMA CHARANA MISHRA     JHKP
6NABAGHAN PARIDA     BOP
7PRAFUL KUMAR SAHOO     RPI(A)
8BASANTA KUMAR BEHERA     KS
9BIJAYANANDA MISHRA     LJP
10JAGANNATH PRASAD LENKA     IND
11DHIRENDRA SATAPATHY     IND
12PRAMILA BEHERA     IND
13SASTHI PRASAD SETHI     IND
POLASARA-124     KABISURYANGAR-125     KHALIKOTE-126     ASKA-128     SURADA-129
SANAKHEMUNDI-130     HINJILI-131
S18-19-OR-ASKA     1NITYANANDA PRADHAN     BJD
2RAMACHANDRA RATH     INC
3SHANTI DEVI     BJP
4KRISHNA DALABEHERA     KS
5BIJAYA KUMAR MAHAPATRO     RSP
6SURJYA NARAYAN SAHU     SAMO
7KALICHARAN NAYAK     IND
8DEBASIS MISRA     IND
9K SHYAM BABU SUBUDHI     IND
CHHATRAPUR-127     GOPALPUR-132     BERHAMPUR-133     DIGAPAHANDI-134
CHIKITI-135     MOHANA-136     PARALAKHEMUNDI-137
S18-20-OR-BERHAMPUR     1CHANDRA SEKHAR SAHU     INC
2PABITRA GAMANGO     BSP
3BHARAT PAIK     BJP
4SIDHANT MAHAPATRA     BJD
5NIRAKAR BEHERA     KS
6ALI RAZA ZIADI     IND
7KISHORE CHANDRA MAHARANA     IND
8A RAGHUNATH VARMA     IND
9K SHYAM BABU SUBUDHI     IND
GUNUPUR-138     BISSAM CUTTACK-139     RAYAGADA-140     LAXMIPUR-141
JEYPORE-143     KORAPUT-144     POTTANGI-145
S18-21-OR-KORAPUT     1UPENDRA MAJHI     BJP
2GIRIDHAR GAMANG     INC
3JAYARAM PANGI     BJD
4PAPANNA MUTIKA     BSP
5KUMUDINI DISARI     SAMO
6MEGHANADA SABAR     CPI(ML)(L)
SUJANPUR-1     BHOA-2     GURDASPUR-4     DINA NAGAR-5     QADIAN-6     BATALA-7
FATEHGARH CHURIAN-9     DERA BABA NANAK-10
S19-1-PB-GURDASPUR     1SWARAN SINGH THAKUR     BSP
2PARTAP SINGH BAJWA     INC
3VINOD KHANNA     BJP
4SUKRIT SHARDA     SP
5GURPREET SINGH KHANNA     BGTD
6YOG RAJ SHARMA     SHS
7RAGHVIR KAUR     LJP
8KULDEEP CHAND SAINI     IND
9GURMEET SINGH     IND
10NARAIN SINGH     IND
11BALBIR SINGH     IND
12LAL CHAND     IND
13VIDYA BHUSHAN     IND
AJNALA-11     RAJA SANSI-12     MAJITHA-13     AMRITSAR NORTH-15     AMRITSAR
WEST-16     AMRITSAR CENTRAL-17     AMRITSAR EAST-18     AMRITSAR SOUTH-19
ATTARI-20
S19-2-PB-AMRITSAR     1OM PRAKASH SONI     INC
2BKN CHHIBER     BSP
3NAVJOT SINGH SIDHU     BJP
4ANIL SINGH     RSP
5DRSURINDER SINGH     DCP
6HARMEET SINGH     LJP
7MAJOR GS GILL     RRD
8JASWANT SINGH RANDHAWA     BGTD
9SHAM LAL     IND
10KANWALJIT SINGH MANAWALA     IND
11GOKAL CHAND     IND
12NARESH SINGH BHADAURIYA     IND
13BAL KRISHAN     IND
14LAVINDER KUMAR     IND
JANDIALA-14     TARN TARAN-21     KHEM KARAN-22     PATTI-23     KHADOOR
SAHIB-24     BABA BAKALA-25     KAPURTHALA-27     SULTANPUR LODHI-28     ZIRA-75
S19-3-PB-KHADOOR SAHIB     1SURINDER SINGH SHAHI     BSP
2DR RATTAN SINGH AJNALA     SAD
3RANA GURJEET SINGH     INC
4DARSHAN SINGH     AIDWC
5BALKAR SINGH     BGTD
6MOHINDER SINGH     LJP
7SUKHWANT SINGH     IND
8HARJIT SINGH     IND
9KANWAR PARTAP SINGH     IND
10GIAN KAUR     IND
11GURJIT SINGH     IND
12JASPAL SINGH     IND
13PRAGAT SINGH     IND
14RAJINDER SINGH     IND
15RAJINDER RIKHI     IND
TALWARA-3     PHILLAUR-30     NAKODAR-31     SHAHKOT-32     KARTARPUR-33
JALANDHAR WEST-34     JALANDHAR CENTRAL-35     JALANDHAR NORTH-36     JALANDHAR
CANTT.-37     ADAMPUR-38
S19-4-PB-JALANDHAR     1SURJIT SINGH     BSP
2HANS RAJ HANS     SAD
3MOHINDER SINGH KAYPEE     INC
4ASHOK KUMAR     BGTD
5JAGJIVAN RAM BHARTI     RPI
6NAV VIKAS     LJP
7RAJINDER SINGH     LTSD
8DR RAJINDER KUMAR     SP
9VIJAY HANS     DBSP
10SANJEEV KUMAR RAHELA     IND
11HARI MITTER     IND
12HANS RAJ PABWAN     IND
13MOHINDER SINGH     IND
14MOHINDER SINGH GILL     IND
15RAKESH KUMAR BHAGAT     IND
SRI HARGOBINDPUR-8     BHOLATH-26     PHAGWARA-29     MUKERIAN-39     DASUYA-40
URMAR-41     SHAM CHAURASI-42     HOSHIARPUR-43     CHABBEWAL-44
S19-5-PB-HOSHIARPUR     1SANTOSH CHOWDHARY     INC
2SUKHWINDER KUMAR     BSP
3SOM PARKASH     BJP
4PRINCIPAL MOHAN LAL KHOSLA     DBSP
5LAL CHAND BHATTI     BGTD
6VARINDER BHARTI     LJP
7SARWAN SINGH     IND
8HARMESH LAL SAROYA     IND
9JATHEDAR DALJIT SINGH SODHI     IND
10MAHINDER SINGH HAMIRA     IND
11MUKHTAR SINGH MUKHA KHUJALA     IND
12RITTA RAHELA     IND
GARHSHANKAR-45     BANGA-46     NAWAN SHAHR-47     BALACHAUR-48     ANANDPUR
SAHIB-49     RUPNAGAR-50     CHAMKAUR SAHIB-51     KHARAR-52     S.A.S.NAGAR-53
S19-6-PB-ANANDPUR SAHIB     1KEWAL KRISHAN     BSP
2DR DALJIT SINGH CHEEMA     SAD
3MAHAN SINGH     CPM
4RAVNEET SINGH     INC
5BACHAN LAL     LJP
6BALWINDER SINGH     SP
7MANJIT KAUR     DBSP
8MOHAN SINGH     ARWP
9VISHWANATH     SHS
10SAT PAL     IND
11SANSAR CHAND     IND
12JASPAL SINGH     IND
13DALJIT SINGH     IND
14RESHAM LAL KAHLON     IND
LUDHIANA EAST-60     LUDHIANA SOUTH-61     ATAM NAGAR-62     LUDHIANA
CENTRAL-63     LUDHIANA WEST-64     LUDHIANA NORTH-65     GILL-66     DAKHA-68
JAGRAON-70
S19-7-PB-LUDHIANA     1KEHAR SINGH     BSP
2GURCHARAN SINGH GALIB     SAD
3MANISH TEWARI     INC
4SANJEEV KUMAR ATWAL     DBSP
5SURINDER SINGH SODHI     LJP
6HARISH KUMAR     RWS
7GIRDHARI LAL     LBP
8GURINDER SINGH SOOD     JKNPP
9JASPAL SINGH     BGTD
10TULSI RAM MISRA     SP
11LADDU SHAH     LPSP
12AJAY TANDON     IND
13SURINDER PAL     IND
14SHAMBHU KUMAR SINGH     IND
15SHIV SUNDER     IND
16SEIKH MUKHTIAR     IND
17HARBANS SINGH SODHI     IND
18KUNAL     IND
19GURCHARAN SINGH     IND
20CHANDER DEV SINGH     IND
21JASVIR SINGH THETHI     IND
22TEHAL SINGH     IND
23DALJINDER SINGH     IND
24BALBIR SINGH     IND
25RAJESH KUMAR     IND
26RAJESH GANDHI     IND
27RAJESH PATEL     IND
28RAVINDER KUMAR SO SOHAN LAL     IND
29RAVINDER KUMAR SO MUNNA LAL     IND
30VIJAY KUMAR GOEL     IND
BASSI PATHANA-54     FATEHGARH SAHIB-55     AMLOH-56     KHANNA-57
SAMRALA-58     SAHNEWAL-59     PAYAL-67     RAIKOT-69     AMARGARH-106
S19-8-PB-FATEHGARH SAHIB     1SUKHDEV SINGH     INC
2CHARANJIT SINGH ATWAL     SAD
3RAI SINGH     BSP
4HIRA LAL     BVP
5KULWANT SINGH SANDHU     SAD(M)
6BP SINGH GILL     LBP
7BHUPINDER SINGH     RSP
8RAM SINGH     LJP
9SIKANDER SINGH     IND
10PREM SINGH     IND
11LACHHMAN SINGH     IND
NIHAL SINGHWALA-71     BHAGHA PURANA-72     MOGA-73     DHARAMKOT-74
GIDDERBAHA-84     FARIDKOT-87     KOTKAPURA-88     JAITU-89     RAMPURA PHUL-90
S19-9-PB-FARIDKOT     1SUKHWINDER SINGH DANNY     INC
2KAUSHALYA CHAMAN BHAURA     CPI
3PARAMJIT KAUR GULSHAN     SAD
4RESHAM SINGH     BSP
5GURMEET SINGH RANGHRETA     PLP
6JASVIR SINGH     MB(S)P
7PRITAM SINGH     RPI
8PREM SINGH     SP
9RAJ KAUR     AIDWC
10SUKHWINDER SINGH     IND
11SHARAN KAUR     IND
12GURPREET SINGH     IND
13NATHU RAM     IND
14NIRMAL SINGH     IND
15VEERPAL KAUR     IND
FIROZPUR CITY-76     FIROZPUR RURAL-77     GURU HAR SAHAI-78     JALALABAD-79
FAZILKA-80     ABOHAR-81     BALLUANA-82     MALOUT-85     MUKTSAR-86
S19-10-PB-FEROZPUR     1SHER SINGH GHUBAYA     SAD
2GURDEV SINGH     BSP
3JAGMEET SINGH BRAR     INC
4SAHAB SINGH     LJP
5JINDER PAL SINGH     AIDWC
6DHIAN SINGH MAND     SAD(M)
7PAPU SINGH     RVNP
8MATHRA DASS     PSS
9ATMA RAM     IND
10SATNAM SINGH     IND
11SARABJEET SINGH     IND
12SUBLAKSHMAN SHARMA     IND
13SHER SINGH     IND
14GURPAL SINGH     IND
15JAGDEEP SINGH     IND
16JAGMEET SINGH     IND
17DALIP KUMAR     IND
18PARAMJEET SINGH     IND
19PRITAM SINGH     IND
20BALJINDER SINGH     IND
21BALTEJ SINGH BRAR     IND
22BAU SINGH     IND
23MANOJ KUMAR     IND
24MUNSHA SINGH     IND
25RAJ KUMAR     IND
26RAJINDER KUMAR     IND
27RIMPAL MIDHA     IND
LAMBI-83     BHUCHO MANDI-91     BATHINDA URBAN-92     BATHINDA RURAL-93
TALWANDI SABO-94     MAUR-95     MANSA-96     SARDULGARH-97     BUDHLADA-98
S19-11-PB-BATHINDA     1HARSIMRAT KAUR BADAL     SAD
2HARDEV SINGH ARSHI     CPI
3NEM CHAND     BSP
4RANINDER SINGH     INC
5KIRANJIT SINGH GEHRI     LJP
6GEETA RANI     ABSR
7CHODHARI RAM CHAND     ABJP
8NAVNEET     SHS
9BHAGWANT SINGH SAMAON     CPI(ML)(L)
10RAJ KAMAL GHARU     RVNP
11LAKHWINDER SINGH     AIDWC
12SURESH KUMAR     IND
13HARDEV SINGH     IND
14KARAM SINGH     IND
15KEWAL SINGH     IND
16JAGROOP SINGH     IND
17DYAL CHAND     IND
18NIRMAL SINGH     IND
19PARVEEN HITESHI     IND
20RAJNISH KUMAR     IND
21RAVJINDER SINGH     IND
22RAJA SINGH     IND
LEHRA-99     DIRBA-100     SUNAM-101     BHADAUR-102     BARNALA-103     MEHAL
KALAN-104     MALERKOTLA-105     DHURI-107     SANGRUR-108
S19-12-PB-SANGRUR     1SUKHDEV SINGH DHINDSA     SAD
2MOHMAD JAMILURREHMAN     BSP
3VIJAY INDER SINGLA     INC
4AJMER SINGH KHUDI     LJP
5SIMRANJIT SINGH MANN     SAD(M)
6JASWANT SINGH CHHAPA     SP
7TARSEM JODHAN     CPI(ML)(L)
8BALWANT SINGH RAMUWALIA     LBP
9SUKHJINDER SINGH     IND
10SUKHDEV SINGH SO JEET SINGH     IND
11SUKHDEV SINGH SO BAGGA SINGH     IND
12JASWANT SINGH     IND
13JARNAIL SINGH     IND
14BALVIR RAM     IND
15BILLU SINGH     IND
16RATTAN LAL SINGLA     IND
NABHA-109     PATIALA RURAL-110     RAJPURA-111     DERA BASSI-112
GHANAUR-113     SANOUR-114     PATIALA-115     SAMANA-116     SHUTRANA-117
S19-13-PB-PATIALA     1DEEPAK JOSHI     BSP
2PRENEET KAUR     INC
3PREM SINGH CHANDUMAJRA     SAD
4AMRIK SINGH     RSP
5BARJESH BATTA     LJP
6ARUN SOOD     IND
7SATISH KUMAR     IND
8SANJIV KUMAR KAUSHAL     IND
9SURINDER KUMAR     IND
10SOHAN SINGH     IND
11HARWINDER SINGH     IND
12KARAMJIT SINGH     IND
13KULDIP SINGH GREWAL     IND
14BANT SINGH     IND
SADULSHAHAR-1     GANGANAGAR-2     KARANPUR-3     SURATGARH-4     RAISINGH
NAGAR-5     SANGARIA-7     HANUMANGARH-8     PILIBANGA-9
S20-1-RJ-GANGANAGAR     1NIHAL CHAND     BJP
2BHARAT RAM MEGHWAL     INC
3SHEOPAT RAM     CPM
4SITA RAM     BSP
5MUKESH KUMAR     SP
6HET RAM     RJVP
7OM PARKASH     IND
8JASWINDER SINGH     IND
9TITAR SINGH     IND
10BHURA RAM     IND
11RAJI RAM     IND
12SHILA DEVI     IND
13SINDU         IND
14SITA RAM MORYA     IND
15HANUMAN RAM     IND
ANUPGARH-6     KHAJUWALA-12     BIKANER WEST-13     BIKANER EAST-14
KOLAYAT-15     LUNKARANSAR-16     DUNGARGARH-17     NOKHA-18
S20-2-RJ-BIKANER     1ARJUN RAM MEGHWAL     BJP
2GOVIND RAM MEGHWAL     BSP
3PAWAN KUMAR DUGGAL     CPM
4REWAT RAM PANWAR     INC
5ADU RAM MEGHWAL     RJVP
6BABU LAL KHANDA     SP
7KUNDAN LAL VALMIKI     IND
8KHEM CHAND NIMBHAL     IND
9RATAN DEVI MEGHWAL     IND
10LAXHMAN SINGH     IND
NOHAR-10     BHADRA-11     SADULPUR-19     TARANAGAR-20     SARDARSHAHAR-21
CHURU-22     RATANGARH-23     SUJANGARH-24
S20-3-RJ-CHURU     1BUDH RAM SAINI     BSP
2RAFIQUE MANDELIA     INC
3RAM SINGH KASWAN     BJP
4JAGRUP SINGH     RJVP
5MANGI LAL     BHBP
6RADHE SHYAM     RMGLMP
7VIJENDRA SINGH     JKNPP
8SHAILENDRA AWASTHI     SP
9GOPI KRISHAN     IND
10CHANDAN MAL     IND
11JITENDER KUMAR     IND
12BHANWAR LAL     IND
13MOHAMMED SALIM     IND
14SHOKAT ALI     IND
15SALIM GUJAR     IND
PILANI-25     SURAJGARH-26     JHUNJHUNU-27     MANDAWA-28     NAWALGARH-29
UDAIPURWATI-30     KHETRI-31     FATEHPUR-32
S20-4-RJ-JHUNJHUNU     1KHATRI MUSTAQ     BSP
2DR DASRATH SINGH SHEKHAWAT     BJP
3SHEESH RAM OLA     INC
4NETRAM BUGALIA     RRD
5PHOOL CHAND DHEWA     CPI(ML)(L)
6RANVEER SINGH GUDHA     LJP
7RAVITA SHARMA     RBD
8DR GOPAL PRASAD SHARMA     IND
9NARAPAT SINGH RATHOR     IND
10RANDHIR SINGH MEGWAL     IND
11RAKESH SABAL     IND
12ROHITASHV KUMAR KALIA     IND
13SHER SINGH     IND
LACHHMANGARH-33     DHOD-34     SIKAR-35     DANTA RAMGARH-36     KHANDELA-37
NEEM KA THANA-38     SRIMADHOPUR-39     CHOMU-43
S20-5-RJ-SIKAR     1AMARA RAM     CPM
2BHARAT SINGH TANWAR     BSP
3MAHADEV SINGH     INC
4SUBHASH MAHARIA     BJP
5ACHARAYA DEVENDRA KUMAR PAURANIK     SP
6D P KUMAWAT     RJVP
7BHAGVAN SAHAY     LJP
8MAKHAN LAL SAINI     JGP
9SITA DEVI     BHBP
10HEM CHAND AGRAWAL     BCP
11AJAY PAL     IND
12JUGAL KISHOR MEGHAWAL     IND
13MAHABEER PARSAD     IND
14MAHESH KUMAR     IND
15RAMESH SHARMA     IND
16HANUMAN SAHAI     IND
KOTPUTLI-40     VIRATNAGAR-41     SHAHPURA-42     PHULERA-44     JHOTWARA-46
AMBER-47     JAMWA RAMGARH-48     BANSUR-63
S20-6-RJ-JAIPUR RURAL     1RAJESH SHARMA     BSP
2RAO RAJENDRA SINGH     BJP
3LAL CHAND KATARIA     INC
4KESHAV RAM SHARMA     BSSPA
5RAJENDRA JETHIWAL KUMAWAT     RJVP
6RAMNIWAS YADAV     JD(U)
7SRAVAN LAL YADAV     RBD
8KALU RAM     IND
9CHHITAR MAL     IND
10DHUNILAL DHUHARIA     IND
11BANWARI LAL MALI     IND
12MATADEEN DHANKA     IND
13DR MUKARRAM ALI     IND
14RADHEYSHYAM MEENA     IND
15RAM NIWAS YOGI     IND
16ROHITASH KULDEEP RAIGER     IND
17VRADHICHAND KUMAWAT     IND
18SHANKAR LAL BUNKAR     IND
19SITARAM BUNKAR     IND
20SUKHVEER SINGH JAUNAPURIA     IND
21SUBHASH CHANDRA SHARMA     IND
HAWA MAHAL-49     VIDHYADHAR NAGAR-50     CIVIL LINES-51     KISHAN POLE-52
ADARSH NAGAR-53     MALVIYA NAGAR-54     SANGANER-55     BAGRU-56
S20-7-RJ-JAIPUR     1GHANSHYAM TIWARI     BJP
2MAHESH JOSHI     INC
3VIJAY PESHWANI     BSP
4NIHAL CHAND     RJVP
5SHYAM LAL VIJAY     RBD
6HARGOVIND SINGH     JGP
7ABDUL RAJAK     IND
8DR AVINASH VISHNOI     IND
9IQBAL         IND
10KAILASH CHAND SAINI     IND
11KAILASH CHAND SAINI     IND
12PREM SAINI ALIAS PREMNATH     IND
13BHANWAR KANWAR RAJAWAT     IND
14BHASKAR DAAGAR     IND
15MANAV     IND
16MOHD RAFIQ     IND
17RAMESH CHANDRA     IND
18RAJ KUMAR     IND
19RAM LAL DHANKA     IND
20RIYAJUL HASAN     IND
21ROHITASH KULDEEP RAIGAR     IND
22VIJAYPAL SINGH SHYORAN VIVEK     IND
23SANJAY GOYAL     IND
24DR SAT DEV NATH CHADDA     IND
25SITA RAM BAIRWA     IND
TIJARA-59     KISHANGARH BAS-60     MUNDAWAR-61     BEHROR-62     ALWAR RURAL-65
ALWAR URBAN-66     RAMGARH-67     RAJGARH LAXMANGARH-68
S20-8-RJ-ALWAR     1DRKIRAN YADAV     BJP
2JITENDRA SINGH     INC
3JAGEDISH     BHBP
4DEVENDRA     JGP
5SNEHRA     SP
6VISWANATH SINGH KHINCHI     RJVP
7SHIV KUMAR     JKNPP
8KIRAN YADAV     IND
9GURDAYAL MANDIE     IND
10JASRAM     IND
11DP ALOK     IND
12DHOKAL RAM     IND
13BANWARI LAL SAINI     IND
14BABU LAL SAINI     IND
15MEGH SINGH     IND
16RAM LAL MEENA     IND
KATHUMAR-69     KAMAN-70     NAGAR-71     DEEG-KUMHER-72     BHARATPUR-73
NADBAI-74     WEIR-75     BAYANA-76
S20-9-RJ-BHARATPUR     1KHEMCHAND     BJP
2MUHAR SINGH     BSP
3RATAN SINGH     INC
4JASWANT KUMAR     KKJHS
5DURGA         RND
6DR PADAM SINGH     SP
7MAHAVEER     RJVP
8ANAND RAM     IND
9ASHARAM URF ASHA     IND
10NAGENDRA SINGH     IND
11PREM CHAND     IND
12MAMRAJ     IND
13MANGAL RAM     IND
14RAMAN LAL     IND
BASERI-77     BARI-78     DHOLPUR-79     RAJAKHERA-80     TODABHIM-81
HINDAUN-82     KARAULI-83     SAPOTRA-84
S20-10-RJ-KARAULI-DHOLPUR     1KHILADI LAL BAIRWA     INC
2DR MANOJ RAJORIA     BJP
3HATTIRAM     BSP
4RAMESH     SP
5SHREELAL KHARE     LJP
6OM PRAKASH     IND
7KANCHAN BAIBAIRWA     IND
8GANGARAM     IND
9JAGAN LAL     IND
10BANWARI     IND
11RAM VILAS     IND
12REKHA     IND
13LAKHAN SINGH     IND
14LALARAM     IND
15VIJAY         IND
16SHREE LAL BAIRWA     IND
BASSI-57     CHAKSU-58     THANAGAZI-64     BANDIKUI-85     MAHUWA-86     SIKRAI-87
DAUSA-88     LALSOT-89
S20-11-RJ-DAUSA     1RAM KISHORE MEENA     BJP
2LAXMAN     INC
3LOKESH     BSP
4GAJENDRA PAL SINGH     KKJHS
5DHARM SINGH     JGP
6BHARAT HOTLA     LJP
7MUKESH KUMAR     BSA
8RAM LAL     BHBP
9SHIVA RAM     RJVP
10QUMMER RUBBANI     IND
11KIRODI LAL     IND
12RAJENDRA SINGH     IND
13RAMESHWAR NIRVAN     IND
14LADU RAM     IND
GANGAPUR-90     BAMANWAS-91     SAWAI MADHOPUR-92     KHANDAR-93     MALPURA-94
NIWAI-95     TONK-96     DEOLI – UNIARA-97
S20-12-RJ-TONK-SAWAI MADHOPUR     1KIRORI SINGH BAINSLA     BJP
2NAMO NARAIN     INC
3SURENDERA VYAS     BSP
4OM PRAKASH     JKNPP
5KALURAM     RJVP
6KRISHAN PAL SINGH     SP
7BHAG CHAND JAIN     FCI
8SAYAR         RDSD
9IQBAL KHAN BHATI     IND
10CHETAN KUMAR RANA     IND
11JAGAN NATH MORLIYA     IND
12JAVED         IND
13PREM LATA BANSHIWAL     IND
14MEETHALAL JAIN     IND
15MUSHAHID ZUBERI     IND
16RAM CHANDRA     IND
17SIV SINGH     IND
DUDU-45     KISHANGARH-98     PUSHKAR-99     AJMER NORTH-100     AJMER SOUTH-101
NASIRABAD-102     MASUDA-104     KEKRI-105
S20-13-RJ-AJMER     1KIRAN MAHESHWARI     BJP
2ROHITASH     BSP
3SACHIN PILOT     INC
4INDER CHAND PALIWALA     JGP
5USHA KIRAN VERMA     IND
6NAFISUDDIN MIYA     IND
7MUKESH JAIN     IND
8SHANTILAL DHABRIA     IND
LADNUN-106     DEEDWANA-107     JAYAL-108     NAGAUR-109     KHINWSAR-110
MAKRANA-113     PARBATSAR-114     NAWAN-115
S20-14-RJ-NAGAUR     1ABDUL AZIZ     BSP
2DR JYOTI MIRDHA     INC
3BINDU CHAUDHARY     BJP
4DASHRATH SINGH     JGP
5RAMJAN SAHAB     LJP
6INDRARAM JAT     IND
7VINOD KUMAR PITTI     IND
8SUNIL         IND
SOJAT-117     PALI-118     MARWAR JUNCTION-119     BALI-120     SUMERPUR-121
OSIAN-125     BHOPALGARH-126     BILARA-131
S20-15-RJ-PALI     1PUSP JAIN     BJP
2BADRI RAM JAKHAR     INC
3SHAMBHU SINGH KHETASAR     BSP
4GANPAT SINGH RAJPUROHIT     JGP
5MISHRI LAL NAYAK     ABHM
6INDRA SINGH RAJPUROHIT     IND
7KANHAIYA LAL PAREEK     IND
8TANMAY     IND
9PREM MEHRA     IND
10BHAGA RAM PRAJAPAT     IND
11MAHENDRA SINGH     IND
12MOOLA RAM MALI     IND
13SURENDRA SINGH     IND
14HARI LAL KALAL     IND
PHALODI-122     LOHAWAT-123     SHERGARH-124     SARDARPURA-127     JODHPUR-128
SOORSAGAR-129     LUNI-130     POKARAN-133
S20-16-RJ-JODHPUR     1CHANDRESH KUMARI     INC
2JASWANT SINGH BISNOI     BJP
3RAJU RAM     BSP
4GURDAN SINGH     JKNPP
5ASLAM         IND
6CHANDRAKANTA     IND
7CHAMPALAL     IND
8DR DINESH KUMAR SHARMA     IND
9DILIP SINGH RAJPUROHIT     IND
10DIDAR         IND
11DEVA RAM     IND
12MEHMOODA BEGUM ABBASI     IND
13MOHAMMAD ARIF     IND
14VIJAY KUMAR     IND
JAISALMER-132     SHEO-134     BARMER-135     BAYTOO-136     PACHPADRA-137
SIWANA-138     GUDHAMALANI-139     CHOHTAN-140
S20-17-RJ-BARMER     1MAHENDRA VYAS     BSP
2MANVENDRA SINGH     BJP
3HARISH CHOUDHARY     INC
4POPAT RAM     IND
5MANA RAM SARAN     IND
6RANA MAL     IND
7LAXMAN SINGH     IND
AHORE-141     JALORE-142     BHINMAL-143     SANCHORE-144     RANIWARA-145
SIROHI-146     PINDWARA ABU-147     REODAR-148
S20-18-RJ-JALORE     1DEVJI PATEL     BJP
2MAGARAM     BSP
3SANDHYA CHOUDHARY     INC
4GANGA SINGH     SP
5CHAGANLAL     IJP
6DINESH KANTEEWAL     LJP
7NANDA DEVI     RJVP
8GOPAL RAM     IND
9CHAGANLAL MALI     IND
10CHAGANLAL MEGHWAL     IND
11POKARA RAM     IND
12PRABHU SINGH     IND
13BAGDARAM     IND
14BUTA SINGH     IND
15BHANWAR LAL WAGELA     IND
16MUKESH SUNDESHA     IND
17MEGWAL SAKAJI     IND
18RAMDEO ACHARYA     IND
19VIKRANT SAXENA     IND
20SHANTI PARMAR     IND
21SUKHRAJ     IND
22HAJARIMAL     IND
GOGUNDA-149     JHADOL-150     KHERWARA-151     UDAIPUR RURAL-152
UDAIPUR-153     SALUMBER-156     DHARIAWAD-157     ASPUR-159
S20-19-RJ-UDAIPUR     1BAXI RAM LATTA MEENA     BSP
2MAHAVEER BHAGORA     BJP
3MEGHRAJ TAWAR     CPI
4RAGHUVIR SINGH MEENA     INC
5OM PRAKASH MEENA     ABCD(A)
6GOTAM LAL MEENA     CPI(ML)(L)
7LAL JI BHAI MEENA     JGP
8SHAKUNTALA DHANKA     SP
DUNGARPUR-158     SAGWARA-160     CHORASI-161     GHATOL-162     GARHI-163
BANSWARA-164     BAGIDORA-165     KUSHALGARH-166
S20-20-RJ-BANSWARA     1TARACHAND BHAGORA     INC
2DURGA DEVI BHAGORA     BSP
3HAKARU MAIDA     BJP
4PRABHULAL RAWAT     JD(U)
5BANNU         BHBP
6BHANJI BHAI     SP
7PROF MOHANLAL DAMOR     LSWP
MAVLI-154     VALLABH NAGAR-155     KAPASAN-167     BEGUN-168
CHITTORGARH-169     NIMBAHERA-170     BARI SADRI-171     PRATAPGARH-172
S20-21-RJ-CHITTORGARH     1DRGIRIJA VYAS     INC
2RADHA DEVI BHANDARI     CPI
3SHRICHAND KRIPLANI     BJP
4AB SINGH     BSP
5KARU LAL MEENA     CPI(ML)(L)
6KRISHNA SINGH KACHHER     JGP
7BHAWNA RAMKUMAR CHAWLA     ABCD(A)
8GUNWANT LAL SHARMA     IND
9JASWANT SINGH     IND
10RAM CHANDRA JOSHI     IND
11LAXMAN LAL JAT     IND
12LAHARU     IND
13SHIVANGI SHASTRI     IND
14SANTOSH JOSHI     IND
15SITARAM GUJAR     IND
BEAWAR-103     MERTA-111     DEGANA-112     JAITARAN-116     BHIM-173
KUMBHALGARH-174     RAJSAMAND-175     NATHDWARA-176
S20-22-RJ-RAJSAMAND     1GOPAL SINGH     INC
2NEERU RAM     BSP
3RASA SINGH RAWAT     BJP
4DEVA RAM     IJP
5MAHENDRA SINGH     LJP
6RAMESH SOLANKI     ABCD(A)
7DR GANPAT BANSAL     IND
8GIRDHARI SINGH     IND
9PRITHVI SINGH ALIAS PRITHVI RAJ SINGH     IND
10BHANWAR LAL MALI     IND
11MANGI LAL RAWAL     IND
12SUKH LAL GURJAR     IND
13SURYA BHAVANI SINGH CHAWRA     IND
ASIND-177     MANDAL-178     SAHARA-179     BHILWARA-180     SHAHPURA-181
JAHAZPUR-182     MANDALGARH-183     HINDOLI-184
S20-23-RJ-BHILWARA     1DR C P JOSHI     INC
2VIJAYENDRA PAL SINGH     BJP
3HARISH GURJAR     BSP
4RAMESHAWER LAL     BHBP
5LAXMI NARAYAN PARMAR     ABCD(A)
6VINEET KUMAR MAHESHWARI     JGP
7OMPRAKASH MEENA     IND
8RATANLAL DHOBI     IND
9RAMPAL SONI     IND
10RAM PRASAD SIROTHA     IND
KESHORAIPATAN-185     BUNDI-186     PIPALDA-187     SANGOD-188     KOTA
NORTH-189     KOTA SOUTH-190     LADPURA-191     RAMGANJ MANDI-192
S20-24-RJ-KOTA     1IJYARAJ SINGH     INC
2GOVIND SINGH PARMAR     BSP
3SHYAM SHARMA     BJP
4PRIYANK     JGP
5FARHEEN KHAN     SP
6BABU LAL MEGHWAL     BHBP
7RAMHET     IJP
8SAMUDRA SINGH HADA     ABMSKP
9JAMUNA PRASAD     IND
10BADAM BERWA     IND
11RAM KRISHAN SHARMA     IND
12RAMESHWAR MAMORE MEENA     IND
13SHYAM SUNDER SHARMA     IND
14DR K SHRINGI     IND
ANTA-193     KISHANGANJ-194     BARAN-ATRU-195     CHHABRA-196     DAG-197
JHALRAPATAN-198     KHANPUR-199     MANOHAR THANA-200
S20-25-RJ-JHALAWAR-BARAN     1ABDUL QAYYUM SIDDIQUI     BSP
2URMILA JAIN BHAYA     INC
3DUSHYANT SINGH     BJP
4GHASI LAL MEGHWAL     BHBP
5ABDUL FARID     IND
6JAGDISH     IND
7JHAPAT MAL     IND
8TARACHAND     IND
9DUSHYANT KUMAR     IND
10FAZAR MOHAMMAD     IND
11MOHAMMAD RAFIQ     IND
12LAXMAN KUMAR     IND
13SHOBHA DEVI     IND
14SULEMAN     IND
YOKSAM-TASHIDING-1     YANGTHANG-2     MANEYBUNG-DENTAM-3
GYALSHING-BARNYAK-4     RINCHENPONG-5     DARAMDIN-6     SOREONG-CHAKUNG-7
SALGHARI-ZOOM-8     BARFUNG-9     POKLOK-KAMRANG-10
S21-1-SK-SIKKIM     1KHARANANDA UPRETI     INC
2PADAM BDR CHETTRI     BJP
3PREM DAS RAI     SDF
4BHIM SUBBA     SJEP
5NAR BAHADUR KHATIWADA     SGPP
6TARA KR PRADHAN     SHRP
7ATRI RAM CHANDRA POUDYAL     IND
GUMMIDIPOONDI-1     PONNERI-2     THIRUVALLUR-4     POONAMALLEE-5     AVADI-6
MADAVARAM-9
S22-1-TN-THIRUVALLUR     1ANANDANP     BSP
2GAYATHRIS     DMK
3VENUGOPALP     ADMK
4SUDHARSANMS     JD(U)
5SURESHR     DMDK
6ELANGO INBARAJV     IND
7ETHIRAJA     IND
8SAMPATHA     IND
9SELVARAJA     IND
10NAGALINGAMKM     IND
11PANDURANGANV     IND
12RAJANK     IND
13VENUGOPALP     IND
14JEEVARATHINAMM     IND
TIRUVOTTIYUR-10     DR.RADHAKRISHNAN NAGAR-11     PERAMBUR-12     KOLATHUR-13
THIRU -VI -KA -NAGAR-15     ROYAPURAM-17
S22-2-TN-CHENNAI NORTH     1ELANGOVAN TKS     DMK
2SANTHASHRINI JOR     BSP
3TAMILISAISOUNDARARAJAN     BJP
4PANDIAN D     CPI
5ANANDHUK     LJP
6SATHISH KUMAR KP     MMKA
7PALANIMOSES N     PKMK
8MOHAMMED ABDULLAH     RPI(A)
9YUVARAJ V     DMDK
10ARUMUGAM K     IND
11ANANDARAJG     IND
12KADHIRAVAN M     IND
13GIRIRAJD     IND
14SANKARK     IND
15SATHISHC     IND
16SATHISH TP     IND
17SARAVANANM     IND
18SIVAKUMARV     IND
19THEYAGARAJANV     IND
20DEEPA     IND
21NIRMAL KUMARA     IND
22BHASKARANV ALIAS AAVIN VBHASKARAN     IND
23MARIMUTHUP     IND
24RAMESHD     IND
25RAJARAMR     IND
26RUDRAMOORTHYM     IND
27VINOBHAGANDHICH     IND
28ZEENATH UNNISSA BEGUMMB     IND
29JAYACHANDRANK     IND
VIRUGAMPAKKAM-22     SAIDAPET-23     THIYAGARAYANAGAR-24     MYLAPORE-25
VELACHERY-26     SHOLINGANALLUR-27
S22-3-TN-CHENNAI SOUTH     1RAJENDRAN C     ADMK
2GANESAN LA     BJP
3BHARATHY RS     DMK
4GOPINATH V     DMDK
5SATHIYASEELAN M     LJP
6MOHANRAJ J     JJ
7RAVINDRA DASS R     KDC
8RAJAMANITHAR SJ     PKMK
9VENKATARAMAN NS     DPK
10JAYARAMAN S     SHS
11JYOTHI GM     PPOI
12ASWATHAMAN K     IND
13IRUDAYADASS A     IND
14ELANGOVAN K     IND
15KARTHIKEYAN G     IND
16GIRIRAJAN M     IND
17CHRISTHUDASS N     IND
18KUMAR VA     IND
19CHANDRA SEKARAN R     IND
20CHANDRAN K     IND
21SHANMUGA SUNDARAM PT     IND
22SHANMUGARAJ V     IND
23SAMPATH KUMAR S     IND
24SARATH BABU E     IND
25ZIAUDDEN N     IND
26SRINIVASAN VR     IND
27SUNDAR J     IND
28SURESH KUMAR M     IND
29TANMAY     IND
30TAMIL SELVAN M     IND
31DEVADOSS KUPPAL G     IND
32PALANI SP     IND
33BALA KRISHNAN M     IND
34BALASUBRAMANIAN V     IND
35BALAN B     IND
36MAHALINGAM JS     IND
37MATHIKKARASU P     IND
38MANIVANNAN C     IND
39RAMASWAMY  TRAFFIC RAMASWAMY     IND
40RAJA LD     IND
41RAJENDRAN V     IND
42VEERAMANI S     IND
43VENKATESAN D     IND
VILLIVAKKAM-14     EGMORE-16     HARBOUR-18     CHEPAUK-THIRUVALLIKENI-19
THOUSAND LIGHTS-20     ANNA NAGAR-21
S22-4-TN-CHENNAI CENTRAL     1DAYANIDHI MARAN     DMK
2MOGAMED ALI JINNAH SMK     ADMK
3YUNIS KHANAY     BSP
4GANGADURAIG     JJ
5THOMASTJACOB     YSP
6NAHAMANIJ     JMM
7RANGGANATHANV     ABKMM
8RAMANA REDDYKV     KDC
9RAMAKARISHNANVV     DMDK
10RAAJ RAMCHAND     SHS
11VASUS     SP
12VIJAYAKUMAR     PPOI
13VISWANATHANE     MMKA
14HYDER ALIS     MAMAK
15ARASAKUMARMS     IND
16ARIVUDAINAMBIN     IND
17ANEES HUSSAINH     IND
18RAVIKUMART     IND
19UDAYAKUMAR     IND
20GIRIJA SHANKERR     IND
21KRISHNANPR     IND
22GUNASEKARANM     IND
23SIVAKUMARS     IND
24SENTHILP     IND
25TEACKRAJD     IND
26DHAMODHARANT     IND
27PARIMALAMV     IND
28PRABUV     IND
29MANIG     IND
30MARIMUTHUE     IND
31MOHAMED ALI     IND
32MOHAMED ALI ZINNAA     IND
33MOHANK     IND
34RAJAKUMARS     IND
35LOGANATHANV     IND
36WILSON PAULS     IND
37SRIDHARS     IND
MADURAVOYAL-7     AMBATTUR-8     ALANDUR-28     SRIPERUMBUDUR-29
PALLAVARAM-30     TAMBARAM-31
S22-5-TN-SRIPERUMBUDUR     1BAALU T R     DMK
2MOORTHY A K     PMK
3RAJAPPA B     BSP
4ARUN SUBRAMANIAN M     DMDK
5SWARNASREE P     PPOI
6THAYUMANA GURU AYYANAR     AIVP
7BHARATHI K     CPIMLL
8MAYA RAMACHANDRAN     THPI
9VARATHARAJAN T     SHS
10VIJAYAKUMAR S     LJP
11JAMES SELVAM C     AIJMK
12AYODHI L     IND
13EZHILARASU M     IND
14KALAISELVAN T     IND
15KARIKALAN C     IND
16KATTU RAJA N     IND
17KARTHIKEYAN T     IND
18KUMAR S     IND
19SHANMUGAM G     IND
20CHANDRU K     IND
21SAMPATH T     IND
22DHARMASATHYAMURTHY V     IND
23DURAIRAJ L     IND
24NAGARAJAN P     IND
25PADMANABHAN S     IND
26BALU D     IND
27MANIMARAN S     IND
28MADHAVARAJ K V     IND
29MINNAL SRINIVASAN     IND
30LAKSHMI S     IND
31VELMURUGAN T N     IND
32RAMESH R     IND
CHENGALPATTU-32     THIRUPORUR-33     CHEYYUR-34     MADURANTAKAM-35
UTHIRAMERUR-36     KANCHEEPURAM-37
S22-6-TN-KANCHEEPURAM     1RAMAKRISHNANDRE     ADMK
2UTHRAPATHIK     BSP
3VISWANATHANP     INC
4SIVASANKARANA     AIJMK
5TAMILVENDANT     DMDK
6PAKKIRI AMBADKARKV     JMM
7JAWAHARLAL NEHRUP     LJP
8ANBURAAJRK     IND
9SATHIYAVASAN MV     IND
10SIVALINGAMD     IND
11SELVAMG     IND
12DAHKSHNA MOORTHYT     IND
13THIYAGARAJANM     IND
14MAGESH KUMARE     IND
15MANIMARANK     IND
16MATHIYALAGANK     IND
17MINNAL SRINIVASAN MAMPHIL     IND
18MURUGASANB     IND
19RUPADEVI RV     IND
20JAYAKUMARPS     IND
TIRUTTANI-3     ARAKKONAM-38     SHOLINGUR-39     KATPADI-40     RANIPET-41
ARCOT-42
S22-7-TN-ARAKKONAM     1MARY JOHN     BSP
2VELU R         PMK
3JAGATHRAKSHAKAN     DMK
4ANNAMALAI S C     AIVP
5ISAAC JEBA KUMAR     AIJMK
6SANKAR S     DMDK
7SHANMUGAM K     JD(U)
8SRINIVASAN K     LJP
9PALANI W B     PNK
10PASSAMIGHU ANNAN VENKATESNOR TA V     ADSMK
11MANAVAULAN K     SP
12SUTHA N     IND
13THULASI G     IND
14PANJATSARAM D     IND
15PANDIAN E     IND
16MUTHIYALU M     IND
17MATHEW N D     IND
18JANAKIRAMAN J     IND
19JAGADEESWARAN J     IND
20JEGAN S     IND
VELLORE-43     ANAIKATTU-44     KILVAITHINANKUPPAM-45     GUDIYATTAM-46
VANIYAMBADI-47     AMBUR-48
S22-8-TN-VELLORE     1ABDULRAHMAN     DMK
2RAJENDIRAN A K     BJP
3MANSOOR AHMED     BSP
4VASU L K M B     ADMK
5RAJAN BABU B     MMKA
6EKAMBARAM E A     NMK
7GOVINDARAJI P V     SP
8SHOUKATH SHERIF     DMDK
9THAGIR AHAMED     LJP
10NARAYANAN R     AIVP
11MUNIYAPPAN K     ADSMK
12ABDUL MAJEED OOSI     IND
13ARIUDAI NAMBI D     IND
14ESWARAN R     IND
15KUBENDIRAN D     IND
16GOPALAKRISHNAN C     IND
17CHANDRAN C     IND
18SURESHKUMAR P     IND
19DANDAPANI T     IND
20NATRAJAN P     IND
21PALANI R T     IND
22PERUMAL D     IND
23RAMAN     IND
24VIJAYAKUMAR     IND
UTHANGARAI-51     BARGUR-52     KRISHNAGIRI-53     VEPPANAHALLI-54     HOSUR-55
THALLI-56
S22-9-TN-KRISHNAGIRI     1SUGAVANAM EG     DMK
2NANJEGOWDU K     ADMK
3BALAKRISHNAN G     BJP
4MOORTHY VV     BSP
5ANBARASAN D     DMDK
6SAKTHIVEL B     LJP
7SELVARAJ M     KNMK
8KUMARESAN M     IND
9GAVURAPPA K     IND
10GOVINDARAJAN V     IND
11SANKAR S     IND
12CHANDRAN BS     IND
13MEENA     IND
14RAMASWAMY     IND
15LATHA G     IND
16VENKATESAN K     IND
PALACODU-57     PENNAGARAM-58     DHARMAPURI-59     PAPPIREDDIPPATTI-60
HARUR-61     METTUR-85
S22-10-TN-DHARMAPURI     1SENTHIL R DR     PMK
2THAMARAISELVAN R     DMK
3PURUSOTHAMAN V     BSP
4ASHOKAN G     KNMK
5ANNADURAI K     UMK
6ELANGOVAN V     DMDK
7GUNASEKARAN D     MMKA
8ARIVAZHAGAN P     IND
9ANANDKUMAR K     IND
10KARUPPUSAMY S     IND
11GOVINDARAJ S     IND
12SAMPATHKUMAR R     IND
13SARAVANAN S     IND
14SIVAN K     IND
15PADMARAJAN K DR     IND
16MANI R     IND
17MURUGAN G     IND
18RADHAKRISHNAN R     IND
19RAJA A     IND
20VELMURUGAN P     IND
21SRIRAMACHANDRAN     IND
JOLARPET-49     TIRUPPATTUR-50     CHENGAM-62     TIRUVANNAMALAI-63
KILPENNATHUR-64     KALASAPAKKAM-65
S22-11-TN-TIRUVANNAMALAI     1GURU A GURUNATHAN J     PMK
2GOVINDASAMY P     BSP
3VENUGOPALD     DMK
4AFROZ HUSNA KS     LJP
5SELVARAJP     SP
6MANIKANDANS     DMDK
7RAJARAM SA     PNK
8ARUMUGAM AA     IND
9RAVI R         IND
10ERSHAD B     IND
11KUMAR MM     IND
12GURU C     IND
13GURUSAMY P     IND
14GURU A GURUMOORTHY S     IND
15SHANMUGARAJAN A     IND
16SHANMUGAVEL M     IND
17SAMPATH A     IND
18SINGARAVELAN P     IND
19SIVADEVAN N     IND
20SENTHIL M     IND
21SELVAM A     IND
22SELVARAJU J     IND
23DHAYANITHI S     IND
24NAGAMALAI R     IND
25BALASUNDAR S     IND
26MANIKANDAN P     IND
27MURUGAN S     IND
28RAVINDIRAN A     IND
29VENUGOPAL SR     IND
30HARI KRISHNAN S     IND
POLUR-66     ARANI-67     CHEYYAR-68     VANDAVASI-69     GINGEE-70     MAILAM-71
S22-12-TN-ARANI     1KRISHNASAMY M     INC
2SHANKAR A     BSP
3SUBRAMANIYAN N     ADMK
4ARIRAJ TV     SP
5SARAVANAKUMAR K     PNK
6MOHANAM RA     DMDK
7SHANMUGAM S     IND
8SUBRAMANI G     IND
9SUBRAMANI P     IND
10DURAI RAJ M     IND
11MURUGAN V     IND
12LOKESH G     IND
13VELAUDHAM M     IND
TINDIVANAM-72     VANUR-73     VILUPPURAM-74     VIKRAVANDI-75
THIRUKOILUR-76     ULUNDURPETTAI-77
S22-13-TN-VILUPPURAM     1ANANDAN M     ADMK
2POYYATHU S     BSP
3GANAPATHI P M     DMDK
4SWAMIDURAI K     VCK
5DEVARAJ G     LJP
6PANCHANATHAN R     JMM
7VENKATESAN S S     AIVP
8VENKATESAN M     CPI(ML)(L)
9ANBALAGAN V     IND
10ANANDAN P     IND
11KUMAR M     IND
12CHANDRALEGA M     IND
13SAMIDURAI M     IND
14SHETT M     IND
15MASILAMANI R     IND
16MURUGAVEL A     IND
17RAMESH K     IND
18LAKSHMANAN R     IND
19VISWANATHAN S A     IND
RISHIVANDIYAM-78     SANKARAPURAM-79     KALLAKURICHI-80     GANGAVALLI-81
ATTUR-82     YERCAUD-83
S22-14-TN-KALLAKURICHI     1SANKAR ADHI     DMK
2SENTHILKUMAR K     BSP
3DHANARAJU K     PMK
4ANANDHADASS C     LJP
5KESAVAN ANNA     JMM
6GOVINDARAJAN K M     AIVP
7SUDHISH L K     DMDK
8RAMESH S     KNMK
9ARUN KENNEDI A     IND
10INIYADAYALAN G     IND
11GANESAN K     IND
12SADEESH A     IND
13SATHISH BABU S     IND
14SIVARAMAN G     IND
15SELVAM K     IND
16SELVARAJU J     IND
17DHANARAJ T     IND
18DINESH M     IND
19NALLATHAMBI C     IND
20NAVARATTHINAM A     IND
21MANNAN M P     IND
22MANICKAM V     IND
23YUVARAJ R     IND
24RAMAJAYAM P M     IND
25RAJAMANICKAM K     IND
26RAJENTHREN D     IND
27RAJENTHREN M     IND
28VASU V     IND
29VIJAYA RAJENDHAR T     IND
OMALUR-84     EDAPPADI-86     SALEM (WEST)-88     SALEM (NORTH)-89     SALEM
(SOUTH)-90     VEERAPANDI-91
S22-15-TN-SALEM     1SEMMALAI S     ADMK
2THANGKABALU K V     INC
3BALASUB